10 Best Wrestlers Of 2021
Roman Reigns, Kenny Omega, Shingo Takagi, Bryan Danielson, Syuri... where do they rank?
2021 breathed life back into professional wrestling in the US. Promotions welcomed full live crowds back during the summer, ending over a year of sterile atmospheres to the sport's immediate benefit. COVID-19 is still here, its myriad concerns remain, but the viewing experience is infinitely better than this time last year.
Things are different in Japan, where audiences are still prevented from loudly singing, chanting, and cheering. This harms show quality and makes it difficult for wrestlers to deliver their best work. Inversely, it makes the efforts of those that rose above and delivered Wrestler of the Year calibre work all the more impressive.
Form is critical on this list. Regardless of skill, a wrestler can't enter the WOTY conversation if they aren't regularly producing WOTY-level work. Names like Sasha Banks, Kazuchika Okada, and Tomohiro Ishii, all of whom are amongst this generation's finest, didn't make the cut, despite the occasional high.
An impressive body of work is important, though this is more than a list of wrestlers with the most ****+ matches. Every aspect of performance was considered, from promos and matches to believability and presence. Consistency was given as much weight as ceilings and floors. Wrestlers' importance to their home promotions and the business as a whole also factored, as well as their significance to the year's wider wrestling discussions.
For notable omissions, check the list of honourable mentions towards the end.
Let's go...
10. Nick Jackson
In the United States, the year's best title reign belonged not to a singles wrestler, but a tandem.
The Young Bucks had an excellent year as AEW World Tag Team Champions. 302 days elapsed before they passed them over to The Lucha Brothers in an acclaimed steel cage war at All Out 2021. Since then, the brothers Jackson have assumed a role further down the card but have continued to excel in a 12-month period yielding excellent work opposite teams as diverse as Jurassic Express, Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley, SoCal Uncensored, The Dark Order, and more.
That the belts felt more important on the night the Bucks lost them than when they took them from FTR in November 2020 cements 2021 as a great year for Matt and Nick. They have found themselves as characters, too, perfecting the obnoxious pr*ck personas they once worked in NJPW, ROH, and on the indies, becoming impossible to root for despite their adrenaline-pumping style.
Nick remains the more impressive of the two, hence why he pips his brother here. This is partly by design, as Matt works a more measured style to contrast with his sibling. Nick, meanwhile, is a freak athlete, an irritant supreme, and also has a wonderful Rampage singles match with Bryan Danielson to bolster his case.
The Bucks will never be for everyone - but nobody is. Nonetheless, for those he connects with, Nick re-emerged as one of his generation's finest tag workers in 2021.
9. Hangman Page
Adam Page doesn't have the mountain of great 2021 matches that some wrestlers on this list possess. At Double Or Nothing, the future AEW World Champion and Brian Cage were tasked with opening AEW's first fully-attended main pay-per-view card in over a year, doing so with an adrenaline-pumping banger, while Page and Kenny Omega's Full Gear main event was extremely well-received and successfully paid-off one of the best multi-year character arcs ever. Beyond these, Page has a handful of great multi-man bouts and tight television matches with the likes of Powerhouse Hobbs and Ricky Starks to his name.
But what Page lacks in obvious Match of the Year candidates, he more than makes up for in the other aspects of his performances.
The aforementioned character arc was sublime. The 'Anxious Millennial Cowboy' wasn't shtick for Page, who did what all the best wrestling personalities do and brought a real, authentic version of his true self to television. For his portrayal of anxiety, depression, and other afflictions, and the way he navigated them to eventually become World Champion, he has become one of the easiest wrestlers in the world to root for - and Full Gear was a finale befitting the excellent journey leading to it.
With the best story in modern American wrestling still ongoing, Page faces new challenges as AEW World Champion. Time will tell if he is a success in this role. For now, delivering performances on par with his outstanding writing earns Page this spot following his year of triumph and tragedy.
8. Tam Nakano
Though rostermates Utami Hayashishita and Syuri have drawn wider critical acclaim in 2021, Tam Nakano is the most complete wrestler in Stardom and has been a constant highlight in an excellent in-ring year for the promotion.
Only 33 years old herself but a grizzled veteran compared to a Stardom roster populated by ultra-talented early-twentysomethings, Nakano has in-ring chops on par with anyone working the joshi scene at the moment. She is an adaptable wrestler with great range, whose best matches (vs. Giulia in a hair vs. hair bout, vs. Takumi Iroha in the 5STAR Grand Prix, and vs. Hayashishita in the same tournament) all feel distinct from one another. Even the greatest wrestlers become formulaic from time to time, but not Tam. Her series with company ace Mayu Iwatani scarcely resembled April's disrespectful clash with Natsupoi.
But what sets Nakano apart, particularly in 2021, are the non-athletic components of her wrestling performances. Tam is a tremendous actress. Her facial expressions and selling are elite tier, few do as good a job as making each match feel as intense and personal, and she emerges from every battle looking like she has marched through hell to get there. Doing all of this without coming across as melodramatic is no mean feat. Tam, in 2021, is close to mastering that balancing act.
7. Roman Reigns
WWE's star attraction from the moment he returned last summer, Roman Reigns has enjoyed a dominant year - and the best of his career to date.
Reigns feels gigantic. Finally presented in a singles role befitting his skillset, he is twenty feet tall when he comes down the ramp, having cultivated an aura and gravitas WWE has been chasing in a top guy for years. It's still frustrating that it took so long to get to this point, of course, and that so much of Reigns' career was wasted on failed babyface pushes will always sting, but he's here now. 'The Guy' is in his finest (but hopefully not final) form.
Roman is confident, assured, and at his best, captivating. Headlining the world's biggest promotion as a villain feels natural to him. Always an underrated wrestler who spaced out his big, explosive spots to great effect, he is currently delivering the best in-ring work of his career within this role. Matches with Daniel Bryan, Edge, and Cesaro tracked as some of 2021's finest. That he has become such a good talker as well means Roman's WOTY case is easy to make.
But that his week-to-week segments often rely on hammy wrestling over-acting, melodrama, and repetitive formulas hurts his positioning. So too do the matches that didn't deliver. Royal Rumble's Kevin Owens match was a hackneyed plunder brawl with only a couple of memorable spots and a damaging botched finish, the Edge bout at Money in the Bank was greatly overcooked, and the long-awaited Survivor Series clash with Big E was a big letdown. Good when it should have been great, that last match suffered for a lack of crowd investment that the absolute best workers would force from a crowd. Reigns, even when speaking directly to the gathered masses, couldn't do that in Brooklyn.
6. Will Ospreay
A divisive figure he remains, but the volume of acclaimed work delivered by Will Ospreay in a shorter window than most of his peers this year is extremely impressive.
2021 saw the 28-year-old score the biggest honour of his career to date by besting Kota Ibushi to become IWGP World Heavyweight Champion. It's a new belt with a complicated lineage and undermined somewhat by the way it came into existence, but New Japan put its trust in Ospreay as the company's top guy this spring.
Ospreay's Takagi matches are destined to finish highly on many a Match of the Year lists. Beyond that are Will's outstanding Wrestle Kingdom effort opposite Okada, a typically impressive bout with Zack Sabre Jr. to continue their long feud, and elevatory performances against up-and-comers Ricky Knight Jr. and Michael Oku in the United Kingdom, both of whom had the best matches of their career with Ospreay.
If his style works for you, Ospreay is an obvious WOTY candidate. Objectively, too, he has done a good job of growing over the years, physically and in terms of the way he wrestles, as while he definitely performs in a way custom calibrated to draw acclaim, he is becoming less reliant on dazzling feats of athleticism and sugar highs. This will serve him well as his career progresses.
The character, ultimately, is what holds Ospreay back from the top five. Apeing Conor McGregor's shtick isn't convincing when Becky Lynch does it on WWE Raw and it isn't convincing here either. Ospreay's flashiness and promos feel forced, not natural. Perhaps this will improve with time, but for now, his presentation is the opposite of the next guy on our list.
5. Eddie Kingston
Eddie Kingston's 2021 has been immensely gratifying for anybody following his career, whether they were with him before AEW or not. He is the realest, most believable, and most authentic wrestler in the world, which makes it incredibly easy to form a connection with him. Any perceived weaknesses go out the window whenever he throws down with an opponent or spits his truth on the microphone. You are drawn in, immediately, because there isn't a line between Edde Kingston, The Man, and Eddie Kingston, The TV Star.
A strong early 2021 saw Kingston find a good role alongside Jon Moxley. Coming out of the pandemic and after grinding himself to dust for the best part of two decades, he would have felt incredible when Daily's Place received him like a hero at Double Or Nothing, where he and Mox battled The Young Bucks in a raucous Tag Team Title match. It's the past few months that really cement King's case, though, and now, Eddie is undeniable.
Opposite CM Punk, Kingston leveraged history to deliver a crash course in how to generate heat and interest for a feud on less than two weeks' notice. The Miro match was a wild, bellicose fight that inadvertently spawned the meme of the year. Then, against Bryan Danielson, King worked another of the year's absolute best bouts, further proving him one of the game's finest in-ring storytellers.
Kingston makes you want to live and die for him. He inspires levels of devotion any wrestler would love to have and now, with his support so strong he turned a building against CM Punk, it'd be a disappointment if he didn't win the big one in 2022.
4. Syuri
The best and most consistent in-ring performer in the best and most consistent in-ring all-women promotion in the world.
Signing with Stardom in October 2020 has allowed Syuri's pro wrestling career to take off like never before. She has worked at least one bout this year that will be talked about forever, thanks to the lavish praise thrown its way by wrestling's most influential tastemakers, and could potentially throw down another by the year's end. Should her trilogy with fellow 2021 standout Utami Hayashishita wrap as impressively as it began on 12 June, the rivalry will come to be known as one of the modern era's great in-ring series - if it isn't already.
Beyond the Utami matches, Syuri has delivered excellence with talents as diverse as freelancer Takumi Iroha, 21-year-old wunderkind Momo Watanabe, uber-technician Konami, and a relative rookie in Maika. Her efforts have helped elevate SWA World Championship to a previously unforeseen level of prestige, legitimising what was once considered Stardom's black sheep belt by fighting for it like her life is on the line. Never before has the strap felt so big and important, which is to Syuri's credit.
A hybrid fighter who transitions between pro wrestling and MMA techniques, Syuri brings a different flavour to Stardom's house style that helps stave off the ongoing Bushiroadification elsewhere. This, combined with her intensity, emotional core, and poise, makes everything she does must-watch.
3. Shingo Takagi
While NJPW's current problems stretch beyond pandemic-related restrictions, said restrictions are still unquestionably one of the biggest factors behind the company's diminished show quality.
Clap crowds are no fun. They're an unfortunate necessity and reality in this era, and have likely helped stave off COVID's creep at Japanese live events, but while the safety concerns make them easy to accept, they still hurt the shows. Events aren't as enjoyable when the audience's noise levels can't meet the effort put forth in the ring, with the environment particularly detrimental to New Japan's house style, which isn't as stiff as, say, NOAH's.
Shingo Takagi is the one NJPW wrestler who appears to be immune to this.
The reigning IWGP World Heavyweight Champion has had an outstanding year despite his environment's obvious limitations. It helps that he's such a robust, dynamic performer and hits harder than almost anyone else on his roster, but this shouldn't be used to reduce The Dragon's 2021 accomplishments, and nor should the lack of impressive individual bodies of work elsewhere on that roster.
Starting the year with a bang opposite Jeff Cobb, Takagi has demonstrated his range with details-first showings against Hiroshi Tanahashi, bombastic displays in the Will Ospreay series, a war of attrition with fellow hammer-thrower Tomohiro Ishii, and a struggle of brawn vs. technique against Zack Sabre Jr. He carries himself like he owns every building he walks into and has a charisma that fills even these sparsely-populated, noiseless spaces. Hopefully, what he has done this year will warrant continued focus in 2021, as nobody is currently doing more to keep NJPW watchable.
2. Kenny Omega
No matter how much credit Kenny Omega gets for what he accomplished in 2021, it won't be enough, given what we now know about the man's physical state.
The former AEW World Champion is hopefully set for a long, restorative period away from the squared circle. Battling multiple shoulder injuries, a hernia, knee problems, vertigo, and likely other things that haven't been disclosed, he has fought on regardless, determined not to take time off until the time was right. So dedicated is Kenny to his craft that he held it together until early November, knowing Full Gear would be the perfect place to hand his belt to 'Hangman' Adam Page. Celebrated matches with Rey Fenix, Christian Cage, Bryan Danielson, and Jungle Boy, an exploding barbed-wire deathmatch, countless incendiary tag and trios matches - he did them all while his body is thrashed.
What's frustrating about Kenny is that while his ceiling is as high as anyone else in wrestling, it comes with occasional baggage. There's a wackiness to him, particularly in his character work, that occasionally undermines his status as a top, top guy. While he likely had fun dressing up as a Ghostbuster with his mates, it makes him look like a jester when he should be the king. The same goes for telling nursery rhymes with Michael Nakazawa in a class of toddlers, the over-the-top facial expressions, cartoon-ish vocal inflexions, and other moments of goofiness.
It's important to highlight this counterargument because the rest of Omega's WOTY case is so strong. While not as explosive and dynamic as he was pre-injuries, his best work still pops and cracks, and his eye for details big and small gets better with age. He is, absolutely, one of the best in the world.
Just not the best.
Honourable Mentions...
Listed in no specific order, the following wrestlers came close to cracking this year's top ten.
In WWE, Bobby Lashley had a career-best year, as the company finally cracked a dominant formula for main event success. With her Royal Rumble and WrestleMania 37 wins and matches with Sasha Banks, Bayley, and Becky Lynch, Bianca Belair's highs were stunning, though she spent too much of 2021 in a booking mire for further consideration. Edge delivered age and body-defying big-match performances in various feuds, though risible week-to-week overacting prevents his placement.
Britt Baker remains amongst AEW's strongest characters but lacks the in-ring body of work for contention. Darby Allin came close, having made even Billy Gunn look good this year. A special case is CM Punk, who has only been back since August but dominated the wrestling conversation in summer and fall and peaked when positioned opposite Allin and Eddie Kingston. Rey Fenix was his usual dazzling self too, with his Kenny Omega and best tag work prominent on many a Match of the Year rundown. Promo-wise, MJF demonstrated himself as one of the best in the business week after week, and his in-ring résumé is catching up as well.
For his work on the indies (particularly in Limitless, where he was an excellent heel champion) and AEW, Daniel Garcia came mighty close. His time on lists like this will assuredly come.
In Japan, Utami Hayashishita continues to prove her mettle as Stardom's new figurehead while company ace Mayu Iwatani had another great year, albeit not as spectacular as her 2021, owing to her positioning. Yuki Ueno continued his DDT ascent as one of the world's most promising high-flyers and babyfaces. That company's ace, Konosuke Takeshita, was remarkably consistent, as was the legendary Jun Akiyama with and without the KO-D Openweight Championship. NJPW had a tough year creatively, but Zack Sabre Jr. transcended much of it, particularly in the G1 Climax.
Tsukasa Fujimoto had one of the year's best title reigns atop Ice Ribbon, while Suzu Suzuki's rise to deathmatch credibility was as compelling as anything else in Japan. NOAH's Katsuhiko Nakajima, meanwhile, finally came of age as a top champion, having built the aura to match his prodigious skillset.
Anywhere, here's the wrestler of the year...
1. Bryan Danielson
In 2021, Bryan Danielson...
... was the most consistent television wrestler in WWE, working a Cesaro mini-feud that was as compelling between the ropes in three minutes as it was in 10, then delivering an underrated series of bangers opposite Jey Uso, setting him up for entry into the WrestleMania 37 program.
... saved a WrestleMania Universal Title that was drier than unbuttered toast as a singles feud. Despite their perceived stardom, Roman Reigns and Edge struggled to raise excitement and engagement for what would become a night two main event, with television ratings struggling to creep beyond the norm. Edge had one particularly bad week where he bombed three individual shows (Raw, NXT, and SmackDown) while teasing which title he'd challenge for after Royal Rumble 2021. Bryan added immediate creative juice and anchored the Triple Threat at 'Mania itself, glueing Edge's hard work and Reigns' bombast together in an excellent bout.
... hooked the world on a stipulation jaded wrestling fans haven't been able to invest in for decades, putting his WWE career up against Roman's Universal strap.
... remained integral to the pro wrestling conversation while inactive for four months. Even when not on television, speculation on Danielson's future made him as relevant as anybody competing on Raw, SmackDown, or Dynamite.
... helped lead AEW to its most successful pay-per-view of all time in All Out 2021. Many of those 205,000 buys will have come from the appeal of CM Punk's first wrestling match in seven years, though Danielson (and Adam Cole to a lesser extent) potentially showing up was unquestionably a factor as well. The debut itself was sensational, too, with Danielson's arrival the knockout blow in a one-two punch with Cole.
... reprised his most compelling character as the American Dragon, a borderline sociopathic competitor driven by the unflinching desire to prove himself the best in the world, whose willingness to operate as nastily as he can without breaking obvious rules (or becoming flat-out evil) allows him to operate effectively on either side of the alignment scale.
... demonstrated unparalleled range between the ropes. Danielson has the Terry Funk gene in that he is as tremendous a face as he is a hell. He's as great in five minutes as he is 35, a world-class singles and tag wrestler, with a firm grasp of every style imaginable. Big-time bouts with Minoru Suzuki, Kenny Omega, Roman Reigns, and more stand amongst the best matches of 2021 anywhere in the world. In more concise midcard offerings with Cesaro, Jey Uso, Alan Angels, Evil Uno, and almost everyone he has faced, Bryan has kept a higher floor than anyone else currently wrestling. This is his truest strength. He never misses, no matter how small the stage.
... brought out a side of Kenny Omega not seen since his New Japan days. Kenny was animalistic opposite Danielson at Grand Slam, throwing knees at Bryan's skull with concussive propulsiveness to leverage real-life knowledge of the former WWE man's concussion history into perfect pro wrestling drama. Never before in AEW had Omega looked so fierce - and it took a competitor like Bryan to draw it out of him.
... gave some of the best wrestlers in the world their finest matches of 2021, including Roman Reigns, Edge, Omega, Minoru Suzuki, Eddie Kingston, and more.
... expertly dialled up some of his character's more unpleasant traits without turning full-on heel opposite 'Hangman' Adam Page. The two-year journey fans have been on with Page necessitated him having full support heading into Winter Is Coming. Cognizant of this, Danielson tapped into his inner bastard without overcooking a thing, working the audience with every new beat. And if he wants to, he can shake hands with Page and go back to being less of a pr*ck post-WIC without it feeling in the least bit unnatural. That's a worker.
And that's WhatCulture's Wrestler of the Year 2021.