Why Every Lead Actor Left Doctor Who

Those TARDIS doors are hiding quite a bit of drama...

William Hartnell David Tennant Doctor Who
BBC Studios

Even though it must be extremely daunting to take on, the role of the Doctor is right up there with the most sought-after parts in the TV business.

With such a huge legacy and a devoted global fanbase, the level of scrutiny these actors are forced to endure is truly extraordinary, and a string of bad episodes could doom them to be remembered in a negative light for the rest of their career.

With that in mind, it's not surprising that most actors only play the character for a couple of years. It must be an honour to step into those shoes, absolutely, but the amount of pressure hoisted upon their soldiers is an unreasonable amount for someone to carry for five or more years, and because the show is so highly publicized, we often hear stories about what prompted the stars to leave Doctor Who behind.

Some actors have straightforward motives, others were victims of unfortunate circumstances, and a few didn't have the happiest of endings. Whatever the cause, it's a subject that each leading man has touched on at one point or another.

13. William Hartnell

Doctor Who The Daleks William Hartnell fluid link
BBC Studios

When William Hartnell agreed to play the Doctor in the early '60s, the concept of regeneration didn't even exist. This was a family program about a mad man with a box – nobody involved thought that Doctor Who would spawn an unprecedented 60-year run.

But sadly, several problems necessitated a plot device that would allow the show to switch leads.

Hartnell was no spring chicken, and as his health deteriorated it became difficult for him to keep up with Doctor Who's gruelling production schedule. He suffered from arteriosclerosis, a condition which hardens the artery walls and restricts blood flow, which would often cause him to forget or mix up his lines.

Combined with the fact that Hartnell didn't get along with producer John Wiles (who replaced original producer Verity Lambert in 1965), the idea was floated to recast him during The Celestial Toymaker. The Doctor would be invisible for most of the narrative, only to return with a brand-new face.

Though this idea wasn't used here, a similar concept of "renewal" (the term "regeneration" wasn't invented until later) was devised for The Tenth Planet, by which point Hartnell's health had declined to such an extent that it was difficult for him to keep going.

The First Doctor changed his face on 29 October 1966, and Doctor Who continued under a new lead actor.


12. Patrick Troughton

Doctor Who Patrick Troughton Second Doctor
BBC Studios

Patrick Troughton reportedly thought that regeneration was a naff concept. "I didn’t think it was a particularly good idea of the BBC to replace Billy", he said. "I thought it was pretty silly, really."

However, he was eventually persuaded to take the leap – the consistent pay cheque no doubt played a role in that decision.

Like Hartnell, Troughton found Doctor Who's production schedule highly demanding. With dozens of episodes being produced per year, it's easy to see why! This is largely what influenced his decision to exit the role in 1969, with three seasons under his belt.

After he left, Troughton advised Fifth Doctor Peter Davison to also follow the three-year model, in an effort to avoid being typecast. Over the years, this has become something of an unwritten rule that many Doctors abide by, intentionally or not.


11. Jon Pertwee

Third Doctor Jon Pertwee Doctor Who
BBC Studios

The Third Doctor's era brought big change to Doctor Who. The show was now in colour, the Doctor was stranded on Earth working with his UNIT family, and iconic characters like the Master, Sarah Jane Smith, and Jo Grant were introduced.

They say that nobody likes change, but in this case, it was a big hit, with Doctor Who enjoying something of a renaissance after ratings had dipped towards the latter end of Troughton's run.

This success might be why Pertwee remained in the role for longer than either of his predecessors, completing five full seasons instead of the usual three. An incredibly positive tenure overall then, but one that was tinged with sadness by the time it concluded.

After the tragic death of his good friend and Master actor Roger Delgado in 1973, Pertwee was motivated to head for the exit. Various cast and crew members were also leaving the show, and Pertwee decided it was time for him to do the same. His request for a significant payrise had also been declined, which further reinforced his decision.

1974's Planet of the Spiders was the first story to use the term "regeneration" to describe the Doctor's face-changing process, and it was here where Pertwee bowed out of the role.


10. Tom Baker

Doctor Who Tom Baker
BBC Studios

Tom Baker is the longest-serving Doctor to date, but in hindsight, the man himself thinks that he might have stayed a bit too long.

The actor has cited the early part of his tenure (under producer Philip Hinchcliffe) as his favourite period of the show, but confessed that he grew more and more frustrated when John Nathan-Turner took the reigns in 1980.

Nathan-Turner added a lot more characters to each story, and Baker felt that the short 25-minute episode format meant that most of these characters ended up being useless. "John Nathan-Turner and I did not see eye-to-eye about very much", he said in 2014. "I think I should've gone when John was taking over to liberate him to recast. Maybe I did one series too many."

In a separate interview, Baker stated that Nathan-Turner "diminished" him in the role, and that he was annoyed by the addition of question marks to the Doctor's collar.

The tension ultimately proved too much, and by the time 1981 rolled around, Baker had decided that his time as the Doctor was over.


9. Peter Davison

Fifth Doctor Tardis Peter Davison
BBC Studios

As previously mentioned, Peter Davison wanted to stick to a three-year stint after listening to Patrick Troughton's advice about not being typecast. So that's exactly what he did!

However, there may be a little bit more to the story than that.

Though Davison was happy with his final season in 1984, he found the middle part of his run rather frustrating, clashing with Nathan-Turner over various creative decisions. Davison wished to bring more levity to his Doctor, which his superior consistently shot down.

Davison had also noted how long Tom Baker stayed in the role, and was concerned that staying any longer than three years might affect his future job opportunities.

And so, the Fifth Doctor regenerated on 16 March 1984, almost three years to the day since his first appearance at the end of Logopolis.


8. Colin Baker

Sixth Doctor Colin Baker
BBC Studios

Colin Baker was at the helm for one of the most turbulent periods in Doctor Who history.

In 1985, the show was put on hiatus due to concerns about its quality and its levels of violence. BBC executive Michael Grade believed Doctor Who felt cheap compared to the likes of Star Wars and E.T., saying "What we were serving up as science fiction was garbage".

Not exactly a fair comparison, but point taken.

Though Doctor Who did return after its hiatus with the season-long story Trial of a Time Lord, it wasn't long before Baker himself had a target on his back. With higher-ups still not convinced by the show's quality (or ratings), they removed him from the role.

Though he was offered a final adventure that would conclude with the Sixth Doctor's departure, Baker refused to return for anything less than a full season. As a result, he wasn't even present for his own regeneration scene, with Sylvester McCoy instead adorning a blonde curly wig.


7. Sylvester McCoy

Seventh Doctor Sylvester McCoy
BBC Studios

Unlike most of his fellow Time Lords, Sylvester McCoy never technically "left" Doctor Who, nor was he fired. He was simply unlucky enough to be the Doctor in 1989, the year in which production of the show was suspended.

It's a shame too, because McCoy had settled into a solid groove towards the end of his era, with he and Sophie Aldred proving a winning combination. Unfortunately, public perception of Doctor Who was at an all-time low, and with viewership declining, the plug was pulled.

Regardless, McCoy was still the incumbent Doctor for the 1993 charity special Dimensions in Time, and the start of the 1996 TV movie. Writer Matthew Jacobs wished to link the movie directly to the classic series, and so it was decided to depict the Seventh Doctor's regeneration.


6. Paul McGann

Paul McGann Doctor Who
BBC Studios

Based on their original runs, Paul McGann is the shortest-serving Doctor of all time – less than 90 minutes in total. But at first, it was hoped he'd get to play the character for a lot longer than that.

The TV movie was intended to kick-start a new series of Doctor Who, a co-production between the BBC and FOX. But despite strong UK ratings, it underperformed in North America, and FOX chose not to go any further.

Like McCoy then, McGann never technically left Doctor Who – he was simply the star of the show at a time when it ran out of steam. No more onscreen appearances were greenlit, though he did reprise the role in the 2001 Big Finish audio drama Storm Warning, marking the beginning of an incredibly successful run in Doctor Who's expanded universe.

In 2003, it was announced that one Russell T Davies had been hired to showrun a new series of Doctor Who. Though Davies decided that the new series would continue where the TV movie left off, he intended to be careful with his acknowledgement of the show's past so as to make it as newcomer-friendly as possible.

To that end, a new Doctor was brought in to lead the charge, and McGann was left without a regeneration scene until 2013 minisode The Night of the Doctor.


5. Christopher Eccleston

Doctor Who Ninth Doctor Christopher Eccleston
BBC Studios

Though precise details are scarce, Christopher Eccleston did not have the best of times shooting his first and only series of Doctor Who.

Production on block one – comprising Rose, Aliens of London, and World War Three – was reportedly chaotic, not least because it fell behind schedule.

This tallies with comments Eccleston has made in the years since, where he's explained that poor management on the part of the showrunners was the main catalyst for his decision to exit after just 13 episodes:

“I left because my relationship with the showrunner and the producer broke down. [I left because of] the politics of the show. I left only because of those three individuals and the way they were running the show.”

It's unclear how bad things got at the time, but Eccleston's recent statement that the only way he'd consider returning to Doctor Who was if current producers Russell T Davies, Jane Tranter, Phil Collinson, and Julie Gardner were sacked is damning, considering those four were in charge back in 2005.

On a more positive note, Eccleston loves playing the Doctor, and has shown a great willingness to engage with fans on the convention circuit. He also returned to voice the Ninth Doctor on audio from 2021 onwards.


4. David Tennant

Doctor Who The End of Time David Tennant
BBC Studios

Eccleston may have lit the torch, but it was David Tennant who ran with it.

Under his watch, Doctor Who became the most dominant show on British television, with the Tenth Doctor achieving some phenomenally high viewing figures throughout his run, including what is still the most-watched NuWho episode of all time – 2007 Christmas special Voyage of the Damned.

Unlike the last few Doctors, Tennant's departure wasn't surrounded by any sort of drama. In October 2008, he made the announcement himself, stating that he didn't want to outstay his welcome, and that, "If I don't take a deep breath and move on now, I never will."

It was a very tough choice to arrive at though, and Tennant did consider staying on for one more series under new showrunner Steven Moffat. The BBC would've gladly kept him too, considering his popularity! In fact, Moffat has since claimed that there might've been plans to consider ending Doctor Who, and that it was a "huge question" whether it could continue without Tennant.

There's no doubt he's iconic in the role, and since regenerating in 2010, he's barely kept away. He's been highly active in expanded media, and returned to play the Doctor onscreen in both the 50th and 60th anniversaries.

Tennant always knew that the deal for the 60th anniversary was for three specials and no more, but based on how things ended, we'll no doubt be seeing him again in the future.


3. Matt Smith

Eleventh Doctor Matt Smith Doctor Who Series 5
BBC Studios

Matt Smith was able to build on the success of the Tennant era, giving the show an international appeal to complement its dominance of British screens.

And as was the case with his predecessor, there was no trouble surrounding his departure – he just decided to move on.

From the beginning, Smith had hinted to Steven Moffat that he wanted to stay for no more than three series. The news was announced in June 2013, half a year before his regeneration in the upcoming Christmas special. Smith stated that it had been an honour to play the Doctor, and that "when ya gotta go, ya gotta go." Like other incarnations, the show's tough production schedule also played a part in his decision.

It wasn't an easy choice to make though, and Smith has confessed that he would've gladly done another year, and that he regrets not getting a full series with Jenna Coleman. Recently, he's also hinted that he wasn't entirely happy with his final episode.

Unsurprisingly then, he's more than game for a return to the show. Though many were hoping he'd appear in the 60th anniversary, Smith is young enough that there's no doubt we'll see him play the Doctor onscreen at least one more time.


2. Peter Capaldi

Doctor Who Heaven Sent Peter Capaldi
BBC Studios

Peter Capaldi actually played two other characters in the Whoniverse before he was cast as the main attraction: Caecilius in 2008's The Fires of Pompeii, and John Frobisher in Torchwood: Children of Earth. Rather than these past lives being ignored during the Twelfth Doctor's reign, this identity crisis formed a core part of his arc.

Despite ratings dipping from the Tennant and Smith eras, Capaldi enjoyed three strong series in the role before regenerating in the 2017 Christmas special. This was actually a last-minute adjustment, with the original plan being for him to bow out at the end of Series 10 in July.

As for why he left? Again, this was another case of the actor deciding to call it quits. Though incoming showrunner Chris Chibnall did try and persuade him to stay – and Capaldi considered it – he opted out, saying that he wanted to leave while he was still enjoying it.

He's also indicated that the workload was a factor. In 2018, he candidly stated:

"To be at the centre of that brand is a lot of work. It was hard to maintain that level of commitment with that schedule any longer. I tried my best to make the Doctor come alive.”

This might explain why he's not so keen on a return. His response when asked about the possibility? A simple "No."

Fingers crossed he changes his mind in future!


1. Jodie Whittaker

Doctor Who Jodie Whittaker Arachnids in the UK
BBC Studios

Chris Chibnall and Jodie Whittaker were the first showrunner-Doctor duo to make the three series rule into a joint agreement.

Upon announcing their exits in 2021, Chibnall explained:

"Jodie and I made a ‘three series and out’ pact with each other at the start of this once-in-a-lifetime blast. So now our shift is done, we’re handing back the TARDIS keys."

Whittaker echoed this sentiment, stating that they always knew they wanted to "pass on the baton together."

Because her regeneration is still so fresh at this point, it's too early for any other potential reasons to come to light, as has been the case with other Doctors. That said, Whittaker thoroughly enjoyed her time at the helm, and has already confessed she'd be "very happy to put on my Doctor's coat again".

With NuWho's 20th anniversary approaching in 2025, who knows what might happen?


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: Which Doctor Said It? - Obscure Quotes

BBC

1. “Oh, Please, Don’t Call Me Human. Just Doctor Will Do Very Nicely, Thank You.”

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!