10 Stupidest Decisions By WWE In 2003

The year where Triple H and The McMahon's egos ran wildest?

Has WWE ever had a roster as stacked as it did in 2003? They had Hogan, Austin, Rock, Triple H, Scott Steiner, Goldberg, Angle, The Undertaker, Lesnar, Kane, Michaels...and that's just the 'top' guys! Down below you had the Benoits, Guerreros, Van Dams, Ortons and Mysterios of the world, who were all tearing it up on a weekly basis. You don't really know what you've got until it's gone, huh? If the WWE roster of today had but half of that mix of genuine star power and in-ring prowess, it's unlikely that fans would continue to tune out in droves (as they are doing now). Although, saying that, WWE's ratings, live attendance and PPV buyrates did slip from 2002 in 2003 and it was clear that WWE was on a downturn (despite being financially healthy and extremely profitable). So what gives? Why were fans moving on when the roster was as good as it was? Well, all the talent and star power in the world won't make up for crappy creative, which is exactly what happened in 03. WWE had all the tools at their disposal but they couldn't put the pieces together, leading to haphazard and short-sighted booking decisions that inevitably left a sour taste in the mouths of fans. As well as creative misfires, WWE also made other costly decisions (personal, business and otherwise) during that year. Here are ten of the stupidest.

10. Having Scott Steiner Wrestle 18 Minutes At The Royal Rumble

Look at that face right there. That is the face of a (very veiny and very muscular) man watching his short WWE career flash before his eyes. That was Scott Steiner after wrestling a pretty damn awful eighteen-minute match with Triple H at the Royal Rumble. Okay, so the match sucked and both guys deserve to take some measure of the blame. But whose idea was it to book Steiner in a match of that length in the first place? Eighteen minutes isn't exactly an Iron Man match or anything, but Steiner had only wrestled a few times since leaving WCW almost two years previously and was clearly not in decent ring shape. Now it could be argued that Steiner, whom WWE forked out big money for, should have been able to do a twenty minute match no questions asked. But this wasn't the same Steiner who had regularly wowed audiences in WCW and Japan. This was a Scott Steiner with a laundry list of injuries and about thirty extra pounds of muscle on his knackered frame. WWE knew this when they hired him. Then there was Triple H, whose performances had been getting gradually worse throughout 2002 (save for that belter with HBK at SummerSlam) and who was frequently on the injured list himself (too many 'vitamins' I think). He was in no position to carry Steiner to a decent match, regardless of whether he thought he was the modern-day Ric Flair or not. WWE really screwed Steiner by putting him out there for that long so early in his WWE run. He should have been booked to work a 10-15 minute brawl, tops. To add insult to injury, Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle went out right after them and contested an absolute barnburner, for which Benoit was given a standing ovation afterwards. Ouch.

9. Brock Lesnar's Shooting Star Press

It's not surprising that WWE wanted Brock Lesnar to perform a shooting star press on WWE TV. After all, he'd done the move numerous times in OVW and in dark matches, hitting it perfectly on ever occasion. What better place to debut the move to the masses than in the main event of WrestleMania? It was supposed to be a 'WrestleMania moment' but it turned into a nightmare for Brock and WWE. Lesnar was convinced to do the move by John Laurinaitis, despite the fact he didn't really feel comfortable doing it and hadn't used the move regularly for over a year. The Next Big Thing completed practiced the move a couple of times before the show and everything seemed OK. He told Johnny Ace and WWE officials that he'd see how he felt when he was out there. Brock must have been feeling confident (or pressured) because he did attempt the move. Regrettably, his attempt was not successful. Brock nosedived, missing Angle by a good few inches and crashing down on his face, head and neck. It was a scary moment and Brock was really lucky that the effects weren't more serious. He escaped with minor injuries and a concussion but he could have ended up in a wheelchair. Lesnar was too tired to do the move after such a long match, he was sweaty and Angle was really far away from the turnbuckle. All of those factors, coupled with big match nerves, combined to ensure that Lesnar didn't hit his target. But it's not really his fault, since he didn't want to do the move anyway and only tried it because certain people backstage pressured him into it.

8. Mr. America

After Hulk Hogan beat Vince McMahon at WrestleMania XIX, in a match billed as '20 Years in the Making', the WWE chairman had to gain a measure of revenge. So he made the Hulkster sit out the rest of his contract at home! He would still be paid but he wouldn't have to actually wrestle anybody for it! Vince McMahon, you son of a b****. Of course the worst thing you can do to Hulk Hogan is tell him he can't appear in front of the cameras, so Hogan devised a genius way to get back in the limelight. He put on a mask and called himself Mr. America. It was one of those clever lawyery loophole tricks that only guys like Hogan are smart enough to pull off. And so the feud continued, only this time with added Sable, Sean O'Haire, Roddy Piper, Stephanie McMahon and Zach Gowen. Awesome! The whole thing was a giant, unfunny misfire and a serious misuse of Hogan, who could have popped a buyate or two as a red and yellow 'special attraction'. Unhappy with his position on the card (along with what he considered low PPV payoffs) Hogan quit the company before the storyline could be resolved. He wouldn't work for WWE again until WrestleMania 21 weekend, where he was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame. Inducted as Hulk Hogan. NOT as Mr. America.

7. Wasting Hell In A Cell

It's seems rather trite to talk about WWE 'wasting' the Hell in a Cell gimmick, considering the company now presents a PPV that features at least two Cell matches in one night. This booking is, undoubtedly, diluting the concept and making it harder for fans to get excited about it (unless it features two genuine legends like Undertaker and Brock Lesnar). 2003 only featured one Hell in a Cell match, the main event of the awful Bad Blood 2003 PPV. Triple H, who was nowhere near his best, and a practically immobile Kevin Nash fought inside The Devil's Playground for 20 uninspiring minutes in which guest referee Mick Foley did most of the heavy bumping while they took every shortcut possible. Not the worst Cell match ever, but horribly uninspiring stuff nonetheless. WWE's decision to have Kevin Nash compete for the title in the first place was a strange one, considering he was totally injury-prone, not really over and WWE had a whole crop of hungry and talented guys who could fill that spot. The likes of Booker T, Rob Van Dam and Kane could have...oh wait, sorry, no they couldn't, because Triple H had already done a job on them in the previous year (when he really oughta have been doing the job for them). The treatment of Booker in the run-up to and at WrestleMania XIX, in particular, was shameful.

6. Unmasking Kane

Okay, so after all these years of mistreatment and bad booking, it would appear as though the Kane character is bulletproof. I mean, here we are in 2015 and he's still in the WWE Title picture, headlining pay-per-views with the top stars of today. It's astonishing that Glenn Jacobs is still going strong and even more astonishing that Kane is still effective. Although the character has had to endure some very corny booking over the years (Katie Vick, May 19th etc.), one of the biggest gambles the WWE creative team took was actually taking the iconic mask off of the Big Red Machine. Kane was very over as a babyface, but WWE wanted to turn him into a monster heel and decided that an unmasking was the way to make him snap and turn to the darkside once more. In the main event of the June 23rd 2003 Raw, Triple H defeated Kane in a World Heavyweight Title vs. Kane's mask match, marking the first time the demon had properly removed his hood. Fans were expecting some sort of burned monster like something out of an eighties horror film but what they got was... Well, what they got was a bloke with a truly bizarre haircut and smudged mascara. What a letdown that was. WWE should have never taken the mask off of Kane unless it had some truly special FX lined-up to validate his backstory. They especially shouldn't have done it on some throwaway episode of Raw that nobody remembered a month later.

5. 'Stone Cold' Shane McMahon

People are quick to point to the egos of Vince and Stephanie McMahon, what with their insistence insistence on being on TV and the way they're booked to look oh so very strong, but they often forget about Shane. Shane McMahon, the man who was booked stronger than Stone Cold Steve Austin in the summer/autumn of 2003. Shane hadn't been on WWE TV in almost two years, deciding to focus on his office job after the whole Invasion thing and was written out of storylines. When the recently-unmasked Kane Tombstoned his mother Linda, however, Shane O'Mac couldn't exactly just sit behind his desk in Stamford, could he? Well, I wish he would have, because it would have spared us some sub-Friday the 13th style WWE TV (Kane was Jason and Shane was some nimble Final Girl, I guess). 'Super Shane' was a farce. Kane should have been feuding with credible top level talent, not some spoiled rich kid whose favourite pastimes included hanging out with the Mean Street Posse and jumping off really high things. Credit to Shane, because as usual he did take some punishment (and even worked house shows for a little bit), but the way he was booked as an indestructible, never-say-die hard man would have made John Cena blush. Kane and Shane finally settled their dispute in an Ambulance Match at Survivor Series, a good three months after the feud began. And a good two after everyone stopped caring.

4. Goldberg Loses To Triple H Inside The Elimination Chamber

While Shane 'Baddest Man on the Planet' McMahon was not only surviving Kane's horror film style attacks but actually coming back stronger the next week, genuine hardcase Goldberg seemed to be constantly getting outsmarted and/or beaten up by Triple H and Evolution. It was obvious that WWE didn't know what to do with Goldberg. In his first match in the company he was pitted against The Rock in a competitive match when, really he should have just exploded onto the scene and ran through some midcarder in a matter of minutes. But no, he was booked to sell, show weakness and be outsmarted by the good guys. Because WWE like paying a performer millions of dollars and then misusing them. Because that's how you draw money. Incredibly, Linda McMahon publicly branded Goldberg a 'disappointment' during a press conference, after Da Man had agreed to work more dates than his contract originally specified. Astonishing. Anyway, after months of frustration and poor creative, Goldberg finally got a chance to look like Goldberg, in the Elimination Chamber main event of SummerSlam 2003. Entering at No.5, big Bill speared and pinned Randy Orton, Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho. Busting out some impressive power moves and looking full of fire, the fans went wild for him. It was down to Goldberg and The Game. What should have happened was Goldberg beating Triple H to a pulp, kicking out of a pedigree and then beating him with a spear/jackhammer combo. What actually happened was Triple H blasting Goldberg with a sledgehammer and beating him in an awfully anti-climactic finish. Trips wasn't able to wrestle due to a groin injury, giving WWE a reason to book the finish they did and prolong the feud. It was a terrible decision, one that p***ed off the fans and made Triple H look even less of a worthy champ to boot. The post-match beatdown of Goldberg was the icing on top of a very crap cake.

3. Jobbing Out Brock Lesnar

While a lot of us would probably like to see Brock wrestling (or at least appearing) on Raw on a weekly basis, one look at the way WWE handled his burgeoning career in 2003 suggests that we shouldn't be so quick to wish for that. Granted, the Brock of 2015 is very different to the 2003 model, but if WWE booked Lesnar to do half as many televised jobs in 2015 as they had him do in 2003, he'd be stripped of pretty much all of his drawing power. Brock did several high-profile jobs in 2003, especially when he turned heel in the summer. Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle, The Undertaker, you name them, Lesnar either tapped out or stared at the lights for them. It was nonsensical and made Brock look a lot weaker than he should have, even if he did get his fair share of wins, too. A star the calibre of Lesnar shouldn't have been cleanly tapping to Chris Benoit on PPV. It just didn't make sense, especially since it was only done to set up a Smackdown title match, not a PPV showdown. Then there was Brock's Miami, Florida house show loss to The Rock which, while it was only witnessed by those in attendance (no cell phone cameras back then!), it really subbed Lesnar the wrong way, since he was gearing up for a WrestleMania main event with Kurt Angle and felt he should have been protected. Lesnar wasn't a mark for the business and didn't really care if he won or lost, as long as he got paid, but he still knew his value as a performer and draw and was smart enough to realise that his value was diminishing with the way he was being booked, which is what partially led to him leaving the company in April 2004.

2. The Big Show - Worst US Champion Ever?

Eddie Guerrero was the perfect choice for WWE's first United States Champion after they decided to bring the belt back in the summer of 03. He was entertaining, he was over and he was wrestling the matches of his life. Basically, he was the total package, and it was a joy watching him tear it up with Chris Benoit, Rhyno, Tajiri, Matt Hardy and others on a weekly basis. His successor, Big Show, was a man whose waistline was increasing at about the same rate that his talent was decreasing. He was a slow-moving, tired act who despite consistent main event feuds over the course of the year, still wasn't close to the level WWE had hoped he would be at. Maybe that's why WWE felt the need to put the US Title on him. Who knows? What I do know is that Big Show was a flop as champ, defending the belt on TV a grand total of two times before dropping it to John Cena at WrestleMania XX. It was a meaningless prop to Show, whereas Eddie actually made the title mean something. Okay, so perhaps Show wasn't as bad a champion as someone like Orlando Jordan, but he was a pretty damn useless one. It was a stupid decision on WWE's part to give him the belt, that much is true.

1. Vince Verus Stephanie

If ever there was an image that just screamed 'sports entertainment'... I'm not above giving credit when it's due and there is no doubt that the McMahons, especially Vince and Steph, have been involved in some truly terrific WWE moments. Too many to name, really. The McMahons just get the business and routinely above and beyond to entertain their audience, which should be commended. What should not be commended, however, is their insistence on being heavily featured in storylines. The McMahons are good in small doses, but when they start taking up too muchTV time (instead of pushing, you know, actual wrestlers) it becomes rather irksome. The whole McMahon family feud was terribly played-out by the time October 2003 rolled around, but that didn't stop WWE from going to the well once more. WWE actually booked Vince versus Stephanie in a Father versus Daughter I Quit match (although Vince changed the rules so Steph could win via pin or submission). Linda and Sable were also involved in a match that saw Vince choking out his only daughter with a lead pipe. Incredibly, the fans in attendance went mental for pretty much everything daddy and daughter did, even if the action was at times incredibly uncomfortable. Smackdown had a very talented roster in the fall of 2003, but many of them didn't make it on the show for this. As for the stipulation that if Stephanie lost she'd be fired from WWE? Give me a break...

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...