10 Most Disappointing Nights In WWE History

That... sucked.

roman reigns wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

No wrestling show will ever satisfy us 100%. If we didn't know that already, we certainly do after watching this week's Monday Night Raw 25th anniversary special.

Next to most episodes of WWE's flagship weekly broadcast - indeed, next to most of its specials - this would have been a more than serviceable effort. Shawn Michaels, Undertaker and (a mute) Stone Cold all made rare appearances, with John Cena humiliated - in front of Jimmy Fallon - by Elias.

But our expectations going into the evening's entertainment were simply too high. Speculation that the Deadman was in Manhattan to set up a WrestleMania 34 retirement match, coupled with wild rumours that Hollywood stars Rock and Batista were in town, meant that everything else seemed somehow underwhelming by comparison.

In a way, WWE is as much to blame as we are. They spent weeks selling the idea that this would be the biggest extravaganza in the show's quarter-century on air. After a billing like that, they can't really blame fans for walking out with a sense that they hadn't got their money's worth.

It won't be the last WWE night to disappoint, though, and it certainly wasn't the first...

10. WrestleMania 25

Triple H Randy Orton
WWE.com

Triple H and Randy Orton took each other places no pair of WWE wrestlers have ever ventured before in the build-up to their WWE Title grudge match at WrestleMania 25 (namely, Randy's family "home", which he shared with his "wife").

For most fans, this storyline stopped being a tired rehash of a feud we'd already seen countless times before, and morphed instead into something interesting, when The Viper knelt over an unconscious Stephanie McMahon and gave her a gentle peck on the cheek, while HHH watched on in handcuffs.

After a scene like that, there was absolutely no way these two could resolve their differences in anything other than an Unsanctioned, No Holds Barred, Extreme Rules Elimination Chamber. With machine guns. And grenades.

So what did WWE do? That's right: they gave us a middle-of-the-road singles bout, whose most violent sequence involved a low-blow and a Pedigree. Regardless of how good 'Taker-Shawn was in the night's third-to-last encounter, that was WrestleMania 25's go-home memory - and it sucked.


9. Monday Night Raw - 3 March 2014

Vince McMahon
WWE

On paper, an episode of Raw that aired on 3 March 2014 sounds ridiculously nondescript; the kind of show that would probably feature a match as tedious as, say, Santino Marella and Emma versus Fandango and Summer Rae.

But fans - at least the kind of fans who spend their waking moments scouring the internet in search of vaguely credible yet completely outlandish rumours - went into this night head-over-heels excited, for one simple reason: CM Punk.

The Straight Edge Superstar had just walked out on WWE at this point, his formal release from the company yet to be officially confirmed. So when Dave Meltzer told WON listeners that his insider sources reckoned Punk would be showing up on a Chicago-hosted Raw, there was every reason to believe him.

In the end, however, it turned out that the usually reliable journalist had been misled (perhaps deliberately). Punk didn't make an appearance, although his entrance music did briefly sound before Paul Heyman walked out in his place - which proves that Vince McMahon is one hell of a troll.


8. SummerSlam 2007

John Cena Randy Orton Summerslam 2007
WWE.com

Though not exactly a vintage WWE year, 2007 largely succeeded in delivering high-quality "Big Four" shows - with one exception. SummerSlam, whose tagline - "the party is over" - turned out to be a prophecy - was a major disappointment.

Two of the major reasons for this were the underwhelming matches that followed the long-awaited returns of much-loved duo Rey Mysterio and Triple H. It wasn't their fault - they were, quite understandably, a long way from full fitness - but these just weren't pay-per-view calibre encounters.

The main event, wherein a super-intense, temple-punting Randy Orton challenged Superman John Cena for the WWE Championship, delivered in terms of quality but its result was a major letdown. This was exactly the moment to relieve Big Match John of his throne - and yet they had him retain.

Everything else, meanwhile, had the whiff of a card thrown together at the very last minute. Batista faced The Great Khali, Kane took on Finlay, and Umaga, Carlito and Mr Kennedy - three heels - contested a triple threat. There was nothing to get excited about.


7. WrestleMania 2000

Big Show Shane McMahon WrestleMania 2000
WWE.com

WrestleMania 2000 is perhaps a cautionary tale in what happens when you take seven of your biggest stars and put them in just two matches. The rest of the card is almost inevitably going to suffer as a result.

In fact, even the show's two marquee encounters ended up being somewhat disappointing. Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle and Chris Jericho, booked in a two-fall triple threat match for the Intercontinental and European Titles, were allowed to go a frankly insulting 13 minutes.

The four-way main event, meanwhile, got plenty of time - but much of it was simply uninteresting. The idea that Mankind and Linda McMahon would end the night standing tall was fanciful, and the same could probably be said of Big Show and Shane too.

Granted, the triangle ladder match between the Hardys, Dudleys and Edge & Christian, though not as good as next year's TLC, was a fabulous under-card curtain-raiser. It's just that everything else fell short of expectations in a big way. Plus: no singles matches on the entire card?* It's WrestleMania, for god's sake.

*Terri Runnels versus The Kat doesn't count.


6. WrestleMania XXVII

John Cena The Miz WrestleMania 27
WWE.com

Opening the show with a world title match is just a horrible idea. It didn't work at WrestleMania XXVIII, where Daniel Bryan was humiliated in 18 seconds, and it didn't work here.

In fact, this show never really recovered from its disappointing opening bout, in which Royal Rumble winner Alberto Del Rio failed to make real his boyhood dreams against Edge in a lacklustre 10-minute curtain-raiser.

In subsequent matches, the remnants of The Nexus (now going under "The Corre") were buried in under two minutes by Big Show, Kane, Kofi Kingston and Santino Marella; Randy Orton and CM Punk were uncharacteristically off their game; and, oh yeah, Michael Cole got a full 15 minutes in the ring.

Undertaker's era-defining match with Triple H was undeniably amazing, but that wasn't the note we ended on. Instead, it was The Miz's hugely underwhelming WWE Title defence against John Cena, a clash that proved the former wasn't yet ready for the main event, and which not even The Rock, the night's "guest host", could rescue.


5. Raw 25

Stone Cold Steve Austin Shane McMahon
WWE

OK, so it's probably true that the extent to which this show sucked has been exaggerated. The WWE audience, like any group of angry fans, have an unfortunate tendency to overstate their strength of feeling in the immediate post-mortem (hence every Arsenal defeat is the team's worst-ever performance).

But it still fell short of expectations, and not just for the television audience either. Some of those who attended the Manhattan Centre leg of the broadcast, whose tickets didn't come cheap, were filmed protesting after it went off air (good luck with that).

It should be a violation of wrestling law to invite Stone Cold Steve Austin to your show and not put a microphone in his hand. He didn't even get the chance to exchange a couple of "whats" with the crowd; he just delivered his Stunners, downed a can of beer, and then left.

Undertaker's promo was anti-climactic too, neither confirming nor quashing speculation that he is set for a return to the ring in April. That would have been fine if there was something else to sink our teeth into, but all the other segments were just standard fare Royal Rumble build-up, which meant that there was little to really get us out of our seats.


4. December To Dismember

Paul Heyman December to Dismember Facepalm
WWE

Vince McMahon has been accused of inadvertently tarnishing ECW's legacy with his half-baked 2006 revival of Paul Heyman's passion project, but that's simply not true. Anyone who saw December To Dismember will know that there was nothing inadvertent about it.

Expectations going into this one, to be fair, weren't exactly through the roof. For one thing, WWE had only announced a couple of matches, with the rest of them to be cobbled together on the night itself from the threadbare remains of the ECW roster.

But there was still reason to believe they'd pull something out the bag at last minute. After all, at this point the rebooted ECW brand had hosted two official pay-per-views in One Night Stands 2005 and 2006, both of them resounding successes. Surely this one would follow suit.

Suffice it to say, it didn't. The headline Elimination Chamber bout - ostensibly "extreme", in that there were a smattering of weapons thrown in - was the worst-ever of its kind, and as for the under-card, well, there have been episodes of Velocity with more exciting matches.


3. WrestleMania 2

Roddy Piper Mr. T WrestleMania 2
WWE.com

One of the major grievances that attendees of this week's Raw 25 show left with - at least those who were at the Manhattan Center leg, anyway - was that they drew the short straw in terms of the action, despite their premium-rate seats.

This situation was perhaps inevitable, though - particularly given that it's not the first time WWE has tried to hold an event over multiple arenas. They also had the debacle that was WrestleMania 2, way back in 1986.

Even if you are prepared to dismiss the issues that arose as a result of this gimmick as an ambitious experiment gone awry, the card wasn't even that great for the audience watching at home either. The Steel Cage main event lacked spark, and the Mr T-Roddy Piper boxing match was about 10 minutes too long.

Considering that this was the second WrestleMania in the event's history - with the first (though not one of the best in terms of match quality) seen as a qualified success - it has to go down as a major disappointment. And one from which WWE doesn't seem to have learned any lessons.


2. WrestleMania 32

aj styles chris jericho wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

As many of us had long suspected, it turns out that Triple H did marry Stephanie McMahon for the sole and exclusive purpose of maintaining his place at the top of the WWE card. How else do you explain the fact that he headlined WrestleMania at the age of nearly 47?

To be fair to The Game, this may have been a last-minute alteration to the planned festivities. His employers were hit by a slew of ill-timed injuries in the build-up, with John Cena, Randy Orton, Seth Rollins and Bray Wyatt all made to watch from the treatment table.

That said, this still has to go down as one of the more disappointing nights in recent WWE history. Just look at the under-card: Undertaker's Hell in a Cell clash with Shane was a dud (and a 30-minute dud at that), and Brock Lesnar versus Dean Ambrose little more than a glorified squash match.

Even Chris Jericho and AJ Styles, two wrestlers of considerable in-ring pedigree, failed to find their rhythm on a night when virtually everything Vince McMahon and co tried ended up falling flat. Even with the wrestling gods against them, it was a pretty lacklustre effort.


1. Invasion

Paul Heyman Stephanie McMahon Steve Austin Shane McMahon Invasion 2001
WWE.com

The best thing about Invasion was the event's promotional poster, which featured a super creepy picture of Shane McMahon morphing into his old man like something out of a 1970s sci-fi movie.

The show, however, was almost entirely bereft of redeeming features, its only rewatchable match being the mid-card Hardcore Title clash between Rob Van Dam and Jeff Hardy (and even that only lasted a meagre 12 minutes).

Here's how bad it got: the night's second bout was contested by two referees, WWF's Earl Hebner and Hulk Hogan's number one fan Nick Patrick of WCW. They actually brought Mick Foley in as the special guest official as well, apparently convinced that this - and not the main event - was the best use of his talents.

The headline Inaugural Brawl wasn't exactly terrible, but it was nothing to write home about either. Nobody bought the idea that the five guys that fought on the side of The Alliance represented the best of WCW and ECW, and nobody cared that Stone Cold had defected. Moreover, neither Goldberg nor the nWo rocked up at the last-second, which means you wasted your money.


Contributor