10 Dream Opponents For CM Punk In WWE

Could these CM Punk WWE return matches happen?! Never say never in pro wrestling!

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL CM Punk Seth Rollins
WWE/AEW

CM Punk was AEW's biggest signing yet when he debuted for the company a little over two years ago. Back then, hopes were high he'd take Tony Khan's group to the next level. Hell, even much-maligned 'C' show Rampage was a big deal with Punk onboard. Now, he's been ditched by All Elite and is a free agent once again.

Don't rule out a sensational return to WWE.

Sure, Triple H always struggled to see eye-to-eye with Punk, and several other top stars like Seth Rollins have gone on record saying he wouldn't be welcomed back, but this is pro wrestling - nobody can definitively rule out ol' CM strolling back into view at Survivor Series in Chicago this November, for example.

Besides, it's fun to play fantasy booker and look at which WWE stars Punk could wrestle if he did launch a comeback. Trips, Rollins and probably countless others don't have a ton of time for Phil Brooks personally, but even they'd have to admit that the might of WWE's machine promoting his return would do some tidy business.

Here's the business they should consider...

10. Matt Riddle

Matt Riddle
WWE

This might seem like an odd first choice on the surface, but stick with it.

Both CM Punk and Matt Riddle have MMA experience. Of course, the quality of their fights differed, but that doesn't alter the fact both appeared on UFC cards. This is something WWE could use to promote a match between the pair if Punk did return.

It wouldn't be anyone's first pick, but it could be handy to creative should Punk stick around for more than just one or two marquee blockbusters. Hearing the smart-arsed stylings of CM on the mic would fire Riddle up, and it'd bring that side of him to the fore again. Y'know, the p*ssed off dude who warred with Seth Rollins, not the fun-loving stoner.

WWE could even go one step further by putting these guys in the 'Fight Pit' and presenting it as some MMA rekindling. Just don't go 'Brawl For All' by promoting shoot elements or Riddle will destroy Punk. Let's be honest here, Mr. Brooks was never the next Ultimate Fighter.

Recent events probably render this a remote possibility, but Riddle always seems to get more chances than most.


9. Finn Bàlor

Finn Balor
WWE.com

One-time smiley babyface Finn Bálor has experienced his ups and downs in WWE, but he's currently riding high as a key member of the killer Judgment Day faction. Together, the group has started dominating like some second coming of The Bloodline, and that'll probably last until mid-2024 at least.

That's enough time to bring Punk in and pit him against Finn.

Bálor, as Prince Devitt, was earning international acclaim around the same time Punk was finding his feet in WWE and winning World Titles. By the time Finn landed in the company via NXT, CM had already told Vince McMahon and Triple H that he was going home, so they've never wrestled.

Punk would surely be interested by the prospect of tangling with a hot stable like Judgment Day and working opposite Bálor. Both earned plaudits on the independent scene pre-WWE, and it's safe to say they'd tear the house down in-ring if given the chance.


8. Logan Paul

Logan Paul
WWE

This is money waiting to pour in.

Critics on social media can say what they want about Logan Paul, but he's taken to this wrestling malarkey like a duck to water. The YouTuber-turned-WWE sensation also commands significant attention from a casual audience everywhere he goes, so it'd be smart business for CM Punk to grab some of those eyeballs.

Honestly, this would be a logical play if WWE fancied turning Punk into some staunch defender of wrestling (and thus a babyface by default in the eyes of most fans). LP would giggle at Punk's prior problems with management, then claim he'd never suffer the same fate because of how much cash he puts in tills.

Paul's natural aptitude for working athletic, impressive matches would lend itself to the style Punk has always enjoyed too. They'd be gold on the mic during promos, and surely wouldn't disappoint come bell time on a major pay-per-view either.


7. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE

CM Punk and AJ Styles are very different men now than they were when the pair last locked horns back in 2004. Both went on to succeed against all the odds, but took vastly different paths to WWE stardom. In 2023, AJ has quietly gone about his business, whereas Punk has become known more for backstage shenanigans.

Time to shoot, brother!

Styles has already worked in some shoot comments during feuds with everyone from Randy Orton to John Cena. He's no stranger to cutting words that fan flames before tasty bouts on PLE, and he'd surely relish the chance to give Punk a piece of his mind.

Of course, a match like this wouldn't build any new stars, but it would be a dazzler for old school ROH fans or those who like seeing WWE present matches nobody thought they'd witness in 2023/2024. Book this for the older crowd, then watch the pair delight a younger demographic too.

If you've followed Punk closely on social media over the last few years, you'll know that the animosity is very real - which always helps!


6. Kevin Owens

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Recent reports suggest that Punk toyed with the idea of leaving AEW in late-2022 then pitching a grand return during the 2023 Royal Rumble match. There, Jungle Boy's favourite wrestler would've been eliminated by Kevin Owens to set up a clash on the grand stage at WrestleMania 39.

That didn't happen, obviously, but there's nothing stopping it from going down in 2024. Why not? Punk likely still has some legal stuff to sort out on the All Elite side before returning to the ring anyway, so a Rumble berth in January isn't out of the question. Also, KO just lost the Undisputed Tag Titles alongside on/off pal Sami Zayn, so he'd be free come 'Mania season.

Unless WWE fancies booking another Kev vs. Sami match, that is.

Creative could always get to Punk vs. Owens down the road even if that was a locked in plan for WrestleMania. This is the sort of bout some figured could happen if KO jumped to AEW, but now it looks more plausible on the WWE side.

Also, again, Punk and Owens do not get along in real life -


5. LA Knight

LA Knight WWE
WWE.com

You might be spotting a trend with some of the picks here. Many of them obsess over what it'd be like to see Punk war with WWE stars over the mic, but that's because the dude writing this firmly believes talking is the man's main strength in 2023.

Naturally, he can still work, but verbal spats would go down a treat on Raw and SmackDown. Right now, few are better-prepared to battle on the mic than LA Knight. That's really why he's on the list. Also, recent reports suggest WWE plan to tie LA down to a longer deal, so it'd make sense if they strapped a rocket to him ASAP.

A win over Punk could do wonders for Knight.

He'd delight in tossing out shoot-style comments about CM's recent plight in AEW (without naming "that p*ssant company", of course) and lining up PLE matches that way. Using Punk's legacy star power to help elevate others wouldn't be a bad plan.


4. Brock Lesnar

WWE WrestleMania 39 Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Consider this a selfish wishlist item from your writer.

It feels like a lifetime ago that CM Punk and Brock Lesnar clashed in a 'No DQ' match at SummerSlam 2013. That pay-per-view happened over 10 years ago now! Back then, nobody thought anyone would be discussing any sort of rematch a full decade on, but it's funny how things change.

Brock is a much smarter worker than he was in 2013 - he'd make sure the match was high quality, and Punk would be motivated to show off his skills when brawling against a much larger dude. That scrappy underdog thing has always suited CM, to be totally honest.

Punk going one on one with Lesnar at WrestleMania (or perhaps as the headliner for some 'B' level PLE after the fact) could be tons of fun. They've got history WWE can plunder, and both have MMA backgrounds that could play a role in the story too.


3. John Cena

John Cena
WWE.com

Obviously, this depends on John Cena's schedule.

The main man might not be coaxed back by another match vs. Punk anyway. Cena may look at the scenario and think, 'Been there, done that'. Also, and this is rather important, JC isn't a patch on the in-ringer he was when these guys last battled in epic bouts over a decade ago.

He's an actor now, and only drops back into WWE occasionally. Regardless, from a fan perspective, there's something timeless about Cena vs. Punk. It's one of those classic company combos that carried pay-per-views on its back. If Triple H is looking for a retro flavour come 'Mania, then this would be the ticket.

Yes, it should make everybody feel sick that 2011-2012 was just called "retro", but let's move on. Punk vs. Cena may well work if it comes after a few CM vs. full time star matches. They'd take priority over this MITB 2011 throwback.


2. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Picture this: Roman Reigns successfully topples Seth Rollins at Survivor Series in Chicago. Just as he's leaving, 'Cult Of Personality' blasts over the PA and a sold out Allstate Arena loses it. Suddenly, a smirking CM Punk appears and stares down the 'Tribal Chief' as Paul Heyman's eyes bug out of his skull.

That'd be a powerful way to end the PLE.

Punk and Heyman have lots of history to dig up during such a feud, and Reigns is a shrewd enough businessman to realise that CM (whilst definitely WWE's past) could prolong his title run and deliver another box office smash hit for the company in the process.

Realistically, Punk wouldn't be coming back to dominate WWE anyway. He'd be there to make oodles of cash and work some big time matches, but there's no way he's supplanting someone like Roman in the championship picture. What a moment that'd be though. It'd be worth it just for the crowd pop alone.


1. Seth Rollins

WWE Payback 2023 Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Workmanlike World Champ and would-be Punk associate (had things turned out differently for The Shield) Seth Rollins doesn't have a lot of time for Phil Brooks. In fact, Seth has gone on record to say Punk should stay away from the company and even called him a "cancer" in the industry.

Ouch.

Again though, there's money to be made from personal issues. Rollins' World Title reign could use a few high-profile banner opponents to make it soar, and Punk is perfect for that spot. Together, assuming the pair squashed all that "cancer" stuff ahead of time, they'd work some sensational matches that'd play before huge interest.

Rollins doesn't need to take a back seat to anybody in 2023. He's earned his flowers 10 times over, but Punk coming in to try p*ss all over those roses could be some laugh. Time for "Philly Phil" to see what 'Sethy Seth' really has left in that back? Maybe.

Who else would you like to see CM Punk wrestle in WWE? For more like this, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After Payback 2023 and 10 New Directions For AEW After All Out 2023!


In this post: 
CM Punk
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.