10 Most Under-Rated Wrestlers 2015

These guys and girls have so much more to offer...

Being an unsung hero can be a difficult path. Scott 'Razor Ramon' Hall has said on numerous occasions - most recently to Steve Austin on his podcast - that there's a fine line between being called a "good hand" and getting a push. In other words, there are wrestlers who are completely unselfish, and don't mind bumping around for their peers. Unfortunately, this keeps them in lower positions, because they're viewed as easy to work with. They're awesome at making others look good, more so than themselves. Some of the performers featured on this list fit into that bracket. It's true that not everybody can be a main event star, but these men and women deserved the chance to show what they can do a bit more throughout 2015. This article explores in-depth those from both WWE and TNA who could accurately be deemed under-rated. The reasons for this are in plentiful supply, but they usually boil down to the way they are viewed by those behind the scenes who are very much in charge. On the other hand, perhaps each performer possesses a flaw which has hampered their year overall. There is a fine line between being dubbed solid and becoming a featured star, but there's also a fine margin between holding someone back and giving them ample opportunity to showcase their skills.

10. Titus O'Neil

At 38 years old, it's logical to imagine that Titus O'Neil will never be a top name in WWE. Age is very much against the chances of him receiving a sustained push, but he's better than company management seems to believe. Earlier in 2015, O'Neil reunited with Darren Young. Together, the team are known as The Prime Time Players, and they are very much bit-part players in the tag-team scene. That last sentence seems to sum up how Titus is viewed in WWE, he's a mid-card attraction. Even though it's fair to assume he won't reach any higher than this, that doesn't mean he's not under-rated. At several points throughout his WWE career, O'Neil has shown how accomplished he is on the microphone. He's entertaining, and has a good rapport with fans. In 2016, that's something which deserves to be highlighted more by WWE than it is. It's fine to keep the man in a tag-team with Young, but the duo have the potential to produce consistently good matches when called upon. They should be a positive to the tandem ranks, rather than just making up the numbers.

9. Damien Sandow

Poor Damien Sandow, he's been shut out in the cold for much of 2015. It's somewhat crazy to think that Sandow previously held the 'Money In The Bank' briefcase in his possession. His descent down the roster can be directly traced back to when he cashed in against John Cena and lost in 2013. From that moment on, he's been an also-ran in WWE. In 2015, Sandow has teamed with both The Miz and Curtis Axel. His previous 'Intellectual Saviour' gimmick was canned for both of these units. With The Miz, he played a stuntman-style impersonator, renaming himself 'Damien Mizdow'. The character was played for laughs, and surely worked, but it was a lower-card comedy attraction. The very same could be said of his alliance with Axel, and the 'Macho Mandow' persona he subsequently played. Since, Sandow has returned to his old gimmick, but with a twist. Now a babyface, he hasn't really been featured much on WWE television. This is a shame, because he's an excellent talker and fans find him entertaining. It seems that officials behind the curtain don't share the same critical appraisal of the man, he's very much on the WWE fringes.

8. Kalisto

WWE have been searching for a Mexican-American sensation who can attract in a predominant portion of the Latin audience. For that very reason, Alberto Del Rio was brought back into the fold. Previously, the company had really tried to make Sin Cara a success story, but the character has only started to be of value since the original man underneath the mask (Mistico) left. The new (and very much improved) Sin Cara - played by the artist formerly known as Hunico - teams with Kalisto. Collectively, they are known as The Lucha Dragons. High-flying is their style, and it works. Most recently, they were arguably the crown jewel of a Triple Threat Ladder Match at TLC, also involving The Usos and The New Day. That should be a launching pad for their careers, especially Kalisto. Since the departure of Rey Mysterio, WWE have been searching for someone to replace him. Kalisto could be just the ticket, his in-ring work is fluid and exciting. Despite this, reports raged earlier in 2015 that Vince McMahon wasn't exactly high on the team. That's tragic, because the diminutive masked man could be a real asset to WWE if used correctly.

7. Emma

Having been around the WWE system since 2011, there's an argument to be made that Emma really should have cracked the main roster by now. In 2014, she was featured on Monday Night Raw and Smackdown, but her role was hardly too thrilling. Aligned with Santino Marella, she even started using a variation of the 'Cobra Strike' favoured by her partner. Portrayed as a happy-go-lucky kind of Diva, the character was paper thin. It's only since returning back down to NXT that Emma has been able to really hone her skills. In short, the Emma who faced Asuka at the recent NXT TakeOver: London event is a million miles away from the bleach-blonde, hyper female who wrestled short bouts against the likes of Alicia Fox and Summer Rae in 2014. It's very much an improvement. In just one performance against the Japanese star, Emma proved that she's ready for another crack at the main roster. Her matches against Bayley punctuated a rather well-received rivalry, and she's been able to plug the gap left by the likes of Sasha Banks and Charlotte in NXT. Surely in 2016, Emma will get a second chance to make a first impression.

6. Rockstar Spud

On the surface, Rockstar Spud isn't the kind of professional wrestler that WWE would typically pay attention to. At around 5ft 4 inches tall, he's one of the smallest male wrestlers currently plying his trade in North America. The British native has earned rave reviews for his larger-than-life personality and ability on the microphone however, something which came to the fore in 2015. Breaking out of his twee heel character, Spud turned babyface due to his feud against Ethan Carter III. The story was a slow burner, but led to a super-heated 'Hair vs. Hair' match in March. Even though Spud came out on the losing end, he had shown he could carry a top-line rivalry. TNA can feel like an empty void in terms of fan reaction these days, but Spud helped (briefly) change that. That deserves a lot of praise, because the general feeling surrounding the company is not good. In a fair world, Spud would be given the chance to show what he can do in NXT. He's physically small, there's no getting past that, but his tenacity and wrestling skill is more notable than his lack of size. If anything, Spud showed that fans are still willing to rally behind babyface underdogs in 2015.

5. Xavier Woods

As a current WWE Tag-Team Champion, it may seem a little strange to claim that Xavier Woods is under-rated. That said, it comes across loud and clear that 2015 has been a slow process for the man. Alongside Kofi Kingston and Big E, Woods - as part of The New Day - has been able to prove to management just how good he is. Initially, it seemed like the company were only interested in pairing Kingston and Big E as a team. On the outskirts, Woods filled the tag-along role, but his performances from ringside were so entertaining that WWE couldn't fail to take notice. When called upon, he has also been wildly entertaining on commentary, his verbal skills seem like something his employers didn't really know he had in such abundance. Unfortunately, Woods hasn't really been handed too many opportunities to show what he can do as a wrestler. That's a shame, because when he has been featured, his matches have been extremely well done. Traditionally, someone like Xavier would be ideal for the Cruiserweight division, but that doesn't exist in WWE any longer. Therefore, he deserves the chance to prove himself in the Intercontinental or United States divisions.

4. Neville

A lot of pro wrestling fans slapped their foreheads when it was revealed that the ever-exciting PAC would be called Adrian Neville in WWE. Assigned to NXT, the high-flying Englishman defied his rather rubbish moniker, turning in excellent performances on a consistent basis. So impressed were company officials that they promoted the man to the main roster in March, 2015. Since that moment, Neville has stalled a little. Aside from a few brief exchanges, he hasn't really been given anything to sink his teeth into on Raw or Smackdown. He's obviously considered a wonderful in-ring performer, but that appears to be all WWE management think of him at this moment. 2016 provides the chance to change that fact, because the guy could do a lot more. A lack of actual storylines has been something that's hurt Neville this year. Aside from being impressed by his flashy move set, fans haven't really been given much of a reason to care about his appearances. Right now, Neville exists in the same space Evan Bourne did a few years before him. WWE should rectify that, and at least give the man something more substantial to work with.

3. Luke Harper

Since debuting the man in August, WWE have put all their chips behind the idea of pushing Braun Strowman as a potential star. He's the newest member of The Wyatt Family, but he doesn't qualify as under-rated. That slot would have to go to Luke Harper, arguably the best in-ring worker (along with Bray Wyatt) in the entire group. Harper is 36 years old, but he has only just been able to show what he can do in the biggest wrestling promotion around. It's true that he was given a short run as WWE Intercontinental Champion in late-2014, but that was transitional. Singles championships don't really seem to be in his future with the company, and Harper is very much an under-rated piece of talent. For a big man, he can shift his weight around the ring in fine fashion. Chris Jericho noted on his podcast that Harper is one of the more popular names in the WWE locker room amongst his peers. Other wrestlers see the guy as easy to work with, which often leads to him being the fall guy during matches involving The Wyatts. Harper has his role, one he seems happy with, but he holds a unique look and the potential to do more.

2. 'King' Barrett

Traditionally, the 'King Of The Ring' title was supposed to elevate wrestlers beyond their current standing. The exact opposite happened with Wade Barrett in 2015, the 'King' moniker turned him into a comedy act with absolutely zero upward mobility. Even now, as part of the League Of Nations, he's treated as one of the weak links of the group. For someone WWE viewed as having endless headline potential years ago, that's a crying shame. During the first season of NXT in 2010, Barrett was the man hand-picked by officials as the one who had the best chance of making it. 2015 has not reflected that at all, the Englishman has struggled to be anything other than a waste of air time. Crucially, that's not his fault. Barrett is very well-spoken, his voice lends itself well to WWE's style of promos. Between the ropes, he's also an excellent brawler. This should add together to make him easy to push, but WWE somehow find that difficult to do. Instead of being mired in a rotten gimmick, Barrett should have been presented in a manner befitting him. He has so much more to offer WWE, but they seem to overlook that in favour of keeping him low down on the pecking order.

1. Cesaro

Currently, Cesaro is on the sidelines nursing a torn rotator cuff. The shoulder injury may force him to miss WrestleMania, and the big pay day which comes with it. That's saddening, because if anyone on the WWE roster deserves to be on a show with the word 'wrestle' in the title, it's the 'Swiss Superman'. Inside the ring, Cesaro is a pro wrestling machine. He's the very definition of someone WWE are not sure what to do with. That came across loud and clear when Vince McMahon effectively said Cesaro was lacking several key components on his road to becoming a top star. Those words on Steve Austin's WWE Network podcast show shocked many involved in the industry. There's a chance that WWE may never fully feature Cesaro the way he deserves to be. Even when he tore the house down against John Cena during a Monday Night Raw bout in July, there was a sense afterwards that solid in-ring performances are all the European star is good for. Fans disagree, Cesaro could be something special if he's harnessed correctly by WWE. What other wrestlers would you say have been under-rated in 2015? Do you agree with the ones listed here? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!

In this post: 
Neville
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.