10 Legends WWE Dumped In Awful Feuds

'Creative has nothing for you' would be preferable.

WWE.com

Every wrestling fan must be familiar with the phrase, 'creative has nothing for you'.

It's almost meme-like at this point when wrestlers reveal in shoot interviews that WWE writers were fresh out of ideas for their characters, and it's even more infuriating when they cite that as one of the reasons why they parted ways with the company. Sometimes though, even a total lack of planning is better than the crud some workers are forced to struggle through.

Legends aren't safe from creative's nonstop game of throwing things out there to see if fans give a toss either. They're arguably in a tougher spot because of their lofty status; writing teams have believed that pairing an icon with literally anybody leads to results since the dawn of grappling time. Sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't, but this harum-scarum methodology often leads to some of the worst feuds of these legendary careers.

The formula goes as thus: Legend A + Wrestler B = fans giving a sh*t automatically. Or, they won't and the sorry rivalries those writers came up with will provide a goldmine of content for lists like this one and regrets from anyone who once said, "what if...".


10. Ric Flair (Carlito)

Ric Flair, Carlito
WWE.com

Premise: Seeking a way to use the man's wealth of star power, WWE programmed Ric Flair with Carlito. The legend claimed that his younger model "had no heart", and would team with Carly until the ungrateful big-haired young buck turned on Ric. They ended their feud at Judgment Day 2007 when Flair won with a Figure-Four.

Why It Was Awful: It didn't help either man.

There was some merit to positioning Flair as someone who could nurture young talent (it was a role he'd done splendidly in Evolution), but WWE raced through the main story beats too quickly. Carlito looked second rate to Ric throughout, and it was also weird to see the 'Nature Boy' propping up the WrestleMania 23 pre-show card in a tag-team dark match.

If they really wanted to make people care, then Carlito and Flair should've bonded properly before the former's turn. This was a poor use of Ric, and the angle was largely forgotten by the time he jumped to SmackDown from Raw in the Draft.


9. Randy Savage (Crush)

Randy Savage Crush
WWE.com

Premise: Former WWF Champion and all-round purveyor of the eclectic outfit Randy Savage was being phased out as a full-time worker by 1993. The 'Macho Man' was carving a career for himself as a bombastic colour commentator when he suddenly launched into a feud with real-life pal Crush. They ended up working a 'Falls Count Anywhere' match at WrestleMania X.

Why It Was Awful: The WWF totally misunderstood the concept of a 'Falls Count Anywhere' brawl, and the entire feud was a shambling mess that failed to make use of Randy's connection to the audience.

Instead of booking Crush as a dominant monster who would rule the '90s and rub it in Randy's face, the company put Savage on top and melded in some skewed rules that meant each man had 60 seconds to return to the ring after a pinfall decision. It was messy, and the cable-tie, upside-down finish was a miserable failure.

What should've been a launching pad for Crush as a heel ended up being a low point. Legend has it that Randy really wanted a feud with Shawn Michaels; that makes this 'Mania X guff even less tolerable.


8. John Cena (John Laurinaitis)

Cena John Laurinaitis Over the Limit 2012
WWE.com

Premise: In yet another rehash of the rebellious wrestler vs. bitter authority figure template Steve Austin and Vince McMahon had perfected over a decade before, WWE put John Cena up against John Laurinaitis in 2012. His surprise win at Over The Limit was supposed to stack heat on 'Big Johnny' for ruining everyone's fun.

Why It Was Awful: Guffawing, clown-around Cena was the worst kind of Cena. Plus, WWE booked their match as a 17-minute pay-per-view main event, and thought a one-sided arse-kicking with some Big Show interference was a fitting end to the night.

The banter between Cena and Laurinaitis was painfully forced on TV too. As much as John L tried his best to be Mr. McMahon from 1998, he lacked true conviction in his promos and Cena just looked like a bully when he booted him around for almost 20 long minutes.

Worse, Show's inclusion was an excuse for WWE to extend the feud between Cena and Laurinaitis for another month or so.


7. Shawn Michaels (JBL)

JBL Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Premise: In the lead-up to 2009's WrestleMania XXV, Shawn Michaels revealed that the ongoing recession had hit him hard. JBL swooped in to offer Shawn a job and treated him like sh*t before HBK beat his would-be mean boss at No Way Out to earn his freedom. That'd clear the way for a classic Michaels vs. The Undertaker whopper at 'Mania.

Why It Was Awful: It just wasn't believable that multi-millionaire Shawn Michaels was struggling financially.

Hearing him talk about how his family's savings had been wiped out by the global recession was almost insulting to those who were genuinely fretting about making ends meet. It was bizarre for WWE to claim that someone who had headlined countless big events was skint and needed JBL's help.

This was an unnecessary speed bump on the road towards Michaels vs. 'Taker. Nobody took it seriously, Shawn's performances harked back to him 'losing his smile' in 1997, and it was swiftly forgotten about as soon as No Way Out finished.


6. Hulk Hogan & Roddy Piper (Mr. America)

Mr America Hulk Hogan
WWE

Premise: WWE booked Roddy Piper against Hulk Hogan one more time in an attempt to prolong Hogan's feud with Vince McMahon. The twist was that Hulk worked under a mask as the "mysterious" Mr. America, and it was up to McMahon and Piper to expose Hogan's ruse. At Judgment Day 2003, Hogan beat Piper in less than five minutes.

Why It Was Awful: The Mr. America character was so flimsy it almost seemed like the writers had found Vince Russo's old booking notes from 2000-era WCW. On top of the ludicrous notion that nobody could prove America was Hulk, neither Piper nor Hogan had any business wrestling one another this deep into their careers.

Their match was a train wreck.

Hogan vs. McMahon should have ended when Hulk beat Vince in a spirited 'Street Fight' at WrestleMania XIX. That was acceptable. This WCW-ish protraction of issues between Hogan and Piper was not, and it's embarrassing to look back on now.


5. Steve Austin (Michael Cole & Jerry Lawler)

Michael Cole Jerry Lawler
WWE.com

Premise: By 2010, Michael Cole had started to become an insufferable jerk behind the announce desk. Despite being WWE's lead-play-by-play man, he'd show clear bias towards heels, laugh at faces and direct much of his bile at colour commentary counterpart Jerry Lawler.

They'd go on to have a match at 'Mania XXVII, and WWE inserted Steve Austin as the special referee.

Why It Was Awful: Even the mighty 'Stone Cold' couldn't save this tripe.

WWE gave Cole vs. Lawler almost 14 minutes of ring time at WrestleMania when it should've been four-five max. Fans were ready to see the 'King' paste Cole and beat him cleanly, but plans called for the anonymous Raw GM to overrule Austin and reverse the decision so Michael won by DQ.

It was one thing to book such a lame spot for Austin at 'Mania. It was another to force him to stand there and watch Michael f'n Cole "wrestle" for nearly 15 minutes on the biggest show of the year.


4. Bret Hart (Vince McMahon)

Bret Hart Vince McMahon
WWE.com

Premise: Almost 13 years on from the infamous 'Montreal Screwjob' at Survivor Series 1997, Bret Hart returned to WWE, mended fences with Shawn Michaels and then tried to do the same with Vince McMahon. Refusing, Vince booted Bret in the balls and set wheels in motion for a match between both at WrestleMania XXVI.

Why It Was Awful: Icon of the industry or not, Bret Hart shouldn't have been in a wrestling ring by 2010.

The terms of his insurance policy meant Bret couldn't bump, and that restricted what he and McMahon could do with their 'No Holds Barred' match stipulation. What was supposed to be a feel good piece of redemption booking for Hart (and a win that'd close the book on 13 years of hurt) ended up being a disaster-piece.

It was too late for this sort of thing by 2010. Bret couldn't work like the 'Hitman' of old, fans had moved on from Montreal and some in Phoenix for 'Mania ended up feeling sorry for McMahon when the entire Hart clan cheered on a one-way steel chair beating.


3. The Undertaker & Kane (KroniK)

Kronik Brothers of Destruction Unforgiven 2001
WWE.com

Premise: Former WCW squash match artists KroniK were brought to the WWF by ex-Right To Censor man Stevie Richards in 2001 when he blamed The Undertaker for breaking up his old faction and vowed revenge. This led to a match at Unforgiven pitting Kane and 'Taker vs. Brian Adams and Bryan Clark, and was designed to bed KroniK into the promotion.

Why It Was Awful: Honestly, just watch it if you've never had the erm... pleasure.

KroniK, who had been bad-ass guns-for-fire akin to The APA during their run in WCW, looked totally inadequate as Stevie Richards' monsters. Fans barely cared about the Alliance, the invasion storyline or anything WCW by September '01, and they yawned their way through the Unforgiven match.

The feud was so awful it didn't last beyond that pay-per-view. Clark was promptly released and Adams was demoted to the WWF's farm system in HWA for conditioning. This must be considered one of the worst rivalries Kane and The Undertaker ever worked together.


2. The Undertaker (Heidenreich)

Undertaker Heidenreich Casket Match
WWE

Premise: Big Jon Heidenreich was the latest monster WWE programmed opposite The Undertaker when he debuted in 2004 and targeted 'The Deadman'. Spurred on by the guidance of Paul Heyman, Heidenreich wrestled 'Taker at Survivor Series '04 and the 2005 Royal Rumble. The latter was a Casket Match.

Why It Was Awful: The Undertaker could be forgiven for blowing a gasket (blowing a casket?) over all the horrible workers he's been asked to carry over the decades. Heidenreich was one of the worst, and he never looked comfortable in-ring or like a genuine threat to 'Taker's legacy.

Fans also refused to treat Jon's poetry as anything other than a hangover from the mid-'90s cartoon gimmick era.

Less than one full year after bothering The Undertaker, Heidenreich was donning face paints as Hawk's replacement in a revamped LOD with Animal. He basically went from stinking up rings under his own gimmick to doing it using someone else's.


1. Kane (Imposter Kane)

Kane Fake Kane
WWE.com

Premise: After filming the horror movie See No Evil, Kane began hearing voices telling him to beware the date 19 May (when the film was due to be released). Eventually, it was revealed that an imposter version of Kane, complete with original mask and outfit, was behind the voices. Kane wrestled his doppelgänger at Vengeance 2006 before stealing his mask back 24 hours later on Raw.

Why It Was Awful: The feud only lasted around a month, and nobody bought into the idea of Kane vs. Kane. It was too similar to 1994's The Undertaker vs. 'Underfaker' nonsense. Luke Gallows, who was beneath the old attire as 'Imposter Kane' was also visibly shorter than Glenn Jacobs, and their pay-per-view match was blighted by a slow pace fans in North Carolina booed.

WWE abandoned ship ASAP.

On Raw after Vengeance, Kane unmasked the imposter and left to promote See No Evil. Rumours at the time suggested WWE fancied the idea of having Gallows work the gimmick when Kane was absent from television, but those plans (if true) changed.

-

What other awful feuds were WWE legends forced to work? For more, check out 10 Things We Learned From Week Two Of WWE's XFL and 10 Wrestlers Who Were Right To Walk Out On WWE!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.