Why Supergirl Just Got Cancelled
The end of another era for the Arrowverse...
Supergirl has been raising the standard for the superhero genre on TV, ushering in a new era of female-led superhero shows and kicking villainous behind with a smile for half a decade, but the Girl of Steel's flight will land in 2021 when the show comes to an end.
In news that came as a shock to many, The CW has confirmed that the Melissa Benoist-led series would conclude following its sixth season.
Supergirl's run has been an interesting one. It got its start on CBS as a standalone series before one crossover with The Flash established it as existing on a parallel universe to The CW's Arrowverse. After the first season came to an end, it jumped ship to the sister network, officially became part of the Arrowverse and hasn't looked back.
It's hard to fully sum up all that Supergirl has accomplished. It's encountered some issues throughout its time on the air but it has, by and large, been one of the most enjoyable superhero shows of all time. It's also become a champion for diversity and representation, tackling important issues through its empowering and thought-provoking storylines.
There are multiple reasons why Supergirl is ending, so let's explore some of them. But first, let's get one thing out of the way...
6. It's Ending On Its Own Terms
Before getting into the specifics of Supergirl's conclusion, it's important to stress one thing: The show has not technically been cancelled - it's just ending.
The CW already renewed it for a sixth season back in January which is set to begin filming really soon. We didn't know back then that it would be its final offering, but given that production hasn't started yet, you can rest assured that making this decision now will give the cast and crew the chance to end the show on their own terms.
All good things must come to an end - and in spite of her incredible super powers, the Girl of Steel isn't immune to that. However, we can take solace in the fact that she hasn't been taken from us by some unjust cancellation. Thus, she will return for one last adventure, consisting of 20 episodes.
Prepare yourselves to go up, up and away one more time.
5. The Ratings Have Been Declining For Years
One thing that could have played into The CW's decision to end Supergirl now is the fact that its ratings have been in decline for years now.
Now, when you've been on the air for a long time, a decline in the ratings is inevitable and that's certainly not helped by the fact that less people are watching network TV at any one time than they used to - something we've seen reflected in the ratings of all long-running shows in recent years - but Supergirl's have taken some tumbles recently.
The first season debuted with an astounding 13 million viewers on CBS but over the course of the first season that averaged out to around 7 million. It also started strong when it moved to The CW, bringing in a solid 3 million viewers for the smaller network - even outperforming network headliner The Flash on occasion.
However, a sharp decline soon began as it found itself falling below 2 million viewers and, midway through Season 4, it fell below 1 million.
While The CW hasn't been as worried about high ratings on the night as other networks are - particularly in regards to the Arrowverse shows given their popularity worldwide - the fact that only two episodes of Season 5 were able to bring in 1 million viewers and the fact that it hit multiple series lows throughout, it's understandable that all involved decided to end it sooner rather than later.
4. The Arrival Of Superman & Lois
This one's a little out there, but fans who are bitter at the show's impending conclusion couldn't help but notice the fact that Supergirl will be bowing out just as Superman & Lois arrives. Yes, they will share one season together on the network but, given that the Girl of Steel's show won't be returning at the same time as the others, it's hard to deduce if the titular stars will be able to interact at all moving forward.
Superman's history in the Arrowverse has been particularly interesting because CBS wasn't allowed to use the character on Supergirl and thus, made reference to him via an internet messaging system and threw in a CGI Supes for the heck of it. When the show moved to The CW, however, they wasted little time and introduced the Man of Steel in the very first episode.
Tyler Hoechlin's Superman has been received incredibly well by fans and many have been calling for him to get his own show for years. Now that it's finally on the horizon, some fans have suggested that the new Kryptonian series could have been one of the main reasons behind the network's decision to end Supergirl.
The notion that the network was only ever really interested in Superman is preposterous because they never would have spent the time, money or effort making Supergirl the success that it is today if that was their intention - not-to-mention the fact they could have ended it with Season 5 if that was the plan - but it does leave you wondering if The CW just wasn't big enough for two expensive Kryptonians.
Either way, let's just hope Superman & Lois can do Supergirl justice by carrying on her incredible legacy.
3. The Delays
That brings us to one of the most likely reasons behind the decision to end Supergirl now, the very one that Deadline itself made reference to in its official report: the delays in production that the show has faced over the past few months.
Like its Arrowverse counterparts, the show was forced to shut down production earlier this year because of the ongoing global situation. It wrapped up just shy of its Season 5 finale, with the 19th episode serving as its concluding instalment instead - and it worked incredibly well, by the way.
While the other shows have all faced the same delays that Supergirl has due to everything going on over the last six months, Melissa Benoist's pregnancy understandably factored into why the show was absent from The CW's 2021 schedule. Much of the cast and crew have returned to Vancouver and production is set to resume very soon, but Supergirl still won't be airing on screens until at least next spring (while most of the others return in January).
With all that in mind and with everything going on at the moment, it's totally understandable that the producers, creative team and Benoist decided to bring the show to a close. Not only does it result in less pressure to meet the demands of the ambitious fall-spring schedule, it allows them to take more time with what is now the final season.
2. A New Era For The Arrowverse

Arrow may have kicked off the Arrowverse but, in a way, Supergirl has been every bit as important to it. While that show changed the superhero landscape and launched a whole universe, it was the Girl of Steel who paved the way for this long overdue renaissance of female superheroes on the small screen - breaking ground in the same way that Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman did four decades prior.
In the five years that followed its debut, we got more female-led programming in the genre and female-led movies like Wonder Woman, Captain Marvel and Birds of Prey.
The Arrowverse now has Batwoman and Stargirl as primarily female-led shows while Superman and Lois and DC's Legends of Tomorrow are co-headlined by women as well. There's a solid chance that will grow further if potential Arrow spinoff Green Arrow and The Canaries gets picked up.
Like Arrow, Supergirl has had an incredible impact on the superhero landscape. However, also like Arrow, part of that journey is the ending. And thus, it makes sense that the groundbreaking Girl of Steel is the first to follow in the Emerald Archer's footsteps by wrapping up an equally incredible run.
1. It's Time
With all of that in mind, one can't help but feel that the time is right for Supergirl to conclude.
Rumor has it that the cast were only contracted for six seasons, so with everything happening right now, it's only natural for everyone involved to consider their options. Should they carry on in an uncertain time and run the risk of facing more delays and further ratings declines or should they end now when the show - and all involved in it - can go out on an unbelievable high?
Does Supergirl still have plenty of stories left to tell? Absolutely, and it's a darn shame that it won't be telling them - especially when the show has the potential to be the very best of the Arrowverse - but it's also had an amazing run that both captivated audiences and inspired them. And that's an incredible legacy that we will always hold onto.
It's been one heck of a journey but, taking everything into account, the time is right for Supergirl to bow out - and there's no doubt that she will do so with grace and honour... but not before taking us on one more unforgettable adventure!
Watch Next
The Flash: You'll Never Score 100% On This True Or False Quiz