10 Gimmicks That WWE Milked Dry
If something works the first time, expect WWE to abuse it until it finally breaks.
Being at the top means you often receive the largest amount of criticism. WWE knows this to be true, and one of the chief complaints against the promotion is a lack of originality. Yet, every once in a seemingly never-ending while, the sports entertainment company ditches the mold and surprises fans with a new (or at least newer) idea.
Alas, longtime fans of the company recognize the inevitable. Whenever WWE strikes gold with a fresh concept, it's bound to milk it to death.
The reappropriation of proven ideas should come as no surprise considering the thousands of hours' worth of content WWE produces each year for its dozens of outlets. Still, some ideas seem to be abused a little more often than others.
Whether a persona, stunt, or plot device, there are many gimmicks the company has used so many times they no longer generate the loud responses of their heydays. Regardless, WWE is often willing to lose a shoe for want of a nail, and several once-good ideas are stripped of their brilliance in the name of boosting ratings, merch sales, and subscriptions. Or because Vince McMahon thought it was such good sh*t.
10. 24/7, 8/7, 7/11, 24/7, I-95… South, European, Television Champion
Fans tired of the clean-cut and often cartoonlike PG Era felt relief in 2019 when rumors of a grittier Raw third hour and new championship made rounds. As Mick Foley announced the show's last hour was getting darker in May, he held onto a covered belt suspected to be the Hardcore Championship. The idea made sense, especially since the 'Hardcore Legend' was chosen to do the honors.
However, signs of hope diminished when out came an eyesore of a championship with a bland 24/7 center plate.
Behind the scenes, USA Network had pressured WWE into adapting the belt. Although the company followed through, it was in the most lackadaisical ways, starting with a mad grab to become the first champ.
Soon, R-Truth became a saving grace. Some may have hoped for a more serious title, but Truth managed to please with his humor and childish charisma.
It was entertaining to watch the 24/7 Champion run from a slew of jobbers, but then, the same bits repeated themselves for months. Nearly two years later, WWE still relies on the tired schtick with no real innovation. You can only tell a joke so many times before it loses its charm. If WWE intends to keep R-Truth alongside the 24/7 title, something has to change to keep the act fresh and keep fans tuned in.
9. The Unlikely Tag Champs
When Charlotte Flair returned at the 2020 TLC PPV to capture the Women's Tag Team Championship, she found a strange partner in Asuka. Although the announcers did their best to explain why 'The Queen' would want to team with her archnemesis, anyone who followed the two wrestlers over the years knew they were presented as anything but friends.
However, Flair and 'The Empress of Tomorrow' are far from the first odd couple in WWE tag team history. Despite the criticisms that ensue, the tag team division doesn't get too much promotion unless two single stars (who aren't a formal tag team) hold the gold.
WWE could utilize preexisting tag teams more, placing them in spots above the lower- and mid-cards. Instead, it continues to create new unlikely pairings with an underlying intention of splitting them up. From a creative standpoint, the trope helps create and extend feuds. Unfortunately, it also takes the focus off of the tag team division (which always needs help) and places the little attention it gets on singles competitors by using the straps as a soon-forgotten catalytic prop rather than a respected and sought-after championship.
8. Go-Home Show Winners Go Home Empty-Handed
A gimmick is defined as "a trick or device intended to attract attention, publicity, or business," according to Oxford, and the following entry involves a creative method that certainly meets the criteria.
Die-hard fans are well aware of one banal trope WWE often deploys during go-home shows, and newer fans don't need to binge episodes of Raw and SmackDown to catch up and find the pattern.
Weeks before a big PPV match, witnessing two foes duke it out in an all-out brawl is an all too common sight. Oftentimes, the last show before an event features one of the main stars getting the upper-hand over their adversary, signaling the end is near once the bell rings on Sunday.
Unfortunately, the abovementioned is the route WWE takes for nearly every one of its PPVs, making it painfully unoriginal and predictable. There have been outliers over time, such as when 'The Fiend' continued getting in the head of Finn Balor before SummerSlam 2019, but they have been few and far between. WWE programming will greatly benefit if creative stepped away from the antiquated habit more often than not. Otherwise, it's almost a giveaway that might prevent a few extra fans from subscribing to the Network.
7. Interference & Distractions
Put on any WWE show or PPV from the last 30 years, and you will witness multiple instances of wrestlers interfering in matches or distracting a competitor. On rare occasions, the hokey finish can help further a feud or a character, but more often than not, it's a lazy ending that renders the match meaningless.
The idea behind the gimmick is that the loser doesn't look weak in defeat or to prevent a straight loss for either wrestler. Although most fans can probably handle a clean loss, WWE seems to believe they are absolutely devastating. Once the company has invested in a performer, it's unlikely to let them lose without shenanigans. Unfortunately, there isn't truly an issue with a main eventer doing the job. One loss isn't crippling as long as more victories are surrounding it.
Nevertheless, when WWE needs to toss out a clean finish (most of the time), it resorts to a cheap victory or throwing out the match altogether. Sometimes, the device works with the likes of Roman Reigns and Drew McIntyre (although it does seem like a lazy finish), but by large, it falls flat and comes off as needless. Given the amount of interference and distractions during episodes of Raw and SmackDown, a fan could almost tune in just for the PPVs without missing a decisive moment.
6. Forced PPV-Specific Allusions
Any time WWE has a themed PPV (which is most of them these days), fans can expect certain tropes to be abused in the weeks leading up to the event.
With Survivor Series, there is often an influx of multi-man tag matches and in-feuding. The Royal Rumble comes with teaser battle royals and performers aimlessly tossing their foes over the top rope on Raw and SmackDown. However, fans already know what to expect in both cases, so it isn't necessary to hand out samples. The concept works slightly better for Survivor Series, as the teams need to be established. On the other hand, there isn't much to explain regarding the Rumble, and the allusions come off as forced and often superfluous.
As time has passed, WWE has continued going to the well even though it dried out years ago. Heading into gimmick-match shows like TLC, fans often see a sudden influx of foreign objects, although avoiding such damage would seem to be in the participants' best interests. Hell in a Cell follows suit as well, with two main eventers often finding their way into the cell on the go-home shows (you'd think they'd stop setting it up early by now).
The act of demoing the upcoming PPV has long lost its luster and often fills time that could be appropriated elsewhere. Perhaps WWE could benefit from focusing more on the feuds leading up to the events.
5. Hell In A Cell Bumps
The Hell in a Cell match is ridiculous when you think about it. First, the cell only exists because the cage gimmick was ruined by constant interference and the escape rule.
What do you do when a cage isn't good enough? Put a lid on it. Of course, WWE didn't make it past the first usage before having a wrestler find their way in. While the structure couldn't prevent monsters from crashing the bout, it still managed to keep the fight inside of its walls... for a hot second.
Ask WWE to put a fight on inside of a cell, and it's going to immediately think, "How do we get outside of this sucker?"
Going outside hasn't been enough either. Almost every year, wrestlers have made their way to the top of the towering cage. When The Undertaker hurled (or gently tossed) Mankind off of the cell in 1998, fans were left shocked. The stunt's execution was flawless, and it seemed as though nothing could have ever topped it.
Perhaps, nothing has. Nearly every year at the Hell in a Cell PPV, one of the main attractions features two top wrestlers battling atop the cell, only to find themselves falling onto an announce table. The sight was quite the spectacle at first, but after over two decades of Hell in a Cell matches, the bump has lost its awe-factor, as it seems almost anyone can take it, even both of the McMahon boys.
4. The White Meat Babyface
From the territory days to the Golden Era, WWE fans flocked to arenas to see their favorite all-American babyface square-off with a dastardly foe in the name of all things good and right.
Rolling into the mid-90s, though, fans no longer wanted to see wrestlers carry out their tired goodie-two-shoes schtick and longed for grittier performers who weren't afraid to bend the rules to do what was right (sometimes).
Ever since then, it has become a curse to be a good guy. A babyface push is actually a way to get a rising star booed in most cases, as overexposure has become inevitable, along with fans' disapproval.
For example, when Roman Reigns' mega-push became growingly apparent, he lost most of his support and received scorching heat WWE played off as a "polarized" response. Of course, that was far from the case.
The concept of a mixed reaction was popularized with John Cena. 'The Master of Thuganomics' was perhaps the last Hogan-esque hero in WWE to gain fan support, but even then, the boos quickly ensued as he won night in and out. Younger viewers still railed behind their hero, but the teens and adults turned on him in droves.
Many of WWE's attempts to create similar stars have failed. It took Reigns turning heel for him to receive more praise than criticism. The righteous protagonist concept is severely outdated, and going forward, it's best for WWE to add a little grit to their faces.
3. The Supernatural
Horror elements often find their way into pro-wrestling, although it might seem they should be kept apart to help suspend disbelief. In American wrestling, The Undertaker was one of the first truly macabre characters fans saw take center stage. In the early 1990s, the ominous character broke boundaries, introducing audiences to a different flavor of sports entertainment.
'The Deadman's' persona didn't clash with the times in terms of WWE's over-the-top (and often cartoonish) presentation, although it was a darker spin than what some were used to. The character was also preserved by the later 90s, which called for edgier and more dramatic content.
Alas, whenever WWE strikes gold with an idea, it's bound to do it again and again. The company tried to replicate the success of a paranormal character with numerous reincarnations. The more exposed the gimmick became, the more fans were turned off by it. It didn't help matters that, in addition to wanting more realistic performances, WWE didn't always treat its monsters with the same gravitas as 'The Phenom.'
When Bray Wyatt returned with his 'Fiend' gimmick, many watched with one brow furrowed, as it required more effort to get the paranormal over in WWE. Likewise, anytime there has been a misstep with 'The Fiend,' fans quickly suggested the character was ruined. The idea of adding a spooky superstar to the roster isn't a terrible one, but it's perhaps one that should be shelved for a while once Wyatt is done with it.
2. Authority Figures
During the height of the Attitude Era, the world fell in love with the authority angle involving Mr McMahon and Stone Cold Steve Austin. Moreover, the concept of an evil boss getting his comeuppance was hugely popular and extended beyond WWE to places like WCW, which saw a more active Eric Bischoff.
Nowadays, the act has grown stale, and fans seek newer, more original concepts. Regardless, whenever WWE finds itself in a creative slump, it brings back the authority angle. Only each time it occurs, it's noticeably less impactful.
Whereas the arc from the 90s cemented Austin as a legend, each reincarnation has done less to get wrestlers over aside from Daniel Bryan in 2014, although his case was largely incidental. Originally, The Authority was pummeling the likes of John Cena and Big Show - again, more made men. For a considerably shorter period of time, Cody Rhodes was involved with an angle, but WWE made sure not to give its younger talent too much shine.
The Austin vs McMahon era lasted around six years. The Authority reigned supreme for an accumulative of five years, and in 2020, the man seems to be rearing his head in the form of Adam Pearce, who exercises his power a little more each week. No wonder fans are turned off by the gimmick. Hopefully, WWE will come up with something more original in the next decade.
1. Breakaway Barricades
The break-away barricade spot may receive a pop from a live crowd, but for WWE fans watching on the ole boob-tube, the act has certainly lost its shine.
Much like the gimmicked announce table, the bit has been used so often it's become a regular feature of big-guy matches. Perhaps the worst offenders are Romain Reigns and Braun Strowman, who seem to crash through the ringside area every time they find themselves in the main event.
The ease with which the corner collapses also undermines other moments, such as when wrestlers misjudge Suicide Dives. The barrier comes off as sturdy as concrete during these occasions, yet the breakaway schtick makes them come off as flimsy as wet cardboard.
Demolishing the barricade also draws attention to the fact that underneath the black padding is generally a steel security railing similar to those used at shopping malls. Although WWE's rails made be anchored (it certainly doesn't want kiddos getting too close), the average joe could dismantle them with a little jostling. A performer's back hitting the fence is enough to push it against the kneecaps of ringsiders.
Two performers going through the barrier certainly makes for a terrific visual (and loads of fun in the video games). Still, to keep receiving those "Holy sh*t!" chants, it's in WWE's best interest to use the spot a little less often, reserving it for larger opponents during major blow-off matches.