10 Best Matches From WrestleMania 35 Weekend

Cole vs. Gargano, Kofi vs. Bryan, and all the best action from a New York City.

Adam Cole Johnny Gargano Kofi Kingston Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

There's no busier time of year to be a wrestling fan than WrestleMania weekend, and 2019's was one of the most chaotic ever as all manner of promotions descended upon New York for five nights of nonstop action.

Dozens of shows took place across NY and neighbouring New Jersey from Wednesday to Sunday, as has become tradition, and your writer can't claim to have seen them all. Still, what he did see was some of the finest matches that'll take place in 2019, coming from a special G1 Supercard in Madison Square Garden, the best NXT TakeOver yet, a bombastic WrestleMania, and all manner of wild independent shows.

Honourable mentions are many. Dozens of awesome bouts went down over WrestleMania weekend. It's impossible to mention them all, so it's with apologies to Matt Riddle vs. Velveteen Dream (TakeOver), Josh Barnett vs. Minoru Suzuki (GCW), and Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Zack Sabre Jr. (G1 Supercard) that we acknowledge their excellence even though they couldn't make the cut.

There's a danger that WrestleMania weekend is close to breaking point, but who could possibly complain about the volume of shows with a Greatest Hits compilation this good?

10. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Jay White (NJPW/ROH G1 Supercard)

Kazuchika Okada Jay White
NJPW

Authenticity was part of what made NJPW's contributions to the G1 Supercard so special, and Jay White vs. Kazuchika Okada was the foremost example of this.

It would've been easy for the headliners to bow to the show's overall feel after the chaos of the three-way ladder match, Enzo Amore and Big Cass' invasion, Tetsuya Naito vs. Kota Ibushi, and that PCO bump. Instead, they stuck to the modern New Japan main event style. That meant going back to first gear after the previous match had finished in sixth, then slowly working through the speeds with gradual escalation, building to a riveting closing stretch that had the crowd more invested than at any other point in the show.

While not as visceral as their Wrestle Kingdom 13 clash, this measured IWGP Heavyweight Championship battle was highlighted by White's incredible heel work. He has become one of the biggest weasels in the game. Here, he schemed and shortcutted his way to the verge of victory several times, though he'd eventually fall to 'The Rainmaker' for the very first time, as Okada sealed his redemption inside Madison Square Garden.


9. Will Ospreay Vs. Bandido (WrestleCon Supershow)

Bandido Will Ospreay
FITE.tv/WrestleCon

If you want an accurate idea of how this match was paced, Will Ospreay hit a Spanish Fly, Space Flying Tiger Drop, and Shooting Star Press within the first 30 seconds. We sh*t you not.

That opening sentence should help decide whether or not this match is for you. It featured all manner of high spots from two of the world's best high-flyers, who held nothing back at the conclusion of WrestleCon's Mark Hitchcock Memorial Supershow on Thursday. It wasn't all cocaine, all of the time though: this bout was defined by sharp, rhythmic pulses. Ospreay and Bandido settled into a slower groove on several occasions, only to come back to life with beautiful bursts of athletic violence. There were counters to counters to counters. At one point, Ospreay gets aggravated with the crowd ("this is the f*ckin' WrestleCon main event!") which only enhances his in-ring aggression, prompting the aspirational heavyweight to launch into a striking battle with the rising luchador.

A thrilling clash closes with Bandido somehow kicking out of the Oscutter, before falling to Ospreay's Stormbreaker. The recent ROH signing then outdid himself a few nights later...


8. Dragon Lee Vs. Bandido Vs. Taiji Ishimori (NJPW/ROH G1 Supercard)

Bandido Dragon Lee
NJPW

A wild gifsplosion of an IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championship match, Ishimori vs. Bandido vs. Dragon Lee was shorter than expected at just 8:54, but still hit all the highs fans had anticipated when the bout was first put together.

It was as if the hyper-athletic trio had taken an 18-minuter and condensed it into half that. In that way, it was reminiscent of last year's ALL IN main event and, like that bout, it may have been a better contest because of it. With no room for flab, the ROH/NJPW trio were forced go all out. They barely stopped throughout. Their three-way was a relentless storm of Destroyers, dives, counters, and Hurricanranas. It was a whirlwind of excitement. They played off each other like experts, with one wrestler's move feeding into another's, and the end product was almost as overwhelming as New York City itself.

The most impressive spot saw Bandido lift Lee and Ishimori for his top rope Moonsault slam, then flip himself backwards to drive both into the mat. He couldn't seal the victory, but he did deliver his latest star-enhancing performance in a year full of them.


7. Daisuke Sasaki Vs. Konosuke Takeshita (DDT Is Coming To America)

Daisuke Sasaki Konosuke Takeshita
DDTPro.com/Scott Finklestein

DDT Is Coming To America was quietly one of WrestleMania weekend's best shows, with the cult Japanese promotion delivering an uncompromised version of their weird and wonderful product on US soil, meshing Shinsuke Nakamura impersonators with big beefy hosses, Joey Ryan's d*ck with blow-up dolls, and cartoonish undercard action with a world-class main event.

It speaks volumes of Daisuke Sasaki and Konosuke Takeshita's ability and star power that they were able to hold the crowd's interest with a limb isolation match after all that chaos. Sasaki ravaged the KO-D Openweight Champion's leg, diving deep into his bag of heel tricks to do so, laying the foundations for a match that grew increasingly destructive by the minute.

These two were trying to kill each other by the end. Sasaki has a way of bumping on his neck/shoulders that makes every move look even more brutal than it should, and his disregard for his own health and safety is something else. At one point he leapt from the top rope, over the barricade, and onto a floored Takeshita with an elbow drop. The thud was as gross as the spot was awesome.


6. Jeff Cobb Vs. Will Ospreay (NJPW/ROH G1 Supercard)

Jeff Cobb Will Ospreay
NJPW

The G1 Supercard proper kicked off with a perfect shot of adrenaline, as Jeff Cobb bet his ROH Television Championship against Will Ospreay's NEVER Openweight strap in the night's first title vs. title contest.

This was straight-up superhero sh*t. Cobb, who might be the strongest wrestler in the sport, tossed Ospreay around like an empty tracksuit (h/t WhatCulture's Adam Nicholas). His indomitable power game formed the bulk of his offence, while Ospreay's prodigious athleticism saw him adopt a gameplan that was one part evasion, one part speed, and another part blunt force. Such is 'The Assassin' in 2019: far from a one-dimensional flyer, he's out to prove he can go blow-for-blow with guys like Big Jeff.

Here's the thing: he can't. Yet. Taken down in a match resembling the Battle of New York from the first Avengers film, Will's transition to heavyweight was halted when Cobb put him away with an earth-shaking top rope Tour of the Islands. Jeff's blend of power and agility (highlighted by a 260lb standing Shooting Star Press) was too much for him. Ospreay will recover and grow stronger, though he can rest safe in the knowledge that he popped the hell out of Madison Square Garden.


5. War Raiders Vs. Ricochet & Aleister Black (NXT TakeOver: New York)

War Raiders Aleister Black Ricochet NXT TakeOver New York 2
WWE Network

This match probably deserves a higher placement. Knowing that he had this specific article to piece together after flying back to the UK, your writer had it pegged for a spot in the top three by the time the final bell had rung, only for the remaining four bouts to come along and throw everything out of whack.

Regardless, War Raiders vs. Aleister Black and Ricochet was an all-out banger.

The in-match storytelling was sublime from minute one. A respectful showdown between two popular tandems, it saw the four grapplers continually counter their way out of each other's moves and holds. Later, they started mirroring their opposite numbers. War Raiders mimicking Black's trademark running back roll was particularly impressive, and it never felt like the teams were taking the p*ss: rather, they were trying to catch each other off-guard.

Both sides started dropping the expected big bombs in the second half, and it raced to the kind of breathless conclusion War Raiders excel at. They are in-ring berzerkers in every sense. The sense of urgency they create is unparalleled in tag wrestling, while Black and Ricochet are two of the most exciting wrestlers in America. Of course this delivered.


4. Pete Dunne Vs. WALTER (NXT TakeOver: New York)

WALTER Pete Dunne NXT TakeOver New York
WWE

Pete Dunne vs. WALTER captured the all-important big fight feel as well as any other match over WrestleMania weekend. Almost two years into his reign as United Kingdom Champion, 'The Bruiserweight' faced a new kind of challenge in 'Der Ringgeneral,' who was presented like a monster movie villain. Casting a stark, black silhouette against his entrance's bright white backdrop, he was a challenge unlike anything Dunne had faced across his 19 previous defences - and so it transpired.

WALTER battered Dunne in the early stages. Pete couldn't figure this new puzzle out, and didn't come alive until abandoning his cautious gameplan for pure, righteous fury. His fire brought the crowd alive. He destroyed WALTER's fingers to the point where the big Austrian couldn't execute his signature chops anymore, and it's to Pete's credit that his opponent was forced to dive deep into his arsenal to end this incredible reign, finishing 'The Bruiserweight' with a top-rope Powerbomb (that saw Pete fly three-quarters of the way across the ring) and a big splash.

If there's one criticism, it's that the minutiae of this tight, detailed European-style match didn't quite connect with the arena. If it had, Dunne vs. WALTER would be a modern WWE classic.


3. Adam Cole Vs. Johnny Gargano (NXT TakeOver: New York)

Cole Gargano
WWE.com

TakeOver: New York's main event the first WWE match to ever break Dave Meltzer's star rating system in this week's Wrestling Observer Newsletter, scoring an outstanding *****½. Whether or not you put stock into the big man's scores is up to you: still, it's hard to argue that the final fall was anything but first-class, state-of-the-art pro-wrestling.

It's unfortunate, then, that the first fall was so dry. It was a nondescript good wrestling match between two outstanding performers, the likes of which you'd see on any episode of Raw or SmackDown or main roster pay-per-view. The second was marginally better, and the third outstanding. This makes it impossible for this writer to score Adam Cole vs. Johnny Gargano any higher, but those last ten minutes were impeccable, and Johnny Champion's overdue triumph felt like a huge moment.

That these were able to turn the crowd from their partisan pro-Cole stance to actively rooting for Johnny's triumph by the end speaks volumes of their skill. They laid out the perfect match for this specific victory, with every character beat and kicking out serving a coronation that'll be replayed on highlight packages for years to come.


2. Kofi Kingston Vs. Daniel Bryan (WrestleMania 35)

WWE WrestleMania 35 Daniel Bryan Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

The best WrestleMania match since Brock Lesnar and Roman Reign's big beefy battle at 31, Daniel Bryan vs. Kofi Kingston was the near-perfect realisation of a perfect story, and an impeccable battle between the ultimate babyface underdog and a complete piece-of-sh*t heel.

It was the kind of bout that makes every cynical WWE promo on "making history" or "creating moments" feel worth it. This was history, and it was a moment, but unlike much of what escapes WWE's creative department at this time of year, none of it felt forced. Kingston's triumph was the culmination of a rise that wouldn't have happened had Ali not been injured pre-Elimination Chamber. WWE sensed the surge, listened to their fans, and capitalised, and the emotion that pulsed through the MetLife stadium as Kofi celebrated with his friends and family begs the question of why they don't book things like this more often.

Credit to the performers, too: both were excellent here. Bryan was at his brilliant best, creating a heart-stopping moment with every single near-fall, while Kingston scrapped with every fibre of his being. The new champion left nothing in the tank in what is sure to become a WrestleMania classic.


1. Tetsuya Naito Vs. Kota Ibushi (NJPW/ROH G1 Supercard)

Kota Ibushi Tetsuya Naito
NJPW

NJPW and ROH brought a stacked card to Madison Square Garden on 6 April, but no match was more hotly anticipated than Kota Ibushi vs. Tetsuya Naito.

A rematch of their career-shortening New Japan Cup war, it exceeded every lofty expectation by taking the previous clash to the next level in terms of drama, excitement, and danger. Yes, there were head-drops, and yes, they enhanced the action despite their inherent ghoulishness. This will make the bout a tough watch even for those with strong stomachs for such violence, though your writer would argue that this is what makes these bouts so special.

Wrestlers like Naito and Ibushi work on the edge of control. They succeed by creating an unparalleled sense of jeopardy, and the feeling that the brutality could reach unfathomable levels by the end. These guys want you to think that one of them is leaving with a broken neck, basically. It generates the kind of peril we don't often get from a sport exposed as "fake" decades ago, and the margin for error is as thin as the skill level is high.

Big bombs were dropped, sick bumps were taken, and fans were wowed. Naito was the most over wrestler your writer saw live all weekend. He lost as Ibushi scored his first major NJPW singles title, but his popularity is bulletproof. New Japan must push him harder than ever in 2019.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.