10 Biggest WWE Creative Mistakes Of 2016

2016: a year of terrible ideas.

James Ellsworth
WWE.com

Things haven't always gone WWE's way this year, but they've had an extremely eventful 12 months. 2016 has been a year of strong pay-per-views, excellent in-ring action (thanks, AJ Styles), and all-round diversification. With the revived Brand Split, Cruiserweight Division, and a refreshed main event scene full of IWC favourites, WWE have put great effort into reviving their product since January, and 2016 will end as one of the most notable years in modern wrestling history.

As is always the case with WWE, you have to take the good with the bad. AJ Styles, Goldberg's return, and the Women's Revolution have been roaring successes, but Roman Reigns, WrestleMania 32, and the ratings crisis? Not so much.

The company's viewership took a significant hit this year, and while figures have been on a steady decline since 2001, September saw Raw hit an all-time low. There are unquestionably a number of external factors influencing this, but the bulk of the blame lies with WWE, and specifically those charged with holding the audience's attention in the first place.

WWE's creative team have given us some fantastic television this year, but they've also delivered more than their fair share of duds. For all WWE's desires to be treated as a serious entertainment company, they regularly deliver some of the most laughable stories imaginable, and 2016 has been a minefield of bad ideas.

Here are the 10 biggest WWE creative mistakes of 2016.

10. Feuding Over A Teddy Bear

Alicia Fox Bayley
WWE.com

The Bayley vs. Alicia Fox feud only kicked off on Raw last week, but its foundations are more than dumb enough to warrant a place on the list. Bayley and Alicia aren’t feuding over a difference of opinion or even for competition’s sake, but because Bayley gave Cedric Alexander a teddy bear on last week’s pre-show, and Alicia’s jealous about it.

Fox has a crush on Alexander, Bayley gave him a gift, and now they’re presumably feuding for his affections. It’s a woefully thin storyline, and one that’s borderline insulting at a time when women’s wrestling has never been more important to WWE. Charlotte and Sasha Banks are treated like two of the company’s most important athletes, but everyone else on Raw is completely disposable, and this story proves it.

It’s good that they’re finding airtime for women outside the title scene, but surely the creative team could’ve come up with something better than this? At a time when WWE fans are crying-out for realism, the company are promoting a story that’d be better suited to Saved By The Bell. Add her last feud with Dana Brooke into the mix, and Bayley’s main roster run looks like misstep after misstep despite her enduring popularity.


9. Zack Ryder's 5-Minute Push

Zack Ryder WrestleMania
WWE.com

Zack Ryder’s Intercontinental Title victory at WrestleMania 32 came out of nowhere. It was widely assumed that he’d been thrown into the traditional ladder match as a spot-filler, and that one of the match’s more celebrated stars - a Kevin Owens or Sami Zayn - would walk away with the gold.

Ryder had become irrelevant. He was barely being used on Raw and SmackDown, and when he showed-up, it was usually to lose. His popularity had peaked years ago, and for all intents and purposes, he’d become little more than Mojo Rawley’s NXT sidekick. He couldn’t possibly win, could he?

He did, and while the victory gave Ryder a heartwarming WrestleMania moment while celebrating with his did, the following night rendered it pointless. Ryder lost his Intercontinental Championship to The Miz just one night after winning it, and that was that. Zack received a handful of meaningless title shots in the aftermath, but he was never going to win, and the push was over.

It goes down as one of WWE’s most pointless moves this year. Zack’s big moment lost all meaning when he lost in front of his father on Raw, and he now finds himself treading water in SmackDown’s tag division. A waste of airtime for a performer who probably deserves better.


8. Enzo & Lana

Enzo Lana Hotel Room
WWE

The past few weeks have seen WWE push their PG rating to the absolute limit with Enzo Amore. It kicked-off a few weeks ago when Enzo decided that it was perfectly acceptable to parade around naked in front of another man’s wife, before Rusev showed-up and squashed him like a bug. Things escalated with a hotel room rendezvous last week: Lana lured the gullible Enzo in, and Rusev sprung the trap.

Last night’s Raw saw Big Cass take to the ring to stand up for his perverted buddy, but the motivations are all over the place. Enzo has been dead wrong since day one, and it’s impossible to feel sympathy for him, even after the hotel room brawl. Rusev, once again, has done nothing more than stand up for his and his wife’s honour, yet fans are expected to believe that he’s the villain in all this.

The angle is a flashback to the Attitude Era’s very worst moments, and the sooner it concludes, the better. It paints Enzo and Cass in a completely unlikeable light, and Rusev, once again, comes-off as Raw’s most valiant babyface. Maybe we’ll get a decent hoss fight between Rusev and Cass out of it, but that’s the absolute best we can hope for at this point.


7. Shane McMahon's Lockbox

shane mcmahon vince mcmahon undertaker
WWE.com

Shane McMahon made a welcome return earlier this year. In a promotion often dominated by megalomaniacal authority figures, Shane is a likeable presence on SmackDown, and while guilty of hogging the spotlight a little too often, his presence is a lot more tolerable than his sister’s on Raw.

Unfortunately, the road that saw him become SD’s Commissioner was long, winding, and incredibly contrived. Shane came back to WWE to demand his father cede control of Raw to him, and used a lockbox full of sensitive information to blackmail Vince’s compliance Vince, of course, started panicking: the box presumably contained some of his deepest, darkest secrets, and if they were revealed to the world, he’d be ruined.

Vince and Shane struck a deal: Shane would face The Undertaker at WrestleMania, and if he won, he’d have control. If he lost, however, he’d leave the company forever, and Vince would remain in-charge.

What happened? Shane lost, Vince gave him the job regardless, and the lockbox was never mentioned again. The charade rendered Shane vs. Taker utterly meaningless in the end, and the lockbox joins the pantheon of unfinished WWE storylines. Creative could scarcely have come up with a more hackneyed way to reintroduce Shane McMahon.


6. The New Day-letion

Big E Wyatt Compound
WWE.com

WWE aren’t exactly shy when it comes to imitating other companies’ ideas. From aping ECW with the hardcore division to repurposing Eric Bischoff’s villainous boss character with Mr. McMahon, the company have been “borrowing” from their competitors for years, and it continued in 2016.

WWE’s monopolistic situation means they can get away with almost anything they want these days, including blatant theft. “Broken” Matt Hardy and The Final Deletion saw TNA benefit from an upsurge in viral popularity this year, and WWE just couldn’t help themselves: they took themselves a slice of the pie, and the results were middling at best.

Creative attempted to recreate The Final Deletion during The New Day’s feud with The Wyatt Family. As the rivalry escalated, Bray Wyatt invited Xavier Woods & co. to fight at the Wyatt Compound, and it was every bit the toned down, PG-friendly fugazi you’d expect. There were no dilapidated boats or drone assaults here: just a bland outdoor brawl from a company terrified of hitting the same levels of absurdity as Broken Matt and Brother Nero.

A terrible idea from start to finish, the Wyatt Compound brawl was rightly slated by all who watched it. The Final Deletion succeeded for its self-aware ridiculousness and all-out fun, but this was just a typical WWE scrap in a different setting.


5. Gallows & Anderson Jump The Shark

gallows anderson old day
WWE.com

What happens when you take one of NJPW’s most prominent tag teams and throw them under WWE’s spotlight? Creative meltdown, apparently.

Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows debuted strongly, but it soon became apparent that they weren’t to be taken seriously. They were used as fall guys in AJ Styles’ feuds with Roman Reigns and John Cena, but as bad as that was, things got exponentially worse in the Brand Split.

While Styles shined on SmackDown, Gallows & Anderson became objects of ridicule on Raw. The duo became entrenched in one of the worst feuds of the year with tag champs The New Day, and suddenly forgot all about the no-nonsense personas that brought them there in the first place. Instead, Gallows & Anderson donned labcoats, started collected testicles, and officially jumped the shark.

If that wasn’t the death knell, then The Old Day certainly was. It was WWE’s worst segment of the year, and a creative low-point for all involved. Comedic imitation segments can be great, but this wasn’t Triple H and Shawn Michaels impersonating the McMahons, and it died a horrible death the moment that Gallows & Anderson brought their elderly New Day surrogates to the ring.

WWE have tried to re-establish The Club as straightforward ass-kickers again in recent weeks, but you can’t put the toothpaste back in the tube. For now, it’s impossible to take them seriously in the tag division.


4. The Entire Cruiserweight Approach

Brian Kendrick TJ Perkins
WWE.com

From the moment they debuted on Raw, WWE’s Cruiserweight division has been a complete creative flop. Their first mistake came from introducing the division without its champion, TJ Perkins, who was white-hot after winning the Cruiserweight Classic. It has been a hot mess ever since, and while the Cruisers now have their own Network show, 205 Live has offered little hope that the situation will ever improve.

For whatever reason, WWE have the Cruiserweights wrestling like nothing more than smaller heavyweights. Instead of showcasing their speed and agility, the Cruisers spend most of their time working restholds and slowing the pace. They’ll throw the odd dive or two into the equation, but that’s it: there’s very little to differentiate them from the company’s other wrestlers, and thus, little reason to pay attention to them.

The lack of character development is unforgivable, though. Rich Swann is building some popularity on his own, but TJ Perkins’ goofy video game gimmick has killed him, and Brian Kendrick’s redemption story died the moment he begged Perkins to let him win. Nobody outside the main title program is ever given a chance to cut a significant promo or let their character grow, and this it impossible to get invested in them.

Creative have botched what should’ve been an exciting niche division, and barring a hard reset, there’s little that can be done to salvage it.


3. The Rock Vs. Erick Rowan

The Rock Erick Rowan
WWE.com

The Rock’s WrestleMania 32 appearance played to two of modern day WWE’s biggest clichés: using part-timers to bury full-time roster members, and cramming their biggest cards with overlong filler.

As the biggest natural celebrity that wrestling has ever created, The Rock had to be involved at ‘Mania. His presence all but guarantees a few thousand ticket sales, but while he continues bringing money into the company even in semi-retirement, his appearances are often to the detriment of another worker.

It was The Wyatt Family’s turn this time around, and specifically Erick Rowan. After a pitifully small scale flamethrower-wielding entrance, Rocky took the best part of 15 minutes to announce the night’s record-breaking attendance before he was eventually interrupted by the Wyatts. The Rock, of course, ran the Wyatts into the ground on the microphone, then eventually challenged one of them to a match. Rowan accepted, and he was promptly squashed in six seconds.

Erick Rowan’s never going to be a huge WWE singles star, but that’s beside the point. The company took whatever heat he had left and fed it to The Rock, who’ll never have to worry about the repercussions. Rocky gained absolutely nothing from the segment, while the Wyatts went home looking like a toothless gang of swamp geeks. Nice work, WWE.


2. Not Turning Roman Reigns Heel

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Mast fans have long since given up on the idea of Roman Reigns turning heel. It was immediately apparently that this “top babyface” project would fail from the moment his hand was raised at the 2015 Royal Rumble, but WWE have stayed their course in the face of escalating negativity. This will likely be the norm for the rest of Reigns’ career with the company, and we might as well get used to it.

That being said, WWE missed an excellent opportunity to finally pull the trigger earlier this year. Reigns walked away from WrestleMania 32 as a reviled World Champion, and as he spoke the next night on Raw, he was dripping with smug arrogance. His “I’m not a good guy, I’m not a bad guy,” quip made for an excellent soundbite, and it looked like WWE were finally tapping into his naturally cocky persona.

But the turn didn’t happen, and Roman Reigns remains Raw’s preferred babyface. Not turning him is a horrendous creative decision that, had it gone the other way, would’ve immediately resolved one of Raw’s biggest problems. It would’ve established Reigns as the brand’s top heel, let Seth Rollins slide into a more natural face role than the one he plays today, and cleared much of the murk surrounding Raw’s current title scene. Unfortunately, this seems like too much to ask for at this point.


1. Overexposing James Ellsworth

AJ Styles James Ellsworth
WWE.com

Goldberg’s mauling of Brock Lesnar aide, the James Ellsworth saga will finish as 2016’s most divisive angle. Some have been against it from the start, but others fell for Ellsworth’s goofy charms from the moment Braun Strowman murdered him on Raw. The main issue now is that Ellsworth has greatly overstayed his welcome, but he’s so deeply ingrained the AJ Styles vs. Dean Ambrose story that he can’t just be unceremoniously removed, and that’s an issue.

WWE could have gotten away with handing Ellsworth one screwy win over the World Champion, but three? Not so much. Sure, Ambrose was heavily involved in all three matches, but losing to a chinless enhancement guy only harms AJ, who’s had a stellar 2016 otherwise.

Furthermore, the damage done to the WWE Championship cannot be easily undone. The belt should exist as a tool to put over the best of the best on SmackDown, and by involving Ellsworth, WWE are essentially saying that hard work, dedication, and everything else it takes to reach WWE’s main event don’t mean a thing anymore. Any old bum can just fumble their way into a title shot, and Ellsworth proves it.

Had this played-out on a smaller stage a la Colin Delaney, everything would be fine. Ellsworth might have been a fun, credible addition had this story taken place in a midcard feud, in fact, but his continued presence only cheapens SD’s main event scene, and dilutes the excellent Styles/Ambrose rivalry.

Fair play to the guy for grabbing his opportunity with both hands, but it’s hard to take SmackDown seriously with him around. Here’s hoping WWE let Ellsworth’s story fall away sooner or later, because there’s little else they can do now that he’s turned heel.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.