Top 25 Sitcom Christmas Specials
15. Futurama A Tale Of Two Santas (FOX, 2001)
Bender volunteers to replace the evil Robot Santa who terrorises the world every Christmas. A comedy set in the far future really lets you have some fun when it comes to Christmas episodes. In Futurama, Christmas is a time for fear and packing heat in the hope that youll survive Robot Santas annual massacre. Although this premise was used brilliantly in the shows first Christmas episode Xmas Story, here it gets a lot more focus as Bender visits various houses delivering toys but finds himself attacked every time and eventually sentenced to death for the old Santas crimes. Its just an inventive premise with a lot of potential thats well-realised and has some great dark humour to it. It delivers on many levels and is a welcome departure from conventional Christmas sitcom episodes. Best Moment: The Professor turning the Planet Express building into an armoured fortress complete with Christmas lights that spell out Trespassers will be shot immediately before sending Fry, Leela, and Bender on a mission to Robot Santas base.
14. Mrs Browns Boys Mammys Ass (BBC One, 2011)
Agness plans for the perfect family Christmas begin to fall apart when she learns that her son Trevor isnt coming back from his missionary work Africa. This is another sitcom that tends to polarise viewers, largely for the same reasons as Miranda but also for the amount of swearing and the fact that Agnes is played by a man. But its one that Ive personally loved right from the start. This episodes got all the brilliantly crude humour of a typical episode but theres also a fairly dramatic undercurrent to it. Some of the plot points are a bit meandering and arent followed up on but when its sticking to the main plot of Agnes preparing for Trevors return and the subplot of petty criminal Buster Brady having to butcher a live turkey, it very rarely puts a foot wrong. A bit scattershot but it largely hits the mark. Best Moment: The final scene where the cast sing Silent Night, ending with Trevor arriving. Its beautifully underplayed and actually quite moving.
13. Some Mothers Do Ave Em Jessicas First Christmas (BBC, 1974)
Frank desperately tries to get a part in the church Nativity play, despite Father OHaras efforts to stop him. Christmas just offers a multitude of new ways for well-intentioned walking catastrophe Frank Spencer to cause chaos. The physical comedy is spot on and the verbal humour also hits the mark, particularly with Michele Dotrice (Betty) acting as the straight man (although she gets a few decent quips in) to Frank strange ramblings like worrying that his baby daughter playing Jesus will cause her to become a lesbian. The episode boasts some very daring stuntwork and, as always, Michael Crawfords (Frank) performance is sublime. Its nothing groundbreaking but its good fun and it doesnt feel like theres too little material for its extended runtime. Best Moment: Franks winch mechanism for the Nativity play catapulting him through the church roof.
12. The Royle Family Christmas With The Royle Family (BBC2, 1999)
As the traditional post-Christmas dinner laziness kicks in, the family watch The Snowman together. This is pretty much the quintessential domestic sitcom Christmas special. Its brilliance lies in its simplicity. Theres more or less no plot, and nothing setting up the dialogue and jokes other than the characters. Theres probably no other Christmas special around that has this amount of universality. Its just one family watching TV and shooting the breeze. Something that practically every will family do at Christmas. Which makes watching this episode a bit like a Christmas version of Inception. Despite the lack of plot and limited locations and camera angles, it holds your attention really well and the naturalistic dialogue and performances are absolutely fantastic. Best Moment: Denise going into labour. Its a surprisingly poignant scene that sees the usually miserly Jim step up and help his daughter in her time of need.
11. Peep Show Seasonal Beatings (Channel 4, 2010)
In Peep Shows first and much deserved Christmas episode, a cash-strapped Mark finds himself hosting Christmas for his sister, belligerent father, and sex-obsessed mother. A situation thats exacerbated by the arrival of his girlfriend Dobby and crack addict Super Hans. What can I say apart from that its Peep Show mixed with Christmas. One of the best combinations since some genius had the idea to wrap sausages in bacon. It tackles the minutiae of Christmas really well and adds a whole new dynamic to Jez and Marks personalities as Jez attempts to have a decent Christmas, even to the extent of resisting sex with Marks sister so as not to ruin the festive atmosphere, and Marks neuroses are brought to the forefront by the stress of Christmas and the presence of his family. All of this leads to some screamingly funny voice-overs and, surprisingly, leads to an episode that doesnt end in total humiliation for Mark or Jez. Best Moment: Its more the one-liners that make this episode so good but the Christmas dinner scene is full of good material, culminating in Mark finally standing up to his father. Merry Christ-Mark everyone.
10. How Not To Live Your Life Its A Don-derful Life (BBC3, 2011)
In the last episode of the BBC3 series following the life of misguided, twenty-something orphan Don Danbury, Don attempts to confess his love for flatmate Sam while preparing to sell his house to a property developer. But can he really break up the bizarre family hes built up? This ones a strange candidate for being so high up on the list given that its only a year old and its a very niche comedy confined to BBC3, but the episode is so strong itself that it really didnt belong anywhere below the top ten. The series trademark cutaways showing various things that have either happened or could happen (e.g. 5 People Dons Spent Christmas With) are a bit scarce but its full of good moments elsewhere. Its a an excellent standalone episode as well as being a decent send-off for the series with a pair of great musical numbers and a show-stealing performance by Leila Hoffman (Bad Education) as foul-mouthed OAP Mrs Treacher. A worthy end to the series and a great Christmas episode. Best Moment: Don waking up in bed with Mrs Treacher.
9. Only Fools And Horses Christmas Crackers (BBC One, 1981)
After Granddads Christmas dinner which includes turkey with the bag of giblets still inside, Del and Rodney decide to spend the evening at the Monte Carlo Club. It pains me not to put this closer to the top of the list but, as enjoyable as this episode is, the story structure drags it down a bit. Its definitely an episode of two halves with the first half being a three hander that deals with Christmas at the Trotters, and the second being one of Del and Rodneys many unsuccessful nights out. I personally feel that the episode would have worked better as a bottle episode featuring nothing more than Del, Rodney and Granddad celebrating Christmas. Apart from that little niggle, its very funny stuff. As usual, John Sullivans dialogue is absolute joy especially when combined with the casts brilliant performances. The jokes about Granddads awful cooking never feel strained despite how extensively theyre used and theres some excellent Christmas related dialogue. Its nowhere near as good as the 1996 Christmas Trilogy but out of the episodes eligible for inclusion on this list, its definitely the best. Best Moment: Granddads Christmas dinner complete with molten plastic inside the turkey, roast potatoes that look like lumps of anthracite, and a very overcooked Christmas pudding.
8. South Park Woodland Critter Christmas (Comedy Central, 2004)
In a masterful parody of old Christmas cartoons, Stan is repeatedly coerced into helping a group of woodland animals prepare for the birth of their lord and saviour. South Parks done quite a few Christmas episodes but, for me, this is the only one that really stands out. Its hard to say much about the episode without ruining the twist that starts the final scene (which comes brilliantly out of the blue) but its a welcome return to straight-up surrealism after the shows shift to focussing on social satire, and is just a pretty decent story in itself with some excellent twists and some beautifully dark content as well as being an ingenious spoof of traditional Christmas cartoons with rhyming narration. Best Moment: The last twist. The one that reveals whats actually going on
7. My Family Ding Dong Merrily (BBC One, 2002)
Christmas is anything but merry for the Harpers as Janey returns home from university with a little surprise: shes pregnant. While Susan obsesses over the identity of the father, Ben has to cope with Nick filling the living room with Christmas trees that he doesnt plan to sell until next Christmas, and Susans turkey coated with chocolate and raisins makes vegetarianism a popular option. Although its frequently derided as cheap and unfunny and is a fixture on most lists of bad sitcoms, in its early years before Kris Marshall (Nick) left, My Family was an excellent programme with some great situations and sharp dialogue. And this episode is one of the best. Christmas takes a bit of a backseat role as Janeys pregnancy becomes the most prominent plot point but that actually works quite well since it lets us see the more paternal side of the permanently cynical Ben as he does his best to stop Susan pressuring Janey about who the father is. It also includes a great guest role from The Vicar Of Dibleys Trevor Peacock as Mr Bradley, a elderly man Nick invites over for Christmas who ends up stealing all of the furniture while the Harpers are at the pub. Overall, its just fun and undemanding viewing with a good mix of verbal, physical, and sight gags. Best Moment: Ben discovering that Nick has filled the living room with Christmas trees and then pursuing him through the trees.
6. The Vicar Of Dibley Winter (BBC One, 1999)
Geraldine is pushed to the brink of her patience directing the village Nativity play while Alice prepares for the birth of her first child. The best thing about this episode is how consistent it is. There are no lulls when there arent jokes or anything plot related going on. And, thanks to Richard Curtiss marvellous writing, almost every joke is a winner. The premise is pretty simple but Curtis manages to wring so much comedy out of it, especially since the rehearsals have Geraldine as pretty much the only sane person in the room, directing the villagers who (apart from snobbish district councillor David) are all complete lunatics. This episode also, for once, sees Alice actually having a good idea as she suggests staging the Nativity play on a farm. And its the play itself that is this episodes real highlight. Its simply an explosion of brilliant moments. The jokes are pretty rapid but it doesnt make them any less funny and it ends with quite a sweet scene that sees the villagers bond over Alice and Hugos newborn daughter who they name after Geraldine. Best Moment: The Nativity play featuring Alice (playing the Virgin Mary) going into labour during the show, David attempting to make King Herod seem more likeable by handing out sweets to the children in the audience, and Jim and Owen (playing the shepherds) improvising dialogue about wanting to have sex with their sheep.