10 Biggest Missed Opportunities In WWE History

Bad things happen when WWE drop the ball.

ECW locker room 2006
WWE.com

Combining the thrills and spills of a Hollywood blockbuster with the comic book world’s big, colourful characters and tales of good vs. evil, wrestling is a sport like no other. At it’s best, it’s one of the most exciting shows in the world, and while many of their practices are far from perfect, WWE have given fans plenty of reasons to cheer over the years.

From Daniel Bryan finally winning the big one and becoming WWE Champion at WrestleMania XXX, to Hulk Hogan bodyslamming Andre the Giant at WMIII, wrestling is defined by those big moments where the stars align and the end result is nothing short of exhilarating.

Unfortunately, WWE have become just as well-known for fluffing such opportunities. Their current monopoly affords them leeway in this department, but that doesn’t change the fact that Vince McMahon’s industry-leading juggernaut has dropped the ball on countless occasions over the years.

As a wrestling fan, few things are more frustrating than seeing WWE botch what looks like an easy lay-up. Here are those moments where WWE failed to strike when the iron was hot, and give the fans what they wanted: the 10 biggest missed opportunities in WWE history.

10. The 2014 Royal Rumble

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan had established himself as WWE’s most beloved babyface throughout 2013. From Team Hell No’s memorable Tag Team Title run to the Triple H/”B+ Player” fiasco, Bryan was white hot. His struggles with The Authority made him a natural underdog, the easiest wrestler in the world to root for, and the ultimate good guy.

Bryan had succeeded in spite of every hurdle the company had thrown in front of him, and the 2014 Royal Rumble should’ve been his big moment. WWE would finally go all-in on their most organic babyface and capitalise on his immense crowd support by finally making him a made man, but it wasn’t to be.

Instead, Bryan didn’t even feature in the Royal Rumble, and lost a match to Bray Wyatt earlier that evening. The Rumble’s first 29 entrants came and went, and by 30, the “YES” chants had hit fever pitch. Surely this was Bryan’s moment?

Nope. Out came Rey Mysterio, who instantly became the biggest heel in the country by virtue of not being Daniel Bryan. The returning Batista went-on to win the Rumble, and while Bryan ended-up achieving his crowning glory at WrestleMania XXX, WWE needlessly flubbed one of their biggest shows of the year for the sake of pushing an ageing part-timer back into the spotlight.


9. Cody Rhodes

stardust cody rhodes
WWE.com

While the legitimacy of Cody Rhodes’ release has been questioned a lot lately, and there’s every chance he’ll re-emerge in the future, there’s no doubt WWE have thrown a potential megastar away.

He’s the son of Dusty Rhodes (one of the most respected figures in wrestling history), a great microphone worker and actor, and an underrated wrestler. Whether portraying the ill-fated Stardust character or acting as one half of The Rhodes Scholars, Cody threw his heart and soul into everything he did, and WWE let him slip through their fingers.

“Stardust” had ran its course a long time ago. A change was long overdue, but instead of granting Cody that wish, WWE let him leave. Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised: WWE had a great opportunity to “make” Cody Rhodes while feuding with his elder brother, Goldust, but the storyline faded out, and so did Cody’s WWE career.


8. Christian As Champion

Lita Women's Champion
WWE.com

Edge had a highly successful singles run after splitting with his long-time tag team partner, but Christian had to look elsewhere.

He’d go on to prove his credentials as a headline-calibre wrestler throughout a fruitful three years with TNA, and when injuries forced Edge to retire and vacate his World Heavyweight Championship in 2011, Christian was the perfect candidate to step-in.

WWE quickly booked a match between Alberto Del Rio and Edge’s former partner, and at Extreme Rules 2011, Christian won the belt. A man who was once forced elsewhere for main event opportunities had returned to the company and followed in his best friend’s footsteps.

In itself, Christian’s title victory was a great moment, but it all came crashing down shortly after.

Christian’s feelgood story hit a screeching halt just 5 days later, when he dropped the belt to Randy Orton on SmackDown. Having already proven himself as an outstanding wrestler and one of WWE’s most entertaining personalities, there was no need for Christian’s reign to be cut short.

WWE had a great opportunity to make Christian a singles star on the same level as his esteemed partner, Edge, and they blew it.


7. "I Did It For The Rock"

Rikishi Heel Turn
WWE.com

When “Stone Cold” Steve Austin was ran over at Survivor Series ‘99, WWE had a great opportunity to build the industry’s next great antagonist. It was easy money - the company’s most popular wrestler had been put on the shelf for a long time, and whoever was found responsible would go-on to become one of the most hated men in WWE.

Unfortunately, WWE picked the wrong guy. After months’ of teasing DX and The Rock, Commissioner Mick Foley revealed Rikishi as the guilty party, and, predictably, it flopped.

Better known for dancing with Too Cool and rubbing his thong-clad rear-end in opponents’ faces, WWE couldn’t have picked a less suitable candidate than Rikishi. His explanation (“I did it for The Rock”) was laughable, his heel turn fell flat, and Rikishi failed as a main eventer.

The wrong guy in the wrong place at the wrong time.


6. Chris Jericho's 2000 Title Win

Chris Jericho WWE Champion Raw April 2000
WWE.com

Chris Jericho has had a long, successful WWE career. He’s one of the most charismatic wrestlers in the sport’s history, a surefire Hall-of-Famer, and a multi-time champion.

Jericho’s done it all, and in 2000, he was absolutely flying. While backstage politics and questionable booking stalled his advancement after crossing over from WCW, Jericho quickly won the fans over with entertaining promos and thrilling ring work.

He challenged Triple H to a World Title match in April 2000, and capitalised on confusion between the champion and referee Earl Hebner to pin Hunter and become champion.

The place erupted, but it wasn’t to be and Triple H quickly coerced Hebner into reversing the decision, pulling the title from Jericho’s grasp as quickly as he’d won it. The crowd’s reaction showed that this was the perfect time for a Chris Jericho title run.

Regrettably, WWE disagreed.


5. The New World Order Rehash

nwo 2002
WWE.com

As easy as it is to deride the New World Order’s later years, the stable had a game-changing impact on their inception, and played a huge role in swinging the Monday Night Wars in WCW’s favour in the mid-90’s.

Unfortunately, he nWo’s 2002 WWE reboot was a complete shambles. Having bought the rights to all WCW intellectual property the year before, Vince McMahon announced that he was bringing back the nWo to “kill his creation”.

Enter Scott Hall, Hulk Hogan, and a visibly out-of-shape Kevin Nash. All three were several years removed from their prime, but fans had been clamouring to see these guys go against the likes of Steve Austin and The Rock for years.

While Hogan and The Rock delivered an all-time classic match at WrestleMania 18, the nWo revival brought few other highlights. Hogan turned face the next evening, leaving the nWo in the process. X-Pac, The Big Show, Booker T, and Shawn Michaels were added, but the nWo could never recapture their WCW magic, and the story vanished without explanation by July 2002.


4. The ECW Revival

Big Show Paul Heyman ECW Champion
WWE.com

Sometimes it’s best to let sleeping dogs lie. WWE announced their intentions to revive Extreme Championship Wrestling on the back of their two highly-successful and critically acclaimed “One Night Stand” pay-per-views, but it was a disastrous move.

In marketing their new show under the ECW banner, WWE set an impossibly high standard for a show that could never live-up to expectations. ECW was a special promotion with a unique identity and the kind of character that just can’t be recreated in a Stamford boardroom, and WWE found this out the hard way.

Initially populating the “new” ECW roster with old faces like Sabu and The Sandman, WWE soon filled the brand with bland personalities like Bobby Lashley, and a host of unseasoned rookies that just didn’t fit the ECW mould.

Culminating with the horrific “December to Dismember” PPV and Vince McMahon himself winning the ECW Championship, WWE made a mockery of what could’ve been a unique, exciting alternative to Raw and SmackDown.


3. The Nexus

The Nexus Entrance
WWE.com

For a brief period of time, The Nexus were WWE’s hottest ticket. Their debut was shocking. 8 young wrestlers appeared during John Cena’s main event clash with CM Punk, destroying Cena, staff, and literally tearing the ringside area apart. It was an instant shot to the arm, and a much-needed jolt of energy for WWE’s stagnating product.

The leader, Wade Barrett, was a ready-made superstar. Charismatic, skilled in the ring, and with a look ideally suited for WWE main events, Barrett and his Nexus stablemates should’ve become megastars. They were young, hungry, focused, and they weren’t going to wait for opportunities. They were going to make their own.

But WWE cut them off at the knees. John Cena refused to put them over, and instead of conquering WWE, The Nexus died a quiet death by Cena’s hand. The group’s formation should’ve made several marketable superstar but, instead, it all but killed any chance of Barrett ever reaching main event level, and only 3 of the group’s 8 original competitors remain on the active roster today.


2. Not Booking Hulk Hogan Vs. Ric Flair

Hogan Flair WrestleMania VIII
WWE

It should’ve been so easy. Ric Flair was the ultimate bad guy, and Hulk Hogan the biggest fan favourite in the business. They were wrestling’s two shining stars throughout the 1980s, and there was no bigger “dream match” throughout that decade.

Fans had been clamouring for Flair and Hogan to collide for years, but while Hogan was busy ruling the roost in WWE, Flair had established himself as the NWA’s cornerstone. As the two champions of their companies, and two biggest stars of the era, Flair and Hogan’s eventual showdown would be an incredible spectacle, and it looked like fans would finally get their wish in 1991.

Flair jumped ship from WCW to WWE, and McMahon’s company tested the waters by pitting the duo against each other on a series of house shows. Flair soon involved himself in Hogan’s televised business, costing him the World Title against The Undertaker.

The belt was put on the line during the 1992 Royal Rumble: Flair won, and this all but set-up a long-awaited WrestleMania match between two industry titans.

It didn’t happen. Amidst rumours that neither man wanted to lose and minimal house show buzz, WWE scrapped the “dream match”, instead pitting Hogan against Sid, and Flair against Randy Savage. WWE couldn’t find a way to make what would’ve been one of the biggest matches in wrestling history happen, and both wrestlers left shortly after.


1. The Invasion

Steve Austin Invasion
WWE.com

Oh boy, where to begin...

How about WWE’s inability to pry top stars like Goldberg and Sting away from their lucrative WCW contracts, and the chronic lack of star power on the Alliance side?

Or maybe Buff Bagwell and Booker T stinking-up the joint in the first WCW Title match to ever take place on WWE television?

Or the swathes of superstars defecting from WWE to join the Alliance, killing the renegade group’s identity and watering their purpose down in the process?

WCW vs. WWE should’ve been the easiest story in the world to tell, but it got-off to a limp start and never really recovered. While WCW’s biggest names sat at home collecting paycheques, the likes of Booker T, DDP, and a list of WCW Thunder alumni struggled to maintain fan interest beyond the first few weeks.

ECW’s involvement felt like a good move at the time, but their role was ultimately neutered when the WWE defections started rolling, and while the Booker T/The Rock feud had its moments, it was ultimately too one-sided to be considered a success.

The Invasion amounted to little more than another turgid McMahon family feud in the long-run. WCW and WWE waging war with one another should’ve been the biggest storyline in wrestling history: instead, it’ll go down as the sport’s biggest waste of potential.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.