10 Best WWE Hell In A Cell Matches EVER - According To Dave Meltzer

Cage Of Enlightenment

Batista Triple H
WWE.com

Bastardised conclusively by the annual pay-per-view event that bears its name, the Hell In A Cell match was once the logical extension to the cage match when only the most fearsome environment could contain a rivalry. Introduced with a match you'll read about at the top end of this list, it now stands merely as a monument to be trotted out when the calendar requires it, rather than conflict.

Truthfully, it's just another sad reality of the more-is-always-more content-heavy WWE of 2017. Superserving audiences almost to a fault, the persistent use of the gimmick over the past decade particularly has done more harm than good, as evidenced by some of the quality contests on display long before the battleground became little more than a forced fixture.

WWE don't always satisfy Wrestling Observer overlord Dave Meltzer, but Hell In A Cell matches maintained an astonishingly consistent level of quality before the concept became an overloaded means to an end instead of the 'Devil's Playground' it always should have remained.

Guts, glory, gore and gratuity are in high supply, with a rich history of heroics and hedonism from the match that once upon a time promised heaven as well as hell.

(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match gets preferential treatment. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest outperforming a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)

10. Batista Vs The Undertaker (Survivor Series 2007, ****)

Batista undertaker survivor series 2008
WWE.com

One of four Match-Of-The-Year candidates between the pair in 2007, the Survivor Series finale between Undertaker and Batista was in many ways a perfect variant of the match.

As a standalone contest, it was objectively excellent. Big Dave and 'The Deadman' redefined what it meant to be superheavyweights in the mid-2000s. Dispelling longstanding criticisms first with their show-stealing WrestleMania 23 and surpassing expectations in every future match they'd have, the giants worked at breakneck pace for performers their size, but never sacrificed the necessary physicality.

Away from the nuts and bolts of the battle though, it was also the end of two loose narrative threads and the start of a brand new one that would ultimately conclude in identical fashion several months later.

After a predictably gruelling war, a returning Edge made his mark disguised as a ringside cameraman. Removing the referee before he could register a certain three-count for Undertaker, the 'Rated-R Superstar' punctuated his vicious return with a camera shot and con-chair-to. Gifting one arch-rival the World Title in an act of spiteful revenge against the man he blamed for his injury absence, Edge closed the book on his story with Batista, as well as the 'Animal's own tale with 'Taker.


9. Brock Lesnar Vs The Undertaker (No Mercy 2002, ****)

brock lesnar undertaker chair HIAC
WWE.com

Though Dave Meltzer would narrowly prefer their Cell sequel 13 years removed from the 2002 vintage (more on that later), Brock Lesnar's No Mercy 2002 victory over The Undertaker marked the true moment he embedded himself deeply within the psyche of Vince McMahon as a main eventer for life.

Victory over The Rock at SummerSlam had propelled Lesnar to the summit, but it was a foundation built on mountainous selflessness from 'The Great One'. Such candour wasn't shared by 'The Deadman' a month later, when a listless Unforgiven main event ended with Undertaker hauling the 'Next Big Thing' through the prop stage like he was disposing of household waste.

As ineffective and insecure as he was at the time, Undertaker may have actually felt that way about 'The Beast;. 2002 needed a star like Lesnar, and Vince McMahon was clearly mindful of the fact. Few if any prior stars had been afforded such such a rapid ascent.

Thankfully, memories of the disappointing display washed away in rivers of blood. Both champion and challenger spouted claret in an evenly matched war (still a shock to see in an Undertaker match even then) en route to a dramatic finale that saw Lesnar triumphantly hold the title aloft atop the structure - the undisputed new king of the jungle.


8. Brock Lesnar Vs The Undertaker (Hell In A Cell 2015, ****1/4)

Brock Lesnar Undertaker
WWE.com

As evidenced by his p*ss-weak WrestleMania encounters with Bray Wyatt, Shane McMahon and Roman Reigns, The Undertaker had little left to give to the organisation grown partially on the back of his incredible legacy.

Crocking him with a legitimate concussion en route to ending his fabled undefeated streak at WrestleMania 30, it was as though Brock Lesnar really had humanised 'The Deadman' when a third F5 left him flat on the mat in New Orleans.

Repeated uses of an almighty hoof to the balls only furthered the impression, as Undertaker embraced a decidedly heelish veneer in his 2015 return clashes with 'The Beast'. Attempting to tell a tale of an overmatched veteran and an indifferent destroyer (because that's exactly what it was), the story stumbled out of the blocks thanks to a hokey finish in their SummerSlam 2015 topliner.

Hell In A Cell would bring their rivalry and 'Taker's relevance full circle. Tearing away strips of the canvas as if to imply that even the 'Devil's Playground' was still too gentle on their fierce hatred, the pair energetically fought to a finish that offered little doubt as to who the company's conqueror was going into the second half of the decade.

Undertaker nobly survived a host of suplexes, but fell victim to his own tactic in the closing stages. Brock gave the aged star an almighty low blow, before hitting his F5 on the boards the pair had previously exposed.


7. Edge Vs The Undertaker (SummerSlam 2008, ****1/2)

Undertaker, Edge
WWE.com

Just over a decade before the SummerSlam 2008 show-closer, 'Hell In A Cell' was as much a term to describe Shawn Michaels' personal torture as it was a revelation of a stipulation that would redefine WWE's biggest possible payoff.

On the night, Shawn escaped the slaughter with a win (more on that later) in spite of the horrific punishment he suffered. Edge would experience many of the hardships 'HBK' sustained, but lacked a 'Big Red Machine' to literally get him out of jail.

Like Michaels, Edge had the beating coming, but unlike the 'The Showstopper', the 'Rated-R Superstar' had few friends willing to save him from The Undertaker's wrath. Following a WrestleMania 24 World Title show-closer that didn't go his way, Edge had waged an campaign of abuse against the iconic star, utilising his 'Rated R-My' to help run his rival out of WWE altogether following a brutal June TLC main event.

Gradually though, Edge alienated everybody that had helped him cling to his beloved prize. Nefarious deeds with Alicia Fox that severed a power-hungry double act with Vickie Guerrero, leaving Edge all alone to take suffer his long-overdue consequences.

Taking each of the moves and finishers he'd inflicted upon 'The Deadman' (including the camera shot and con-chair-to that started it all) as well the usual Chokeslam/Tombstone repartee in a thrilling final stretch, Edge's comprehensive kicking was a fitting payoff to memorable conflict.


6. Batista Vs Triple H (Vengeance 2005, ****1/2)

Batista Triple H Vegeance 2005 Hell in a Cell
WWE.com

As if to atone for the numerous Monday Night Raw talents left grasping for air as he poured dirt on their main event dreams, Triple H went all in when he helped elevate Batista through three powerful promotions in 2005.

Foreshadowing WWE's philosophy going forward with three excellent and high-drawing World Title main events (before the bastardised concept left us all with 2017's Bray Wyatt/Finn Bálor programme), the pair's Cell match was the fitting final end to a blood feud that saw the collapse of an empire and the theoretical dawning of a new era.

Decked out in brilliant white, Batista highlighted just one of the lessons he'd learned from NWA loyalist Hunter and cage veteran Ric Flair. It was 'The Game's blood that added an ominous pink hue to the attire, but the Champion's soon followed after a brutal DDT on a barbed wire steel chair.

From then on, it became little more than an exhausting fight between warlords. Whomever hit harder would walk out a winner, leaving a loser with literally nothing left. Batista's astonishing physical mass won out as he utilised the ungainly steel ring-steps to splatter his former boss across with a frightening spinebuster.

Triple H grabbed his beloved sledgehammer as he was hoisted up for the Batista Bomb, but he was simply too immobilised to use it. It lay flat-out and dormant alongside its soundly defeated owner in the shattering aftermath.


5. WWE Title Six-Pack Challenge (Armageddon 2000, ****1/2)

Kurt Angle WWE Champion Armageddon 2000.jpg
WWE.com

Labelling a card as a one-match show adds untold pressure on the performers in said encounter, but luckily for a still-red hot WWE, this particular main event had five of the industry's biggest ever stars, and literally the biggest man to take a bump from the ceiling of the Cell.

The perpetual chaos that followed the WWE Title around for much of 2000 had stalled when the ultra-talented Kurt Angle took possession of the strap at October's No Mercy pay-per-view. However, stability came with a caveat. Booked credible despite his comedic side all year, Angle was severely reduced in the shark-infested waters of the company's main event scene at the time.

With the exception of The Rock, every other topliner chewed Kurt up and spat him out en route to failing to take the title from the Olympian. It partially stifled a spectacular and energetic multi-man main event that saw Stone Cold Steve Austin hilariously treat the cage as cheese grater on anybody that came within a right fist of him, Rikishi take a chokeslam from The Undertaker onto the back of a conveniently-placed flatbed truck, and all six men take turns wailing on one another with every available prop after the door was ripped off by Vince McMahon's aforementioned vehicular intervention.

The barbarism almost feels wasted on re-watch, with elements of the match resembling the humour of the hardcore division rather than the bloody hardships of championship endeavour. Angle's cheap win only further sullies the deflating mood.


4. Triple H Vs Cactus Jack (No Way Out 2000, ****1/2)

Triple H Cactus Jack Ring
WWE.com

The Triple H/Cactus Jack rivalry was another perfect storm in a series of them that swept WWE so far beyond WCW that the once-combative rivalry between the organisations instead resembled how 'The Game' would later treat most of the Monday Night Raw midcard.

Doubts had rightfully been cast over Hunter's suitability to lead the company as a Champion was still expected to do in 1999, but injuries to Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Undertaker had forced McMahon's hand to go all in on his future son-in-law alongside established headliners Mick Foley and The Rock.

'The Great One' had already done his best to elevate his former Corporate ally in the wake of his official babyface turn, but Foley's incredible generosity in their brutal feud marked a tonal shift for the 'Game' persona and Triple H's matches in general.

Managing to follow their incredible Royal Rumble WWE Title match, the No Way Out 2000 encounter had evocative stakes thanks to Foley's pledge to retire, but the lowering of the Cell over top only raised expectations thanks to mad Mick's infamous prior encounter within it (more in that later).

The two not only delivered a brawl on par with their January bloodbath, but also offered a unique conclusion that would have marked a fitting end to Cactus' career had the company actually enforced the stipulation.

Mirroring Foley's terrifying plunge through roof at King Of The Ring 1998, Triple H backdropped the challenger through a loose panel. Cactus plummeted yet again, but made a dent in the ring bigger than the one he'd left in every fan's heart after tearfully bidding farewell following the loss.


3. The Undertaker Vs Mankind (King Of The Ring 1998, ****1/2)

The Undertaker Mankind Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

As Shane McMahon crossed his heart and hoped not to die at WrestleMania 32, he did so looking to use his body to create a moment that would last a lifetime in the hearts and minds of wrestling fans the world over.

The reality of his situation was rather less romantic. The unforced plunge of a 45-year-old spoilt rich kid lacked the gravitas of the...gravity that dragged Mick Foley's battle-worn frame so beautifully back down to earth with a thud following an Undertaker throw that will rightfully be replayed ad infinitum.

It was a vile yet beautiful bump, with a million stories flickering through the fall like the flashbulbs that accompanied it. Mankind and The Undertaker despised one another after a 1996 angle that reinvigorated 'The Deadman' as much as it did make Foley. Though ostensibly a babyface, the involvement of brother Kane in his WWE life had brought an unpleasant and violent side out in 'Taker that manifested in the form of such wanton brutality.

Foley's perception had shifted in the opposite direction. A brief view into the man behind the mask in 1997 replaced his horrific veneer with something more human. Fans the world over now knew of his Dude Love dreams and Cactus Jack concessions, and felt physical pain alongside Mankind's emotional strife.

His second bump through the roof to the ring was even more sickening. But you don't need this article to tell you that - you've seen the match a hundred times and will see it a hundred more, such was the power of the legendary opening bump.


2. The Undertaker Vs Triple H (WrestleMania 28, ****3/4)

The Undertaker Triple H Wrestlemania 28
WWE.com

There are few matches that have the simultaneous opportunity and pressure of paying off an extensive four-year story arc, but the Triple H/Undertaker WrestleMania 28 Hell In A Cell match gleefully revelled in utilising every aspect of the well-told tale.

Billed as an 'End Of An Era' match thanks to the decreasing main roster responsibilities of both stars (and guest referee Shawn Michaels), Undertaker wrestled with a shaved head for the first time, with the storyline suggesting he'd tried and failed to escape the version of himself that only just defeated 'The Game' one year earlier.

It was canny gamesmanship from WWE - Hunter had lost that night, but in walking out under his own power in contrast to a stretchered Undertaker, had he really?

The ultimate frenemy of both men in storyline terms, Michaels was a natural fit as referee, and aided the absorbing drama when a Superkick/Pedigree nearfall created perhaps the greatest nearly-moment on Undertaker's WrestleMania CV before Brock Lesnar F5'ed it into oblivion.

The overarching message at the time was that 'The Deadman' simply could not be stopped. Not by the DXers, and not on that night, anyway. 'Taker was successful, and in a memorable and poignant visual, helped a truly defeated Triple H backstage when he was unable to do it himself.


1. The Undertaker Vs Shawn Michaels (Badd Blood, In Your House, *****)

Shawn Michaels Undertaker Hell In A Cell
WWE

Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker contested what many people consider to be the greatest match in WWE history at WrestleMania 25, but Dave Meltzer had already afforded them a perfect score 12 years earlier for the first and best Hell In A Cell match ever.

Like the exhausting Steve Austin/Bret Hart WrestleMania war that challenged it for Match Of The Year honours in 1997, the Badd Blood made the very best of having all the ingredients necessary in assembling a bonafide classic.

The Cell itself was both novel and needed. Replacing WWE's traditional blue bar cage with the wire mesh and a roof was as much to do with creating an antidote to antagonists as it was aesthetics. Shawn Michaels had, in the main, escaped The Undertaker's wrath thanks to endless interference from his soon-to-be-DX comrades Triple H, Chyna and Ravishing Rick Rude. The locked steel structure would negate his numbers game.

Few took a sh*t-kicking better than Shawn Michaels, particularly as a heel when he didn't need to pepper the contests with hope spots and comebacks. Subsequently, the match was a protracted massacre, with half of Shawn's offence motivated by sheer desperation in between running like f*ck from a vengeful 'Deadman'.

And yet, the snivelling little turd still escaped with a win. Kane's spectacular debut could have found no better home than the 'Devil's Playground', and his legitimately shocking arrival crafted a grand conclusion to a war for the ages.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.