10 Huge WWE Comebacks That Led To More Huge Comebacks
When one major Superstar return leads to another major Superstar return.
The WWE Universe clamours for thrilling returns from main event or beloved fan favourite wrestlers. It’s why Royal Rumble, with its surprising and shocking in-ring returns, is considered by many to be WWE’s most exciting PPV of the calendar year. It’s why WWE Superstar returns compilations on YouTube garner millions of views online. It’s why only recently Chris Jericho’s one-time return to WWE on the Broken Skull Sessions with Steve Austin drummed up huge interest amongst fans and more potential paid subscribers to the Network.
Fans loved when John Cena elicited one of the biggest pops in the history of Madison Square Garden at Royal Rumble 2008 when he returned months ahead of schedule from injury. Or when Shawn Michaels returned to the squared circle in 2002 after a 4 year hiatus and went on to have some of the most legendary matches to ever take place in his second run with the company. Or when Bray Wyatt returned with a hugely dramatic character change as The Fiend at SummerSlam 2019.
There are times when huge comebacks like these can lead to more huge comebacks. Like D-Generation X and nWo returning for one night for Triple H and Sting in their match at WrestleMania 31.
These 10 returns only came to be after someone close to them made the endeavour to return to WWE first.
10. First Brock Lesnar, Then Paul Heyman (2012)
When Brock Lesnar’s familiar ‘Next Big Thing’ theme hit the American Airlines Arena on the Raw after WrestleMania XXVIII, fans went wild with excitement. In the 8 long years Lesnar stepped away from the ring, he stepped into the Octagon for UFC and became a mainstream star. Brock delivered a devastating F5 on John Cena that night, and went on to have a thrilling Extreme Rules match with him later that month.
The only issue to Lesnar’s return was he was dealt with cutting promos, an art he wasn’t keen on delving back into. Plus WWE only had Lesnar signed to a unique part time contract, and needed to advance storylines without him being a regular feature on TV. This all led to the return of Brock’s former manager Paul Heyman returning to the company after 6 years away when he hugely fell out of favour with Vince McMahon over the return of ECW.
Heyman marched to the ring on Raw a month after Lesnar returned to the surprise of fans and wrestlers alike and cut a promo on behalf of Lesnar that put near the entire locker room to shame. This was the start of a beautiful relationship where Lesnar ruled the decade, with Heyman in tow hyping him up as the “reigning, defending, undisputed WWE Heavyweight Champion of the World.”
9. First Daniel Bryan, Then Brie Bella (2018)
After being plagued with concussion issues and having to emotionally retire on Raw in 2014, Daniel Bryan shockingly got medically cleared and returned to the ring at WrestleMania 34. In the time he spent away from competing he was made SmackDown General Manager and co-hosted Talking Smack. But being so close to the craft he gave his whole adult life fuelled Bryan to look for any way he could to get back to wrestling in the ring.
After passing a series of rigid medical tests Bryan got the all clear and was on a collision course with The Miz, who he had a built-in organic feud with after their Talking Smack back and forth and Miz taunting Bryan and audiences by stealing Bryan’s moveset. At SummerSlam The Miz scored a win over Bryan after Maryse interfered and snuck him a pair of brass knuckles.
This would all lead to Brie Bella returning to WWE for a showdown between the real life couples. Brie hadn’t been featured as a full-time performer on WWE TV since 2016 when she left to start a family with Bryan.
Bryan and Brie took on Miz and Maryse in an entertaining mixed tag match at the Hell in a Cell PPV, with fans cheering away as Bryan and Brie delivered duelling ‘YES’ kicks to the Mizanins.
8. Beth Phoenix (2018), Then Edge (2020)
After growing increasingly frustrated with the way women wrestlers were being portrayed and positioned on the card, ‘The Glamazon’ Beth Phoenix handed in her notice to WWE in 2012; one year after her future husband Edge had to leave the business behind due to debilitating neck injuries catching up with him.
In the years spent away from the ring, Phoenix and Edge took a much-needed break from wrestling and started a family in the mountains of North Carolina. That time was pivotal in the way women were featured and showcased on WWE TV, with the ‘Women’s Evolution’ gaining momentum after performers like Paige, Charlotte and Sasha Banks stived for equality. This led to Phoenix returning to the company as a commentator and occasional performer for big-time events, like the first-ever women's Royal Rumble match in 2018 and WrestleMania 35.
Her return and being so close to it got Edge to think about a comeback for the first time, with his neck having had a chance to recuperate in the years he spent retired. Phoenix helped Edge train to get back into ring shape, with Edge claiming after his gripping return at Royal Rumble (2020): “none of this is possible without Beth having my back and being my support through all of this.”
7. Edge (2020), Then Christian (2021)
So far Edge has made the most of his second run/chance in wrestling, putting in an impressive 25 minutes of ring time after 9 years away at Royal Rumble (2020), somehow living up to some lofty expectations in his match with Randy Orton at Backlash (after it was labelled ‘The Greatest Wrestling Match Ever’ weeks before it took place) and main eventing WrestleMania 37 in a thrilling triple threat with two of the best to ever do it Roman Reigns and Daniel Bryan.
Edge’s return from an injury everyone thought was impossible to return from inspired his tag partner and best friend Christian to take the plunge back into the wrestling business. Christian worked hard to get back into shape and medically cleared after suffering numerous concussion issues.
Christian returned one year after Edge at the same event Royal Rumble and looked better than ever, emotionally hugging Edge at one point in the match in disbelief they were both back doing what they love. Christian’s commented on how Edge helped him when he decided to come back: “He was one of the very few people that knew the work I was putting in. I told him what I was thinking, and he was very supportive because it had been taken away from him as well.”
6. Mick Foley, Then The Rock (2004)
Mick Foley after four years away came out of retirement in 2004, after getting the itch back and wanting to financially provide more for his growing family. He chose the upcoming Randy Orton as the man to kickstart his comeback, with them going on to have what both men consider the best match of their careers at Backlash where they bloodily tore the house down in a hardcore classic.
But before that was Mick’s in-ring return at WrestleMania XX, where he was scheduled to clash with ‘The Legend Killer’ Randy Orton and his Evolution buddies Batista and Ric Flair. Wanting to make the match special, WWE worked out a deal with The Rock to come back for one more match at the landmark event and one more time tagging with Mick as The Rock 'n' Sock Connection.
Hollywood executives were trying to get Rock to distance himself from pro wrestling at the time for his new acting career, but the temptation to electrify Madison Square Garden and tag with his friend Mick before he quietly retired was too much for ‘The Great One’ to pass up.
5. The Undertaker, Then Paul Bearer (2004)
After a lengthy sabbatical post Survivor Series 2003 and years spent as ‘Big Evil’ and ‘The American Bad Ass’, The Undertaker was persuaded by Vince McMahon and creative to roll back his eyes once more and return as ‘The Phenom’ for WrestleMania XX.
At Survivor Series, Kane beat down and buried Undertaker alive to close the show. Months later, the build-up to The Dead Man’s return at WrestleMania XX was regularly teased on episodes of Raw, with paranormal happenings spooking and scaring The Big Red Machine.
Undertaker strongly felt Paul Bearer should be by his side for his WrestleMania match against Kane, having played such a big part as his manager and mentor in his early days with the company. So to complete the metamorphosis, WWE quietly contacted Paul Bearer about returning to the company to manage Undertaker once again. They wanted him so much they went as far as paying for gastric bypass surgery for him, with Bearer having gained a considerable amount of weight in his time spent away from WWE.
It was worth it though. Fans popped big when they first heard Bearer’s classic “Oooh YES!” at WrestleMania XX to signify his and The Phenom’s return.
4. Bruce Prichard (2018), Then Eric Bischoff (2019)
After never believing he would ever have a chance to return to WWE, Bruce Prichard started his Something to Wrestle podcast, where he discussed all the behind the scenes details that went into bringing classic WWE matches and moments to life. The podcast became hugely popular and surprisingly led to Bruce being brought back to WWE as a part time creative consultant, which then led him to coming back full time as Vince McMahon’s right-hand man, which then led to him becoming WWE's Senior Vice President.
With Bruce being so close to Vince it enabled him to put in a good word for his close friend Eric Bischoff to return to the company too as Executive Director of the SmackDown brand, with SmackDown being looked as a priority, with it moving to Fox on Friday Nights in a deal worth millions.
It was short-lived for Eric, only lasting a few months in the role after not acclimating himself to the WWE environment, but enjoying himself nevertheless.
Eric has revealed how Bruce was able to get him back into the WWE fold:
“Bruce Prichard and I have been friends really since my tenure at WWE as a talent, going back to 2002, and we remained very close friends during that period of time. And shortly after Bruce came back to WWE, we were chatting. He said, 'Hey, do you mind if I drop your name? Would you be interested in perhaps coming back to work for WWE?'. I said, 'Sure. Feel free'. And a couple months later, I was packing my bags and moving to Stamford."
3. Hulk Hogan, Then Roddy Piper (2003)
Hulk Hogan fell out with WWE after main eventing SmackDown with Brock Lesnar in 2002, where Brock was booked to bloodily beat him up and hugely dominate him. Hogan afterwards took a hiatus from the company and bickered with Vince McMahon, who wanted him to once again do the job to Lesnar at Survivor Series, with Hogan refusing.
After some time Vince and Hogan were able to come to terms for him to return in 2003 for a high-profile match with Vince at WrestleMania XIX. With nostalgia running heavy, Vince two days before the event wanted to add a surprise to pop fans in the match, and was looking for ideas. Bruce Prichard suggested “Rowdy” Roddy Piper do a run-in, knowing he would fit well, given Piper’s history with Hogan and WrestleMania.
And with that one suggestion Piper interfered in Hogan/Vince’s match and laid out Hogan with a steel pipe. This would set in motion Piper signing a new contract with WWE, aligning himself with Sean O’Haire and feuding with Hogan on SmackDown.
Both old timers Hogan and Piper’s returns were cut short, with Piper later being fired and Hogan quitting once more over creative and pay. It was good while it lasted.
2. Roman Reigns, Then Paul Heyman (2020)
‘The Big Dog’ Roman Reigns was on a collision course with Goldberg for the Universal Championship at WrestleMania 36 but ultimately had to drop out when the pandemic hit, with him being immunocompromised from his battles with leukaemia. Thinking about himself and his family, he took a step back and time away from WWE.
Paul Heyman too took a leave of absence around this period, after his client Brock Lesnar stopped working for WWE following WrestleMania 36 when he dropped the WWE title to Drew McIntyre. It looked for the longest time WWE had no use for Heyman without Lesnar. But plans change, pal.
Roman made his long-awaited return at SummerSlam, beating down Braun Strowman and The Fiend, and showing a viscous side he hadn’t before. As revealed on the next few episodes of SmackDown, Roman was turning heel. Needing to cement his heel turn, WWE brought back Heyman to manage him. Heyman has said on their partnership: “We both wanted to see just how much we could transform this industry, set the trend, and blaze a path that no one had had the balls to blaze before.”
You can’t argue it hasn’t worked. With Heyman by his side, Roman’s delivering the best work of his career or of anyone on the roster.
1. Cody Rhodes (2016), Then Dustin Rhodes (2019)
After Cody Rhodes finally scored his release from WWE, and was able to ditch the Stardust character they had made him portray and he’d long grown tired of, he set the independent circuit on fire. He returned as ‘Cody’, without gimmicks but turning the volume up on his real self. Aligning himself with The Elite, he would help form AEW and the rest is history.
Cody reinventing himself the way he did inspired his brother Dustin Rhodes to ask for his release from WWE, so he too could ditch his well-known Goldust character that was being used as nothing more than a comedy punch line there. It was a big risk for Dustin to leave a secure job and a character he had portrayed for years with WWE, but Dustin was tired of the schedule and wanted more out of his career.
Dustin got his release and immediately aligned himself with AEW, returning to his old school ‘The Natural’ gimmick and signing up to wrestle Cody at AEW Double or Nothing:
Dustin has said on his WWE exit and his legendary match with Cody:
“With the WWE, I'd had enough. It was time for me to go. It had been such a long, storied career with the Goldust character and, do you know, I really thought that I was going to retire - and then I got pulled in and my passion got reignited when I wrestled my brother, and we had the match of the last decade, probably, if not the last two decades.”