10 Most Believable Underdogs In Wrestling Today

Some people can make a career out of fighting from underneath. It makes victory that much better.

Rey Mysterio underdog
WWE

It's been said that nothing in life worth having is ever obtained easily. If given something without earning it first, people have a tendency to be unappreciative, or, even worse, squander the gifts they have been provided.

It is because of this that people have a natural tendency to gravitate towards the underdog. There is just something undeniable about watching success in the face of adversity - to see an individual encounter setback after setback only to eventually reach greater heights. It is an old story, but one that has stood the test of time.

The wrestlers on this list seem to get that. They can take a beating, but they remain undeterred. Giving up is not on the cards for these men and women, and because of that, fans want to hope, want to believe in them. Because in a way, their triumphs start to feel like our triumphs while we mourn their losses. And, for a moment, audiences can suspend their disbelief, and feel that their cheers, their faith, and their love can pay off when their favorites succeed when the world said they couldn't.

10. Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio WCW
WCW

Considered by many to be the greatest luchador of all time, Rey Mysterio has earned accolade upon accolade throughout his career, which has spanned over twenty-five years in American wrestling promotions. Whether plying his trade in ECW, thereby bringing lucha libre into the consciousness of American wrestling, becoming the face of WCW's now-legendary Cruiserweight division, or elevating himself into the ranks World Champions in WWE, the masked marvel has legitimately done it all.

After leaving WWE for a few years beginning in 2015, Mysterio was granted something he had not received in ages: time. It is well known that his flashy style had taken a toll on his body and that paper clips and the power of friendship essentially were all that held Mysterio together. Taken off the rigorous WWE travel schedule, nagging injuries seemed to heal and Mysterio was reborn, tearing it up in promotions like AAA and Lucha Underground. His return to WWE seemed inevitable.

Indeed, Mysterio came back looking, amazingly, better than ever. At 45 years of age, Mysterio moves around the ring like someone 15 years his junior, throwing down with the likes of Andrade, Samoa Joe, AJ Styles, and even receiving the highly coveted lose-to-Brock-at-a-PPV spot. Mysterio's size always means he's fighting from underneath, but his pedigree always has the fans believing he has a chance.


9. KUSHIDA

Kushida NXT
WWE

KUSHIDA is one of those names that has has been seemingly overlooked by NXT, an enigma given the prolific resume he forged for himself during his stint in New Japan Pro Wrestling. A stalwart standout of the Junior division, KUSHIDA amassed an astonishing six reigns as NJPW Junior Heavyweight Champion, two Super J Tournament victories, a Super J Cup win, and an additional two reigns as a Junior tag champion and the 2012 Super J Tag Tournament with Alex Shelley, known collectively as the Time Splitters, one of the fastest and most innovative teams of the last twenty years.

KUSHIDA, whether in singles or as a tag, could apparently do no wrong. With a reputation like that, it is admittedly a bit frustrating to see him struggling to find his footing in NXT. Debuting with tremendous hype like so many before him, KUSHIDA bested Kassius Ohno, also like so many before him, before not doing much of anything. KUSHIDA would later be seen in the Dusty Rhodes tag classic reuniting the Time Splitters with Shelly only to lose in the very first round.

Now entrenched in the tournament for the interim Cruiserweight championship, KUSHIDA is an incredible talent that the crowd is salivating to see break out of the pack and distinguish himself. The question is whether or not the WWE will afford him that very opportunity.


8. Dustin Rhodes

Dustin Rhodes
AllEliteWrestling.com

Dustin Rhodes is a man who is at his absolute best when he is fighting with something to prove. It is a time-tested tradition that has worked time and time again for the veteran. Despite his size and experience, Rhodes proves that underdogs do not need to be diminutive high-flyers to be effective in the role.

Logic dictates Rhodes should have passed his prime by now, but is wrestling better in 2020 than he ever has. Seemingly reinvigorated by stepping away from WWE and joining with his brother in AEW, the two had an absolute classic at Double or Nothing. Since then, Rhodes has been on the periphery of the battle with Chris Jericho's Inner Circle stable. Whether he is standing up, but ultimately falling, to Jericho's heavy Jake Hager or putting his career on the line against Kip Sabian in the TNT Championship tournament, Rhodes consistently tries to find ways to get the crowd invested in his journey.

Dustin is the modern-day equivalent of an aging gunslinger. One day, time will catch up with him, and he will not be able to win the fights that count the most any longer. But he's made it clear that if he goes out, he's going to go down swinging, fighting on his own terms, and that the crowd will be behind him every step of the way.


7. Drake Maverick

Drake Maverick Jake Atlas
NXT

A controversial entry, Drake Maverick's current situation in WWE is tenuous at best. Before receiving his release from the company in April, Maverick was a small, charismatic foil that served as the antagonist seeking to free the 24/7 Championship from R-Truth's stranglehold. Tying his championship victory to his real-life marriage and subsequent (hopefully not real-life) consummation, there was something about his relentless scheming, setbacks, and dogged determination to see it through that made Maverick endearing. Of course, as with all nice things, WWE eventually just stopped trying, and took him off TV entirely.

Maverick's gut-wrenching video in the wake of WWE's mass layoffs made him instantly relatable and sympathetic. It is difficult to tell where the storyline ends and the reality of the situation begins when it comes to Maverick. Is WWE taking making a storyline out of his release? Are they forcing him to work during his no-compete period, during which he is hoping to engender support once he is inevitably let go? On the other hand, is this a situation where the former Rockstar's job is literally on the line, offering him up a new contract if he becomes popular enough?

The point is that people love Drake as much as they loathe WWE's shady business practices. It is because his passion and his caring shine through that the crowd has now grown passionate and care about him winning, futile though it may be.


6. Shorty G

Chad Gable
WWE.com

CHAD. GABLE. Now that that's settled, Gable has so much more to offer, and it is a damning indictment of the current system that many underdogs exist in present WWE are born not because of their stature or their determination, but out of the will of the people to see their favorites succeed in spite of, rather than because of, the booking.

There is probably a clever, nuanced way to portray a character like Chad Gable. Someone who embraces what others may see as a detriment and uses it to rise above, stand up to bullies, and emerge victorious. Honestly, the Nia Jax/Alexa Bliss storyline was not a terrible example. What doesn't help is Gable being on the losing end of a feud with Sheamus.

This story writes itself. People want to believe in the shorter, scrappier babyface that believes in himself. He is someone the crowd can empathize with, who has a respectable work ethic, and has a trump card in his deceptive power game on top of his agility. But if you book that person to be a perennial loser, then it is only a matter of time before the audience stops believing in him.

Gable can, and has, proved that he has what it takes to be a major player in the organization if only the company would get behind him. The crowd WANTS to believe in Gable, and the obligation is on WWE to give them a reason.


5. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy
AEW/Lee South

The Freshly Squeezed one's gimmick is one that immediately lends itself to telling a great story in the ring. It is a blessing that the man portraying the character also happens to be an exceptionally good wrestler, which furthers the crowd's love of him.

A laid-back, super chill guy, Orange Cassidy puts forth just enough effort to get by, which is a sentiment virtually the entire working class can probably relate to. However, get him between the ropes and... he's basically the same guy, at least for a while. The crowd sits on edge waiting for Cassidy to finally, as succinctly put by Best Friend Chuck Taylor, actually try.

Cassidy's move set brilliantly reflects his style, with the character feeding the fighting style, often using traditional moves but employing them in a hands-in-pockets fashion whenever possible. Being able to make good moves look both impressive and effortless is an absolute delight, and most wrestling fans appreciate how difficult a task that can be.

Cassidy’s losses usually don’t hurt him, as he’s often seen as being apprehensive to get in the ring to begin with. Similarly, falling to him can often be booked as a blindsided, under-prepared foe being caught off guard by his unorthodox method. So far, AEW has learned the value of maximizing his minutes, allowing him to be a highlight of each week without overexposing him. Hopefully, they can continue the trend.


4. Cameron Grimes

Cameron Grimes
WWE.com

Not every underdog lives in a world where they're plucky, never-say-die heroes that feed off the crowd's support. Indeed, some of them are simply the victims of circumstance, and have to rely on their cunning and ambition in order to get ahead. Enter Cameron Grimes.

The former Trevor Lee has cultivated a look that instantly puts fans on his bad side. The hair, the beard the weird tongue thing and his stupid hat - I hate it, get it off my screen! But perhaps Grimes has a reason to be surly with the NXT faithful: he walks in the land of the giants.

Slotted into the hunt for NXT's North American title, Grimes is, on paper, hopelessly outclassed. Compared to competitors like Damian Priest, Dominik Dijakovic, and champion Keith Lee, Grimes sticks out like a sore thumb.

Don’t let that size disparity fool you, however. Grimes is more than capable between the ropes, mixing high-flying offense when needed with a surprising strength. His deadlift German suplex is incredibly devastating on every opponent he comes into contact with, size be damned.

Perhaps his biggest asset is the Cave-In, Grimes's finishing maneuver. A leaping double stomp to the chest that cuts off the forward momentum of the opponent, it has the makings of all the best match-enders: it looks brutal, it’s an effective counter, and can come without a moment's notice to crush an unsuspecting foe. Opponents shouldn’t sleep on Cameron Grimes, or they may find themselves counting the lights.


3. Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan Natalya
WWE.com

Fans and wrestlers alike have bemoaned the imaginary brass ring of Vince McMahon. The idea that hard work and perseverance will eventually get wrestlers to the upper echelon has been proven empirically false time and time again. However, the crowd appreciates someone who visibly gives it their all, and perhaps nowhere is that better exemplified in Liv Morgan.

The New Jersey native has recently put her days in the Riott Squad behind her to become the Living Embodiment of Karma - whatever that means. Setting aside WWE's infamously bad nickname generator, Liv has shown that she is willing to bet on herself, take chances, and has grown before the audience's very eyes.

In the Riott Squad, Morgan was totally unafraid, exemplified at TLC when she took a horrific spill through a table at ringside. Now that she has distinguished herself from the pack, she's improved her grappling game between the ropes by leaps and bounds, punctuated by the Oblivion, a quick, impactful new finisher.

People have rooted for Morgan for years but she has never been taken seriously as a top-quality prospect within the company. However, with her new look, new attitude, and new ringwork, more people are starting to get on board and want to see her succeed. Given what seems to be an endless amount of determination, she may very well do just that.


2. Jungle Boy

Jungle Boy
Scott Lesh

When the Young Bucks became EVPs of All Elite Wrestling, they made a proclamation that they would re-emphasize, re-energize, and re-legitimize tag team wrestling in North America. Boasting excellent teams like The Lucha Bros, Private Party, Proud and Powerful, the Best Friends, the Dark Order, SCU, and the Young Bucks themselves, it's hard to argue that they haven't achieved their goal.

However, one standout trio within the division is The Jurassic Express. Important to the group’s diversity, each member has a distinct role to play. While Marko Stunt has the heart of a lion, he is at times difficult to buy as a viable competitor against larger opponents. Luchasaurus is awesome as the heavy of the group, but may find himself hampered by his gimmick. Jungle Boy (Jack Perry if you're JR) is a totally different story.

Jungle Boy has great credentials, working for the likes of PWG and All Pro Wrestling before joining with AEW. Blessed with an athletic move set, movie star good looks, and an inherent fire that makes him easy to root for, Jungle Boy went ten minutes in the ring with then-AEW World Champion Chris Jericho on a December episode of AEW Dynamite, proving to the world that he could contend with the best.

Of the three members of the Jurassic Express, he absolutely has the best chance of becoming a breakout star, and has the perfect mix of intensity, grappling skills, and inherent likability to make him a major player.


1. Darby Allin

Return Darby Allin
AEW

Darby Allin was in the first match in the history of AEW Dynamite, winning a bout before the broadcast against CIMA. I should know, because I was there. The unique high-flyer captured the attention of the crowd from the moment he set foot in the ring. From there, his stock in the company has only risen in a way that has him earmarked as a future world champion.

Allin is utterly captivating to watch in the ring. A fearless daredevil, everything from his facepaint, to the way he moves, stalking around like a wild animal, to his dazzling array of attacks, punctuated by the awe-inspiring Coffin Drop, make him an enthralling spectacle.

There's something about him that commands attention in a way that hasn't been seen since a young Jeff Hardy left jaws on the floor during the heyday of the Attitude Era. Similar to Darby, Jeff was initially seen as too small, too reckless to work on as a main eventer, but eventually proved everyone wrong.

Allin, like Hardy before him, has embraced total fearlessness, and it shows in everything he does. He wrestles with total conviction, believing in himself in everything that he does. And it turns out, if a wrestler has complete confidence and belief in themselves, the audience will be sure to follow.


In this post: 
Rey Mysterio
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A former Army vet who kept his sanity running D&D games for his Soldiers. I'll have a bit of D&D, pro wrestling, narrative-driven video games, and 80's horror movies, please and thank you.