Tiger King: 12 Unanswered Questions Season 2 Must Answer

So... did she do it?

Carole Baskin Tiger King 2
Netflix

Never before has a Documentary series had such an impact than the phenomenon that is Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem and Madness. Concentrating on the 'strange cat' that is Joe Exotic, the Netflix series that has been watched by over 35 million viewers (and rising), unleashed a series of outlandish mysteries upon the viewer. While the likelihood is that many of our burning questions will remain unanswered, there is a wealth of potential angles a second series of Tiger King could take to address these mysteries.

Without doubt the most talked about mystery of the show was the disappearance in 1997 of Don Lewis, the second husband of Big Cat Rescue founder Carole Baskin. While there were many aspects to this mystery that really got tongues wagging and raised questions that need to be addressed in future series, the biggest mystery of the season was Joe Exotic himself. The man seemingly switched from Tiger campaigner to opportunistic exploiter of animals, but who Joe really was as a person remained frustratingly out of reach.

The mysteries of course didn't stop with Carole or Joe, with other seemingly disreputable folk like Doc Antle and Jeff Lowe leaving us with so many unanswered questions, including if any of them actually gave a damn about the Tigers anymore.

So prepare to grab a seat and chuck a tiger cub on your lap as we explore twelve questions that need answering in a second season of Tiger King.

12. What Happened To Carole Baskin's Husband?

Tiger King
Netflix

One of the great mysteries that turned this Documentary series on its head was the stunning reveal that Carole Baskin's second husband, the wealthy Don Lewis, vanished 20 years ago. On top of this revelation, was the widely speculated theory that Carole herself was responsible for murdering her husband, and feeding his corpse to Tigers to cover her crime.

While Carole and her new husband flatly deny the theory and the likes of Joe Exotic sung about Ms Baskin's murdering ways, the series never came close to get a definitive answer of what exactly happened to Don. While it is hard to imagine an open confession from the murderer or Don turning up on his ex-wife's doorsteps with an amazing tale to tell, a conclusive answer as to the manner of Don's disappearance would need to be at least theorised in a second season.

The series did a good job of exploring Carole's potential motives for 'offing' her husband, including reports of domestic abuse against Don and a suspiciously written will. With the Cold Case now being reinvestigated by Florida police, it would be likely that a second series would closely monitor any revelations that come forward about Don's disappearance. Amongst the investigation, there will no doubt be one specific question that will be asked...


11. What Was Don Lewis' Mission To Costa Rica?

Carole Tiger King
Netflix

In the truly absorbing third episode of the series, 'The Secret', it was revealed that Don Lewis had intricately planned a mission to Costa Rica that "would change everything." The mystery as to what on Earth this actually meant by this is something the first series only briefly explored, but would surely become a major focus of the Florida Police Investigation, and a second Tiger King season.

The chronology of events as explained in the series lead viewers to believe that Don's mission to Costa Rica that 'would change everything' was most likely linked to getting out of his marriage with Carole. But apart from some unsubstantiated suspicions from former friends and family, there was no clear links of Don's mission to Costa Rica having anything to do with a potential divorce or 'refinancing' to keep Carole away from his fortune.

The answer to what the secret mission to Costa Rica was about may just lay with another important question- did Don make it to Costa Rica at all? His car was found empty at an airfield, but numerous experts pointed out that none of Don's planes had the capability of making its way to Costa Rica, while Carole noted that Don had crashed his planes on multiple occasions before.

While the first series explored in detail why Don's wife is the chief suspect in his apparent murder, Carole Baskin herself had some other theories...


10. Why Did Carole Baskin Suspect Her Husband's Secretary Was The Murderer?

Tiger King
Netflix

One notably missing aspect of the show's portrayal of the mysterious disappearance and apparent murder of Don Lewis, was Carole Baskin's theory of what happened to her husband. While proclaiming her innocence and emphasising just how ludicrous the idea of her feeding her husband to tigers was, Ms Baskin also had a theory as to how he died- his secretary murdered him.

Baskin outlined this idea to the filmmakers, who chose not to use the footage, perhaps feeling that it moved the focus of the story too far off track. It is a shame though, as it is another amazing angle to this perplexing mystery that viewers desperately want answered. For the show runners of the second season it will be essential to not just discuss the theory with Don's secretary, but also to identify exactly why Carole thought the secretary was involved.

Of all the potential questions to be answered, this one may prove the most elusive, considering Baskin's detailed complaints in regards her depiction in the show. The likelihood of her sitting down with the filmmakers and outlining in detail why she believes her ex-Husband's secretary would have killed him seems unlikely, leaving us to hypothesise about just how viable this theory is.


9. Who Was The Disgruntled Empolyee That Gave Joe Exotic Carole's Diaries?

Tiger King
Netflix

Of all the weird and wonderful moments from the series, the revelation of Joe Exotic reading verbatim from Carole Baskin's diary was truly astonishing. While it was unclear as to how exactly Joe would get his hands on such personal information, there was no discussion that the information was anything but the truth.

The topic of how on Earth Joe got his hands on this information is one question that should be easily answered in a potential second season, because the answer has (kind of) been revealed. In a a Robert Moor article in New York Magazine from September 2019, it is explained that a disgruntled employee of Baskin stole the information and gave it to Joe.

While it is not stipulated in the article who the person was, it would surely be a great angle for future seasons to explore. Having an interview with a disgruntled employee of Baskin would be gripping stuff, especially in regards why they became disgruntled in the first place.

The fact that the employee was not named also lends some credit to the idea that it was possible Joe who either burgled, or organised to burgle Carole Baskin's property. Footage within the series displayed Joe making a 'stealth operation' inside Baskin's Zoo, so it wouldn't be too hard to imagine Joe pulling off such a stunt.


8. Did Doc Antle Slaughter Tiger Cubs?

Tiger King Doc Antle True Geordie
YouTube/TrueGeordie

The exploration of Bhagavan 'Doc' Artle proved to be one of the most interesting aspects of the series, while also giving the show its greatest villain. While Joe himself was convicted of the slaughtering of innocent Tigers, it was strongly insinuated in the second episode of the series that Doc Artle was also guilty of slaughtering Tiger cubs. Former employee Barbara Fisher stated that the turning point that lead to her leaving the park was when a Tiger cub she had nurtured over many years simply disappeared.

The strong inference from the filmmakers was that Doc Artle was responsible for the slaughter of numerous tiger cubs, due to them no longer serving a purpose for his business when they hit a certain age. While there was no concrete information to verify these claims, it is interesting to note that PETA has since inspected Artle's facilities.

With Joe Exotic locked up, a greater focus on the 'secondary' Tiger King would most definitely be a focus of a second series. While Doc Artle bristled at comments that he treated the Tigers poorly, the accusations laid by an ex-employee and the sheer mystery of where all those Tiger cubs go is one that desperately needs answering.


7. Are Doc's 'Girls' Really Free To Leave?

Tiger King Netflix
Netflix

The revelation of the 'cult' that was 'Doc' Antle and his posse of attractive wives/workers/slave labour force, was the moment many viewers realised that Tiger King was like no other show we'd seen before. The revelations of ex worker Barbara Fisher amongst other comments from Doc and his 'employees' revealed the slave labour like conditions that they endured, some more willingly than others.

While Barbara Fisher managed to 'escape', it's unclear just how free Antle's 'loyal servants' were to come and go from the premises as they please. The workers seemed very happy with their insane working hours, low wages and forced breast implants, many becoming one of Doc's wives. The potential of Doc's 'girls' watching the series and gaining greater insight could make for some more interesting revelations, if the women are allowed Televisions at all.

The ability for this question to be answered would somewhat depend on Doc Antle's willingness to participate in another Tiger King series, which seems quite unlikely considering his poor reaction to the show. Our greatest hope for an answer to these questions would instead come with another 'insider' interview of the likes Barbara Fisher presented. Further questioning of Fisher and any other ex-employees detailing Doc's tight reign would likely prove quite illuminating.


6. What Happened To Joe Exotic's PETA Complaints?

Tiger King
Netflix

In the final episode of the series, Joe's new husband, Dillon Passage, gathered a significant amount of information to pass on to PETA in a seeming act of retribution against those who 'framed' his husband.

Presumably the information provided was designed to incriminate a number of those Joe blamed for his incarceration, most notably Jeff Lowe, and quite possible Carole Baskin. The final episode inferred that PETA was chasing this up, with a strong inference made by the filmmakers that more charges would follow. One would think that this would be one plot point a second series would follow closely, especially with PETA already having inspected Doc Antle's facilities.

A secondary topic to be explored in regards the information given to PETA relates to Joe's relationship with Doc Artle himself. As we viewed Dillon collecting the information, the shot picked up information that appeared to be an invoice of some sort related to Doc Artle. As filmmaker Eric Goode mentioned the information, Dillon quickly removed the paperwork from the 'evidence'.

But what information did this paperwork contain? Was it an invoice of some description? And why would Joe have instructed his husband to remove that information? There always seemed to be a friendship of sorts between the Doc and Joe, but this information seemed to suggest that the relationship went a lot further. And there is no other person who deserves greater exploration of his shady history in a future series than the other Tiger King, the Doc himself.


5. Is Joe Exotic Remorseful For His Actions?

Joe Exotic Mugshot
Santa Rosa County Jail

The man known as Joe Exotic always seemed to be an egotistical fella who put himself before the welfare of the company he kept, be it human or otherwise. There was however some small snippets within the show that displayed that the man may have had some semblance of a conscience. While clearly feeling ripped off and hard done by for receiving a prison sentence while the likes of Alen Glover and Jeff Lowe walked free, there were a few moments that made us ponder if he was somewhat remorseful for his actions, especially towards the animals he professed to love.

During a phone interview in prison, Joe noted that he "felt like an animal trapped in a cage." It's hard to know if this comment was Joe's way of reflecting on the poor way he treated his animals, or if he was too busy lamenting his own misfortune to recognise the irony of the situation.

Other evidence surfaced within the series, most notably the final episode, that Joe had come to some realisation of the mistakes he'd made along the way. A brief clip where Joe reflected on the harm he inflicted through the caging of a pair of apes demonstrated some previously unsighted introspection.

A crucial aspect of a second series would be if any lessons have been learnt by Joe. Although from what we saw this series, there is a good chance the man will have learnt very little, if anything at all.


4. What Is Joe Exotic's Reaction To The Show's Fanfare?

Joe Exotic Gun
Joe Exotic TV / YouTube

One question that was asked repeatedly in both the final episode and 'aftershow' special, is just what Joe's reaction would be to the show. The verdict seemed split from Joe's ex colleagues and friends between Joe either loving the attention, or feeling down and depressed about missing out on all of the fanfare. As outlined in the previous entry on this list, there was some evidence that suggested that, however unlikely, Joe Exotic had possibly learnt from his mistakes and become a more humble person in the process.

The ability for a second series to examine Joe's reactions would be largely dependent on the ability to gain access to a one on one interview with Joe on camera. It would only take one half hour/hour long interview for the producers to utilise footage throughout a new series, and would allow the focus of the show to remain on the series' 'star'.

The reaction of Joe to the worldwide phenomenon that Tiger King has become may also have a great impact on future appeals that Joe makes against his conviction. The prospect of fundraisers or go fund me pages in raising money for the best legal team has already been floated, but it's hard to know if Joe Exotic's 'infamy' will help or hinder future court appearances. The exploration of Joe's court appearances, especially if live coverage of his case is allowed, would definitely play a major role in a second series.


3. Will The New GW Zoo Ever Be Completed?

Como Zoo
Wikimedia Commons

Another of the great mysteries surrounding this series was the character of Jeff Lowe, lauded as a saviour in some circles and as a broke conman by others. Considering that the GW Zoo is still open for business is a sign that Lowe must have some resources behind him, although it is still unclear if he is as wealthy as he would like to suggest.

One aspect Jeff Lowe was at pains to emphasise in the finale episode was the building of a brand new facility for the GW Zoo, which would be rebranded 'Oklahoma Zoo'. There already appeared to be tensions in the construction of the new site however, with the accusations of Lowe being a conman again resurfacing.

How much focus the construction of the new Zoo would garner in a second season may well depend on how successful Lowe is in getting the park built. While the hope is that the park will be constructed and prove a better space for the animals to live, there has to be genuine doubts that the new Zoo will ever come to be.

While bad news for the Tigers and other animals of the park, failed construction attempts would definitely prove to be a fascinating story arc for a new series. This would especially be the case if Lowe proves to be a conman and can't afford the upkeep of the animals, which could open up a whole new story arc.


2. What Happened To Joe Exotic's First Two Husbands?

Joe Exotic Husbands
Netflix

One aspect of the Documentary that was bizarrely left out of the series was that Joe Exotic had actually been married twice before the 'big wedding' displayed in the show. While the first episode of the series emphasis on his brother's death in a car accident having a major impact on Joe, it was a particularly strange choice to leave out the details in regards Joe's first two husbands.

As reported by a Robert Moor article in New York Magazine from September 2019, Joe was first married to a man named Brian Rhyne. The article reports that Joe met Rhyne while working as a security guard at a gay cowboy bar during the late 1980's. The two resembled each other with matching mullets, and built the initial GW Park together. Rhyne died in 2001 of HIV complications, which appears to coincide with Joe's changed attitudes in regards the treatment of his animals. The story seems to be quite a pivotal part of Joe's journey so it was strange it was not addressed, and would surely be a major focus of future seasons.

Another focus for a new season could be on Joe's second husband, J.C. Hartpence, whose adventures could fill up a series of its own. The Moor article reports that Hartpence once held a gun to Joe's head in a drunken rage, before being convicted of murder after breaking up with Joe. Just when you thought the story couldn't get any crazier...


1. Why Weren't Alen Glover And Jeff Lowe Charged For Their Involvement In The Carole Baskin Plot?

Jeff Lowe Tiger King
Instagram @oklahoma_zoo

While the Documentary does a good job of outlining why Joe Exotic was prosecuted by police for both attempted murder and the mistreatment of animals, it still remains a mystery how both Alen Glover and Jeff Lowe avoided prosecution. Glover in particular was pivotal to the plot of the attempted execution of Carole Baskin, having accepted $3k for the hit, before using the downpayment to get drunk instead. While Glover did not follow through on the hit, the reasons for why the Police chose not to prosecute him is something that definitely needs to be explored.

If anything, Jeff Lowe seems even more guilty than Glover for his involvement in planning Baskin's murder. It was Lowe who brought up images on Google Earth to demonstrate to Joe just how easy it would be to carry out an execution of Baskin and on top of this, it was Lowe who suggested that Joe consult with Glover about carrying out the hit.

The penultimate episode of the series outlined how Lowe volunteered to help police capture Joe, but what deals were made to allow Lowe to get off scot free is something that definitely needs further exploration. Considering how implicated Lowe and Glover were, it's fair to say that the prosecutors involved need to be questioned as to how these men were allowed to walk free.


In this post: 
Tiger King
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

While he likes to know himself as the 'thunder from down under', Luke is actually just a big dork who loves all things sport, film, James Bond, Doctor Who and Karaoke. With all the suave and sophistication of any Aussie half way through a slab, Luke will critique every minute detail of films and shows from all eras- unless it's 1990's Simpsons episodes, because they're just perfect