2. Josh Holloway (The Black Rider, Season 2-A Few Paintballs More)
Im sure Community and Lost share a lot of fans, so it was a joyous day for them when Josh Holloway appeared in season 2s penultimate paintball episode. The school has once again been overrun by a paintball game, the winner receiving $100,000. But a mysterious man, known only as the dark rider, has showed up and begins taking everyone out. His presence brings out Jeffs self-image issues pretty quickly, as he explains that hes not that handsome. (You got a problem, man, Troy tells him) His game comes to an end, though, as Pierce fakes yet another heart attack. As The Black Rider goes to help him, the group tells him its not real. What is wrong with you people?, he says before Pierce shoots him in the chest.