10 Deadly Mistakes WWE Must NOT Make Before WrestleMania XL

It's a long road to Philadelphia; here's everything WWE shouldn't do...

Cody Rhodes Roman Reigns thumbnail
WWE

WrestleMania 39 was subjectively a leading example of how to promote a lucrative pro wrestling product.

Everything that has since succeeded it, has subverted WWE's breakthrough with fan interest.

Vince McMahon is back. He has the final jurisdiction on what makes it through the curtain as NewCo's Executive Chairman following Endeavour's deal with WWE. McMahon, who'd been out of full creative (mis)management since the summer, was reported to have had a hand backstage in the running of 'Mania's second day, a duty that significantly and evidently expanded by the time the post-WrestleMania Raw was broadcast. A litany of last-minute revisions, an emblem of Vince's time at the helm of WWE, culminated in the worst Raw ever.

Objectively, WWE has never been in a worse state. Its diehard audience is threatening - or at least attempting to, albeit incompetently - to boycott shows. While that won't outwit WWE, it may cause GUNTHER, the ruling Intercontinental Champion whose Final Boss identification has brought compelling dignity and prestige back to the title, to crudely drop the title to Shanky, such is the cynicism of a Vince McMahon-led WWE.

That's just one of the myriad of neglectful blunders WWE can't make en route to WrestleMania XL...

10. The Beast Ends The Story

Brock Lesnar Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

This was not the right call.

Cody Rhodes, who'd been conveyed as a determined, boisterous God since his April 2022 comeback, was ultimately felled by Roman Reigns in a 'Mania phenomenon that yielded a counterfactual result. Rhodes was the guy, the one to beat Roman, the one babyface who has possessed the same natural, gripping charisma not seen since peak-John Cena.

And then he lost.

And then he got battered by Brock Lesnar.

Rhodes vs. Lesnar will doubtlessly be a grandiose contest the likes of which WWE markets itself on, but how will they consummate the accurate result? Cody's lost all momentum. The audience was cheering when he got mauled by Lesnar - a move that is undividedly WWE's wrongdoing - so a Cody Rhodes victory may not be the enviable conclusion it once was, though it's unquestionably the correct one.

Cody, in theory, needs to get past Brock to get back to Roman. There's a way of tying this senseless heel turn together; Lesnar, unable to challenge for the top prize as long as it's on Roman's shoulder, could have been employed by Paul Heyman to mutilate Cody with the affirmation of a title contest.

It's too elaborate a story beat for WWE's inconsequential and trivial 'storylines'. But it works, so long as Cody slays 'The Beast'.


9. Retiring The Women's Tag Team Titles

WWE Women's Tag Team Championships
WWE.com

WWE does not care about the Women's Tag Team titles.

Introduced out of necessity, not want, WWE has done little to underscore the value of the titles in the four years they've existed. Lengthy reigns with the titles don't illustrate fabled reigns; they represent WWE's lack of intelligence that they do indeed still exist. Such was the case in 2022 when, after unceremoniously stripping Sasha Banks and Naomi of those belts, they immediately promised a tournament for the now-vacant titles that never came to fruition until three months later.

Post-Banks and Naomi, the doubles titles haven't been in improved health. However, there is no qualified reason for WWE to bin the straps.

They're not distinguished, reputable, or carrying any meaning, to the point they were the only titles not defended at WrestleMania 39, but they do provide a playground for WWE's female midcarders. That's wasn't quite the case lately, with Becky Lynch and Lita holding the championships for a spell, but take a glance at the prior few sets of champions - and indeed new Tag Team Champs Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez - for a forewarning of what discarding the titles would do.


8. Switching Plans

Trish Stratus Becky Lynch Lita
WWE.com

Frustration and demoralisation have been the leading feelings backstage in WWE in lieu of Vince McMahon's return to creative power, a position he'd promised, a position Paul 'Triple H' Levesque promised, and a position Nick Khan promised that he'd never return to. Said Vince, verbatim, when questioned on his role within WWE's creative team during his CNBC interview on 3 April, hours before his dispiriting Raw return:-

"On a higher level, yes. In the weeds, no. Can’t do that."

WWE under Levesque wasn't undamaged. He had a propensity at the onset of his run for serial cheap pops, re-signing a horde of budget cut victims who, in truth, weren't victims at all; they were better outside of WWE.

A redeeming quality of Papa H's regime, though, was his aptness to stick to the plan. This can be disadvantageous at times, of course - maintaining Karrion Kross as a main eventer in his first few months back when he was colder than Glacier was fishy, for example - but when it works, it really works.

Remarkably, WWE under Levesque's navigation purportedly had "a year of post-'Mania plans". The Raw after 'Mania, though, was not what was planned; that's been well-documented. Such plans as the reported Becky Lynch vs. Trish Stratus SummerSlam attraction, however, are still going ahead. Straying from these plans would've disheartened the audience and those involved, which is perhaps why Becky had a face like a slapped ar*e on the Monday after WrestleMania 39...


7. Austin Theory, Top Star

Austin Theory
WWE.com

Austin Theory did not stagger under the Paul Levesque regime - but he hardly blossomed.

Theory and 'The Game' go back to before the former was a WWE mainstay; Levesque had scouted Theory while he was in EVOLVE and was hands-on with his progress while in NXT. Vince McMahon, meanwhile, took Austin under his wing, inordinately pushing him, and in turn shattering any modicum of fan interest left that had itself already taken a whipping. A ruinous, objectless Money in the Bank win and needless continuous reigns as United States Champion did nothing to profit Theory, nor the briefcase/title.

So there's a solid chance it'll all happen again!

WWE sees Austin Theory as the next big thing in wrestling, in spite of his lack of any convincing main eventer qualities. He's good, not great, but being adequate is cause for a Vince McMahon creatively-led WWE to strap up. "Someone will like it", Vince will guffaw, that someone being him; he's his own biggest supporter.

Theory won't be written off. He's too young. WWE should instead play a waiting game with him before spontaneously deciding upon him as the next face of the company. Not every WWE lifer will be a headline-quality talent; for Theory, that ideology must ring true before it's too late.


6. The Judgment Day Falls Flat

Dominik Mysterio The Judgment Day
WWE.com

Though Dominik Mysterio and Finn Balor both lost at WrestleMania 39, The Judgment Day remains one of the hottest things on WWE television.

There was a long period in 2022 when the initially Edge-helmed faction made for arduous viewing. The segments were desolate, the directionless characters lifeless, and the matches simpleminded; it sucked. Bad.

What changed it?

Dominik Mysterio.

Dom's addition to the group, which now comprised Finn Balor, Damian Priest, and Rhea Ripley, brought them life when, before, the third-generation Mysterio had been something of a deplorable buffoon between the ropes, too green even for WWE's rocket-fuelled push standards. He's amended his in-ring blunders to such a degree that The Judgment Day can come away from any given week as WWE's most must-see segment; Dom's 'Mania 39 entrance underlined this.

The group's prosperity came under Paul Levesque's command, with Vince McMahon's creative leadership nearabout seeing the group become supernaturally entwined. Edge was against this idea, sensibly, and thankfully the decision didn't go ahead even after his own removal from the group. This Vinceism - the idea of making any dark and broody gimmick supernatural - must stay away from the group in its current form; they're a Paul Levesque success story, of which there are dismally few.


5. Ruining The Ring General

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 GUNTHER Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

GUNTHER, under Paul Levesque, was promoted as a legitimate Final Boss, parading the Intercontinental Title as if it were a real, legitimate sporting trophy, a venomous striker whose every blow could be the last, a destructive powerhouse who makes Ricochet his basketball, a tenacious worker whose inaugural Royal Rumble performance broke a 17-year performance record set by Rey Mysterio (the Greatest Royal Rumble excluded), a dependable hand who was expectantly going to play a primary role for ten to 12 years.

GUNTHER, under Vince McMahon, was going to be buried.

WrestleVotes, per GiveMeSport, reaffirmed the belief that Vince McMahon wasn't impressed by GUNTHER's 4 July stint vs. R-Truth, and was indeed ready to either send the Austrian leviathan back to NXT or bury him. The former WALTER had already undergone a laborious task in order to gain upper management's confidence, shedding an incredible amount of weight ahead of his Intercontinental Title prevalence.

Vince McMahon coming back to power doesn't wholly mean GUNTHER is doomed, but he's hardly in the position he was previously. A spruce WrestleMania triple threat vs. Sheamus and Drew McIntyre, alongside his Royal Rumble performance and slew of Intercontinental Title defences, will ideally install trust in GUNTHER from Vince.


4. Still Fighting Forever

Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE Network

Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn have wrestled 18 televised singles matches in WWE; that number rises to 40 if you factor in tag team matches and 48 if you include multi-man fracases.

It's too much.

Their matches are no longer as unexampled as they were during their lauded Battleground 2016 collision. This marked only their fifth singles match under the WWE banner, and it was breathtaking. It laid the groundwork for what a Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn match should look like. Unfortunately, this meant everything that followed found it insurmountable to match it.

The above GIF, for instance, while once a cool-as-f**k spot that illuminated the contempt they held for each other, progressively turned into a humdrum spot, churned out whenever Owens and Zayn locked horns.

It's tiresome.

Thankfully, the duo are now the Undisputed Tag Team Champions, their days of squabbling and throwing Dark Order goober fists over. WWE, in dethroning The Usos as the champions, have left Owens and Zayn in a precarious position. Their involvement in The Bloodline angle is evidently not finished, and here's hoping WWE thinks of something creatively engaging for them in the coming weeks and months.


3. A Lacklustre Royal Rumble

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Logan Paul Ricochet
WWE.com

Vince McMahon famously didn't envisage the Royal Rumble match as a wise opportunity for his soon-to-be sports entertainment empire. You could argue that he still doesn't, given the scarce cautiousness with which they've often been produced, in spite of the professed WWE Universe's deep devotion for the stipulation.

2022's was a mess, its victors awfully predictable, its shock entrants either unimaginative or weirdly pre-announced, and its prevailing atmosphere being discouraging. 2017's was no better, a Randy Orton victory going down like a wet fart in a cramped church congression. 2014's is infamously blah, though not totally a terrible match.

2023's Royal Rumble was a modernised archetype of how a Rumble should look. Its winners were predictable, yes, but it was the right outcome in both cases. The surprise entrants were sensible, either for storyline purposes or through making use of NXT talent already being flown in. Keeping the use of blasts from the past to a minimum, using just two (Booker T and Michelle McCool). Star-making performances were in abundance across both Rumbles, GUNTHER and Rhea Ripley being made to look like epic, Godlike superhumans.

A return to banal Royal Rumble matches would genuinely turn a large fraction of the viewership away.

It's more important than WrestleMania to so many.


2. ANOTHER Saudi Title Change

Roman Reigns Solo Sikoa Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Roman Reigns is not losing the Undisputed WWE Universal Title until WrestleMania XL.

That should be the hypothesis WWE works with. His reign has become too grand for it to end at a SummerSlam or a Royal Rumble; however, it's principally true with WWE's forthcoming jaunt to Saudi Arabia. May's King and Queen of the Ring marks the ninth WWE Premium Live Event in the dubious country, and a prime occasion for WWE to strap up Cody Rhodes.

Rhodes' victory would be cherished by the live audience, but elsewhere? Not so much. As iterated earlier, the enthrallment surrounding Cody Rhodes is gone. A bleak WrestleMania and post-'Mania Raw have, for now, ravaged his respectability to the extent that defending WWE Champion Cody Rhodes is the last thing anyone wants to see. "LMAO Cody" was a defiant (see: hilarious) sign from Wednesday's AEW Dynamite; that this was in AEW, where Cody was for a while considered a hero, shouldn't be considered a jab at WWE's lackadaisical booking, but rather an apt depiction.

It just so happens that the date of King and Queen of the Ring - Saturday, 27 May - will mark exactly 1,000 days for Roman Reigns as Universal Champion. It'll be too easy, even by WWE's lethargic standards, to make the change.

That said, the easy option is rarely the correct choice.

'Mania XL it is.


1. Stifled Creative

Triple H Vince McMahon
WWE

The above image is not recent, but it does interpret the current feeling within WWE.

The Raw after WrestleMania 39 was the worst in history. Not subjectively, but objectively, the worst. A Cagematch rating of 0.61 at the time of writing ranks it the third worst pro wrestling show in history; for reference, the 28 September 2010 NXT (which featured no wrestling!) and the catastrophically terrible Heroes of Wrestling are the first and second worst shows. That's the level of awful dross we're dealing with.

On paper, the card wasn't cruddy. Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn vs. The Street Profits, Bobby Lashley vs. Mustafa Ali, and Austin Theory vs. Rey Mysterio are all, on paper, satisfactory and average Raw bouts.

Owens and Zayn ultimately didn't defend the Undisputed Tag Team titles, and instead contested a non-performance, a letdown of what could've been subjectively charming. Lashley pulverised Ali for just 38 seconds. Theory vs. Mysterio was as much of a house show match as Theory vs. John Cena was from two nights prior.

Matt Riddle returned, though, so, yay? No Jay White. No Randy Orton. No Big E. The audience did have their hopes up, it must be stated, but this?

This was Vince McMahon Vince McMahoning WWE all over again.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.