10 Most Mysterious Wrestling Gimmicks

Did WWE make the most of the Papa Shango character?

The word 'mysterious' is itself fairly cryptic. On one hand, the word's definition states that for something to be mysterious it must be difficult or impossible to understand. The other meaning concludes that mysterious means something is 'deliberately enigmatic'. In many respects, the word works greatly within the paradigms of pro wrestling. Over the years, wrestling promoters have enjoyed mystery. There's something exciting about creating characters that are mystical. In addition, some of the absolute best storylines in grappling history have included at least some degree of mystery. One of the most memorable is even included on this list. This article is set up solely to explore 10 of the most mysterious gimmicks in pro wrestling history. Common sense might dictate that this means only scary characters will be involved, but that's not necessarily the case. Something doesn't need to be downright terrifying to be classed as mysterious, which is why there's such variety included here. From undead zombies and shaman witch doctors, to androgynous freaks and nameless authority figures, there's a lot to soak in. Regardless of the wide scope of characters studied, all could accurately be described as completely mysterious. Whether that be down to their backstories or actions, these 10 figures remain some of the most curious in wrestling folklore.


10. Mr. America

Back in 2003, Hulk Hogan was embroiled in an on-screen feud opposite Vince McMahon. At WrestleMania XIX, the pair conducted a brawl that had no business being as entertaining as it was. The rivalry continued after that big event, and Hogan was eventually fired and told to sit at home by McMahon. This led to the creation of a unique character for Hogan to play. All of a sudden, vignettes started to air on Smackdown for the debut of 'Mr. America'. At first, fans were confused. The new character seemed woefully out of date, so the idea of handing it to be a new, up-and-coming wrestler seemed preposterous. In time, it became clear that it was simply a storyline vehicle for Hogan to continue making appearances. The man underneath the mask was clearly the Hulkster, but WWE instructed announcers to act as though he was a newcomer to the promotion. It was a mysterious time, both for the company and Hulk Hogan. Eventually, the character was outed and Hogan ditched the mask, but it remains a wholly unique time in the career of one of wrestling's biggest stars.

9. The 'Mystery Man' (Brutus Beefcake)

Who knows what success Brutus Beefcake may have been earmarked for in the then-WWF before an unfortunate accident. Whilst out parasailing, Beefcake's face was completely caved in by a friend's knees, causing intense surgery to repair his facial structure. This put a hold on the man's wrestling career, but he did make a curious return to screens in 1991. Wearing red jeans, a curious piece on his chest, and a star-emblazoned mask, Beefcake returned on an episode of Superstars. Stopping Earthquake from crushing a jobber, the man was not named by the commentary team. He made several more appearances, attacking the likes of Rick Martel and Dino Bravo. The whole situation was curious. It makes sense to think that Brutus was on a mission to stop heels from paralysing their foes, but that was never mentioned on television. Instead, Beefcake merely returned to playing 'The Barber' character later that year. No mention was ever made to his 'Mystery Man' phase, which is truly bizarre.

8. Se7en

Dustin Runnels is the only man to appear on this list twice, under the guise of 2 distinctly different characters. One of his more famous incarnations will be explored later, but first comes the idea of 'Se7en' (pronounced 'Seven') in World Championship Wrestling. Leaving the WWF in 1999, Runnels returned to WCW and created an entirely new persona. Clips were shown in the lead-up to the man's debut. These creepy vignettes had Runnels, as 'Se7en', standing outside a child's bedroom window in nightmarish fashion. Quickly, WCW cancelled these videos, over fears that people may view the character as someone who abducts kids. Making things even more auspicious, Se7en literally floated to the ring during his first appearance on Monday Nitro. From there, Runnels tore the gimmick to pieces, saying he was sick of playing stupid characters. The faux-reality ordeal made little sense, and the character was dead in the water almost immediately. It's perplexing to think what WCW's creative team were hoping to achieve with the gimmick, and why they even introduced it in the first place.

7. Anonymous Raw GM

For over one full calendar year, the 'Anonymous Raw General Manager' ruled with an iron first on Monday Night Raw. In June, 2010, the character was first introduced. Michael Cole would read out emails from this nameless authority figure, who would interrupt the show at random points to make matches and give messages. It was a compelling idea, but there was only one problem. The WWE creative team themselves didn't seem to have any clear idea who was supposed to be behind the unnamed GM. Eventually, in July, 2011, Hornswoggle was offered up as the one who controlled things from beneath the ring, which was clearly frustrating for fans. The diminutive star was not a good enough pay-off for people. As it turned out, WWE made the decision to have the idea return in late-2014. After The Authority had seemingly been vanquished at Survivor Series, Raw closed with the message that the anonymous power head promised to bring order into the company again. As of the publishing of this article, the promotion still haven't actually revealed who was behind it all.

6. The Boogeyman

To this day, The Boogeyman can be expected to make surprise appearances every now and then. Lately, the character has been used to fill a space in the annual Royal Rumble match, but he does have an unpredictable need to show up occasionally. The character first appeared in July, 2005, and was last seen on the WWE Network show, 'WWE Swerved'. Played by Tough Enough season 4 contestant, Marty Jones, the gimmick has been mildly popular over the years. It's likely that the persona terrifies young children, but there's a real mystery behind the whole thing. Looking for all the world like a witch doctor of some sort, The Boogeyman isn't the same character that is regularly used as a mythical threat to stop kids from misbehaving. Instead, the gimmick has been used as a heel who targets the good guys as well as heels. When WWE have tried to portray the character as more of a babyface, it usually falls flat. The very nature of the worm-eating Boogeyman gimmick doesn't lend itself well to being well-liked by fans. Perhaps what makes the whole character so mysterious is that he can still turn up at any time.

5. Goldust

Dustin Runnels has said during shoot interviews that he didn't know what to make of the Goldust character when it was first presented to him. As a tough-talking Texan, Runnels likely thought he was being ribbed by Vince McMahon over the guise. On the contrary, McMahon was deadly serious, feeling the character would be controversial. An androgynous, deluded freak, Goldust existed in some sort of Hollywood-inspired world of his own creation. The gimmick was definitely unique, and Runnels had a love/hate relationship with it over the years. When he made his debut as 'Se7en' in WCW later, the man remarked that the idea almost killed his career. Incredibly, it also made him a bigger star than ever before. Embracing the idea from the get go in 1995, Runnels made Goldust wildly popular. There were questions over exactly what the character's motives were, using homophobia to get inside the head of his opponents. Known as 'The Bizarre One', Goldust remains one of the most mystifying gimmicks in history.

4. Kane

When Kane made his then-WWF debut in October, 1997, the general consensus was that he'd only be around for a short spell. It was widely believed that once The Undertaker defeated him for the first time, Kane would be history. Defying that belief, the character has been around ever since, albeit in very different forms. At first, fans were led to believe that the man's face was horrifically scarred due to a fire set by Undertaker years before. Hence the need for Kane to wear his trademark black and red mask. The black flame motif on his outfit also gave credence to Paul Bearer's claims. Over the years however, Kane has been given an even more convoluted backstory. This is something that Glen Jacobs, the man behind the character, has even poked fun at himself on WWE TV. Somewhere along the line, WWE have chosen to largely ignore that first origin story they had in place for Kane. Instead, he's been given love interests before entering the company, and even held a full driver's license. The whole 'Katie Vick' saga is one the organisation would rather people forgot, but each layer of Kane's story has just continued to make him more and more strange.

3. Papa Shango

In interviews after the fact, Charles Wright has always been pretty laid back about the fact his 'Papa Shango' character didn't work. Others, such as Bret Hart, have stated their belief that the WWF should have done far more with the gimmick. In Hart's mind, Shango had all the tools to become the top heel in the promotion, and he wanted a program opposite him in 1993. That year would be the end of the witch doctor persona for Wright. Soon, he'd go on to debut as an entirely new character in 1995. Known as 'Kama', the man would never return to the shaman nuances of old. That's a shame, because Papa Shango could have been special had the company shown more patience. By 1993 however, the company was ready to try a different direction at the top of the card. Outlandish characters were no longer as welcome, and Vince McMahon favoured smaller, more realistic wrestlers like Shawn Michaels and the aforementioned Bret Hart. Nonetheless, Papa Shango will forever be remembered for his out there angles with the likes of The Ultimate Warrior, during which he used rituals and spells to make Warrior sick.

2. The Undertaker

Even in 2015, there's still something mysterious about The Undertaker. Many have hailed Mark Calaway's alter ego as the greatest gimmick the WWF/WWE have ever come up with. It's hard to argue with that point, given the fact that 'Taker has been around pretty much constantly since debuting in 1990. Much like his storyline brother, Kane, Undertaker's back story has been toyed with greatly. At first, the gimmick was simple. Appearing as an undead zombie of sorts, Undertaker was then controlled by the contents of an urn clutched by his portly manager, Paul Bearer. A rebirth of sorts was experienced for the character in the mid-90's, and Calaway started to show more of his actual wrestling ability as time wore on. Quickening the pace of his matches proved crucial in keeping The Undertaker relevant. Evolving once more into an infernal overlord, Undertaker was the leader of the 'Ministry Of Darkness' in the late-90's. A short sabbatical was followed by a more realistic approach. Becoming the 'American Bad Ass', 'Taker acted more like a normal human being, and fans were even told he had a life outside of wrestling. Nowadays, he's a unique character, one who simply exists as a legend in WWE. Calaway has managed to constantly tweak his character without sacrificing intrigue or mystery, which he deserves a lot of credit for.

1. The Higher Power

Speaking of The Undertaker, he played a huge part in the infamous 'Higher Power' angle of 1999. Joining his 'Ministry Of Darkness' faction with Shane McMahon's 'Corporation', the combined effort became known as 'The Corporate Ministry'. Feuding with Vince McMahon and terrorising the entire promotion, 'Taker started talking about a 'Greater/Higher Power' who was pulling the strings. That's where McMahon entered the scene, revealing himself on an episode of Raw Is War. Previously, Undertaker had strung Steve Austin up on his 'symbol', a segment which received widespread criticism. Many felt the company had pretty much staged a crucifixion on live television. During the skit, the 'Higher Power' - hidden under robes - revealed their face to Austin. Fans wouldn't find out who it was until later, when McMahon infamously shed the robe and revealed himself to be the character. This would lead to yet another feud with Austin, wrestling over control of the WWF. The Undertaker's storyline power was lessened by the revelation, but at least for a while people were genuinely intrigued as to who the 'Higher Power' could be. What other mysterious wrestling characters can you think of? Do you agree with the ones listed here? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!

In this post: 
Papa Shango
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.