10 Dream WWE Returns That IMMEDIATELY Became Nightmares

You're back on WWE TV and things look good. Oh no, wait...no, no they don't!

Shane McMahon WWE WrestleMania 39
WWE/YouTube/YourWrestlingYard

So you've made a dreamlike return to WWE and life looks good, eh? It'd be a shame if someone ruined it!

That meme-like sentence could sum up the borderline trolling of pro wrestling fans, WWE's own creative team (seriously, what were they thinking with some of these?!) and the universe itself to explain this nightmarish collection of comebacks that ended up being total disasters.

Frankly sh*te repackage jobs, bizarre attempts to give workers some personality and make them "entertaining", unwanted add-ons that backfired spectacularly and more - these happy moments turned sour in a heartbeat. Admittedly, it look a little bit longer for the rot to set in for some.

Not too much longer though.

Imagine the embarrassment of rocking back into view at WrestleMania, only to see your dreams dashed by an injury your own father once suffered on pay-per-view. That must've been humiliating for one Shane McMahon. What's that? Oh, surely you knew the wannabe Royal Rumble wrecking ball was going to feature here.

Shane-O isn't alone though. He's got some bad company when it comes to crappy comebacks that went terribly wrong almost instantly.

10. Matt Bloom

Lord Tensai Debut
WWE.com

"AAAAAAAALBEEEERT! AAAAAAAALBEEEERT! AAAAAAAALBEEEERT!".

Matt Bloom must've wanted the entire WWE audience to go f*ck themselves as he tried to carve out a new path for himself by introducing the cartoonish Lord Tensai on the 2 April 2012 Raw. The traditionally-rowdy post-WrestleMania masses were out in force for his comeback, and they eh...sure made it memorable.

People trolled Bloom hard during his first WWE appearance since 2004. They totally ignored his new-fangled gimmick, and instead gleefully let the watching world know that this dude used to be called Albert. In fact, he used to be called Prince Albert - yeah, he was a walking penis piercing!

Tensai wasn't laughing along with the crowd though. He was desperate to make this second go at WWE life stick, and he was surely horrified when peeps rejected the fresh look to remind folks of a name he hadn't used since 2002.

This Lord was dead in the water creatively within minutes.


9. Bobby Lashley

Bobby Lashley FFS
WWE.com

One Bobby Lashley didn't quite experience the post-'Mania Raw torture that Tensai did when he returned in 2018, but big Bob didn't have a great time of it either. If anything, it'd be a few years before Lashley felt at home in WWE again after launching his second run the night after WrestleMania 34.

Bobby worked a few tag team bouts before starting an awful feud with Sami Zayn. Who could ever forget his stilted, awkward sit-down interviews with Renee Young, or the infamous "Lashley Sisters" segment that had onlookers wondering if WWE's writers were deliberately sabotaging his comeback?

It was that bad.

This was a less-than-impressive start to life back in the fed for a future WWE Champion. He was roundly mocked for the sibling/family backstory stuff, and outright failed to convey any sort of natural charisma during those chats with a visibly-bored Renee before working some plodders against Sami over the dismal summer months.


8. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle Jason Jordan Raw 2017
WWE

The entire wrestling world was excited to see what Kurt Angle could do when he returned to WWE following a decade-long stay in TNA. His 2017 comeback made headlines for the right reasons, and everyone braced for cracking matches between Kurt and some of the E's finest.

Or not.

Instead, definitely due to his physical limitations, Kurt was turned into a bland Raw GM and then had to smile his way through the anchor that was Jason Jordan being revealed as his kayfabe son. Christ, people did not take kindly to that rubbish, and they were only too happy to let WWE know about it.

Worse, the story didn't really go anywhere in the end anyway. WWE lost interest fast, and Jordan was forced to retire from the ring early due to injuries. So, rather than watch the Olympian tear it up against Seth Rollins, Dolph Ziggler and others, fans saw Kurt as a dull authority figure who capped off his career vs. Baron Corbin.

Yuck.


7. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt Blonde Wig
WWE

Surprised to see Bray Wyatt here? Don't be.

OK, maybe this is a slight cheat, but it didn’t take long for the wheels to come off Bray's return run creatively. His introspective 'I'm battling demons' story had some legs, but WWE pressed the repeat button on it for far too long after his sizzling comeback at Extreme Rules 2022.

His first mini-feud, vs. LA Knight, was saddled with Mountain Dew branding that felt like it took away from the "Pitch Black" situation at Royal Rumble earlier this year. As if that wasn't enough, Wyatt sort of/kinda/almost brought back a neon-drenched version of his 'Fiend' alter ego and teased a union with chief antagonist 'Uncle Howdy'.

WWE stretched the most paper-thin of material out during his comeback run, then things got so bad a planned 'Mania 39 match with Bobby Lashley was scrapped. People were excited for Bray's return when it happened; they aren't now.

His future remains unclear.


6. Brian Christopher

Brian Christopher
WWE.com

Silence is never good for pro wrestlers.

Back in 2011, a heel Michael Cole decided to taunt chief rival Jerry Lawler by bringing his rebellious son Brian Christopher back. There, on the 14 March episode of Raw, Bri walked out to complete and utter crickets before berating his father for being a poor parent.

Meanwhile, folks opposite the hard cam could be seen chatting amongst themselves and/or getting up to hit the bathrooms, merchandise stands etc. Christopher, who hadn't been featured on company television since playing Too Cool's Grandmaster Sexay in 2001, continued laying into the 'King' at the commentary table.

The whole segment was painful to watch. Cole giggled his way through it, but Christopher and Lawler's faces told the story of two veterans who knew this was tanking big time on live TV. Those Grandmaster-esque dance moves during Brian's entrance are hellish awkward to watch now - people just didn't seem to know who he was, or care why he was there.


5. Scott Hall

Scott Hall 2002
WWE

It's really nice that Scott Hall received an iconic send off at the 2014 Hall Of Fame. His "Bad times don't last, but 'Bad Guys' do" line will live forever, and rightly so. The one-time Razor Ramon had personal demons aplenty, but he was a legitimately great worker in his prime.

2002 was not his prime.

Years of real-life problems during an often controversial stay in WCW had changed Hall by the time he returned as part of the nWo in '02. Heavily publicised substance abuse issues still had a hold on the guy, and they'd result in contractual termination mere months into his second go-around as a WWF'er.

During that run, Scott worked a depressing match vs. Steve Austin at WrestleMania X8, and turned in mediocre performance after mediocre performance as part of the rapidly fading nWo. He became background noise to Hulk Hogan's conversion from monochrome back to red and yellow, then got shown the door shortly after misbehaving (to put it incredibly mildly) on the infamous "Plane Ride From Hell".


4. Kevin Nash

Kevin Nash CM Punk
WWE

Originally, Kevin Nash's own 2002 was going to take this slot on the list. That was certainly a rotten time for the ex-Diesel, and he'll 100% never forget blowing out his quads during a Raw match. However, 2011 was just as soul-destroying for 'Big Sexy', and for fans watching him end the "Summer Of Punk" on a low note.

Nash surprisingly attacked Punk at SummerSlam, which paved the way for Alberto Del Rio to cash in his MITB briefcase. That led to a convoluted story about doing Triple H's bidding - the whole thing was so clumsily-told that fans lost interest almost immediately, and they wouldn't switch back on.

Kev's run ended after an ill-advised ladder match at TLC vs. Hunter.

So, to recap, he'd caused a title change nobody really wanted, ditched the rivalry with Punk in favour of one vs. Triple H, then worked a ladder gimmick despite having bad knees. Man, did anyone stop to think any of this through?!


3. The Ultimate Warrior

Ultimate Warrior Vince McMahon 1996
WWE.com

Granted, this was more of a "dream return" for Vince McMahon and his WWF than The Ultimate Warrior himself. Warrior blatantly fancied coming back for a payday, not because he was super invested in pro wrestling. To McMahon, his re-signing represented much-needed star power mid-battle with WCW.

It wouldn't take long for Warrior's ego to run wild yet again though.

He'd already been through the wringer with Vince in 1991, but things seemed peaceful until Warrior began making demands about his un-fancied comic book and skipping bookings all over again. His entire comeback run in '96 played out like a fever dream (see that smoking segment with Goldust for proof).

Warrior squashed Triple H at WrestleMania XII, then went on to wrestle a handful more televised bouts before the summer brought about his latest WWF departure. Being honest, things went south quickly, chiefly 'cause the real-life Jim Hellwig was very difficult to deal with.

Few on the roster were sad to see him go.


2. Batista

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE.com

'Are they saying Boo-tista?'.

Nah, fans in attendance for the 2014 Royal Rumble were definitely jeering as the fireworks rolled around a giant WrestleMania XXX sign and Batista pointed towards it after winning the 30-man match. In-ring, 'The Animal' looked baffled that folks would jeer his comeback success. Why were they doing it anyway?!

Two words, one name: Daniel Bryan. He'd caught fire with the core audience, and so fans dismissed Batista as a Rumble winner. They wanted the underdog technician, damn it! Big Dave took that one personally for a while, and obviously didn't care for the fact that a packed house in Pittsburgh booed the sh*t out of his return.

In fairness, that cannot have felt good for the returning hero. Batista could be forgiven for thinking everyone would be pleased to see him headline 'Mania, but no - Bryan was the name on everyone's lips. The feedback was so fiercely negative that WWE had to turn Dave heel.


1. Shane McMahon

WWE WrestleMania 39 Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Shane McMahon received a polite reception when his famous, "Here comes the moneyyyyyy" refrain blared over the speakers at SoFi Stadium for WrestleMania 39. Snoop Dogg had introduced Shane as The Miz's surprise opponent, and the bell sounded on an impromptu match.

Seconds later, McMahon was grounded on the mat clutching his leg. He'd torn his quad during a routine leapfrog spot literally right as the match began, and that was very much that. His 'Mania performance boiled down to a so-so reaction from fans, some rabbit punches, a leapfrog and then a hospital visit.

It isn't cool to see anyone get hurt at the best of times, but this was also terribly embarrassing for Shane-O. Thinking on his feet, Snoop stepped in and smacked Miz around for a bit before hitting a People's Elbow and confirming what everyone already knew: Professional wrestling is so f*cking weird.

And painful, if you're Shane.

Which other dream WWE returns went sour almost instantly? For more wrestling, check out 10 Nightmares That Could Come True In Vince McMahon's New WWE and 2 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage (April 7)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.