10 Most Successful WWE To AEW Transitions
Who have been the greatest WWE straight to AEW success stories?
Cody Rhodes' landscape-changing switch over from the Land of All Elite to the World of Sports Entertainment acted as one of the first real instances of an AEW talent moving over to the biggest wrestling operation on the planet.
Before that, the most common direction saw a disgruntled or suddenly released WWE star quickly decide to give TK's promotion a spin - once their 30 or 90-day non-compete was up, of course. And it's within that very much successful alternative to the sports entertainment giant that many a figure has been given the space to grow into arguably a bigger success than they ever were under Vince McMahon/Triple H's watch.
They all likely got paid the money they're worth to do so, too. Which is always a bonus, eh?
Now sure, not every transition from WWE Superstar to All Elite Wrestler has been entirely smooth and impressive, with the odd unquestionably gifted soul falling victim to the roster being a little over-stuffed in recent times. But there's still been enough commendable WWE to AEW success stories to make whittling this list down to just ten a pretty tall order.
So, for those who didn't quite make the cut - be it due to spending a significant spell away from wrestling in-between moves, not quite excelling as consistently as others, or simply not being in the company long enough to make the same sort of impact as the names to come - never fear; there's still time to break into this particularly Elite top ten later down the line.
10. Brodie Lee
No one ever doubted just how effortlessly talented the towering ball of menace Brodie Lee was throughout his time under the WWE banner.
Whether operating as the unhinged variable of The Wyatt Family, a hugely underrated mid-card champ, or wreaking havoc alongside long-time pal Erik Rowan, the then-Luke Harper often felt like a performer whose potential was never truly realised - and likely never would be - whilst Vince McMahon was calling the shots.
Not even an unfortunately crowd-less All Elite debut in March 2020 after finally leaving WWE in December could keep the now-Mr. Brodie Lee from taking the AEW ball and sprinting with it, though, when finally given his moment to shine as a charismatic singles star.
Mesmerising those watching on at home with his equal parts terrifying and unexpectedly hilarious work when leading the once-doomed Dark Order, the tragically late monster of a performer bulldozed his way to an AEW World Championship war with Jon Moxley and TNT Championship victory over Cody Rhodes.
And it truly felt like AEW had merely scratched the surface when it came to what this all-round legend of a human could have given to his new wrestling home.
9. FTR
The version of the two tag team masters now known as Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler (occasionally) seen on AEW programming is quite simply a world away from the unit who scraped their asses across a canvas during their disastrous time on WWE's main roster.
Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder, after an undoubtedly impressive run on the black and gold brand, were little more than a painful punch-line for many an unfunny Vinnie Mac attempt at a joke from 2017 to 2020. And from the moment the pair asked for their release in January 2019, it felt fairly inevitable that the Top Guys' days in the sports entertainment sphere were numbered.
And for those who questioned whether the one-time Revival could actually hang with The Young Bucks of the world, did Dax and Cash have a treat for you.
While it could be argued that FTR's strongest displays since being allowed the freedom to embrace the old school tag wrasslin' ways they so love have come in the likes of ROH, AAA, and NJPW, it was their initial swift transition back into being a hard-as-nails throwback duo in mid-2020 and time roughing up The Elite, Jurassic Express, and rest of the All Elite roster that most certainly paved the way for an iconic 2022; one that involved many a title being won and a Briscoe Brother series for the ages.
8. Serena Deeb
Away from her brief stint as a member of CM Punk's shaved-head society, Serena Deeb's WWE career mostly consisted of the star helping guide the next generation of talented ladies behind-the scenes.
And while Deeb definitely enjoyed passing her knowledge on to the future of wrestling, the technical wizard still couldn't escape the feeling of having unfinished business in-between the ropes.
A blessing in disguise in the form of a sudden release from WWE in April 2020 soon paved the way for Deeb to finally dust off her wrestling boots for the first time since surprisingly popping up in the inaugural Mae Young Classic in 2017.
For those who hadn't seen that much of the cold, calculating Professor since her aforementioned SES days, Deeb's impressive first few displays on AEW programming from September onwards understandably caught them a little off-guard. But they soon became the merciless norm as the body-twisting one-time NWA Women's Champion went about brilliantly punishing everyone from Thunder Rosa to Hikaru Shida in the years that followed.
And with Deeb also lending her priceless coaching skills to those up-and-coming All Elite stars of tomorrow, it's safe to say that the former Performance Center coach's stock has only increased since parting ways with WWE.
7. 2point0
Despite some corners of the Internet seeing all along that Matt Menard and Angelo Parker had enough charisma to power an entire city, WWE suddenly felt that the one-time Ever-Rise just weren't the sports entertainers they were looking for in June 2021.
Proving they well and truly had what it takes and then some from the minute 2point0 stopped by AEW programming for the first time a few months later, though, the duo absolutely erupted off the screen in their various backstage explosions and in-ring performances opposite the likes of Jon Moxley, Sting, Eddie Kingston, and Darby Allin.
They weren't done there, though.
Not too long after that unexpected delight of an initial spell, the larger-than-life duo fully embraced the heelish sports entertainer schtick alongside Chris Jericho and the rest of his Appreciation Society.
Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ange have not looked back ever since, forcing you to burst into a fit of laughter one moment with their nipple antics and saluting their willingness to put it all on the line inside of Blood & Guts the next.
And with Menard also effectively transitioning into the role of AEW commentator, too, getting cut from the NXT roster was likely the best thing that could've ever happened to these under-appreciated, wise-cracking goofballs.
6. Toni Storm
The New Zealander enjoyed a dominant 230-day reign as the NXT UK Women's Champion, won the second-ever Mae Young Classic, and popped up in the Royal Rumble and a few traditional Survivor Series elimination matches.
Outside of those occasional highlights, though, it's hard to look back on Toni's time in WWE as anything other than a bit of a missed opportunity; especially her dreadful final few pie-faced months on the main roster.
And for a time, it was feeling as though Storm may suffer a similar under-utilised fate on the AEW roster, too, with the 27-year-old still not quite clicking in the way many fans had hoped she would out of the gates.
That all changed the second she got her hands on the Interim, but later undisputed, AEW Women's World Championship, however. When finally given the time to do that wrestling stuff she's bloody best at, Toni's hard-hitting battles against the likes of Britt Baker, Athena, Serena Deeb, and Jamie Hayter helped re-establish the belt as a prize that demanded your attention.
And her newly heelish switch-up, alongside fellow Outcasts Saraya and Ruby Soho, looks like it has all the potential to establish the three former WWE Superstars as truly Elite attractions capable of taking the company's women's division to new heights.
5. Claudio Castagnoli
With the former United States and Raw & SmackDown Tag Team Champion occupying a spot on the WWE roster for a decade or so, many understandably assumed that the Swiss nearly-man would see out the remainder of his in-ring days as a sports entertainer.
But in a move that stunned a great many after a particularly impressive 2021 in-between the ropes, a then-Cesaro opted to call time on his WWE run in late February 2022. And WWE's quiet loss was AEW deafening gain on the night of Forbidden Door a few months on.
Spinning the audience into a frenzy, along with a helpless Zack Sabre Jr., it soon became clear that this wasn't The Bar star folks had witnessed often silently going about his business under Vinnie Mac's watch for 10 years+. Here was a fiery, superhuman force of nature, with bucketloads of charisma and a new lease on in-ring life.
And it wasn't too long before the tough-as-all-hell Blackpool Combat Club member was lifting his first-ever World Championship over in Ring of Honor, arguably becoming more relevant now battering unlucky souls along with Moxley and Yuta than he was when butting heads with the former's Shield buddies.
4. Sting
The fact Sting wasn't afforded the chance to do much of anything at all in WWE on the back of suffering a career-ending injury against Seth Rollins at Night of Champions 2015 set the bar rather low for Tony Khan back in December 2020.
So, with very few honestly expecting much more than the odd on-screen appearance as Darby Allin's manager from The Icon after signing on the dotted line at Winter is Coming, the visual of Stinger actually throwing down and even taking full-on bumps once again was about as surreal as it gets.
And not only that, but the 64-year-old has somehow found a way to once again feel like a genuine special attraction over in The Land of All Elite, with TK masterfully lacing the legendary WCW figure into frequently joyous party matches that deftly keep the veteran from breaking his ageing body in front of a live audience.
Simply put, few ever imagined they'd see a day when this one-time retired mythical figure would crash through tables, no-sell superkick parties, or mimic Orange Cassidy's schtick after his WWE run was cut unfortunately short. But here we are.
Enjoy this wonderful time while it lasts, folks.
3. Christian Cage
Joining long-time pal Edge as a legend who remarkably managed to make a retirement U-turn, after seemingly being forced to hang up his boots for good due to numerous concussions, Christian's comeback at the 2021 Royal Rumble felt like a chance to go out on a WWE high for Captain Charisma.
Only, instead of slotting right back into Vince McMahon's promotion on a more regular basis after that surprising return, the former world champion did something even more shocking.
Feeling Tony Khan's promotion was the right place to both showcase himself and help elevate the next generation, the return of Christian Cage at that year's Revolution eventually set in motion one of the longest-running and most compelling sagas in AEW history.
Going from wise babyface mentor to maniacal, turtle neck a-hole, Cage's relationship with Jungle Boy helped him accomplish both of those aforementioned goals masterfully.
For Christian to not only laugh in the face of retirement, but then go on to forge an All Elite run that highlighted just how much of an under-utilised creative genius the decorated veteran often was throughout his time as an active WWE star proved that it is never too late to bet on yourself, and a new start.
2. Bryan Danielson
Make no mistake, Daniel Bryan accomplished monumental things whilst under WWE contract, lifting World Championship gold in WrestleMania main events, executing some of the finest character work of modern times, and producing clinics time and time again before and after his enforced retirement in 2016.
But even the most sadistic and violent version of Bryan in the sports entertainment sphere couldn't hold a candle to the bloodthirsty American Dragon who has gone about dismantling the All Elite roster since arriving on the scene at All Out 2021.
There have been a few moments of getting lost in the shuffle somewhat, sure. But on the whole, Danielson has evidently relished getting back to his best in the world roots, bludgeoning and taking just about every top-level star on the roster to their absolute limits during his first year-and-a-half as an AEW talent.
Did you ever honestly think there was a chance you'd see the former SmackDown General Manager going for a hellacious hour on two gruelling occasions, even just a few years ago?
Probably not, and the best still feels as though it could be yet to come...
1. Jon Moxley
Jon Moxley and Dean Ambrose are not the same man.
One was seen as little more than a kooky, slapstick nutjob that could be thrown into whatever bizarre scenario WWE dreamed up next. Whereas the other has gone about crafting one of the most believable babyface badasses ever to grace a squared circle. And he's done it all in a deliciously violent way, with a ton of unfiltered heart, and without so much as a whiff of inauthentic "lunacy."
Double or Nothing 2019 marked the rebirth of not only Jon Moxley the character, but Jon Moxley the human being who bloody loves this thing called wrasslin'. And despite the Elite company being one that was forged before his arrival, you will find very few who would argue against The Purveyor of Violence being the undisputed heart and soul of AEW.
Rising to the challenge whenever Tony Khan needs someone to carry his sometimes volatile promotion on their back, the multiple-time AEW World Champion justifiably sits as one of the greatest and most diverse currently doing it today; a far cry from the bloke who spent his latter WWE days wearing a gas mask and rallying against germs.