10 Modern Wrestling Pops That Sent Shivers Down Your Spine

Wrestling should always make you feel something. Here are the moments that did that best.

roman reigns raw
WWE.com

On the most basic level, like any other form of entertainment media, wrestling is all designed to elicit the best possible pop from the crowd when the good guy overcomes the villain. As we know however, it always seems to be much more complicated than that.

Sometimes when a moment is expected to be accompanied by thunderous cheers from the crowd, it is greeted by virtual silence, such as when Roman Reigns faced Triple H at WrestleMania 32 - while other moments designed to get cheers are met with vociferous boos, such as when Batista when the 2014 Royal Rumble.

Other times, moments generate pops when WWE were intending the crowd to boo. This is especially a problem WWE have today, with fans often choosing to cheer the supposed heel because they prove to be more entertaining than the face, such as during Chris Jericho and Kevin Owen's run together from 2016-17.

However, if there's one thing that is missing during the empty arena era of wrestling shows, it is the cheers heard by an audience when someone they love finally achieves success. Drew McIntyre should have beaten Brock Lesnar to the adulation of over 60,000 people at WrestleMania, however instead his crowning moment came to amid the silence of the WWE Performance Center. Though Drew finally climbing to the top of the wrestling mountain will be a moment long cherished by WWE fans, it will likely never be mentioned in the same breath as Hogan slamming Andre or Mankind winning the title.

Here are some moments that might.

10. Brock Is Back

BROCK LESNAR Return Raw
WWE

WWE programming was in an awkward spot coming out of WrestleMania XXVIII.

The show was mostly built around John Cena vs The Rock and The Undertaker vs Triple H, however only John Cena was going to be around afterwards, leaving him and CM Punk to carry the company through its post-'Mania blues season. The fact that the much maligned John Laurinitus had just taken control of both Raw and Smackdown meant hopes were not exactly high for WWE going forward.

However, one beacon of light shone through the period, and that light was Brock Lesnar. Having seemingly wrapped up his time in UFC the previous year, it felt nailed on that Brock would return to WWE and prove himself once more after his disastrous departure match at WrestleMania XX with Goldberg.

Fans spent much of the Raw after WrestleMania chanting for Brock Lesnar, desperate for The Beast Incarnate to show his face on WWE TV for the first time in eight years. When John Cena invited The Rock out to congratulate him on his win, Brock's music hit, and the roof flew off the arena.

Lesnar's time in the UFC had added a whole new element to his character, with his F-5 to Cena establishing him as an immediate threat as the most legitimate combat athlete in WWE history. Though we may be sick to death of him now, fans will always cherish the moment The Next Big Thing returned, which kickstarted the idea of the Raw after WrestleMania as the night for big returns in WWE.


9. Here To Show The World

Dolph Ziggler Cashes In
WWE

Dolph Ziggler was one of the first signs of the work-rate era that has come to define WWE over the past five years or so.

In a time where WWE still seemed to favour size over anything else, Dolph would stand out as someone who gave everything they could into every match, bumping like crazy and drawing the the crowd in with his exciting move-set. Though he had high-profile opportunities against the likes of CM Punk and Edge, The Show Off always felt like a transitional opponent for champions before they moved into marquee programs, and seemed destined for life in the mid-card.

Therefore, when Ziggler won the Smackdown Money in the Bank Ladder Match in 2012, thus booking himself a shot at the World Heavyweight Championship in the process, fans saw it as Dolph's chance at finally winning the championship many felt he had deserved for years. However, Ziggler held onto the briefcase for an agonisingly long time. Fans started to doubt whether WWE would ever have enough faith in Ziggler to pull the trigger.

The night after WrestleMania 29, Ziggler finally got his chance, cashing in on an injured Alberto Del Rio to a staggering pop. Booked masterfully, the match played off fans fears that WWE may never give Dolph the shot they knew he deserved, making that final Zig-Zag all the more special.

Though the reign itself was a disappointment, fans will always have the pop that came with Ziggler finally winning the big one.


8. Bayley Wins The Big One

Bayley Sasha Reverse Hurricanrana TakeOver Brooklyn
WWE

Sasha Banks vs Bayley came at a crucial time for the women's revolution.

WWE had done a tremendous job of botching the hard work of their talented female roster by shoving them all into factions, which had the effect of getting precisely nobody over with the crowd. Furthermore, the women were generally given one segment per episode of Raw, two if they were lucky, meaning any matches between opposing factions contained little in the way of actual story.

Bayley and Sasha's match flew in the face of that. In front of NXT's largest ever crowd at the time, the two told a relatively simple story, but one that resonated with the crowd perfectly. Sasha was the arrogant heel who was as infuriating as she was brilliant in the ring, while Bayley was the plucky underdog who was just trying to make her dreams come true.

The two worked one of the very best matches in WWE that year, with the highlight being the Reverse Frankensteiner off the top rope Bayley hit on Sasha just before the finish. When Bayley slammed Sasha into the mat and the referee counted to three, it created one of the most emotional pops of the decade.

Not only had the two just told one of the best stories ever seen in a WWE ring, but they had just changed the game when it came to women's wrestling.


7. Enter John Moxley

Ups Downs From AEW Double Or Nothing 2019
AEW

AEW's inaugural pay-per-view, Double or Nothing 2019, had already been an excellent show, highlighted by the emotional clash between Cody and Dustin Rhodes. However, it needed that one moment to cap it all off, the image that would define the event as the beginnings of WWE first true rival in almost twenty years.

Then Jon Moxley came out.

In a moment reminiscent of Lex Luger appearing on the first episode of Monday Nitro, the former Dean Ambrose stormed to the ring to wail on both Chris Jericho and Kenny Omega, who had both just wrestled an excellent main event.

Moxley had been the one member of The Shield WWE had never quite been able to get right. Once seen as the most likely of the three to break out into superstardom, WWE continued to drop the ball with him time and time again. So often presented as an idiot who pushed hot dog carts, lost because of holograms and forgot about tv monitor wires, fans were thrilled to see The Lunatic Fringe reborn as Jon Moxley.

His appearance on the show marked AEW out as a force to be reckoned with, while generating a pop that matched among the greatest WWE have ever produced.


6. Mr TNA Arrives In WWE

AJ Styles Debut
WWE.com

For years, AJ Styles had led TNA in its futile attempts to compete with the WWE machine. Proving himself as one of the very best in-ring workers of his time, The Phenomenal One had delivered in high profile matches all over the world, including in an incredible stint in New Japan Pro Wrestling. Therefore, when news broke that Styles had finally signed for WWE, there was both elation and trepidation from fans; they thought of all the dream match scenarios that were now possible, while also fearing the treatment WWE had often given to other big names who had made a name for themselves while working for their rivals.

However those fears were quickly dispelled the second Styles stepped out into a WWE arena for the first time. Entering at number three in the 2016 Royal Rumble, fans in the arena were greeted by an unknown theme as the words "I am Phenomenal" appeared on the TitanTron. Unfortunately, fans at home were greeted to a nice closeup of Roman Reign's confused face. However, that didn't stop fans giving one of the biggest ever pops for someone making their first appearance in WWE.

That initial pop is all the more special looking given how consistently Styles has delivered over the past four years. Whereas others to join WWE, such as Shinsuke Nakamura, have struggled to retain their early momentum, Styles has gone from strength to strength, winning multiple orld championships and facing The Undertaker in possibly his final ever match.


5. Da Man Returns

Goldberg return
WWE.com

Just like the man he stared down on that calamitous night in 2004, Goldberg had lots of unfinished business in WWE. His year in the company had always been seen as a huge missed opportunity, with his momentum being obliterated by a single shot from Triple H's sledgehammer. Goldberg fell out of love with the industry, and had not been seen in a WWE ring in twelve years by the time he returned in 2016.

However, coinciding with his appearance as a pre-order bonus in WWE 2K17, Goldberg finally returned to WWE on the October 17th edition of Raw in 2016. Announced ahead of time, the entire night built towards Goldberg appearing at the end of the show. There was some skepticism about how Goldberg would be treated, especially given his acrimonious exit from the company and fears he wouldn't fit into WWE's work-rate era.

Goldberg however arrived to one of the greatest ovations the company has ever heard for a returning legend, with Michael Cole's introduction being greeted with rapturous cheers before the Pepsi Centre in Denver, Colorado began thunderously chanting Goldberg's name. Everyone was suddenly transported back to 1998 as this Clint Eastwood like figure returned to declare himself for battle one last time.


4. "I'm In Remmission Y'all"

Roman Reigns Announces His Leukaemia Is In Remission Batista Returns To WWE More THUMB
WWE

Isn't it nice to finally like Roman Reigns?

After years of fans booing Vince McMahon's latest pet project into oblivion, fans have finally come around to the fact that Roman truly deserves his spot at the top of the card. The Big Dog consistently delivers the best match no matter what card he is on, is an excellent ambassador for the company and knows how to present himself online (looking at you, Seth Rollins and Braun Strowman).

The uncomfortable truth is that fans would likely never truly have been able to come around to Roman had it not been for his devastating announcement in October 2018, when he came out to announce he was fighting leukaemia for the second time. After over three years of fans feeling like they were watching a caricature of the worst elements of John Cena and Hulk Hogan, they finally got to witness the real Joe Anoia'I. The open and honest account resulted in fans flocking to the man's side, as the whole wrestling world got behind Joe to kick leukaemia's candy-ass.

Therefore, when Joe stood in the ring in February 2019, and uttered that now famous quote, the State Farm Arena exploded in cathartic joy, as fans celebrated the victory of a man who refused to back down in the face of adversity. Since then, Roman has remained just as popular with fans as ever, and when he feels he is finally able to return to the company, which will likely be around when fans are able to return, you can be sure that the reaction will be just as thunderous.


3. A Kiss Goodbye

Cm Punk Money In The Bank 2011
WWE.com

There's a reason that CM Punk's storyline heading into Money in the Bank 2011 with John Cena is attributed by many disillusioned fans as what got them back into wrestling.

Punk exuded a sense of fire and rebelliousness not seen since prime Stone Cold Steve Austin, with his astonishing diatribe on the company on Raw sending shockwaves throughout the industry. For the first time in years, wrestling was cool again.

The pop as Punk entered the All-State Arena, in front of his hometown of Chicago, would have made this list on its own, had it not been topped by the pandemonium that accompanied his victory. Following a fantastic match, which received WWE's first five star rating from Dave Meltzer since 1997, John Cena's virtuous ways cost him the title, as he stopped John Laurinaitis from handing him the win, only to walk into a GTS which put him down for three.

With Punk's contract status still up in the air at the time, fans genuinely had no idea how the match was going to play out. However the crowd in the arena that night knew one thing, and that was that they wanted CM Punk walking out as champion no matter what. Therefore, when the referees hand hit the mat for the third time, and when Punk walked out of the arena through the crowd, it created one of the most bone-chilling pops of all time.


2. Rated R Return

Edge Return
WWE.com

It was that sense of lost opportunity towards Edge, who it felt like still had several years left at the top, which added to the sheer elation fans felt when Edge finally returned at the 2020 Royal Rumble. Edge had made sporadic appearances for the company for much of the 2010s whenever the company needed him, inckludialmost being murdered by Seth Rollins in order to get The Authority back into power in 2014 because wrestling.

Rumours first began to circulate when Edge hit a spear on Elias at last year's SummerSlam, the first time we had seen him do any move since 2011. Even then, it was still cast off by many as a one-off. In the weeks leading up to the rumble, every dirt sheet under the sun was reporting Edge was set to the return at the Rumble, despite his claims to the contrary.

Thus when Edge stepped out as the 21st entrant in the Royal Rumble, it managed to retain much of its shock for the fans who don't read dirt sheets and those, much like this writer, who never truly thought that they would ever get to see Edge back in a WWE ring, and resulted in one of the most emotional pops of all time.


1. A Miracle On Bourbon Street

Daniel Bryan Pointing Wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

Terrible Michael Cole line aside, there is no hiding just how significant Daniel Bryan finally capturing the WWE World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 30 was. WWE had decided months in advance that Batista was going to return at the Royal Rumble before beating Randy Orton in the main-event of WrestleMania for the title. He would then spend the summer as champ, promoting Guardians of the Galaxy as he did it, providing WWE with some of the sweet sweet crossover appeal they always desperately search for.

As much as the company have attempted to twist the narrative in recent years to suggest that they engineered the whole storyline, the reality is that the fans decided Daniel Bryan should main-event the Show of Shows, and if he wasn't going to, they were going to do everything in their power to change that. Following Batista's Rumble win, fans continued to chant for Daniel Bryan in almost every segment of Raw and Smackdown in the hope that WWE may finally listen.

Eventually, realising the main event of their biggest show of the year could be ruined if things stayed the same, WWE relented. Bryan went on to have one of the best opening matches in WrestleMania history against Triple H, before facing Batista and Orton in the main-event.

Though the match itself was a little overbooked, when Bryan locked Batista in the Yes Lock, you could feel the tension build as everybody in the arena waited for Dave to tap. When he finally did, months of pent up frustration with the product was released by fans, resulting in an earth-shattering pop to accompany one of the greatest WrestleMania performances of all time. It is a testament to the connection Bryan had with the WWE Universe that, on the same night The Streak ended, he was able to rouse them one final time to witness the culmination of his incredible journey.


In this post: 
Roman Reigns
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Alfie Seymour hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.