10 Coldest Performers In WWE Right Now
Oh, Enzo Amore.
This list is shaped relatively.
It isn't a ranking of which jobber is the worst jobber - mostly for the sake of variety and to avoid drilling into the minutiae of why Curt Hawkins is slightly worse at selling offence for a minute and a half than Primo Colón.
The status of these performers isn't necessarily - or at all - their fault. RAW has largely lived up to its rich legacy in recent weeks. as the much-maligned creative regime remembers that it is Big 4 pay-per-view season. The Dean Ambrose/Seth Rollins reconciliation angle has revitalised both men to a level thought inconceivable just a couple of months back. All four men involved in the SummerSlam headliner appear very much as the monsters they have been depicted as. That match - Godzilla Vs. Biollante Vs. Gigan Vs. Destoroyah - has been hyped brilliantly. Even Akira Tozawa Vs. Neville has been lent a degree of intrigue, even if the method was dubious at best. Elsewhere, outliers and name stars alike are caught in the cogs of the spluttering WWE machine, either as ill-fitting parts or out of date software.
In some cases, the apathetic booking is catching, infecting the performance levels of those victimised by it.
10. Mike Kanellis
Is Mike Kanellis already knackered?
He's done what boils down to nothing at all on SmackDown Live, given that his sole televised win - over Sami Zayn on the July 18 SmackDown - was retconned at Battleground. He also lost a meaningless tag team bout alongside Aiden English to Zayn and Tye Dillinger on the very next SmackDown. He didn't really show much in any of those three bouts, either. He spent the vast majority of his time on the receiving end of offence - from Sami Zayn, perennial punching bag, remember - which probably served his cowardly character. But what is his character, really? A catchphrase and an awesomely cheesy entrance theme?
It's baffling. There's no other word for it. There must have been some sort of long-term plan in place; why else debut the double act on the main roster proper? Isn't that what Triple H insists upon when batting away accusations that too many talented acts are doing anything of real significance in WWE?
All we have at this point are questions - but Kanellis, unquestionably, is dead on arrival.
9. Bray Wyatt
The Bray Wyatt character has reached such a nadir that it's difficult to determine if he embodies wasted potential or emperor's new clothes. Was he ever any good? That Daniel Bryan match from Royal Rumble 2014 was incredible. But then, most major Bryan matches were. The Last Man Standing bout with John Cena at that year's Payback was another blinder, but Cena tends to excel under that stipulation.
It's just so, so tiresome at this point. Wyatt waffles on about his Godlike powers before either getting soundly beaten or using the most mundane tactics imaginable in what is wrongly depicted as creepy psychological warfare. Monday's bloodbath angle might have impressed as a spectacle, if the red stuff rained down from on high. It didn't; Wyatt was handed a mundane bucket from a crew member when the lights went out. He also trapped Randy Orton under a fridge during the naff House Of Horrors match at Payback. He might as well use a remote control as a foreign object at this point. At least then, he'd have our undivided attention.
His recent performance level and confidence has degenerated in parallel with his eternally shoddy booking. He doesn't seem to hit his body avalanche with the same oomph anymore. Sister Abigail doesn't have the same snap.
Is a full reset in order?
8. Dolph Ziggler
It's strange to recall 2013, the year in which Dolph Ziggler was poised to belatedly enter the main event picture. It didn't happen; even though the stars aligned to turn him face, a scenario many of his supporters had already schemed to engineer, by many accounts Vince McMahon just didn't see top-level potential within him. His concussion wasn't a felix culpa but reinforcement that he didn't have the stuff.
On his day, Ziggler remains a very good performer - the problem is that, face or heel, he is indistinguishable from the 2013 vintage. The vast majority, if not all, of Ziggler's matches follow a somewhat shallow back and forth template in which he looks far more convincing selling than he does on the offensive. He always has. He has never been able to balance his act, and that's likely the problem. The Dolph Ziggler shorthand is "good at bumping" - hardly headliner material. He looks and wrestles like a guy besotted with the WWF's New Generation era midcard.
Ziggler's stock in trade was fun, frenzied matches at his peak. Those are now the norm in WWE. He has been eclipsed by the post-NXT crowd, and you get the impression that his surroundings no longer inspire him. His last singles PPV singles bout, opposite Shinsuke Nakamura, of all people, was tepid.
If anybody in WWE needs to take the Cody route to renaissance, it's Dolph.
7. Lana
You've almost got to feel sorry for Lana. She's nowhere near ready to wrestle on the main roster, but she's a popular star and has thus been promoted prematurely...into a position designed to mock and strip her of that popularity. She is trapped in this stupid paradox like a hamster in a wheel, perhaps even less relevant than she was in 2015 at the the depths of the Dolph Ziggler affair.
On the August 8 SmackDown, Charlotte acted as a proxy for the audience when, before their match, she crossed her arms and more or less p*ssed herself laughing. After one solitary hope spot, Charlotte dispatched her with the greatest of ease. Lana is booked as being out of her depth. And she is. There's no real drama to that. Isn't wrestling meant to be a work? She's a heel, so the audience isn't being conditioned to support her, à la Mikey Whipwreck. And since she's demonstrably less qualified than everybody else in the division at her job, it's nigh on impossible to jeer her. She's just pitiable. That, sadly, is the point.
You can't even hate her for being deluded, because it borders too closely to genuine mental illness.
6. R-Truth
R-Truth is custom-built for Main Event in 2017 - a show watched only by the absolute diehards at home - because they are the few who still care about him. His schtick is engaging enough for the live crowds, so his continued employment makes sense in the context of a glorified dark match hype man.
The problem is that he remains a fixture on RAW. He's a profoundly exhausted presence on WWE television, playing the same role he debuted in nine years ago. That's longer than Bret Hart's entire WWF singles run. His feud with Goldust went about as well as the tag team did, which makes you wonder why WWE bothered. But those three hours of RAW barely fill themselves.
Truth heard little Jiminy Crickets when he interrupted Goldust's The Shattered Truth bit on the July 3, RAW - probably because the prospect of a match - truly, any R-Truth match - was uninspiring in the extreme. It's not his fault; he's hardly going to add to his repertoire or do something new when his typecast role is so limited. But why...has he been employed...for nine years?
He's safe, reliable, loyal and free of injury. There's an upside to him - from the perspective of the office only.
5. Jinder Mahal
It might not be fair to judge Jinder Mahal by the standards of a WWE headliner - but we're being asked to, so there you go. He is less incongruous as WWE Champion than he has any real right to be, but not at all credible at that level.
On some level, putting the belt on Jinder Mahal works. He's not a workhorse, he didn't earn his stripes the hard way, he is a McMahon wet dream, transmogrified - a perfect heel for 2017, basically. It just doesn't yield entertaining wrestling matches because the standard set is impossible for Jinder, with his still-basic mechanics and lack of big (even long) match experience, to meet. Mahal requires a certain legitimacy to lend something to his inelegant, basic style. He doesn't have any. His facial expressions have improved, but they're still of the gurning foreign menace garden variety. The novelty was worn off. Mahal as WWE Champion is no longer controversial, interesting, or fresh, if it ever was. It is tedious.
Luckily, he wasn't replaced as WWE Champion by the equally unconvincing...
4. Baron Corbin
Baron Corbin isn't as bad as his many critics make out. He carries himself - and it's vulgar - but the best way your writer can think to put it is as a piece of sh*t. Just a nasty, careless, aloof, entitled guy. He has body language nailed down - it's just that this approach to character doesn't translate to entertaining or even interesting pro wrestling matches.
His style is almost defiantly ugly. There's no intensity to it. He just sort of ambles about, sluggishly striking his opponents with a detached sloppiness. It works on paper. He's an intentionally boring, no-frills bruiser who wrestles a style antithetical to what's popular. It might translate better, if he were to establish that foundation and race through the gears with a reluctant urgency, once his babyface foes get the better of him during their comebacks - but he doesn't. He only knows one, and it yields very little excitement.
The approach might work, if he were part of a big man tag team. But he isn't; he's a singles act pushed far beyond his limitations. It's especially irritating, given that there are plenty of other guys on the roster far more capable of generating effective heel heat. Neville, for example, can reconcile workrate and character.
Corbin, alas, cannot.
3. Jason Jordan
It's bordering on the disastrous, this Jason Jordan business.
Here's a guy who electrified TakeOver crowds with his and Chad Gable's über-athletic Steiner Brothers update. He had some much going for him: likability; babyface fire; crisp, crowd-popping hope spots. At least, he did, before he was unveiled as Kurt Angle's son. The angle hasn't worked. At all. You can sort of see what they're going for with it. An injury contrivance on the August 7 RAW forced Angle to throw a nearby enhancement talent at Jordan to fill TV time. This accidental nepotism didn't generate effective heat. The usually molten and invested Toronto crowd amused themselves with detached, mild chants of "Let's go, jobber!" They rattled Jordan, whose smooth offence unravelled in a clumsy mess. He reacted with an expression that more or less read as how did this go this wrong this quickly?
The tactic of programming Jordan with Miz, usually guaranteed to receive the desired reaction, hasn't worked either. It's strange even on paper. If the match with Jean-Pierre Goulet was meant to trigger accusations of favouritism, as part of a slow-burn heel turn, why position him in a feud with a heel? Arguably the best one, no less?
WWE have contrived to make a tall order even taller by confusing everything. The only thing that makes sense is the crowd reaction.
2. Emma
Emma is obviously disgruntled. She took to Twitter recently to confirm as much. WWE have spun fiction from this fact in a classic careful-what-you-wish-for scenario. She wanted an opportunity...so was afforded the luxury of losing to Nia Jax in two minutes on the July 24 RAW. She progressed on this week's RAW, in that it took Mickie James three minutes to put her away.
It's as if she is suffering from Dolph Ziggler Syndrome; she's telling WWE how good and how under-utilised she is without necessarily showing it. Emma, when motivated, is an awesome talent. Her match with Asuka at NXT TakeOver: London was easily the best women's match not involving a Horsewomen WWE has ever promoted. None of the viciousness she displayed then, none of the urgency, was displayed in the James match. Emma took her down with a hair-pull snapmare, and applied a full nelson - but she was going through the (slow) motions. There was no intensity to it. Just barely suppressed resentment, and you can't really blame her. She knows she's being punished.
Her recent prove yourself story arc makes no sense for a heel because it's not really a story arc at all, but a disciplinary measure. Still, Emma might be better equipped than anybody on this list - which would have included Neville of all people last year, proving how quickly things can change - to improve her lot.
1. Enzo Amore
Enzo Amore has never been confused with a good wrestler. His positioning is dire - even dangerous at times. Barely anything he does looks painful. In the pejorative sense, yes, if you're feeling unkind. But that's not what he's there for.
He's there for reasons that are fast becoming redundant. He's a hype man for nobody, once this Big Cass Vs. Big Show feud is done with. It's obviously far too soon to reunite him with the former - and the nuclear heat he has with peers and management alike is probably as good a reason as any (in their mind) of turning the latter heel for the umpteenth time, purely for a schadenfreude-tastic beat-down angle. He can't (or won't) become a manager because WWE doesn't do managers. Corey Graves recently suggested a switch to 205 Live. Maybe he can compere it, because it's already struggling for acceptance as the workrate hour it is meant to be.
He's already looking like a relic. And, as popular as he is, he isn't immune to poor reception through mistreatment. He's been treated as an annoying ant, more or less, during this Cass/Show business. When Show carried him up the ramp at the close of the July 31 RAW, nobody cared about his plight.
At SummerSlam, WWE is literally putting him up on the naughty chair. Reinforcing the growing perception that he's a toddler is hardly going to help his cause.
If you enjoyed this article, and hold an interest in reading more in-depth work of mine, please head over to shop.whatculture.com and purchase my book Development Hell: The NXT Story.