10 Amazing Wrestling Feuds With AWFUL Endings

Hulk Hogan, Sting, and WCW Starrcade '97: here's what happens when straight fire gets put on ice.

Sting Hulk Hogan
WWE

Perhaps the wackiest entertainment medium ever devised, professional wrestling's eclectic blend of simulated violence, soap opera yarns, and larger than life personalities can lead to one-of-a-kind storytelling. Mind-blowing collisions like Austin vs. Rock and Flair vs. Steamboat kept audiences glued to their TVs, amazed by both the athletic pedigree and the colourful storylines that gave them meaning.

Sadly, it can also lead to one of a kind craptastrophes.

There have been plenty of wrestling feuds over the years doomed from the start. When Triple H outed Kane as a necrophiliac, for instance, we knew to change the channel immediately. Other times, however, it's not as clear cut, and feuds and angles that initially immerse us ultimately crash and burn.

Crafting a great beginning, middle and end can be hard. Creative teams the world over frequently fall into the trouble of throwing their own great ideas down the toilet at the last hurdle.

While the likes of WWE, WCW and TNA have frequently been ragged on as the biggest offenders in this regard, they're far from alone with just about every promotion ever, big and small, botching a once-hot feud at one point or other...

10. Bruiser Brody Vs. Antonio Inoki (NJPW)

Bruiser Brody Antonio Inoki
NJPW World

One of the last actual outlaws wrestling had, Bruiser Brody was known for two things: selling tickets and screwing promoters.

As hot-headed as he was talented, Brody was a major star in Giant Baba's All Japan during the early 80s. Fans were wowed by his chain-swinging, forehead cutting antics and promoter Giant Baba was surprisingly tolerant of Brody's aversions to selling and jobbing. In 1985, Brody made the jump to New Japan after the king of the super chins, Antonio Inoki, made a lucrative offer.

Inoki booked himself as borderline unbeatable, frequently bringing in gaijin beasts for the express purpose of losing to him. That just didn't work for Brody, leading to a series of brutal no-contests between the two. It was a dream match for puroresu and the savagery of their brawls blew audiences away. The finishes were spun as a reflection of the mutual hatred and their inability to fight by the rules because of it. It was great but eventually, viewers hoped there'd be a definitive winner.

After an unfortunate in-ring scuffle with Seiji Sakaguchi, Brody bailed and started no-showing. The feud was left unresolved with one final match the next year doing little to provide closure. A monumental dream match-up, Brody vs. Inoki wound up getting shafted via the enormous egos of the men involved.


9. Triple H Vs. Kurt Angle (WWE)

Triple H Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Now here was a super hot angle (no pun intended). 2000, arguably WWE's single most entertaining year, saw the rise of Kurt Angle from goofball rookie to goofball main-eventer. On his way to the world title, the Olympic Hero went to war with Triple H over his infatuation with Stephanie McMahon.

Soapy and trashy like many of the best Attitude Era storylines, Angle went out of his way to sabotage the Helmsley-McMahon marriage, even trying to convince McMahon Triple H was cheating on her with Chyna (a slightly uncomfortable moment to watch these days). Furious, Triple H sought revenge and was granted a match with Angle at Unforgiven. They cost each other the title the month prior at Summerslam and viewers were amped to see them throw down one-on-one.

Rumours have since abounded that the Cerebral Assassin was not a fan of Angle or the storyline as a whole. That might explain the odd decision to run a poor comedy segment in which Triple H implied that Angle was gay due to his crying after winning at the 96 Olympics. An abysmal moment in an otherwise great feud, it foreshadowed the disappointment ahead.

Ultimately presented as a geek compared to the Game, Angle was soundly beaten at the pay per view and the angle with Stephanie was quickly dropped. While Angle did win rematches on TV and at the next year's Royal Rumble, the feud had run cold and the wins were not clean. Despite a great start, the feud ultimately did little for either wrestler, arguably hindering Angle's first main event push.


8. Randy Orton Vs. Edge (WWE)

Raw Randy Orton Edge
WWE.com

Randy Orton cut some of the finest promos of the past 10 years in the build to his WrestleMania showdown with Edge last year. Coming off as a volatile psychopath, Orton had incendiary segments with Edge, Matt Hardy and Beth Phoenix. Back after nine long years, Edge's heroic comeback was sullied by an old pal turned bitter rival. Fans were furious and their clash was highly anticipated.

While the storyline remained exceptional, the match fell painfully flat. From Edge randomly climbing everything in sight to a distasteful hanging attempt in the Performance Centre gym, nothing really worked. The Greatest Match of All Time that followed was better but still rather odd thanks to liberties taken on the production front. With Edge taking time off for a triceps injury, Orton reignited the feud's heat by punting Edge's pal Christian. It was good enough to keep interest in a rubber match alive.

Fast forward to this year and we got exactly that when they had a surprisingly brief clash on RAW. Instead of Edge triumphantly vanquishing his foe, he picked up a tainted win because Alexa Bliss decided to puke squid ink by the ring post. A distracted Orton seems to have just forgotten about all that now a mere week later. With Edge moving on to a world title match at Mania, it appears this feud is on ice. Starting stronger than any WWE feud in the last five years, Orton vs Edge ended on a pitiful whimper. Good luck in the Firefly Funhouse Randy, you're going to need it.


7. Kento Miyahara Vs. Suwama (AJPW)

Kento Miyahara Suwama
All Japan Pro Wrestling

After several years of scarily declining business and a general lack of star power, All Japan found its new ace in the form of Kento Miyahara. Young, brash and technically skilled, Miyahara connected with audiences and ticket sales finally started moving in the right direction in 2016.

Miyahara's fourth Triple Crown reign saw him crush all challengers for an utterly insane 519 days and tie Toshiaki Kawada for most successful defences at 10. During last year's Dream Power Series, Miyahara defended against long-term nemesis, Suwama. A six-time champion, Suwama was a pseudo ace before Miyahara and many hoped this would be an official passing of the torch moment. Instead, Suwama absolutely obliterated Miyahara, taking the title and Miyahara's dream of setting a new 11-defence record.

While the result was a huge surprise, it was also counter-productive. Suwama's reign in the year since has proven unspectacular. His total destruction of Miyahara could've been a massive credibility booster for a newer star such as Jake Lee. Instead, the old guard won and nothing hugely exciting or fresh has happened since. A disappointing end to a long-running, dramatic rivalry.


6. Randy Savage Vs. Ric Flair (WWE)

Randy Savage Ric Flair
WWE

Nothing ticked off the Macho Man quite like targeting Miss Elizabeth. When Ric Flair discovered Randy Savage would be his WrestleMania VIII opponent, he did just that.

With Curt Hennig and Bobby Heenan in tow, Flair started throwing rather lewd claims out about himself and Elizabeth. The philandering Nature Boy even threatened to reveal compromising photos of the former Mrs Savage. It was all a hoax of course but one that ignited a blood feud between two of the greatest to ever do it.

Understandably miffed, Savage charged into WrestleMania for a ferocious, emotional title match with Flair. They beat the tar out of each other with Flair even blading (a forbidden act in WWE at the time) to sell his opponent’s ferocity.

Sadly, it was all downhill from there. Flair moved on to ruin Savage’s long-awaited rematch with the Ultimate Warrior at SummerSlam before regaining the belt in a lacklustre bout on Prime Time Wrestling. It was a deflating end to Savage’s second world title reign. With the return of Curt Hennig in the wings and The Ultimate Warrior out the door (again), the Savage vs. Flair dispute fizzled out after Survivor Series with Savage just kind of forgetting all the hell Flair had put him through. Flair moved on to feud with Mr Perfect in an ill-fitting babyface role before being ousted from the company. One can’t help but feel Savage sending Flair packing would’ve been much more satisfying.


5. Cactus Jack Vs. Vader (WCW)

Cactus Jack Vader
WWE.com

Mick Foley wasn't really into that whole health and wellbeing thing. Determined to take hardcore wrestling to a darker extreme than previous pioneers like Bruiser Brody and Terry Funk, Foley was prepared to take life-altering bumps to sell his craft. Potato punch king Vader was more than happy to oblige, powerbombing Foley onto concrete during their sadistic feud to set up a storyline injury. Working themselves into a shoot, Foley wound up genuinely incapacitated with a concussion and lost sensation on the left side of his body.

It was an unbelievable angle, the kind that leaves jaws on the floor. Foley had wanted the injury aspect of their feud to be played seriously. The long term plan he had was for Cactus Jack to return with a new wave of babyface sympathy for a grudge match with Vader. The top brass in WCW disagreed, believing a comedy storyline about a doddery, amnesiac Cactus Jack getting institutionalised would put more butts in seats.

None of it was funny and the decision killed the feud stone dead. At Halloween Havoc 93, they did battle in a ferocious Texas Deathmatch. While the match itself lived up to both men's reputations, the goofy direction of the storyline and the idiotic decision to make it a non-title bout despite being on PPV in the main event sapped the feud of its former strength. A criminal misuse of 2 of the toughest, grittiest SOBs on the roster.


4. Seth Rollins Vs. Dean Ambrose (WWE)

Seth Rollins Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

The 2018 rivalry between these two was nothing short of a disaster.

The 2014 one, however, began as a blistering war between two rising stars. Betraying The Shield and cashing in on that awful laugh to become a hated villain, Seth Rollins was knocking his new heel role out of the park. Dean Ambrose, the one many expected to do the aforementioned heel turn, proved to be a fantastic babyface. His passionate, vicious promos on Rollins' betrayal were emotional and nuanced in a way the often creatively sterile WWE scripting isn't. Ambrose connected with audiences everywhere and received immense support in his assault on the Architect.

Rollins escaped Ambrose's clutches time and time again lending further heat to their increasingly personal beef. By Hell In A Cell, many believed it high time Ambrose get his win back and both men move on to main event pushes. There were clues this one might go off the rails earlier on. Ambrose's bizarre mannequin promo in the lead-up was hokey and jarring for one, a goofy misstep in a storyline that boasted plentiful dramatic value.

Despite both workers putting an insane amount of effort into their grudge match, it was all for nought when resident heat killer Bray Wyatt inexplicably butted in. With assistance from a hologram, Wyatt cost Ambrose the match in a result that left fans scratching their heads. Frivolous and deflating, it was a nonsensical epilogue to a once awesome feud.


3. Hulk Hogan Vs. Nick Bockwinkel (AWA)

Hulk Hogan Nick Bockwinkel
WWE

It's important to roll with the times.

AWA owner Verne Gagne was an all-time great in the business; a top-notch NCAA amateur wrestler who hit the big bucks when he transitioned into professional wrestling. Gagne was a stickler for old -chool, technical wrestling. Babyface sensation Hulk Hogan was not.

Coming off his famous cameo in Rocky III, Hogan was hitting it big in the AWA and New Japan by 1983. His wild, larger than life promos, gargantuan physique and great showmanship left many believing him to be the next big thing. The ace of AWA at the time was Nick Bockwinkel, a master heel nearing 50. Despite Bockwinkel's exceptional workrate and longevity, it was clear audiences wanted something new. They wanted Hulkamania.

They clashed in a heated title bout where Hogan picked up the win to a booming reception. Gagne had the biggest star of the 80s in the palm of his hand but ultimately chickened out of letting him be front and centre. The decision was reversed at Super Sunday and the status quo was restored with Bockwinkel back in the driver's seat as champ.

It was a dispiriting and just plain annoying conclusion to a hot, intergenerational angle. A glimmer of hope came later that year when Gagne finally offered Hogan a proper reign. When Hogan realised it came with the condition he hand over a large fraction of his merchandising and New Japan royalties to Gagne, he packed up and moved to WWF. The Bockwinkel vs. Hogan feud was forever left on a bum note with AWA eventually going out of business.


2. John Cena Vs. CM Punk (WWE)

CM Punk John Cena belts
WWE

The Summer of Punk went out not with a bang, but with a whimper, ending on a sledgehammer ladder match between Triple H and Kevin Nash.

After going full Deadpool and breaking the fourth wall, CM Punk was the most talked about star in the whole industry. His pipe bomb promos on John Cena and Mr McMahon were unlike anything WWE had done in years and the sky appeared to be the limit for the Second City Saint.

Marching into his hometown, Punk picked up Cena's title and ditched the company in an all-time great main event. So what next for the Straight Edge Saviour? Title defences in other promotions like he'd implied? Nope. Try returning eight days later for a convoluted double champ angle with Cena (speaking of which, was Cena ever more despicable than when he beat Rey Mysterio for the title the same night Mysterio won it?).

Punk then enjoyed a series of jobs to Cena, Alberto Del Rio, Triple H and even The Miz and R-Truth tandem, making him look like a real jabroni shortly after he'd rocked the house. For something so cool and provocative initially, Punk vs. Cena got anchored down in a whole lot of Kliq nonsense and wound up doing little to spice up the WWE the way most were hoping.


1. Hulk Hogan Vs. Sting (WCW)

Sting Hogan Starrcade 97
WWE

Hogan got screwed.

In perhaps the most cumbersomely booked main event in wrestling history, the Hulkster picked up a clean win on everyone's favourite Crow cosplayer. Nick Patrick counted a standard 1-2-3 and what does he get for his fair, impartial officiating? A right hand courtesy of Bret Hart. Hart then restarts the match and Hogan submits to Sting's Scorpion Deathlock. Patrick was supposed to do a fast count but he counted on the regular with Sting still staying down for the three for some reason. Confusing, inane, disappointing, there's plenty of words for this finish but above all else, it was sad.

An 18-month build led to Starrcade '97. The silent, brooding Sting struck a chord with viewers, a fantastical antihero in the cartoonish world of the nWo. Heel Hogan had ruled the roost as WCW champ for most of that time (bar a foolish 5 day Lex Luger run) and fans were screaming for him to finally be humbled by the Stinger.

Instead of the feel-good clean victory for Sting and WCW, we got an overbooked mess with middling action, poor character work and a botched homage to the Montreal Screwjob. WCW were dominating the ratings war throughout '97 thanks to the Sting and Hogan angle. The catastrophic ending to wrestling's biggest feud was the first sign in the impending demise of Billionaire Ted's promotion. By the start of '98, Steve Austin was a hot commodity and viewers were returning to WWF in droves.

Many rumours have circulated as to why it all went bottoms up that night. Blame has landed on everything from Hogan's dreaded creative control to Sting not being tanned enough for anyone's liking.

Talk about snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.


Watch Next


Contributor

John Cunningham hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.