10 Gimmick Matches WWE Should NEVER Book Again

Time to put these stinkers out of their misery.

Big Show Akebono Sumo Match WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

A good gimmick match should leave you breathless, excited and entertained, but a bad one can leave you gasping for air too. Either that or you'll be palming your forehead and muttering, 'Who the hell booked this sh*t?'.

Stipulation bouts make sense - they're ideal for blowing off feuds, and they should (in theory) be perfect as unique selling points on bigger pay-per-views. Somehow though, WWE has muddied its own waters by introducing or returning to some of the worst ideas in company history. They need to start learning lessons, and they need to cast these match types out permanently.

The earliest example here is from 1994, and the latest is from this past week's episode of Raw. That's a sure sign that WWE hasn't learned any lessons when it comes to tragic gimmick matches; there are three bouts from 2020 alone on this list. That's...worrying, and the promotion should make sure they never repeat these abominations.

Don't work with children or animals? Add talcum powder, boats, hoods, well-known weapons and musical instruments to that. Welcome to the least fun collection of gimmick matches ever...


10. Kennel From Hell

Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

There's no better place to start than here.

The 'Kennel From Hell' match at Unforgiven 1999 between Big Boss Man and Al Snow was an unintentional comedy of errors. The "attack dogs" positioned between cages were there to snarl, bark and act aggressively, but they were far too busy humping one another and crapping all over the place for that.

Those turds were like a visual representation of the bout's quality. Seeing the old blue-barred steel return was weird enough, but placing that inside the iconic Hell In A Cell structure made things even more trippy. This was, by far, one of the least-effective gimmick matches in WWE history, and it must never return.

Start getting worried if Roman Reigns turns babyface and back into the 'Big Dog' next year. WWE might not learn from this dire piece of history, and they could be doomed to repeat it. Nobody wants to see this again. Nobody.


9. Crybaby Match

The 1-2-3 Kid Crybaby
WWE.com

What do you want to see when watching a pro wrestling pay-per-view? Thrilling in-ring action that you can't get anywhere else? Violent grudge matches? How about a grown man getting covered in talcum powder as another tries to put a nappy on his unconscious body?

That's what happened at In Your House 6.

The February 1996 show featured the WWF's first ever 'Crybaby Match', but the only ones shedding tears afterwards were the fans. Obviously, The 1-2-3 Kid and Razor Ramon did some nice work during their 12-minute opener - they were too talented not to. However, that 'Crybaby' ending sucked ass.

Kid's dramatic tantrum was WWF/WWE comedy at its worst. He flailed around like somebody had stolen his favourite toy, and the gimmick fell flat. The live crowd in Louisville responded to a gritty cage headliner between Bret Hart and Diesel with more vigour. Imagine that.


8. Blindfold Match

Santino Marella Drew McIntyre Blindfold Match
WWE.com

Attention all pro wrestling promoters: 'Blindfold Matches' are rubbish.

They're comedy set pieces, sure, but they have to rank amongst the worst tricks the 'variety show in tights' spectacle of wrasslin' can throw up. Once you've seen one, you've seen them all. That's a huge problem, because it doesn't leave much for individual ingenuity or flashes of inspiration.

Fans watching know workers will stumble around pretending they can't see one another at all. They also know that the heel will lift up his/her hood behind the referee's back to gain an unfair advantage. It's pure pantomime, and not in a good way. Every match plays out in almost identical fashion, which is boring.

WWE should think twice before booking another one of these snores. They're the kind of match type that should be restricted to house shows (when they come back), because they're only good for entertaining the kiddies in between trips to the merch stands.


7. Wyatt Swamp Fight

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman
WWE.com

WrestleMania 36's Bray Wyatt vs. John Cena was a remarkable blend of self-deprecation, wrestling culture and cinematic silliness. It was everything that was right with WWE's latest mid-pandemic trend, and it'll live long in the memory as one of the most charming spectacles of 2020.

The 'Wyatt Swamp Fight', meanwhile, will not.

WWE tried to recreate some of the brilliance of 'Mania and add a harder edge to it when Bray and Braun Strowman settled their differences at the awkwardly-titled 'Horror Show At Extreme Rules' pay-per-view. The result was a messy, disjointed and altogether unsatisfying brawl.

18 minutes felt like 18 hours. If this was supposed to become Bray's new signature match, then forget about it - it made the 'Firefly Fun House' epic look even better; in movie terms, it was Jaws: The Revenge, only somehow less charming.


6. Chairs Match

Sheamus Big Show Chairs Match
WWE.com

A bloody Chairs Match.

WWE's TLC pay-per-view hinges on the titular gimmicks themselves. Fans know they'll see people crash through tables and dive off of ladders. What's the worst part of that three-lettered acronym? The chairs. They're too commonplace to be anything other than a complement to the first two gimmicks.

So, it was a bit baffling that WWE decided to introduce them as a standalone match type when they turned TLC into a pay-per-view series in 2009. The Undertaker and Batista drew the short straw when creative told them they'd have to ignore tables and ladders in favour of belting one another with chairs like they erm... did every week on regular TV.

The 'Chairs' idea has been churned out on almost every event since, and it has never been tolerable. Hey, at least things can't get any worse though? Right? It's not like WWE would reach even deeper into a bag of sh*te to pull out something worse.


5. Stairs Match

Big Show Erick Rowan
WWE.com

OK, scratch that.

In 2014, the company decided they needed something a little extra to sell the December pay-per-view. Someone (curse them) piped up in a creative team meeting to say that maybe the steel steps attached to the ring should get some spotlight. Thus, 'Tables, Ladders, Chairs and Stairs' was born.

The braintrust also settled on Big Show and Erick Rowan as the perfect pair to make this lame idea work. If you're even slightly intrigued by what happened next, don't be. Show and Rowan struggled to make their stair-laden battle soar. They can't be blamed for that. Even Daniel Bryan and AJ Styles would've toiled.

Fans in Cleveland rightly rejected the notion that two big dudes lumping around the ringside steps was a worthwhile attraction. This was a failed experiment that somehow made the sorry Chairs Match idea seem slightly less egregious. Only slightly though.


4. Punjabi Prison

Orton Mahal Punjabi Prison
WWE.com

Confession time: Your writer was once taken by the thought of a barbaric bamboo cage. It seemed like the kind of battleground Jean-Claude Van Damme would've suffered through in one of his movies, and it definitely fit The Great Khali's 'final level boss' vibes. Then, he got injured and Big Show replaced him against The Undertaker.

So much for that signature feel.

It didn't help that the physical cage was painful to look at too. Fans squinted through the multi-layered shell at whatever action was taking place inside the ring. Then, they had to sit through interminable sequences and the whole trap door formatting. None of this fed urgency or excitement.

WWE revived the gimmick in 2017 for Jinder Mahal, but removed the spikiest of spikes and straps attached to the bamboo. If they ever think about wheeling this out again, they should whip themselves with those straps first, then cancel it.


3. Eye For An Eye

Extreme Rules Seth Rollins vs. Rey Mysterio Eye for an Eye
WWE.com

The best wrestling stipulations are those companies can actually follow through on. For example, the recent "I Quit" bout between Roman Reigns and Jey Uso at HIAC 2020 didn't end until the latter had screamed those magic words. Simple, easy to understand and doesn't need an elaborate out.

WWE's 'Eye For An Eye' match did need an out, and the promotion couldn't find one. That meant Rey Mysterio had to doctor his trademark masks to reflect the pretence that he'd "lost one of his eyes" against Seth Rollins. No-one believes it - they didn't believe it before the match happened, and they don't believe it now.

Future stips need to be a little less...over-the-top.

That might seem odd considering pro wrestling is OTT to begin with it, but yes. The thought that Rey lost one of his eyes forever following 'The Horror Show At Extreme Rules' was a bit far-fetched, and it's one to avoid for creative going forwards.


2. Sumo Match

Yokozuna Earthquake Sumo
WWE Network

There's a joke in here about sweaty blokes jostling for position. That's how some people view wrestling anyway, but they haven't witnessed true torture until they've watched WWE's mediocre attempts to piggyback on the sport of sumo. God only knows why Vince McMahon has tried this more than once.

1994's original between Yokozuna and Earthquake fit Yoko's gimmick and 'Quake's real-life background, but it wasn't a fun watch. Also, whomever decided that Big Show should show off his giant ass to the entire watching world against Akebono at WrestleMania 21 should get a healthy lashing with those straps mentioned in the 'Punjabi Prison' entry.

Wrestling fans just don't want to see this style of grappling, and most couldn't give a hoot about the traditional elements of it. It's always agonisingly slow, and it never leads to anything meaningful anyway. WWE's version of sumo can get in the bin.

It might not fit in the same one as Show's mawashi.


1. Anything On A Pole

Elias Jeff Hardy Guitar On A Pole
WWE.com

Fire up the WWE Network, head over to the WCW section, watch Vince Russo-era Nitro and you'll see an alarming number of 'Object On A Pole' scraps. Russo was obsessed with these, and his legacy has carried on for a good 20 years. The latest example was Elias vs. Jeff Hardy on the 2 November Raw.

Their 'Guitar On A Pole' bout was rather uninspiring.

That shouldn't come as a surprise. These 'Pole' duds are regularly tough to sit through, and the item wrestlers have to scramble for is rarely dangerous enough to make it worthwhile. Why would Hardy bother scaling for one of Eli's balsa-wood guitars when he could clock his rival with a weapon from under the ring instead. Sure, he might lose the match (depending on the leniency of the DQ rules), but so what?

It's not like beating Elias in some hokey gimmick match on Raw is going to define the 43-year old's run.

Wrestling has put everything from instruments and kendo sticks to gift boxes and even human beings 'On A Pole' (or, in Judy Bagwell's case, 'On A Forklift') over the years. It's time to end this nonsense for good.

What other gimmick matches do you think WWE should avoid for good? For more wrestling, check out 10 Storyline Moments WWE Can’t Afford To Book and 10 Surprising Wrestlers Who've Done Deathmatches!


In this post: 
Elias
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.