10 Reasons Why RAW Is Quickly Becoming WWE's B-Show

What's SmackDown doing that might allow them to usurp RAW?

Roman Reigns WWE Raw Fan Sign
WWE.com

Since January 1993, Monday Night RAW has served as WWE's flagship television show.

RAW became required viewing before long, supplanting Superstars and Wrestling Challenge as the company's premier program. When SmackDown debuted in 1999, it was treated much like RAW at first, but after a few years, it became clear that RAW was still WWE’s golden child. In 2017, however, RAW may now be the incumbent fending off opposition, much like Superstars in the early 90s.

Last July, WWE implemented its second-ever brand extension in which with half the roster was made exclusive to RAW and the other half, SmackDown. This coincided with SmackDown moving to Tuesday nights (on the USA Network) and finally airing live.

Months that followed saw SmackDown ratings improve while RAW’s steadily declined. The combination, along with other reasons, has left RAW struggling to maintain its position as WWE's A-show.

Of course there’s a long way to go until Vince McMahon and other senior WWE leaders admit to that, but for now, let’s take a closer look at how SmackDown could be slowly usurping RAW as WWE's premier program…

10. Vince McMahon's Fingerprints Aren't As Obvious On SmackDown

WWE Raw Vince McMahon
WWE.com

As the flagship show for decades, Monday Night RAW remains the primary focus of WWE CEO Vince McMahon which, in 2017, actually benefits SmackDown. McMahon remains the final editor on all things WWE, but recently Brian James (Road Dogg) has reportedly been tasked with heading up SmackDown while VKM focuses on RAW.

At least for the first six months following WWE's 2016 brand split, SmackDown had a much different feel to it, especially in comparison to RAW. It wasn't WCW-to-WWF different, but given the parity that had existed throughout all WWE programming since its purchase of WCW in 2001, the change was noticeable. And welcome.

While the novelty of SmackDown Live! may have worn off in recent months, the show did a nice job in separating itself, again at least initially, from the negative connotations RAW had acquired in recent years. This is to say the Tuesday night show didn't feel like it was covered in Vince McMahon's fingerprints.

Thirty years ago, that would've been a problem, but at nearly 72 years old, McMahon's ability to connect with the audience is seriously lacking.


9. Talking Smack Adds Considerable Value

Shane McMahon AJ Styles Talking Smack
WWE

SmackDown Live's post-show has been a major asset in terms of boosting the blue brand.

The combination of Renee Young and Daniel Bryan, as well as the unscripted, off-the-cuff promos conducted by the various talents has given SmackDown Live a leg up on RAW. The Tuesday night post-show provides a fresh opportunity for blue-branded talents to craft their own words and even their own backstories.

This type of creative freedom, once a staple to WWF programming, has been relatively nonexistent in modern-day WWE. With the promotion wanting to keep everything so homogenized and uniform, including verbiage on promos, the quality has suffered and many of the so-called superstars fail to get over. Talking Smack has returned a little bit of that freedom, and has given at least some of the responsibility back to the talents.

Although RAW produces an answer to Talking Smack known as RAW Talk, a lack of consistent scheduling - as well as an inability to match the Young/Bryan on-screen chemistry - makes RAW's post-show pale in comparison to SmackDown's.


8. SmackDown Live Pay-Per-Views Have Been Better

WWE TLC 2016 AJ Styles Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

Looking back at the SmackDown produced WWE Network events since last July's brand split, and the following highlights come to mind: AJ Styles and Bray Wyatt winning their first WWE Championships; Dolph Ziggler's potential career-ending match against The Miz; Heath Slater & Rhyno winning SmackDown's Tag Team Championships; Randy Orton joining the Wyatt Family and winning the tag team titles; the return of Elimination Chamber; Naomi winning the SmackDown Women's Championship twice - and, of course, Jinder Mahal becoming WWE Champion.

Compare those developments to the RAW events from the same time period. Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins engaged in a tiresome feud that lacked any type of conclusion, Charlotte and Sasha Banks traded wins (and RAW Championships) like it was a hot potato that nobody wanted. Roman Reigns continued to be front and center, Sheamus and Cesaro formed a tag team, and Goldberg won the Universal Championship in 23 seconds.

Judging by the Pay-Per-View developments alone, SmackDown has produced the more compelling and entertaining product. This isn't to say RAW has lacked any interesting developments, but when compared to the talents and freshness of the blue brand, RAW has been left in the dust.


7. How Many New Stars Has SmackDown Created?

Shane McMahon SmackDown
WWE.com

Part of producing compelling professional wrestling television is the introduction, and promotion, of new and interesting characters. While RAW has done a solid job in building up Braun Strowman, SmackDown's elevated numerous talents in many different divisions. RAW has been unable to hold a candle to SmackDown's character development.

AJ Styles, Jinder Mahal, Naomi, Alexa Bliss, Becky Lynch, The Miz & Maryse, Baron Corbin, Tyler Breeze, Fandango, Heath Slater. These are just a few of the names that have won championships or were made into bigger stars than they were prior to the brand split and their days wrestling on RAW (if they got any Monday night TV time, that is).

When it comes to creating new stars, SmackDown knows no limits. The Women's division, the tag team division, the main event, and the Intercontinental (now United States Championship) scenes have all featured numerous, new superstars competing for (and winning) the titles.

This has made for a fresh-feeling show when compared to the same old stars featured in the same boring segments every Monday night.


6. How Many New Stars Has RAW Created?

braun strowman
WWE.com

On RAW, which new stars have been created since last July's brand split, besides Braun Strowman? Incidentally, who are the "same old stars" that have continued to hold onto RAW's top spots for the past several years?

Roman Reigns, Brock Lesnar, Seth Rollins. Triple H. Stephanie McMahon.

Monday nights have revolved around these superstars for as long back as can be remembered. Sure, there have been some new faces sprinkled in at times, like Kevin Owens, Finn Bálor, or Goldberg, but whether it was due to bad luck (read: injuries) or Creative's decision to return to the status quo, the aforementioned RAW staples always regain the focal point.

This isn't to say that main event staying power is a bad thing; quite the contrary. The top of the card shouldn't be a turnstile for all wrestlers to come and go as they please, but a little variety, along with some in-depth character development spreading beyond the Golden Children of WWE, would go a long way towards improving the RAW ratings.

As it is, RAW's perception will continue to weaken especially as it pertains to developing new stars.


5. The Women's Division

Women S Tag SS
WWE.com

Since Alexa Bliss and Bayley replaced Charlotte Flair and Sasha Banks as the female focal points of Monday Night RAW, it's easy to forget just how limited Monday night's women's division was just a few months ago.

Prior to April's Superstar Shake-Up, RAW's women's division was in desperate need of a makeover. Since Battleground in July 2015, Charlotte Flair was featured in every premier RAW Pay-Per-View women's match until she switched brands in April 2017. That's 21 straight RAW events that involved The Queen while The Boss appeared in 10. Throw in Bayley's seven since her main roster debut last July, and that's not much variety for the red brand.

On the other hand, SmackDown has done a great job rotating female talents in and out of the title picture. Becky Lynch was crowned SmackDown Women's Champion before Alexa Bliss and Naomi each had their turns. In addition, the division also had meaningful contributions from Nikki Bella, Natalya, Carmella, a returning Mickie James, plus several other females.

While both brands have improved on past presentations of the female WWE superstars, SmackDown has clearly established itself as the more balanced show.


4. 3 Hours Is Too Long For A Weekly Wrestling Show

WWE Raw Samoa Joe Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Fans don't have to dig too deep into the product to find the next reason why RAW is slowly becoming the company's B-show: the three-hour runtime.

Ironically, the shift from 2 to 3 hours was always part of WWE's narrative as a major factor in the demise of rival WCW. It was seen as over-saturating an already overexposed product yet WCW forged ahead with a three-hour Nitro just as WWE has done with RAW since 2012.

To many wrestling fans, three hours is just too long to watch every Monday night. If the show (and Creative) was firing on all cylinders, it would be a lot more tolerable if not still long, but given the current direction of the flagship program, sitting through three hours of RAW has become a chore for even the most passionate fans.

SmackDown benefits from remaining at two hours, the industry standard since around 1997. The Tuesday night program moves along more rapidly, contains less filler, and generally flows a lot more smoothly than the slow, plodding 180+ minutes of Monday Night RAW.


3. RAW Has Dropped The Ball On Returning Talents

Miz Ambrose Extreme Rules
WWE.com

Thanks to April's Superstar Shake-Up, several former SmackDown-exclusive superstars were moved over to RAW and vice-versa. While SmackDown's done a decent job with their post-WrestleMania 33 acquisitions, RAW has struggled mightily with the talents the red brand recently acquired.

The most egregious examples of talents that have seemingly regressed since making the move back to RAW are The Miz and Dean Ambrose. The Miz, and real-life wife Maryse, experienced a career resurgence in 2016 thanks to incredible mic work on both SmackDown Live and Talking Smack, and was involved in a feature match at WrestleMania against John Cena & Nikki Bella. For Ambrose, he was the #1 draft pick of SmackDown Live last July and joined the blue brand as WWE World Heavyweight Champion.

Their careers have taken a big step backwards since switching back to RAW. Neither man has been presented as anywhere near the level of stardom they experienced on SmackDown as former WWE Champions.

Meanwhile, SmackDown's taken their new recruits of Jinder Mahal, Charlotte Flair, and Kevin Owens and have made them the focal points of Tuesday nights.


2. SmackDown Provides Legit Opportunity

Breezango SmackDown
WWE.com

Shane McMahon has nicknamed the Tuesday night brand "The Land of Opportunity," and it seems to be a very appropriate title.

In under a year, SmackDown has promoted countless superstars that would not have had the same opportunity on RAW. This has allowed for a much fresher product on Tuesday nights and, by comparison, has made RAW appear extremely stale.

There doesn't seem to be many limits on the talents SmackDown is willing to take a chance on. Jinder Mahal is arguably the best example, but it's not restricted to the main event. Up and down the card, talents are getting more opportunities to show what they can do on the blue brand. The number of fresh faces that have become SmackDown regulars, and entertaining components of the show, really blows RAW out of the water.

Although SmackDown's been in a slump in recent weeks, it still feels like the fresher show. If Brian James and Ryan Ward can recapture some of the success it had during the months that immediately followed the brand split, RAW constantly looking into its rear-view, trying to avoid becoming WWE's unenviable B-show, could become the new norm.


1. RAW's Reputation Has Changed

titus kalisto
WWE.com

This next entry would've been almost unimaginable just a couple years back.

Monday Night RAW is no longer perceived as this important and exciting wrestling show where major developments happen every week. Once upon a time, RAW was can't miss episodic television - and if you did miss it, you missed major storyline progression!

Nowadays, RAW's reputation is very different.

Even after the historic Monday Night War ratings settled down to around three-four million viewers each week, RAW still had the feeling of being an important show. Today, however, fans can go months without watching an episode and miss very little, if anything, that can be considered exciting and episodic television - much less entertaining.

It could be due to the growing importance of the WWE Network and the Special Events/PPVs that take place every 2 weeks. It could also be due to SmackDown's move to the USA Network in early 2016. It could also be as simple as poor creative finally catching up to them.

Regardless of the reason(s), RAW's reputation has gone from required viewing for professional wrestling fans to a forgettable, tedious three-hour weekly epic that can't stop a haemorrhaging viewers.


In this post: 
Roman Reigns
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.