25 Great Wrestlers That EVERYBODY Turned Against
WWE legends who suffered historic lows after the highest of highs
Wrestling is a fickle game ran by fickle promoters for fickle fans.
Imagine you're a pro wrestler. You wake up of a morning and your first job is to locate specifically where that pain is coming from, try to find the best way to deal with it and still function enough to get up, get out, probably get to the gym or get something (the exact right thing) to eat, and then get back to work - the place where all the pain started and will almost certainly reoccur.
Yes, this ignores the incredibly cool things that come from being a made megastar, but it's not as if those spots are in particularly high supply, and paymasters and fellow performers alike will repeatedly tell you as much. Everybody's life can be a grind, but when even your best bits come with significant caveats, it's easy to see why so many wrestlers crumble under the intense pressure or find themselves hating everything they once considered part of the dream.
The last thing you need at that point is for the aforementioned fickle promoters to shunt you down the card (or fire you!) and fickle fans to take their emotional and financial investment elsewhere. It's not for everybody, even those that know full well how people feel...
25. X-Pac
The Attitude Era moved at a frightening pace.
Driven - like everything else - by rampant competitive capitalism, Monday Night Raw's job in 1997 and 1998 was to catch up with, keep pace with and ultimately overtake WCW Monday Nitro in a ratings battle that, temporarily, benefitted both sides. By 1999, the gap widened to such a degree that the end result was never really in doubt, and WWE took a while to adjust to a world that wasn't driven primary by combat against the other side.
Before Vince McMahon even purchased WCW, Sean Waltman was one of the biggest victims of the war.
Having returned to the company with a bilious promo at Eric Bischoff's expense following an acrimonious WCW exit, X-Pac's man-of-the-people aura was the driving force behind D-Generation X's babyface turn. His matches, meanwhile, were carrying midcards as the market leader tried to make the best of a relatively shallow talent pool. For all the right reasons, he was beloved. Within a year of that though, DX had split and splintered, leaving X-Pac and Road Dogg as the loser babyface outliers in the divorce. A reunion as heels in late-1999 temporarily solved the problem, but when that frittered away in 2000, the same two couldn't buy reactions for their work on a roster that included the likes of Chris Jericho, Kurt Angle and The Radicalz.
Ambivalence meshed with anger to form a mulch of a reaction known then and in subsequent years as "X-Pac heat". There was nothing more brutal for a wrestler than being only mildly over when everybody was white hot, and the former human litmus test unfairly because a barometer of a different kind.
24. Shawn Michaels
It'd be inaccurate to say that Shawn Michaels didn't have a friend in the world at the height of his 1990s excess, but only because of the existence of Triple H.
Shawn Michaels was a self-confessed "angry young man" at the time, and regardless of why that might have been, he had absolutely no problem taking that anger out on just about everybody. As the top star and office favourite, he had more room than most to behave abhorrently, and anybody that spent time with him then has since spoken of a man unravelling (and an ego spiralling) uncontrollably.
In a few short years, Michaels indiscretions included but weren't limited to courting getting a kicking from the Disciples Of Apocalypse, ending up in a real life fight with Bret Hart after years of needle between the two, bullying Vader all the way out of a top spot, politicking a needless European Title win in England at the expense of Davey Boy Smith after the Bulldog had dedicated a win to his sister with cancer, and perhaps most apocryphally, threatening to not lose to Stone Cold Steve Austin at WrestleMania XIV under threat of - lol - getting a shoot beating from The Undertaker, sat ominously waiting at Gorilla for business to get done.
When he departed after that show at just 32, potentially forever, plenty of his enemies felt as though karma was real and justice had been served.
23. Chris Jericho
Chris Jericho was a beloved figure by at least half the North American wrestling audience in late-2019. He had to be.
The former 'Y2J' had been the surprise leader of a wrestling revolution, legitimising All Elite Wrestling as one of its banner stars and inaugural World Heavyweight Champion. He was a fabulous, complete heel in his new role, but the sort fans loved to hate, rather than actively disliked. It was perfect for the time, but Jericho was the last one to acknowledge when that time had passed.
An uneven 2021 in particular was a sign of things to come, but a particularly excellent in-ring run in 2022 led many to reasonably assume that the career renaissance man had done it again. It turned out to be the last peak of his time with the company.
A constant grating presence, his matches and promos were consistently the weakest aspects of Dynamite, Collision and Ring Of Honor (he spent time on all three), and quality of work seemed to have no bearing on quantity of appearances. Latterly in his tenure, some allegedly unsavoury actions outside the ring resulted in many audiences seemingly disassociating from anything he was doing on-screen, furthering the malaise.
As of writing, an once-thought-unlikely WWE return looks almost certain thanks to just how much he's in need of a fresh start.
22. Ronda Rousey
Comparisons to Kurt Angle didn't seem that wild as Ronda Rousey wrapped up her maiden year with WWE in the main event of WrestleMania.
The triple threat against Charlotte Flair and eventual winner Becky Lynch was far from perfect, but just about everything else she did from her debut at the prior WrestleMania onwards certainly was. Her debut alongside Kurt Angle against Triple H and Stephanie McMahon was a cast-iron Sports Entertainment instant classic, and she rode a wave of momentum into the summer months, becoming Women's Champion and working thrilling bouts against everybody from Nia Jax to Nikki Bella. 2018 was the year of the first women's Royal Rumble and the first all-women's pay-per-view Evolution. She debuted at one and headlined the other. 'The Baddest Woman On The Planet' was all in on WWE, and audiences were as grateful for her work as she seemed to be to have the opportunity to present it.
A brutal Survivor Series scrap with Flair was the best of the lot, but that was the night something shifted in the stands. Ronda heard boos (and lots of them) for the first time, and couldn't hide how crushed she was. That upset eventually turned to anger, and the character went from babyface to tweener to heel in a matter of weeks, supported by a host of caustic social media posts that were either in keeping with her character's shift or simply the real person getting frustrations out on a fanbase that had collectively turned its back.
Her Royal Rumble return in 2022 carried the burden of this breakdown, and a lack of great matches to offer a counter-argument resulted in disinterest winning out. Her final exit from the company in October 2023 was an auspiciously quiet affair, standing in direct contrast to going out at the top of the game four years earlier.
21. Charlotte Flair
Charlotte Flair might not have imagined that her 2025 return (at the Royal Rumble, with a victory in the Rumble match itself no less) would require rescuing by aligning her with Alexa Bliss less than six months later, but fans had made it crystal clear what they thought of her before she linked up with her fellow golden era NXT alumni.
It would have been reasonable to assume that absence had made hearts grow fonder for Flair, but outside of the battle royal win, the opposite was true. Flair was positioned against WWE Women's Champion Tiffany Stratton heading into WrestleMania, and when their promo battles very quickly developed into both women delivering fairly sharp barbs at one another, the fans made it clear who they favoured.
'The Queen' couldn't mask her disappointment at how quickly things had reverted to type, but what chance did she really have? The character had been relentlessly spotlighted during the last insane years of Vince McMahon's creative tenure, so much so that unfavourable comparisons were constantly made to the dire Roman Reigns megapush of the 2010s. Audiences have long memories, and the prospect of yet another extended singles run for the Charlotte Flair character at Stratton's expense pinpointed something very specific from the recent past they simply had no thirst for.
Ultimately, their WrestleMania battle was decent, Flair lost and the crowd - now free from panic - gradually re-embraced her as one of the division's true legacy players.
20. Dr Britt Baker DMD
Being popular with a mainstream television audience wasn't something that came easy for Dr Britt Baker DMD, but in many respects she had the best route to the promised land.
A failing babyface run in All Elite Wrestling's earliest days forced a heel turn right on the crest of the pandemic, and as lockdown restrictions were enhanced, so to were her animated facials and killer promos. She was almost immediately such an excellent heel that the fan-forced babyface switch became inevitable, but it was during that run where things turned badly, badly sour.
Baker lost a lot of time through injury, but had enough credit in the bank that a feud with Mercedes Moné in 2024 promised to deliver the biggest women's match AEW had ever promoted. Unfortunately, it was a long long way from being the best. The pair had the worst match at Wembley Stadium, and Baker's only appearance of note in the aftermath was a television match that ended with her verbally annihilating Serena Deeb right down the lens, killing the feud and both characters' presence on the show almost instantly.
As of writing, she's not been featured since, making it over year and a half since one of the company's biggest ever stars appeared on the show she helped make huge. It's been a damning period of time away thanks to the various political fires she was involved in before her exit, and though absence typically makes the heart grow fonder, Baker may yet be a rule-proving exception if/when she resurfaces.
19. Tessa Blanchard
It would be hyperbolic to say Tessa Blanchard had the whole wrestling world in her hands before revelatory social media posts unearthed stories from an ugly past. But a World Title reign was all hers, and looked set to be historic before old actions had new consequences.
Blanchard was crowned Impact Wrestling World Heavyweight Champion in January 2020 with a victory over Sami Callihan at the culmination of an impressively-booked intergender feud between the two, but right before her biggest professional triumph, a curtain was pulled all the way back on the person about to ascend. Blanchard had tweeted about what women can do in a predominantly male business when they support one another - a sentiment always worth trumpeting and one that was easily woven into the story set to culminate on pay-per-view. Alas, she'd made more than a few enemies that told tale of her doing anything but that along the way.
Allysin Kay (Impact' Sienna from 2016 to 2018) was the first to allege Blanchard's bullying and racism of fellow talent and members of the public dating back to 2017, found support from former Impact wrestler and future WWE star Chelsea Green, Shanna (then with AEW), Renee Michelle and eventually La Rosa Negra - a alleged victim, who noted an incident from several years prior.
Blanchard still won the title and held it as the pandemic took hold in 2020, but was stripped of it in line with her contract being terminated in June. After years in the wrestling wilderness, she returned to the re-rebadged TNA in 2024, but did so with so much baggage that many simply couldn't or wouldn't engage with her kayfabe persona without being consumed by the potential reality lurking underneath.
18. The Young Bucks
Much of this article relies on anecdotal evidence and/or widely-accepted narratives about talents that have either been enormously popular, hugely hated or most likely a combination of the two.
Somewhat regrettably, WhatCulture.com itself has evidence of The Young Bucks' distinct lack of popularity, regardless of what they've contributed to the industry over the past two decades. Over 2024 & 2025, WhatCulture Wrestling has ran fan polls for best tag team of the year, and not only have Matt and Nick Jackson not won either - they've failed to even come close.
Historically, The Bucks will offer at least one match a year that could make a case for being the match of the year, but through either a baked-in dislike of the pair, the never-ending tribal war between fans of WWE or AEW or possibly even the last dregs of a the CM Punk/Elite saga, there's something alienating about The Jacksons that exceptional action can't overcome.
This isn't the first time their quality has been so obviously overlooked or over-criticised. The pair named their book "Killing The Business" based on the preposterous accusation that was levied at them for daring to apply irony in their matches before it became commonplace, and have at very least leaned into the criticisms ever since.
17. Jerry Lawler
When territorial wrestling ruled North America, it was commonplace for wrestlers to portray different versions of themselves depending on where they worked. It didn't make sense not to - you didn't have to worry about your local hardcore fanbase catching you flipping the script on another channel because, bluntly, they couldn't.
There was only so much wrestling to watch on a national scale without the era's very best tech, and for Jerry Lawler's spot as Memphis' top star, this was perfect. Not only could he sometimes take his business elsewhere and experience a refreshing new crowd to work in front of, but when he finally elected to take a WWE deal in late-1992, he was able to play a monstrous heel on a standard Raw, Superstars or Challenge while completely justifying his behaviour back home.
This was never more fun that during his feud with Bret Hart. The unexpectedly exceptional rivalry traversed between WWE and USWA, but with the roles completely reversed. On any given Raw, Lawler would be telling Stu Hart to put his false teeth in backwards and eat himself to death, enraging 'The Hitman'. Meanwhile in Memphis, Bret led a WWF army including Randy Savage (!), Giant Gonzalez (!!) and Vince McMahon himself (!!!) to get revenge, but with actions that marked his lot out as the bad guys rather than the beloved 'King'.
The whole thing worked a treat for keeping both companies going during difficult times, serving as a reminder of how hatred in wrestling remained the quickest route to financial prosperity.
16. Jeff Jarrett
Right as Triple H was politicking his way to a groan-inducing "reign of terror" in WWE, TNA was starting as it meant to go on by donating its formative years to pushing founder Jeff Jarrett.
The logic around pushing the boss (or the boss' kid, or the boss' best friend) is that they're least likely to up sticks and leave when things aren't good, but problems with the conventional wisdom show themselves fairly rapidly the moment any aspect of the business takes a downturn. It's only then that the supposedly reliable performer is at the root of the biggest problem, and fans learn the hard way that maybe not every intention of the performer in question was a good one.
Jarrett's complex legacy with the company he formed resulted in him developing the reputation of being one of wrestling's savviest snakes. Active dread was the general feeling around his signing with AEW in 2022, particularly as many already considered the company vulnerable in the long looming shadow of Brawl Out.
His run ended up surprising even the fiercest cynics, but an early-2025 attempt at a Sting-esque retirement run was a reminder of the lingering dissent. After a couple of very poorly-received promo battles with MJF, the prospect of him potentially being a World Champion was dropped cold, as was his in-ring run with the company out-right. As of writing, his last match was a dreary defeat to Clauio Castagnoli in January, and the calls haven't been particularly loud for his return.