10 Infamous WWE Conspiracy Theories

Were there actually two Ultimate Warriors?

WWE.comWWE.com

Conspiracy theories are everywhere, and professional wrestling is no exception. Traditionally, wrestling has been based on secrecy, the fans aren't supposed to know what really goes on backstage, and are expected to believe that everything they see in the ring is one hundred percent legitimate. It was much easier to keep up that illusion when the internet was not around, but now, with such easy access to fan created rumors, and the so called "dirt sheets," fans are more in touch with the inner workings of the business than ever.

That may not always be a good thing though. One anonymous post on a forum can spread through the internet and be accepted as the truth. This is because everybody loves a good conspiracy. Why was my favorite wrestler fired? Was this scandal covered up by the people in charge? Was this match really supposed to end that way?

Of course, most of them are complete rubbish, but some run deeper than others, and many of them even make a lot of sense. Wherever the truth may lie, it sure is fun to speculate. From the totally outlandish to the utterly depressing, this is a look at some of the stories that wrestling fans have been arguing about for years.


10. HBK's Back Injury Was Over Embellished

WWE.comWWE.com

Shawn Michaels is one of the greatest stars of our time, and is the subject of more than his fair share of backstage shenanigans. In 1998 he suffered a back injury during a casket match against The Undertaker.

This lead to an early retirement from wrestling, though he still made sporadic appearances on TV for the next 4 years. He eventually returned to the ring in 2002, and continued to wrestle until 2010, where he lost his "retirement match," ironically against The Undertaker.

This sounds reasonable enough though. He had a back injury, had surgery, and then later felt well enough to perform again. What strikes the fans as odd is how can a man who was nearly crippled from a back injury return to wrestler for the next 8 years, and why did he keep getting paid during his entire absence? Compound that with the fact that Michaels was a notorious party animal and drug user at the time of his first retirement, it seems as if there was more to the story.

It has been said that the real reason Michaels left was because he needed to enter rehab for an addiction to painkillers. Ok, so he wanted to get clean, but why continue to pay him for so long?

That is where things get weird. According to some, Vince McMahon and Shawn Michaels were actually lovers and that is why Vince continued to pay Shawn. Granted, most of those sources aren't very credible, but some people swear it is the truth.


9. There Were Two Ultimate Warriors

WWE.comWWE.com

The late Ultimate Warrior was one of the most recognizable stars of the late 80's until his abrupt absence from television in 1991. He had beaten Hulk Hogan for the Heavyweight Championship just a year earlier at Wrestlemania VI, and was set to be the biggest star for years to come. Why would he be taken off of TV so abruptly?

Fans were shocked at his return at Wrestlemania VIII, when he stormed down the aisle to assist his friend, and former opponent Hulk Hogan. Something was different though, this man was somewhat less muscular and had much shorter hair.

This was not The Warrior that everybody remembered. It must be a different person! Yes, that's it! The real Warrior must have died, and Vince McMahon, brought in another look-a-like to cash in on the Warrior name, and the fans would never know the difference.

The truth about this one though actually all comes down to money. The Warrior tried to strong arm Vince McMahon out of more money after Wrestlemania VI and threatened to no-show events unless his demands were met. Vince caved initially, but then released him once the events Warrior was promoted for were over. The change in look? Well, that had to do with the ongoing steroid scandal, and a poorly executed hair cut.


8. The Pipebomb Was A Work

WWE.comWWE.com

2011 was the summer of Punk. Following an epic promo where he tears into everybody, including his own fans, he won the WWE championship and promptly left the company with title in hand. Well, he left for a week and then returned, but either way, he had sent a surge of energy through the WWE universe. He was the hottest star for months and was seen as the next anti-authority figure who was so popular he could do whatever he wanted.

The thing about CM Punk that many people love is that he is totally unpredictable. He also loves to screw with the heads of wrestling fans, so there is no way to really know if what he is saying was a total shoot, or if he had permission to say anything he wanted.

It is accepted that what CM Punk said in his most famous pipebomb was actually how he felt, but was he told to do it? Was Vince himself responsible for the vitriol that spewed out of Punk's mouth that night? Is it possible that CM Punk and Vince McMahon were working together the entire time to stir up the WWE Universe?

Some people swear that it was a legitimate shoot, while others claim the heat between the two was part of the plan all along. The truth probably lies somewhere in between, but with Punk's most recent departure we can be sure that he wasn't entirely happy with the company.


7. Vince McMahon Covers Up Murder

Jimmy Snuka Murder

Here is what is known for sure. On May 10th, 1983, Nancy Argentino was rushed from the motel room of Jimmy "Superfly" Snuka, to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead. An autopsy report, released publicly just last year, stated that she died from €œtraumatic brain injuries consistent with a moving head striking a stationary object.€ The case was ruled a homicide and Snuka was a key suspect, however, no person was ever arrested following her death.

Those are the facts, now here is the speculation. Snuka supposedly gave differing stories about what happened that night, at first claiming it was an accident where he pushed her and she hit her head. He then claimed that she had slipped while walking on pavement. The conspiracy states that Vince McMahon was sent to help speak on behalf Snuka, who did not break kayfabe, and played the role of an innocent islander who did not speak english well.

The investigation into Nancy Argentino's death was recently reopened for investigation, so only time will tell if a conclusive end to this sad story will be told.


6. Shockmaster Sabotage

WWE.comWWE.com

The Shockmaster debut is still regarded as one of the most unintentionally hilarious debuts of all time. He was the mystery partner for an upcoming 8 man tag match, who was to be revealed on live television. As his name was announced, he burst through a wall of sheetrock and he fell flat on his face. His glittering stormtrooper helmet fell off and he clumsily tried to recover and save what was left of his dignity.

It was too late, and ruined any legitimacy he may have had. The promo was a bust and his character was subsequently turned into a comedic one, as opposed to the serious monster he was set out to be. Was this an unfortunate mishap, or straight up sabotage?

David Crockett, an executive for WCW at the time, was apparently not very fond of the idea of The Shockmaster, so it is rumored that he wanted to sabotage his debut. You really can't blame him though, because even if he hadn't fallen over and embarrassed himself, fans still would not have taken that character seriously.

The practice run before the show had gone well, but to ensure that things would not go according to plan, Crockett had nailed a board at the base of the wall without telling anybody. When The Shockmaster was set to burst through on air, he tripped over the board, and sealed his fate as a laughing stock for years to come.


5. Randy Savage Is Blacklisted From The Hall Of Fame

Randy Savage Stephanie Mcmahon

Every year the discussion comes up of why Randy Savage isn't in the Hall of Fame? He is certainly the most glaring omission, and people were certain that he was a shoo-in after his death in 2011. He actually seems strangely absent from mention in the WWE in general. He left the WWE in 1994 and never returned for another appearance, even though the WWE had multiple opportunities to bring him back in one form or another. So what gives?

Rumor has it that Randy Savage had an affair with an underage Stephanie McMahon. Vince got word of this and decided to not renew his contract, later claiming that the two could not reach an agreement and left mutually.

It isn't even known if the tryst between the two even took place, but as the years go by, it seems more and more plausible that it may be the reason McMahon has held a grudge against him for so many years.

He was such an iconic superstar of his time so whatever Savage did must have been pretty bad. Aside of being included in WWE 2k14, he has been persona non grata in the WWE. He may be inducted next year, or maybe the year after that, but until it happens, fans will always murmur about his affair with Stephanie.


4. Nash/Hall Were Sent By Vince To Destroy WCW

Copyright: WWE nWo: The Revolution Blu-rayCopyright: WWE nWo: The Revolution Blu-ray

Scott Hall and Kevin Nash were legitimate stars in the WWE, and both of their contracts were coming to an end. After acquiring Hulk Hogan in 1994, WCW was hungry for some more superstars from the WWE roster, so Hall and Nash were on their radar. A bidding war ensued, but due to Ted Turner's deeper pockets he ultimately won out and signed both stars.

WCW soon became the number one wrestling promotion in the world, but over the years, due to poor booking, terrible management decisions, and exorbitant spending they eventually were bought out by the WWE.

Was this Vince McMahons idea all along? Think about it for a second, he had some great up and coming stars with the likes of HHH and Steve Austin, so why not artificially drive up the price of some of their other wrestlers to squeeze money out of their rivals? Even though the short term effects would be negative, their long term goals were much higher.

Also, with the introduction of two more high profile stars, other members of the WCW roster started demanding higher contracts, therefore causing WCW to start pouring more and more money into their already aging roster.

Did this really happen? Probably not, considering that WCW dominated WWE in the ratings for 84 straight weeks, and as savvy of a businessman Vince McMahon is, it is unlikely that he would want his company to look weak by losing more top stars to their competitor.


3. WWE Covers Up Gay Sex Scandal

WWE.comWWE.com

Pat Patterson was the first Intercontinental Champion, and is an executive for the WWE who is openly gay. He is well respected in the wrestling community, but has a pretty dark cloud that hanging over his head. A gay sex scandal broke out in 1992 involving Pat Patterson and his friend, Terry Garvin, who also worked for the WWE at the time.

Murray Hodgson, a 29 year old announcer, filed a wrongful termination lawsuit against the WWE, claiming that he was fired after turning down one of Patterson's advances. According to Hodgson, Patterson's favorite pickup line was "So you're the new guy. What do you taste like?" This issue was largely dismissed as ridiculous, but gained traction when others came forward with accusations of assault involving either Garvin or Patterson.

This was the last thing that the WWE needed at the time because they were involved in a steroid investigation at the time, so it was more or less swept under the rug and settled out of court. Patterson and Garvin both resigned from their positions, but Patterson was rehired a year later, and became a prominent figure during the attitude era as one of Vince McMahon's "Stooges." Was Patterson innocent, and just a victim of homophobia, or did the WWE help sweep clean any wrongdoings?


2. Savage Gave Hogan A Black Eye

WWE.comWWE.com

Nothing will stir up rumors faster than something left totally unexplained. At Wrestlemania IX, Hulk Hogan showed up with a noticeable black eye, but it was never explained how he got it. Even though Hogan left the event as the WWE champion, more people were talking about what had happened to him before the show. Eventually, it was settled on by the fans to be one of two scenarios.

The first scenario was that Bret Hart was upset about the way the main event was booked. Hart had just lost his match against Yokozuna. As Bret goes to the back, Yokozuna challenges anybody in the back for a shot at the belt, Hogan accepted, then won. Many people felt that Bret was upset after hearing this decision and socked Hogan before they went on air.

The other scenario is a little juicier. The Hulkster's part time friend Randy Savage found out about an affair between Hogan and his wife Miss Elizabeth. An enraged Savage attacked Hogan before the event which led to the black eye.

The truth is actually a bit more mundane. The most likely case was that Hogan was involved in a Jet Skiing accident a couple of days before the event, and the WWE just didn't feel the need to mention it.


1. Bret Was In On The Montreal Screwjob

WWE.comWWE.com

This is it, the big one. The conspiracy to end all conspiracies, but with bit of a twist. It is not known exactly what happened leading up to this infamous match, but the general consensus is that Bret Hart was planned to win the match and retain the WWE title, but lose it the next night on Raw and then leave for WCW. Vince McMahon was not happy with that plan, so he made the referee end the match early, and award Michaels the championship without Bret's knowledge.

That is the extremely abridged version of the story, and some people even think that what we saw that night was all an elaborate ruse. It has been claimed that Bret Hart was in on it the whole time, and the plan was carried out to elevate everybody involved. It does make some sense, since Bret became the most talked about wrestler at the time, and Vince McMahon immediately became the biggest heel in the business. Shawn Michaels gets to be champ again, and the attitude era is born.

So was Bret in on it? That is doubtful at best. Bret's shock and disgust was so genuine that if it was faked he deserves an Oscar. Plus the corroborating stories of Bret legitimately beating up Vince backstage point towards that Bret didn't know. Like most conspiracies, there may be a grain of truth lying somewhere deep down, but very few people know the exact circumstances of that night.

What other conspiracies seem to crop up a lot? Many rumors go around about what happens backstage, but which ones really make you think that there is more to those stories than what you see on the surface?


Contributor
Contributor

Brandon Tischer is an avid wrestling fan who has been watching since he was a kid. He, along with his friends, have made a pact to never miss a Wrestlemania together.