10 Best Big Man WWE Matches Ever

Big isn't always bad.

Big Show Braun Strowman
WWE.com

The big man vs. big match is a bizarre specialty in wrestling. Most often these showdowns are quite bad, and sometimes the scars from watching one will stick with you for a lifetime. But there’s something about the irresistible force vs. the immovable object that is strangely compelling to watch. It’s like Godzilla vs. King Kong or Mechagodzilla come to life. There's going to be a lot of destruction and a lot of punishment, even though it may not be pretty.

As stated, there have been many duds over the years when giants collide, like The Undertaker vs. Giant Gonzalez at WrestleMania IX, or The Big Show vs. Akebono or ECW’s terrifying Monster Mash Battle Royal (Bobby Pickett is still spinning in his grave over that one). Vince McMahon just loves two giant bears trying to rip each other apart, but it almost always sounds more fun than it actually is.

The reason the matches are usually so terrible, is because big guys often need a talented smaller wrestler to do most of the work. The undersized wrestler is going to be the one taking the majority of the bumps, while the larger opponent mostly stands there and looks like a killer. When you put two huge beasts against each other, you're often slowing down the speed of a regular match by half...if not more.

Still, there are exceptions in big man vs. big man matches. Now and then when two behemoths get together in the ring they’re able to create something memorable and satisfying...


10. Braun Strowman Vs. Big Show - Raw 2017

Big Show Braun Strowman
WWE.com

It’s probably a bit too soon to rank this match higher on this list, but damn, whoever thought we would get something like this from Braun Strowman? A year ago, the big man was rumored for a match against The Undertaker at WrestleMania. Fans nearly rioted over the prospect of it. Now, quite a few of them would actually look for to seeing that. Wrestling is incredibly unpredictable at times.

The two massive athletes had fought in Aug. of 2016 on Raw, and no one cared. Their second showdown received “This is awesome!” chants. A lot of credit goes to Vince for splitting Strowman up from The Wyatt Family, and for giving him a convincing singles run while protecting him nearly every step up the way. Of course, though, if Strowman was going to be the true giant in the company he had to beat the old one.

While WWE always limited Show vs. Great Khali matches to only a couple minutes long after Khali’s star had fallen, they gave Strowman plenty of time to shine in his main event spot. It was a bit clunky at times, but that’s to be expected. If anything, it made the match feel a bit more realistic. The important thing is that Show made the younger wrestler look dominant, and put him over in a way that the prior generation often hasn’t done for their successors. Strowman also shined in the bout with his unbelievable kip-up and impressive feats of strengths. To top it off, they didn’t even let Roman show him up in the post-match beat down!

Now who’s up for a rematch?


9. Hulk Hogan Vs. Andre The Giant- Showdown At Shea 1980

andre hogan shea
wwe.com

Hulk Hogan vs. Andre the Giant at WrestleMania 3 is one of the most iconic matches in wrestling history. It’s a spectacle that may never be duplicated. But from a pure technical standpoint, it was pretty terrible.

At that point in his career, Andre was largely immobile. His enormous size had taken its toll on his body, with his back barely able to handle the workload of a tag bout, let alone a singles match. However, as much as the company hyped it up as their first time facing each other, Hogan and Andre had actually battled each other many times before Vincent K. McMahon took over the company from his dad. Before that, the roles were reversed with Hogan as the cocky heel (with legendary manager Freddie Blassie at his side), and Andre as the larger-than-life babyface figure.

In 1980 at Showdown at Shea, the two titans met up in front of a huge crowd and it was pretty impressive. The match still largely consisted of punches, and simple submissions but there was an athleticism to it all that was missing years later. Andre even busted out a pair of splashes! Post-bout, Hogan opened up his opponent and made him bleed from the forehead before running off like a coward. It was a great visual to cap off the monstrous match.

Plus, there’s nothing quite like watching Andre’s wild afro in its prime, and Hogan with a decent amount of head on his hair as well.


8. The Undertaker Vs. Festus - SmackDown 2008

What often makes big man matches so unsatisfying to watch is that they lack a sense of urgency. The two behemoths exchange a series of slow punches, then cinch on a headlock and maybe hit one big move before calling it a match. When Festus met The Undertaker on an episode of SmackDown, he brought it to The Dead Man in a way that few others ever have. Yes, Festus, the future Luke Gallows.

Since it was early in his WWE run, and because he was stuck with a limited gimmick, it seemed he had something to prove in the biggest match of his career at that point. Festus moved with the speed of someone half his size, and showed a high level of intensity in his relentless attacks on the veteran. To Taker’s credit, he sold like crazy for the younger star until it was time to put him away.

Festus was still protected in defeat too, because his character didn’t understand the concept of tapping out, so instead he passed out to Taker’s submission. It’s a bit strange that management gave up on the young wrestler so quickly after this showing, as he proved that he could deliver a great big man match against the most respected wrestler in the entire company.


7. Big Show Vs. Mark Henry - Vengeance 2011

Big Show was the first member of Mark Henry’s Hall of Pain, and he didn’t seem to appreciate the induction. In fact, he wanted a little bit of vengeance for it.

In the storyline, Show’s fibula was broken, so he when he healed up he went after Henry and his World Heavyweight Championship. The two long time veterans had been in their share of matches against each other over the years on TV, mainly due to the fact that they had both been in the company since the late '90s. None of those bouts were all that memorable, but their collision at Vengeance 2011 was surprisingly pretty good!

The announcers billed them as a combined 897 lbs., and both men were looking exceptionally massive at that point in their careers. The match told an effective story, which saw Henry targeting that injured fibula, along with dishing out the occasional impressive power move. Henry and Show took each other to their limit and both kicked out of a finishing move. Something big was going to have to go down, and that's exactly what happened.

While Brock Lesnar and Big Show did the spot first, Show was superplexed by Henry and it broke the ring. Unfortunately we didn't get an actual finish to the match, but if you're going to be a little cheap with the ending, you might as well make it incredibly memorable.


6. Kane Vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania 14

Taker Kane
WWE.com

The Undertaker and Kane have fought many, many times in their career (probably too many to be honest). But their first match was their best. What that bout possessed that none of their future battles had was a sense of mystery. What would it be like when the two indestructible brothers finally locked up? What kind of hell would they unleash on each other? And how many Tombstone Piledrivers would it take to put Kane away? The answer to that last one: three.

The match itself isn’t exactly pretty. There’s a lot of kicks and punches, and a few submissions that go on too long, but it’s the atmosphere surrounding their fight that makes it so memorable. We’d seen Taker battle forgettable big men at WrestleMania in years past like King Kong Bundy and Giant Gonzalez, but none to that point had been so threatening and intriguing as his own flesh and blood.

Don’t go into this one looking for a technical classic, but it’s a satisfying big man match with one of WWE’s strongest (and admittedly most outlandish) storylines ever backing it.


5. Big Show Vs. Brock Lesnar - Judgment Day 2003

big show brock lesnar
WWE.com

In 2003, Big Show seemed like a pretty big flop in WWE. While he had held the World Title, and had a hand in main-eventing WrestleMania 2000, he didn’t feel like a larger-than-life character like Andre the Giant before him. To get fans to take him seriously again, he needed someone who could bring the best out of him, and deliver a series of good, hard-hitting matches. Brock Lesnar was that man.

The two ended up as great opponents for each other. Brock got to look like a beast by tossing his much larger opponent around, and Show had someone who could take all his punishment and get right back up for more. While their most memorable moment was that implosion of the ring on an episode of SmackDown, their best battle was in a stretcher match at Judgment Day 2003.

Usually a stretcher match is a great cause for concern, because they’re generally pretty bad. Somehow Brock and Show turned it into an art form. Just watching those two whack each other with a stretcher is pretty ridiculous fun. They were creative with the rest of their offense as well, and the finish involving a forklift was a classic ending to the brutal contest.

While the rest of the pay-per-view was pretty bad (Piper and Hogan probably shouldn't have been wrestling each other at that point in their career), the two younger wrestlers ended the night on a surprising high note.


4. Big Show Vs. The Undertaker - Cyber Sunday 2008

big show undertaker
WWE.com

The month before Cyber Sunday at No Mercy, WWE gave fans a screwy finish when Big Show knocked out Taker and the ref called for the bell. It seemed it was a way of getting The Dead Man from having to do the job in clean fashion. But the move set up their rematch at Cyber Sunday in a Last Man Standing match, and it ended up being the better outing.

Show walked into the match exceptionally cocky, thinking he had the older veteran’s number. However, Taker’s barrage of punches soon changed his mind. Both men had their working boots on, and put together a fun brawl that the crowd was engaged in throughout. Taker getting chokeslammed off the top of the ring barricade through the announce table, and Big Show taking a brutal looking DDT were among the highlights of the brawl. There was also a few chairshots to the head (luckily, it looked like both men got their hands up), which is something you won't see on TV anymore.

What makes the match even more impressive is that the two had battled years earlier over the course of multiple feuds, but it was never very good. Somehow they both got better with age, and were finally able to deliver a compelling big man battle against each other.


3. The Undertaker Vs. Diesel - WrestleMania 12

Undertaker, Diesel, WrestleMania XII
WWE.com

Kevin Nash was nearly on his way out of the WWF by the time WrestleMania 12 came around. He had been offered a huge guaranteed contract from WCW, and was getting ready to cash in. However, Vince McMahon wanted him to put over a few wrestlers before leaving, to which Nash agreed to. One of those names was The Undertaker.

Now, with Nash nearly done, you might have expected him to half-ass the match, even if it was at the biggest show of the year. That couldn’t be further from the truth. It seems that he wanted to put in a good showing on the way out, perhaps as a favor to Taker and Vince. Both men worked hard, which resulted in Diesel having one of the best outings in his entire WWF run. As soon as the bell rang the two went at it and rarely let up. You can't say that for the majority of Nash's future matches.

Eventually, Big Daddy Cool’s cockiness cost him big. He took his time after Jackknife Powerbombing Undertaker, and didn’t bother going for the pin. His arrogance gave his opponent enough time to get back into things, and a Tombstone Piledriver quickly ended Diesel's hopes of leaving the promotion on top. All in all, it was a surprisingly satisfying clash of the titans.


2. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Big Boss Man - Saturday Night’s Main Event 1989

Big Boss Man Hulk Hogan Cage Match
WWE.com

At the beginning of May 1989's episode of Saturday Night’s Main Event, Hulk Hogan vowed to pass a final sentence on The Boss Man inside of a steel cage. Lucky for millions of Hulkamaniacs around the globe, he succeeded.

To be fair, there is a pretty silly spot in the match. Boss Man should have easily won, as he was on the other side of the cage and basically just had to let go of it to win, but he was painfully stalling for an extended period of time for Hogan to get to his feet. However, this absurdness lead to Hogan superplexing his opponent off the top of the cage in a pretty incredibly spot for its time.

The rest of the match had a lot of drama and intensity behind it as well. Hogan looked like he was done for multiple times, but was able to make one of his more realistic comebacks, as opposed to just Hulking Up out of nowhere. The two worked well together, and it's a bit of a shame that Boss Man isn't really remembered as a top tier threat to Hulkamania.

While the stage was smaller, this was a much better cage match for Hogan than the one against King Kong Bundy a few years prior at WrestleMania 2. It also solidified Boss Man as one of the toughest, and all around best, big men in the company.


1. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Undertaker - No Mercy 2002

Undertaker Brock Lesnar No Mercy 2002
WWE.com

There’s something about The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar that just works so well, which is a bit odd. After all, one is a legit fighter and the other has a supernatural gimmick. Their matches should be a trainwreck, but they’re so good at what they do, and have such great chemistry together that they usually create magic.

While they’ve had some great battles over the years, their Hell in a Cell match at No Mercy 2002 was their best—and by far their most violent.

Brock had never competed in a Hell in a Cell match to that point, which should have left him at a big disadvantage, except that going into the fight Taker’s hand was “broken”, which left the veteran with a giant cast. Over the course of the match, Brock broke that cast wide open by tearing it apart after a series of chair shots. The Dead Man got in plenty of shots of his own, though, as he turned Brock into a big, bloody mess. Actually, both men heavily bled, along with Paul Heyman, just for fun!

The match showed that Taker was willing to put over a younger wrestler, and made him look like a million bucks in victory. He was also willing to take one hell of a beating to accomplish that feat. It could be a long time before we see two big men deliver a match this good again in WWE.


Contributor

As Rust Cohle from True Detective said "Life's barely long enough to get good at one thing. So be careful what you're good at." Sadly, I can't solve a murder like Rust...or change a tire, or even tie a tie. But I do know all the lyrics to Hulk Hogan's "Real American" theme song and can easily name every Natural Born Thriller from the dying days of WCW. I was once ranked 21st in the United States in Tetris...on the Playstation 3 version...for about a week. Follow along @AndrewSoucek and check out my podcast at wrestlingwithfriends.com