10 Best WWE Matches Ever (According To The Internet)
Online, but are they on the money? WWE's best EVER matches, as voted for by the World Wide Web...
What makes an “Internet fan” now?
An ancient criticism tied to the mid-90s when early online adopters first dared to offer opinions along with an even more niche selection of newsletter subscribers (and wrestlers raged about them engaging with the matches on a second or third level), it seems to still hold currency in locker rooms despite half of the performers once embodying the term themselves and literally any person possessing so much as a pay-as-you-go phone now being able to dive into the discourse.
In this case at least, it applies to Cagematch. The ultra-detailed wrestling database offers all sorts of facts and stats on all the action, while also encouraging users to rate what they’ve watched in an effort to democratically arrive at the industry’s bests and worsts.
The consequences of this great collaborative process are, uh, divisive.
There are a host of piping hot classics that didn’t make the grade here, and before anybody boots off in this direction, your writer is trying not to quietly fume while listing some of those off too.
Sasha Banks/Bayley at TakeOver: Brooklyn, Johnny Gargano/Adam Cole at TakeOver: New York, Shawn Michaels/The Undertaker at Badd Blood: In Your House, Sasha Banks/Bayley at TakeOver: The End, Bret Hart/Steve Austin at Survivor Series 1996, CM Punk/John Cena from Raw in 2013, Sasha Banks/Bayley at Hell In A Cell 2020, and on and on and on it goes.
These incredible offerings couldn’t crack the top ten. So what on earth did?
10. Chris Benoit Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Triple H
Starting not how we mean to go on, the highly-rated WrestleMania XX main event is something many fans may never have seen and many more may never watch again.
This is the legacy - if you can call it that - of Chris Benoit following his actions and the tragic events of the last days of his, wife Nancy and son Daniel’s lives back in 2007.
What makes this specific entry from Benoit’s exhaustive back catalogue so jarring compared to other clashes from his career is how shaped around his past, present and future it was.
He was the man that could never ascend in the market leader because of his perceived shortcomings. He especially stood no chance against a Shawn Michaels and Triple H being presented as at the top of their games. And he was the man, alongside Eddie Guerrero, tasked with shouldering a philosophical shift that Vince McMahon barely even committed to before their untimely deaths just three and one years later respectively.
All of the above feeds to in to an epic tale, but fictional physicality may simply never be enough to distract from the brutal and devastating reality.
9. Tyler Bate Vs. WALTER (NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff)
The main event of WWE's second NXT UK TakeOver did much to erase fans' memories of the terrible first one, but little was left to chance when longstanding rivals Tyler Bate and Walter were matched up against one another. The pair headlined a PROGRESS Wembley Arena show in 2018, and NXT UK aped that atmosphere even if their own glowed-up production earnestly enhanced the drama between the two throwbacks.
Heavy duty pro wrestling violence stacked like Bate himself was on the ring apron in one of the contest's most memorable spots, the battle called for no more (!) than the two to be the the most tunnel-visioned versions of themselves. The otherwise-valueless UK Championship suddenly became the richest prize in the game as two of the hardest lads to grace the canvas tried to kill each other for it.
Breaking Dave Meltzer's five-star scale to become one of the highest rated matches in his canon, this attritional war was perfectly pitched for its time. Bate chopped down the tree with work on Walter's leg, his chest, his back and his head. Walter simply chopped and chopped and chopped in response. Quantity and quality, the sheer willingness of Bate to eat sh*t in reality and kayfabe put over the Champion's unstoppable aura, particularly when he followed a series of dramatic near-falls with with a mind-melting one-count kickout.
The proverbial last act of a desperate man, it triggered a crushing lariat from the Austrian that finished the job and concluded perhaps the glossiest no-bullsh*t match in WWE history.
8. The Dudley Boyz Vs. Edge & Christian Vs. Jeff Hardy & Matt Hardy (WrestleMania X7)
Tasked with topping their legendary original while also contributing to a pay-per-view with developing Greatest-Of-All-Time vibes as it went along, the combatants in TLC2 deserve credit not just for assembling something as special as they did but for doing so under the sort of pressure that would have ground others into dirt.
One of the greatest and most grandiose spotfests in WWE history, the six men artfully escalate the danger with such lightness of touch that almost nothing feels constructed despite the props and people needed to assemble the every terrifying scene.
Every match has a standout moment, and this one's remembered most for Edge spearing Jeff Hardy out of the sky as he hung on to the title belts for dear life. Time stands still as the bodies collide, and the impact creates pause for thought on all they're doing in a way that's the bigger than the battle itself. Three teams at the peak of their powers, stealing the show from underneath the stars that have drawn a full stadium for the first time in nearly a decade and doing so with admirable but insane lack of consideration for their own wellbeing.
Neatly folding in Spike Dudley, Rhyno and Lita, the use of each teams' seconds was one more victory lap in a series of them - the duos having wars just as powerful as this had been so successful that they'd helped get several other stars over in the process.
7. The Revival Vs. D.I.Y (NXT TakeOver: Toronto)
A beloved closer to an epic feud in a transcendent tag division, this TakeOver: Toronto two-out-of-three falls match was artful, indulgent and gripped the Canadian crowd tighter than Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson were able to in the stunning climax.
After each team scored a fall apiece with their own finishers, the only "simplistic" element of a contest concluded. From their, the drilled and dynamic duos mixed classic tag tropes with dizzyingly complex exchanges in front of a crowd that were frothing at the gills to get the finale they craved.
NXT as a brand was pivoting from a little-engine-that-could-and-did developmental to established super-indie at the time, and while the four men were visions of both sides of the divide, the storytelling in the run up fused golden era creative brilliance with the new escalated in-ring ceiling. There was palpable panic that DIY could and would fall apart (Ciampa and Gargano's split was every bit the beautifully woven tale even if they bastardised it years later), and nothing cut through people's emotion quite like these Revival cut-offs.
Holding on to each other until they could no longer hold onto the gold, there was no better way for Dash and Dawson's iconic reign to conclude, and it was the beginning of the end for their run on the black-and-gold brand too. Sadly nothing under main roster WWE's reckless booking for the next three years touched the magic they crafted here.
6. Ilja Dragunov Vs. WALTER (NXT TakeOver: 36)
A darling like few others in independent wrestling by the time he surprisingly signed on the dotted line for WWE, WALTER was one of the rare prodigious signings touted as a can’t-hit rather than the cliched opposite.
Not literally, of course. His chop was his most potent weapon in the ring and his most useful one for catching Vince McMahon’s attention. But a physique not typically in keeping with McMahon’s taste, a lack of obvious line delivery dexterity and zero Sports Entertainment sparkle didn’t exactly shine the best light on - and here’s the most frustrating bit - one of the best wrestlers in the f*cking world.
By the time his 2021 rematch with Ilja Dragunov rolled around, this thankfully wasn't much of a problem. Having held the ill-fated WWE/NXT United Kingdom Championship for 870 days, he was at very least established as the company's biggest Big Bad and Dragunov knew it better than most.
He'd waited 10 months for a second shot at the belt after their minor miracle in the BT Sports studio, and this gripping sequel was almost as epic as the original. Dragunov's back being as pickled as his gnarly front by the end was the perfect visual signifier for what his body went through over 22 absorbing minutes, as was his emotional breakdown as he clasped his hard-earned prize. Securing it via tap-out was key too - he never gave up in their two clashes or over the long haul. It was this that separated him from the 'Ring General' when it counted.
5. Shawn Michaels Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania 25)
An innovation within WWE even if it was borrowing from tropes and tricks that had typically been considered excessive by those in the bubble, Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker leaning on post-kick out shock and finisher spam elevated the form before it became normalised within the system.
It's easy to understand exactly why Michaels coaches and drills this sh*t into the NXT trainees so much - reactions like the ones 'The Heartbreak Kid' and 'The Deadman' received for their herculean all-star clash at WrestleMania 25 were the sort of dragons to chase forever. What he seemingly fails to realise is that they just may not have been there on such a grand stage if two company icons weren't either. That 'Taker's streak was still in play enhanced every tease too, especially when their instincts kicked in - the very best moment of the match was not one of their many reversal exchanges but Michaels desperately shooting for a count-out win after a near-disastrous missed dive by his opponent.
The magic in this - especially on rewatch when its obvious influences and the the many things it obviously influenced are both widely available - is in seeing a stadium have their minds blown by the old pros subverting their expectations. Michaels' retirement is more heartfelt the following year, and their Hell In A Cell match over a decade earlier had the sense of danger and violence this didn't need.
Long before wrestling ate itself with this sort of melodrama, two master craftsmen shot for the cinematic and somehow pulled it off.
4. CM Punk Vs. John Cena (Money In The Bank 2011)
There's (still) perhaps no better match to explain specifically what it is about CM Punk that people love than his iconic Chicago clash with John Cena. He's as good a Sports Entertainer as he a Pro Wrestler, and on occasion he grasps and elevates the magic of the former without neglecting the latter.
The pair had some strong in-ring outings either side of Money In The Bank 2011, but a platonic ideal between excellent work and magnificent spectacle was struck in the 'Second City'.
From Punk's spine-tingling entrance to the kiss he blew to Vince McMahon as he left with his richest prize, the fourth-wall smashing storyline hit all its marks and was performed to utter perfection by the 'Straight Edge Superstar' and 'The Champ'.
Never the cleanest executors, both men found themselves in such a furnace that every move they made was a masterstroke of audience manipulation. It's high end soap more than high end action, but Punk in particular has always excelled more in that arena than he's given credit for. Technique counts for much, but the physical struggle here felt realer than Cena suddenly tightening up his STF for once.
High stakes taken to peaks few believed the pair could reach, this match and its impact actually managed to achieve what almost nothing else about the Summer Of Punk could - it actually made good on Punk's original "Pipe Bomb" promo.
3. Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin (WrestleMania 13)
Number One with a bullet if your writer was "The Internet" in this case, Bret Hart's WrestleMania 13 bout with Stone Cold Steve Austin transformed the entire wrestling business and remains comfortably the most important match in WWE.
Immune to the ravages of time and ever-changing tastes, it's as electrifying and awesome as the day it first occurred.
Subverting the submission match stipulation by morphing into one of WWE's first real street fights, the pair do everything either as good or better than any of their peers. And in most cases, they're doing it for the very first time.
The crowd brawl is dangerous and untethered rather than rote. Low blows and weapon shots were struck with urgency, panic and opportunism rather than because it was time to head along to the next spot. Austin's blood - ultimately the takeaway image from the contest forever - was integral to the story of the match which itself was integral to a finish that flipped both men's alignment and begat the run that carried WWE all the way back to the big time.
Not enough bona fide classics speak loudly enough for themselves in the content super-service era. This screams from the rooftops until you pay attention and pay in some respect.
2. Ilja Dragunov Vs. WALTER (NXT UK, October 29th, 2020)
WWE absolutely f*cked the pandemic.
The circumstances were less than ideal, but when wrestling insisted that it was as essential as doctors and nurses and carried on fulfilling its television contract anyway, a bar was quickly set by AEW Dynamite's oddly charming adjustment to the new way. Acknowledging the awkwardness but leaning in with wrestlers-as-fans and stipulations filling the spaces left by absent crowds, this was pandemic wrestling without the very phrase being a total paradox.
WWE's attempts first to no-sell it before eventually accepting their fate were either eerie, distressing, or a combination of the two. It was odd - the escapist entertainment that swore blind was needed for its public was in fact one of the harshest reminders of the state we were all stuck in. The exceptions to the rule in 2020 were in single figures, and the best of the lot was this impossibly great sensory overload strike battle.
Dragunov being presented as at least an equal to Walter in terms not just of how hard he could hit but also how much he could take was integral to its success, as was the sheer intensity and brute force of just about everything both men hit. With the sound of silence haunting their pain, the match became more than it would have been in front of fans, leaving memories that carried the heft of the rematch when crowds were allowed back in 10 months later.
1. Andrade Almas Vs. Johnny Gargano (NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia)
A match that became an instant genre classic before audiences began tiring of the genre itself, Andrade Almas Vs Johnny Gargano from 2018’s TakeOver luxuriated in all that NXT had become as a super-indie under WWE's seemingly-expanding umbrella.
Building on a total ripper they'd had the prior summer, this was - fittingly for its placement - the main event version of their killer opener format. Both had ascended up the card since then but the difference was in their routes, with the Champion forced to prove his killer instinct against a Challenger to haunted by the ghosts of his recent past to keep kicking out when it counted.
'Johnny Wrestling' as the sympathetic (almost-)never-say-die babyface had clicked for the brand like never before, while the violent snap behind Andrade's kicks, knees and elbows never ever looked as terrifying as when they appeared to be concussing Gargano into early retirement.
The impact of it all broke everybody's brain and the sheer quality broke through Dave Metlzer's five star ceiling for the first time in the "developmental" brand's history, but it most importantly broke everybody's hearts. The defeated and depleted Gargano gained more in defeat than he ever could have in victory here, and it was painfully clear how his hostilities with Tommaso Ciampa needed to be settled before he stood another chance of competing for the show's biggest prize.