10 Dumb Stipulation Matches WWE Should Never Book Again

Apologies to Judy Bagwell, but no more weapons, contracts, or family members on poles, please.

Elias Jeff Hardy Guitar On A Pole
WWE

Some rivalries can't be ended with a "normal" wrestling match. Sometimes, the heat is so intense that there needs to be something extra to send both combatants into an explosive finale. Something that raises the stakes well above a simple 1-2-3.

And a Punjabi Prison match ain't it, folks.

People like to give Vince Russo hell for being the king of the asinine gimmick match, but wrestling history is rife with examples of match types that cheapen a feud instead of building it to a spectacular end. Whether it's a classically held match variety dating back to the territory days or a custom blow off created specifically for a storyline, there is a demonstrably wrong way to up the ante. If professional wrestling is going to continue to convert new viewers, then it's time WWE evaluates its stock of stipulations and eliminates some of the most glaring cringe.

Luckily, most of these shameful stips haven't been seen on WWE TV in a long time, but if Elias' recent booking is any evidence, there's no guaranteeing we won't be seeing some facepalm-inducing booking in the near future. To help pre-empt that shameful day, we're counting down the incredibly dumb match stipulations that need to be retired for good...

10. Object On A Pole Match

On a Pole Match
YouTube

Poor Elias.

As alluded to in the intro, the once-Drifter has been the butt of a couple of guitar on a pole matches in recent history, rendering the capable worker a two-time victim of one of the worst bout gimmicks in wrestling lore. Worse yet, he's lost both times, taking a smack of balsa wood across the back each time

All wrestling fans dread object on a pole matches. Ever since 2000, when viagra, treasure chests, and Buff Bagwell's mother were all hoisted above the turnbuckles as prizes for match contestants, the stipulation has been a stain on the industry. It's now synonymous with creative decline, an association WWE should be wary of.

Object on a pole matches can be funny, and not everything needs to be serious in wrestling, but no one walks out of one of these clashes looking better than they went in. Nor does the audience get much excitement out of watching wrestlers struggle to pluck a foreign object that dangles just barely above their grasp. Best leave this one in the bin of history.


9. Flag Match

Bret Hart Flag Match
WWE.com

At one point, nationalism was all you needed to build a red-hot feud. But in a fully globalized society, hanging a rival banner just isn't the insult it used to be.

Flag matches were invented as a way to bring the war-like fun of capture the flag to the squared circle. There were a couple of classics, notably the hyper-patriotic tilt between Hulk Hogan and Nikolai Volkoff in 1985, and the stipulation was basically Jim Duggan's entire gimmick on the late-80s house show circuit, but the Cold War was the last time the match meant anything. Latter-day variations seem forced and jingoistic, with Rusev's 2017 match against John Cena being the most enduring evidence of how WWE just could not get the Bulgarian Brute's booking right.

The last great nationalistic angle WWE filmed was when the Harts became Canadian heroes in the early days of the Attitude Era. They got two low-profile flag matches out of that, and they amounted to little more than cheap heat in the long run.


8. Chairs Match

Bayley Chair
WWE.com

Chairs matches are the bastard child of every TLC pay-per-view. Include solely out of obligation to fulfil the show's title, these matches always feel like an also-ran next to the other hardcore matches on the card.

There's nothing inherently wrong with a steel chair. On its own, it's still a visceral threat inside the wrestling ring. But everything that can be done with steel chairs has been done. Now, it's nearly impossible to build an effective match around the stipulation that they'll be involved.

WWE seems to have wisened to this fact, and they haven't booked a chairs match on a TLC since Randy Orton took on Rey Mysterio Jr. with a glut of folding chairs thrown in for good measure. The match was cold, and Mysterio won with a hurricanrana, of all things. Even Edge and Christian, masters of the con-chair-to, were almost never booked into this ho-hum match type.


7. Ambulance Match

Randy Orton Ambulance
WWE.com

When you're not even allowed to say "hospital" on WWE television, what impact does an ambulance have?

An attempt to add some realism to the casket match, the ambulance match lacks the wow factor of its supernatural cousin. We see emergency vehicles so often in everyday life that seeing two wrestlers grapple to shove each other into the back of an ambulance lacks any real threat. Sure, there's always a nice bump on the roof, but it never feels like the wrestlers are in any real danger.

Spare the viewers another one of these contrived feud-enders. If the loser absolutely must be sent off in a vehicle, there are more creative options on the table. Hell, even the trash truck that disposed of Braun Strowman at TLC 2017 was a welcomed change to the formula. At least there was an element of harm, they weren't just rushing him off to the "local medical facility" to tend to his kayfabe injuries.


6. Any Bray Wyatt Gimmick Match

Bray Wyatt Randy Orton
WWE

Like the Undertaker before him, Bray Wyatt has the kind of gimmick that just lends itself to specialty matches. But unlike Taker, the Eater of Worlds has never achieved that level of classic signature match.

There was the half-baked Wyatt Compound match in 2016, the abysmal House of Horrors match in 2017, the disastrous Ultimate Deletion in 2018, and the beyond-bonkers Firefly Inferno just last December. All of them sensational on the level that you would expect from WWE's most theatrical gimmick, but together they feel like cheesy attempts to recapture the magic of the Phenom's Buried Alive matches.

Since the Fiend got lit on fire in the Firefly Inferno match, rumors have been swirling that Wyatt and Randy Orton are headed to a third theatrical gimmick match. Here's hoping that WWE finally cracks the code and gives Wyatt the showstopper he deserves, but if history has proven anything, it's that they're better off booking the standard fare.


5. Inferno Match

Kane The Undertaker Inferno Match
WWE.com

While on the topic, let's just cut it out with inferno matches altogether.

Kane made the inferno match famous, playing into his pyromaniac gimmick nicely, but in every char-broiled battle, were you ever really concerned that he'd be legitimately barbecued? Fire is almost never utilized convincingly in professional wrestling, and lacing the outside of the ring with gas piping and lighting it like a propane grill has always looked ridiculous. The whole match usually builds up to an incredibly choreographed spot that is rushed off-screen, lest any of the children see and decide to torch their siblings.

That's perhaps the worst part about the stipulation. The danger is incredibly real, both to the wrestlers and viewers. Fire marshalls oversee everything, and stunt actors consult on how to minimize danger, all for a pretty underwhelming payoff of a dude's boot being set aflame for a half-second. With Kane moving on from any serious in-ring bumping, there's no character-driven reason to light the ring anymore. Let the match type retire with the Big Red Machine.


4. Punjabi Prison

Punjabi Prison
WWE.com

The Great Khali wasn't enough of an attraction on his own, it seems.

WWE booked the 7-foot Indian superstar like an absolute monster when he burst onto SmackDown! in 2006. Khali beat everyone from Mark Henry to the Undertaker, blazing a path through the roster like a man of his stature should. But when he and Taker were set to faceoff at that year's Great American Bash, WWE creative escalated the feud to a groan-inducing level with the introduction of the Punjabi Prison.

Basically a double cage match, with the bars being made out of "steel-reinforced bamboo" (whatever that means), the Punjabi Prison had an extremely complicated escape scenario involving four doors open for only 60 seconds each and a slew of primal weapons for combatants to torture each other with. It was also impossible to see through. When the match finally made it to pay-per-view, Khali wasn't even cleared to compete, and Big Show replaced him in one of the most frustratingly shot matches to air on WWE programming.

WWE seem to have realized how innately silly the concept is. When they revived it in 2017 to help put over the Randy Orton vs. Jinder Mahal WWE Championship match, there was an element of absurdity in the presentation. The Punjabi Playboy even made a cameo, but he's not looking as menacing in his middle age. Neither is his signature match, so maybe it's time to relegate the bamboo to the WWE warehouse for good.


3. Arm Wrestling Competiton

Steiner Triple H
WWE.com

In the leadup to their confrontation at Royal Rumble 2003, Triple H and Scott Steiner engaged in a contest of alpha male showmanship.

There were testosterone-filled promos, a pose-off, a bench press contest, and a pull-up competition, all meant to build anticipation for the first physical confrontation between the two hulks. But this was quickly undone when both The Game and Big Poppa Pump locked palms in an arm-wrestling competition on one episode of Monday Night Raw.

The old school appeal of two muscled-up rivals testing each other's strength is apparent, but in the kayfabe world of wrestling, it doesn't make for good theater. Rewatch the match, and you'll some of the most obvious over-selling in either man's career. The contest is completely devoid of drama, and it goes on longer than any shoot arm wrestle would. What a waste of the pair's first touch. The followup match was considered one of the worst in Royal Rumble history, which is thanks in part to this totally bogus stipulation being inserted into the build.

Lashley and Braun Strowman repeated the gimmick during a lifeless 2019 feud, and Hunter himself reprised the gimmick for a 2017 run with the Great Khali, so we know this is still in WWE's repertoire. We're lucky Drew McIntyre hasn't been booked to go palm-to-palm with Goldberg yet.


2. Strip Match

Melina Candice Michelle Bra And Panties
WWE.com

We'd thought the Women's Evolution had spelt the end of strip matches for WWE, but with the call for more edgy, sexualized content, who's to say WWE Creative won't book an evening gown or bra and panties match?

These nudity-teasing matches were a highlight of the Attitude Era, and as WWE tries to recapture the magic of the early 2000s, we could see a return of the detestable Strip Match. It's been 16 years since Melina and Torrie Wilson ripped each other's clothes off during Great American Bash 2005, and it felt cheap and exploitative back then. A revival in modern WWE would be tasteless and out of touch, though not totally out of the question.

Of all the entries on this list, strip matches are definitely the least likely to get booked in 2021. The brand has far too much equity to lose amongst its growing female audience, and the talent is well above the indignities of an undressing contest. But it never hurts to remind WWE of just how bad an idea this stipulation was to begin with.


1. Dog Collar Match

Piper Valentine
WWE.com

In nearly all its variations, the strap match is a thrilling culmination to any feud. Two bitter enemies, tethered together head-to-head separated only by a length of rope, leather, or chain. There is, however, one version that is silly enough to undermine the whole concept.

What does a dog collar accomplish that a normal wrist-bound chain can't? Unless you have a dog gimmick like Junkyard Dog or Rob Steiner, how do you even write this into a storyline? Invariably, it comes off as forced, and wrestlers would be better suited with an Indian strap or bull rope between them.

There's a lot of old-school nostalgia associated with dog collar matches, the most notable being Greg Valentine and Roddy Piper's defining battle at Starrcade 1983. Jericho and Perry Saturn tried to emulate the classic in 1999 at WCW Uncensored, but it ended up exposing the stipulation for all that it shouldn't be -- goofy and overwrought. Yes, Cody and Mr. Brodie Lee proved last year that you can do dog collars right in the 2020s, but history shows there tends to be more bad than good when two rivals resort to canine couture.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Elias
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jerard Fagerberg loves a good cheese danish. But does cheese danish love him back? Read on to find out.