10 Huge AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 Predictions You Need To Know

Controversial title changes, weapons everywhere, and personal issues drawing money in Sin City.

Double Or Nothing Jeff Jarrett
AEW

It’s impossible for Double Or Nothing not to feel a certain brand of special in whatever lore All Elite Wrestling decides to carve out for the event as the years pass.

In 2019, it was a defining moment in North American wrestling history. A proof-of-concept so effective that it convinced millions of jaded fans the world over to invest fully in an unfinished product over an uneven summer with the promise of what a weekly version could offer in the fall.

A year later, and with AEW already feeling way more established than the 18 months it had actually been operational, Double Or Nothing 2020 was a message from the company to its audience that they'd make it through the worst of the pandemic eventually, 2021 was an emotional celebration of seeing light at the end of the tunnel, and 2022 was ostensibly a bold step into the future with CM Punk as the brand new World Heavyweight Champion. That wasn't quite to be, but the bizarre and unpredictable 12 months that followed resulted in two more hours of television for the company and the banked billions to keep it in business for years to come.

The history is rich. Will 2023's less-than-seminal build be forgotten in the wake of another epic Las Vegas spectacle?

10. Ethan Page & The Gunns Vs. The Hardy Party

HOOK Ethan Page
AEW

There's a minor Rampage spoiler incoming should you be reading this before the show airs or before you've watched it, but it feeds into analysing the prospective quality and the result of this awkward undercard offering, so read ahead at your peril.

On the go-home Rampage, the babyfaces confirmed that Isiah Kassidy was unable to join Matt and Jeff Hardy in their trios bout with The Gunns and Ethan Page, but a replacement had been sourced; Hook.

The 'Cold Hearted Handsome Devil' has been more cold-feeling undercard also-ran of late, such is the danger of the Matt Hardy vortex in All Elite Wrestling,

To recap this risible nonsense once more - if the Hardys win, Matt Hardy will own Ethan Page's contract, which will represent quite the turnabout in their fortunes over the last few months. But then what? More of this absolute sh*t. Heels winning rarely brings about something conclusive in wrestling, but let's let contractual disputes die along with Matt and Page ever interacting again.

Winners - Ethan Page & The Gunns


9. Adam Cole Vs. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Adam Cole
AEW

The addition of Sabu as an enforcer for this Unsanctioned Match on the go-home Dynamite was the sort of earnestly bizarre cameo booking Tony Khan made a staple.

Cole tried gamely to make sense of a pre-existing relationship with the 'Homicidal, Suicidal, Genocidal' maniac, but he needn't have bothered. The point was made clear that if and when the Jericho Appreciation Society interfered, they'd eat a chair to the face or something even worse thanks to the ECW legend. It's not exactly a numbers game arrested, but it's one dealt with in order to let the action in the ring breathe.

And in the ring is probably where this one needs to stay. This storyline's been a quiet triumph, but it's had its share of bells and whistles attached. All weaponry - and the kendo stick is certain to feature - should be fought over between the ropes with Anarchy In The Arena and a Ladder Match elsewhere on the card, but there are fewer wrestlers as creative and resourceful as these two to ensure it delivers on the night.

Winner - Adam Cole


8. Wardlow (c) Vs. Christian Cage

Christian Cage
AEW

AEW playing with its audience's expectations when Christian Cage announced that he would challenge Wardlow for the TNT Championship rather than Luchasaurus was the first of many positives to come from the recent upgrade in the 'War Dog's fortune.

The Challenger's been a perfectly pitched pr*ck yet again, this time going for the Champion's new mentor Arn Anderson as a target for his abuse, and various plotting and beatdowns escalating the stakes to include a ladder should include exceptional in-ring details from one of the masters of the craft.

It shouldn't go without mention just how quickly 'Double A' has given the TNT Champion a renewed sense of vigour and purpose, and the fact that it's been folded so neatly into his first programme since retaining the belt has been a welcome reminder of what AEW can do at its impressive best. A hard-fought victory here will do much for the reheated big man, even if a half-big man half-beast presumably awaits in the aftermath.


7. The House Of Black (c) Vs The Acclaimed & Daddy Ass

Malakai Black
AEW

A lowkey big deal on a loaded card, this Trios Championship match finds inarguably the two hottest acts in the division and the promise of making at least one set of them losers by the end.

The Acclaimed and Daddy Ass haven't had much going on of late, but have remained almost as over as their Tag Team Championship peak nonetheless. Meanwhile, the House Of Black - and Malakai in particular - have entered serious sh*t-kicking form of late. They simply can't lose the belts for this reason alone.

With the result not really in doubt and the immense quality of the action assured, the intrigue falls on exactly what Max Caster, Anthony Bowens and Billy Gunn will choose as one of their House Rules. After two weeks of divisive lighting, they should probably just ask for the building to be bathed in bright pink to try (and fail) to throw the champions off their game.

This, along with the potential brilliance of the bout, will be more than enough.

Winners - The House Of Black


6. Jade Cargill (c) Vs. Taya Valkyrie

Jade Cargill Taya Valkyrie
AEW

Taya Valkyrie is the best opposition Jade Cargill's had for a while, but is she the best woman to end this inaugural TBS Championship reign?

Not quite.

Valkyrie's decent efforts in AEW so far have effectively sold the title change, but the story has yet again been below par for the longstanding titleholder. It's listless verbal jousts, fake-feeling contractual disputes and long angry stares, and that sort of angle advancement only gets challengers so far. In Valkyrie's case, it's probably not just far enough.

It's a recurring problem with this belt, this division and Jade, but the performer herself shouldn't be punished for the promotion's failings. A demotion of any kind for Cargill right now would be little to do with how she's performed in the role, and completely down to the creative being half-baked and uninspired. And in the current climate, a title loss at 59-0 would absolutely be a demotion.

Winner - Jade Cargill


5. Orange Cassidy (c) Vs. 20 People

Orange Cassidy
AEW

Orange Cassidy is falling apart and the whole thing is kind of amazing.

As of the go-home edition of Dynamite, he's now clocked up 21 defences of the International Title and his prize for that is this 21-man Blackjack Battle Royal where he stands to lose it in the most cruel fashion imaginable.

Cassidy's selling within the individual contests has been incredible. The man that built a brand on not trying has become the workhorse and the mounting injuries have added such fire and courage to his offerings that he's become one of - if not the most - valuable Champions in all of wrestling.

AEW have smartly folded feuds between Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland and Ricky Starks and Bullet Club Gold into the multi-man rather than simply filling it with wrestlers that currently simply aren't in 'Freshly Squeezed's league. Subsequently, it'd be both ultra-cruel for Cassidy to lose the belt in such heartbreaking circumstances, and resourceful to heat up a singles feud with a new title. Swerve and 'The Switchblade' become heavy favourites, and Lee pouncing Swerve out to set up their overdue payoff is too appealing an elimination not to will into existence. Thus...

Winner - Jay White


4. FTR (c) Vs. Jeff Jarrett & Jay Lethal

FTR Jeff Jarrett Jay Lethal
AEW

There are few builds better on this entire card than the latest unlikely Jeff Jarrett success story and the fight over AEW's Tag Team gold.

Maybe none, in fact.

From a division that otherwise looks barren comes a story rich in action, comedy and potential heartbreak for the Champions if they can't keep special guest referee Mark Briscoe on side and the cartoonishly fiendish heel squad at bay.

Jarrett using Jay Lethal to try and manipulate Mark was a hoot down on the farm but genuinely gripping when the two sides hit the ring and the ROH icon inadvertently ate a piledriver from Dax Harwood. Karen Jarrett's shocking debut provided yet another addition to the entourage that will look to double down on this miscommunication, and seeing the endearingly dastardly heels get their comeuppance - and Jarrett yet again fail to hold AEW gold - will make for one of the most enduring moments of the night.

Winners - FTR


3. Jamie Hayter (c) Vs. Toni Storm

Jamie Hayter
AEW

The best version of a singles contest between the warring Homegrowns/Outcasts stables, Jamie Hayter Vs Toni Storm doesn't feel white hot, but is one of several recent big AEW matches to have that alright-on-the-night vibe coursing through the match graphic.

Hayter's been slightly marginalised of late, gladly taking a backward step for Dr Britt Baker DMD to lead the charge, and while all of this could set up a devastating turn (and/or turn of events) during a prospective Blood & Guts match between the two sides, it leaves this pay-per-view title match feeling slightly redundant as a result. That's where workers of their calibre step in to elevate the middling material.

They'll both hit incredibly, incredibly hard, but the catharsis of the babyfaces overcoming the heel shenanigans for a change will add to the gratification of the injured Hayter looking otherwise back at the top of her game.

Winner - Jamie Hayter


2. Blackpool Combat Club Vs. The Elite

The Elite
AEW

On the go-home edition of AEW Dynamite, Jon Moxley put his four year's worth of character equity on the line to express just how incredible - and incredibly violent - Anarchy In The Arena was going to be.

It was bold, but pointed. Last year's inaugural edition of the match was one of the finest brawls in the genre's history, culminating with the intoxicating visual of a blood-soaked Eddie Kingston returning with a gas can when shoot murder felt like the only option. It set a lofty standard, and Moxley was as good as promised to meet it.

He stands a great chance thanks to the man around and against him. Only fools would bet against The Elite in creative circumstances such as these - they've done even more with even less in the past, and there are multiple examples of them working electrifying hardcore arena-wide brawls in AEW let alone in their careers beforehand. It's impossible to dive into the minds of the top-tier talents when given a blank canvas such as this, so predicting spots feels more flippant than foreshadowing. but the result itself can be pondered. Do the BCC win and throw The Elite into renewed disarray so soon after their reunion?

Or sometimes, is it just nice for AEW EVPs to finish the story?

Winners - The Elite


1. MJF (c) Vs. Sammy Guevara Vs. "Jungle Boy" Jack Perry Vs. Darby Allin

MJF Jungle Boy
AEW

There's no talking around it - the "Four Pillars" of All Elite Wrestling simply haven't felt like that for the bulk of this story.

MJF has shown exactly why he was the one to reach the summit first, and shown it over and over again, but at various points, all three challengers have stumbled as they've attempted to join him at the top of the mountain.

Darby Allin spoke so confidently in the early and latter stages of a wonky build that he raised flags that the whole thing should have just been a singles match, but his character went off the rails during a mid-story mini-tournament and has only now worked its way back on track. Jungle Boy and Sammy Guevara have lost and gained followings respectively during the same timeframe, but having to see Jack Perry received as a heel and 'The Spanish God' reverting to ill-fitting babyface as the drama's unfolded feels like risky business for both.

It's also been slightly undermined by a whispered and knowing predictability too. The story might be setting the Champion up to fail but absolutely nobody believes he will.

On plenty of evidence, nor should he.

Winner - MJF


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.