10 Big Mistakes WWE Made At SummerSlam 2016
What went wrong last night? Well, quite a lot actually...
Well, that was a bit of a mess wasn't it?
SummerSlam comes with the baggage of being WWE's second biggest show of the year, and in 2016 it seemed like that baggage became too heavy for the company to carry. What we got was some sort of WrestleMania-lite, a show filled to the brim for the sake of appearances as opposed to storyline necessity.
It wasn't all bad, of course.
Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho continued their excellent partnership with a solid win over Enzo & Big Cass. AJ Styles defied history and logic to defeat John Cena clean in their second match, turning the 'John loses one, wins three' trope on its head. Finn Balor and Seth Rollins had a technically-proficient match for the WWE Universal Championship and Charlotte regained the Women's Championship from Sasha Banks in a cracking little match in the first hour.
Still, even the most ardent WWE supporter will say that last night featured more misses than hits. The last hour in particular was a strange one, with an apathetic crowd going through the motions when quite the opposite was expected/hoped for.
So what mistakes did WWE make at SummerSlam 2016? Here are 10 of the biggest boo-boos...
10. The Show Was Too Long
I don't want to complain about having 'too much wrestling', but once again this show was too long.
WrestleMania 32 was the Slog of Slogs as opposed to the Show of Shows, and at six hours (including the Kickoff) and 13 matches this show was just too much. Nobody wants that much of anything in one sitting. I mean, 'The Wire' is the greatest television show (or thing) ever, but I'm not going to sit through six whole straight hours of it.
WWE has a real issue when it comes to pacing its shows at this point. SummerSlam 2002 was arguably the best SummerSlam of all time, and looking back at that card it is the timing that stands out. Eight matches long, it truly was all killer, no filler. WWE has a tendency these days to throw everyone onto big shows for the sake of being there, as opposed to creating stories that justify their placement.
The crowd were visibly burnt-out throughout this show. By the time Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler locked up for the WWE World Championship the apathy shown to both men dragged that bout down terribly. You can lay the blame at the feet of the WWE Network, but WWE is also getting far too liberal when it comes to its show lengths.
Sometimes, less really is more.
9. Where Was Sami Zayn?
There were two notable absentees from the show last night. I'll get onto the second in a moment, but where in the blue thunder was Sami Zayn last night? Well, we know where he was: he was slotted into a throwaway tag team match on the Kickoff show with Neville against the Dudleyz.
Zayn and Neville won and the Dudleyz dissension continued, which in itself is a head-scratching move right now.
Last month at WWE Battleground, Sami Zayn defeated his blood rival Kevin Owens in what may go down as the best WWE main roster match of 2016. His reward was a high draft placement at number 11, yet WWE creative could find nothing for him at this, the second biggest show of the year.
A number of names were missing from the show last night, outside of Zayn and the second. Baron Corbin, Braun Strowman, Kane, Nia Jax, Kalisto and others, but you can pretty much accept those guys missing out. Zayn was the highest-placing draft pick to miss out on the main show, a main show that included 10 matches and a total of 30 competitors.
This is ridiculous.
8. Cesaro And Sheamus On The Kickoff
Many folk have been complaining about the fact that Cesaro and Sheamus are going against each other in a Best-Of-7 series, on account of them facing each other so often recently. In truth, why are we complaining? There aren't many better match-ups in WWE today, and the style of match these two put on is the type that rarely gets old.
The two Europeans were demoted to the Kickoff show last night, but any pretence that they would give anything less than 110% went out the window straight away. Sheamus picked up the win in a match that was as good as anything on the card that didn't involve AJ Styles. This series is going to be a whole lot of fun, trust me.
Both men deserved more than being shunted onto the Kickoff show. This is going to be a complaint with most big shows, but the two brutes put on the sort of bout that a New York crowd would be able to get behind and are capable of the sort of 8/9 minute sprint that can ignite a flagging show.
Sheamus will probably go down in history as one of the best wrestlers in WWE history that nobody ever truly loved.
7. The Final Evolution Of The New Day
When The New Day arrived on WWE TV, they were one of the worst parts of the show.
The happy clappy babyface schtick was groan-inducing from the start, but a heel turn saw messrs. Kingston, Woods and E. become the most entertaining act on WWE programming. They won the WWE Tag Team Titles and consistently defended them, bringing a credibility back to the belts that had been long missing.
Somewhere along the way they turned face again, and have now completed one full rotation of the sun so to speak. They started off irritating before becoming awesome, and have now smoothly transitioned back into the lame side. Jon Stewart became an honorary member here, and his interference towards the end of this match was painful to watch.
Something must have gone wrong, because once Stewart was involved it seemed as though everyone was moving through sludge.
As for The Club? Something just hasn't clicked. The duo needed to win the titles here and end New Day's record run, before defending the titles and becoming the bad-ass duo they really should be. As it was, New Day retained by getting disqualified and being cheered for it.
This was awful.
6. Welcome Back To The Midcard, World Championship!
There was a certain inevitability about this, wasn't there?
Towards the end of the first brand split the World Heavyweight Championship essentially became a secondary championship, defended at the beginning and in the middle of PPVs and used as a testing ground for those WWE were thinking of moving towards the main event.
When Dean Ambrose was drafted to SmackDown last month, many held out hope that his WWE World Championship would continue as the number one prize in the game. It may be a slightly damning indictment, but once Dolph Ziggler was confirmed as the number one contender to that title any pretension of it being the main event went out the window.
Last night, Ambrose vs. Ziggler was the 6th match out of 10 on the main show, following the tag title match that pretty much fatally deflated the crowd. The match itself was more than cromulent, but the general feeling was that Ambrose winning was an inevitability and the crowd therefore didn't care.
If you treat a world title in such a throwaway manner, it'll be perceived as such.
5. Where The Hell Was Bray Wyatt?
I've covered Sami Zayn's absence from the main show last night at SummerSlam, but at least he was on the Kickoff show. Bray Wyatt was nowhere to be seen at all night. No backstage promo, no vignette, nothing. Bray Wyatt was the highest drafted performer who wasn't on the show at all last night.
Now, I'm fully aware that we can't keep looking at the ranking positions as being important, but Wyatt is a little more than just a high pick. He is in theory the number two heel on SmackDown, a SmackDown that is severely lacking on the bad guy side. Surely keeping Wyatt on TV is important at this point?
It is a tough cookie, for sure. The show is packed enough as it is, throwing more performers onto the show just to get them on doesn't make any sense. The problem is the lack of placement for Wyatt and Zayn, two integral cogs in a machine that needs to keep moving forward.
4. The Demon King! The Demon King! The Demon King! The Demon King Ad Nauseam
Finn Balor overcame Seth Rollins last night to become the very first WWE Universal Champion. The Irishman also became the first man in WWE history to win a world championship in their first pay-per-view match, as the monster push that Balor has received since arriving in WWE continues.
The match itself was a lot of fun - two of the best in the world going at it on a big stage pretty much guarantees that.
But how in the name of all that is pure have WWE managed to make Demon Balor less interesting and exciting? Well, it shouldn't really surprise anyone. WWE has a tendency to find something extremely cool and then batter it into the ground until it draws only groans and hand movements.
We saw it with 'Suplex City', and now we're seeing it with 'Demon King'. Balor's demon was so thrilling because it was protected, it only came out at certain times, it was spoken about in hushed tones. With Cole, Graves and Saxton blathering on repeating those two words - 29 times from entrance to finish last night - they are creating a situation where one simply doesn't care about the demon.
Heck, I'd rather see Demon Kane at this point...
Actually no. I take that back.
3. Big Matches That Don't Happen
Maybe I'm old-fashioned, but if a match is announced for a pay-per-view I kinda feel like it should take place, you know? Slotted into the semi-main event position (Reigns still managing to place higher on a card than his Shield brethren in world championship matches), the planned United States Championship match between Rusev and Roman Reigns never got started.
Reigns attacked Rusev from the off and the fight continued to the point where the match was simply unable to start proper. It was called a no-contest, and Reigns delivered a Spear to the Bulgarian Brute after the decision in order to continue looking as strong as possible.
This feud has been a mess. It began over cake, and the supposedly babyface Reigns has consistently looked like an awful human being throughout. Rusev yet again finds himself in a feud where he is the logical face but working as the heel. Tell me; who wins here?
Well, nobody wins, because the match didn't happen! The two will probably have a full-length singles match on RAW tonight.
2. Brock Lesnar
Okay, we really need to talk about Brock Lesnar.
We may talk about Brock Lesnar a lot, but we need to talk Brock Lesnar within a World Wrestling Entertainment context. What exactly does Brock bring to the table now? Name value, mainstream media coverage, casual fan interest and a certain superstar quality, to name just four things. Brock Lesnar is a unique beast in the wrestling world.
It is this last point that is the real issue with Brock Lesnar. The divide between 'WWE Superstar' and 'Brock Lesnar' has grown to the point of no return. This entire 'Suplex City' thing was great fun two years ago when Cena was being decimated, because it was shocking and new. Lesnar's destruction job to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 31 was also fun, because of the intensity of it all.
But Lesnar phoning it in against Ambrose at WrestleMania 32 or opposite Orton here? No thank you.
What is this all building to? If Randy Orton faces off against Lesnar at a big show down the road and gets a clean win then, sure, there's a point, but is that going to happen? Whilst it is great to have standalone beasts in wrestling, the whole point of the game is for good to overcome bad. If Lesnar just continues smashing things into the ground, where is the inspiration?
If Lesnar is only willing to put over dick-kicking zombie part-timers or those in power in the company, what point is there to this? With each passing year, Lesnar dominating in this fashion becomes less interesting and less valuable.
1. Yet Another Non-Ending Ending
For the second straight year, SummerSlam ended with a Brock Lesnar main event match that ended with some controversy. In 2015 Brock and Undertaker took part in a match with a shady finish, and this year saw Lesnar win by TKO against Randy Orton. It seems that WWE is frequently trying to incorporate more UFC-inspired aspects into its shows, and this for me is a mistake.
The ending of last night's show is case in point. The TKO finish isn't such a terrible idea, but in professional wrestling there is too much of a gap between the KO and the finish itself, time in which the audience disconnects from the action in front of them. Legitimate combat sports are as much about the ending as the action, and whilst we do love the finishes of wrestling matches it is the story that matters.
As mentioned earlier, if this leads to Orton cleanly defeating Lesnar down the line then, okay, it is excellent. It also really solidifies Lesnar as a heel, but the problem with Lesnar as a big heel is that the likelihood of a babyface vanquishing him grows smaller all the time. Sure, this could make it a huge deal if someone beats him, but does anyone believe that will happen?
This was WWE's second biggest show of the year, and it ended with a 'oh, right, that's the end of the match?'. That is merely lazy booking, a lack of desire to make the sort of decisions that will be remembered for years to come. That is the central issue of Brock Lesnar headlining WWE shows right now and the biggest mistake of SummerSlam 2016.