10 Stupidest Decisions By WWE In 2005

Another year, another host of idiotic calls from the standard-bearers of the pro-wrestling world.

Look at the above picture. It shows Muhammad Hassan and Stone Cold Steve Austin facing off with one another. Hassan was a red-hot heel with a controversial gimmick, a rookie very much on the rise, while Austin was WWE's biggest ever star and still incredibly damn over with the fan base. It was a big moment that WWE booked to go down live on Raw. Before the year was out, both men would be gone for the company. What led to their departures, you ask? Just yet more stupid decisions courtesy of everyone's favourite sports entertainment monolith. The fact that WWE could let a potential future World champion and a sure-fire Hall of Famer leave within the space of six months just demonstrates how erratic the company was in 2005 and highlights but a couple of seriously stupid decisions. Sure, WWE got a lot right that year - the meteoric rise of Batista, the concurrent rise of John Cena, the introduction of the Juniors Division (okay, so maybe not that one). But for every home run, WWE seemed to strike out at least twice. Erratic booking, public displays of spite, counter-productive talent burials - yup, WWE had a lot to answer for in 2005. So, where did they go so wrong? Observe...


10. Firing Matt Hardy After Lita/Edge Affair (And Then Burying Him When They Brought Him Back)

You're on the bench with a serious knee injury. You discover that your long-term girlfriend and love of your life is having a secret affair with a man you thought was a close friend. Your fired from your job, while injured, because you made the story public. You're brought back to feud with the man who ruined your dreams, a feud that you lose. You're then buried and shunted down the card. 2005 was not exactly a banner year for Matt Hardy, was it? It was hard not to feel sympathy for Matt, given all he went through. WWE certainly didn't cover themselves in glory when they let the former Sensei of Mattitude go. Many felt that, if anybody should be given their pink slip, it should be Edge (and perhaps Lita) for causing the whole mess with their infidelity. That's what many normal companies would do, but WWE is not a normal company, and decided to fire the guy who made the story public. Matt no doubt regretted his impassioned response when looking back with the benefit of hindsight, but he can hardly be blamed for the nature of his reaction. WWE, on the other hand, can most certainly be blamed for the way they treated the North Carolina native. Matt could have had a great run on the indies and in TNA but he decided against that, opting for a return to WWE instead. It was a mistake, since WWE went about burying him pretty much from the get-go, having him decisively lose his dispute with the Rated-R Superstar, and subsequently being banished to Smackdown. While on the blue brand and trying to revive his flagging career, Matt persuaded a road agent to allow him to avoid an Undertaker chokeslam during the show-closing angle at Survivor Series. When the Deadman and JBL learned of this, they immediately went about chewing him out and the 'Wrestling God' dismantled him in the ring during their Armageddon PPV opener. A stupid decision by Matt, yes, but that whole thing could have been avoided had WWE handled the Edge/Lita affair fallout better.

9. Cutting Shawn Michaels' Heel Run Short

It was such a refreshing change to see Shawn Michaels play a heel in the summer of '05, after years of him doing the well-worn babyface act. The Heartbreak Kid specifically turned heel in order to feud with uber babyface Hulk Hogan, with the two set to clash in a blockbuster match at SummerSlam. HBK didn't necessarily want to turn to the dark side, citing his newfound religious beliefs, but was talked into it in order to do a short, money-drawing programme with Hogan. Michaels turned on the Immortal One following a tag match on the July 4th Raw. Turning heel on Mr. American on the fourth of July? I'm surprised he wasn't a villain for life after that. The Showstopper was an absolute riot as a heel, sending up Hogan during a parody of the Larry King show, nailing Roddy Piper and Jerry Lawler with Sweet Chin Music and, most memorably of all, trolling the Montreal crowd by playing Bret Hart's music during his opening promo on Raw. Honestly, it was the most exciting Michaels had been in a long time but, sadly, all good things must come to an end. What sucks is how soon that end came for Michaels' heel run. As soon as the Hogan programme was over, Michaels was back to being a babyface and entered into a feud with the up-and-coming Chris Masters. There was supposed to be a rematch between Hogan and Michaels the next month, with the Hulkster doing the job, but he became mysteriously injured and unable to compete. Final score: Hogan 1 - 0 Michaels. Still, Hogan match or not, WWE should have kept going with Michaels as a heel for a little longer. He could have had a fantastic feud with John Cena over the WWE Title or had a fun midcard dispute with someone like Shelton Benjamin. Sadly, WWE and Michaels went right back to the formula, which you can't help but see as stupid decision.

8. Triple H Vs. Jim Ross - Raw (18/4/05)

This one rarely gets talked about, but it deserves to be brought up as an example of WWE's often vindictive approach. Trips had already beat up the voice of WWE on an episode of Raw in 1999 (roughing up Ross was one of WWE's biggest heat-seaking angles for a long time), but their 'match' on Raw took things to a whole new level. First of all, what kind of main event is Jim Ross versus Triple H, anyway? It's especially baffling considering the April 18th Raw took place from Madison Square Garden, a very demanding and important audience, as far as WWE is concerned. Secondly, why the hell did it last for TWELVE whole minutes? And finally, why did JR do a bladejob? Actually, Ross didn't do a bladejob - the crimson mask he's sporting in the picture above is the result of several potato shots courtesy of the usually safe Cerebral Assassin. It was obvious when watching the match that Triple H was laying them in a bit stiffer than usual, which was either him working out years of frustration with the former Vice President of Talent Relations or a direct instruction from someone else backstage (there was a rumour that it was a receipt for JR lowballing him on past contract negotiations and giving poor payoffs). Adding to the weirdness of this whole match/angle, it was the Oklahoman who eventually got the duke - Good 'ol JR pinned The Game following interference form Batista. It's doubtful that the commentator felt like a winner afterwards, though, since he had blurred vision and a nice shiny black eye for some time afterwards. Dumb for booking the match in the first place and even dumber for the way it was executed. It made Triple H and WWE look like real bullies. Be a Star, guys.

7. Making Fun Of JR's Colonoscopy

Of course, the bad news didn't stop there for JR. In 2005 WWE and Vince McMahon really looked to be sending the message that he was old news and very much on the way out. Despite the fact that fans and wrestlers loved both Ross and his iconic voice, Vince, right-hand man Kevin Dunn and the like felt he was too fat, too old, too southern and took himself way too seriously. They wanted change. That change was Jonathan Coachman, a man who (while he would find his niche sometime later) just didn't cut it as a play-by-play man. Yes, WWE wanted to replace arguably the best commentator of all-time with The Coach. Sometimes, the mind boggles. Oh, WWE were also negotiating with UFC commentator Mike Goldberg, reportedly offering him between $350,000 and $500,000 to come on board. After seeing what WWE does to their employees and expressing a desire to stay in the real sports world, Goldberg rejected the offer. Which must have pissed Vince McMahon off and had something to do with the way he went after JR. First, Ross was fired in the ring in a risible segment which ended with Linda McMahon kicking him square in the balls, and then came the infamous 'Dr. Hiney'... If you're not away of Dr. Hiney or have somehow been lucky enough to wipe it from your memory (sorry for reminding you, in that case), allow me to aware you: Dr Hiney was a pre-taped skit/segment where Vince McMahon played a doctor, removing objects from 'JR's' backside. Ross had just underwent a colonoscopy and was in very serious pain, naturally. Vince looked like a kid in a candy store as he, ably assisted by 'Nurse Slobberknockers', pulled items ranging from a Stone Cold Steve Austin Doll to a bottle of BBQ sauce to JR's own head out of the dummy's arse. The payoff for this interminable laugh drought? Nothing. JR didn't get to come back and get even with Vince, although he did get some measure of revenge when WWE came crawling back to him after Joey Styles didn't work out behind the announce desk. The whole thing was shot entirely for Vince McMahon's amusement. I'm sure that today, in an era where his superstars promote anti-bullying campaigns and Ross is a well-respected Hall of Famer, that he probably regrets his decision to film it.

6. Firing Eighteen Superstars In Order To Re-Hire Brock Lesnar (Who Didn't End Up Signing)

It's been a while since WWE had a mass talent cull, but they used to happen with almost frightening regularity. On July 8th 2005, WWE took the unprecedented step of letting go of eighteen performers, including the Dudley Boys (as well as Spike), recently married couple Charlie Haas and Jackie Gayda and a pregnant Dawn Marie. Naturally, the wrestling press and those posting in online forums were quick to scold the company for taking away the income of the newlyweds and mother-to-be, questioning how they could be so callous and whether costs couldn't be cut somewhere else. Why were WWE even saying 'adieu' to almost twenty talents, anyways? Seemed a bit excessive, no? Simple: because they were negotiating with Brock Lesnar, who hadn't appeared for the outfit since WrestleMania XX in March 2004 and was actually in the process in suing WWE over his no-compete clause. Obviously, Lesnar would be a big signing for them, and a big signing costs big money. Lesnar was on a $1 million per year downside guarantee (minimum) when he was a WWE star between 2002-04. The Next Big Thing had a meeting with Vince McMahon in late June, which opened the door for negotiations. WWE even ran with the story on WWE.com and were supposedly confident of signing him. Then Lesnar balked at their 'insultingly low' financial offer and the expectation that he work a full-time schedule, and the lawsuits were back on. So WWE got rid of eighteen employees, many of whom had talent and potential or were in difficult personal situations, in order to free up the funds to sign Lesnar, and then he rejects the deal? Another smart and classy move by the 'WWE family'.

5. Not Pulling The Trigger On Christian

You know what must suck? When you're a guy that WWE sees a midcard level performer and you somehow find a way to get over, despite a complete lack of interest from the writers and bookers. It almost always ends in you being buried or punished in some way. Just ask Zack Ryder and Daniel Byran... Before those guys had to endure this bizarre punishment, however, Christian set the standard for talented midcarders striking a chord with the masses and being de-pushed because of it. Captain Charisma was on fire in 2005, really showing an improvement and confidence on the stick, as well as changing his ring style to a more main event-friendly one. He oozed confidence and challenged the likes of John Cena to matches and rap-offs in entertaining segments ('Tomko, gimme a beat' 'No'). He got one or two main event matches on Raw out of it but he never won any of them and it was clear that he was just being used as a warm body in those instances. He challenged for the WWE Title at the Vengeance PPV, taking on Cena and Jericho in a triple threat match, but that's as close as he came to the big belt. After failing to win it, he was transferred to Smackdown, where he engaged in a totally uninspired feud with Booker T. Despite being one of the more over acts of the spring/early summer months, Christian didn't appear on the SummerSlam card, which must have been frustrating to him. In early autumn he was right back in the same old US Title midcard spot. Eventually, he decided he'd had enough and, rather than tread the same old water again and again, he chose not to renew his contract, opting to sign with the then-promising TNA instead. WWE really screwed up by not giving Christian more of a shot. The man would have been dynamite in a singles feud with Cena, or could have even turned face for the first time in four years. Alas, it was not to be. WWE allowed him to walk out of the door, right into a high-profile, big-money spot with their No.2 competition.

4. The Self-Destruction Of The Ultimate Warrior

Have I mentioned during this article that WWE could be quite vindictive in the past? Oh, I have? Well, just in case you even more proof of that, as well as further proof of how stupid and short-sighted the company could be, let's take a look at a little DVD release called The Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior. Jim Hellwig, who legally changed his name to Warrior in order to become the owner of Ultimate Warrior character and likeness, hadn't been seen in a WWE ring since 1996, when his ill-fated comeback came to an abrupt end after he began missing dates. He left on very bad terms, as he had in 1991 and 92. He hadn't been seen in a wrestling ring since his embarrassing stint in WCW in 1998 and, by 2005, he had drifted into obscurity, some relic for a bygone era. Why then, did WWE feel the need to release an entire WWE burying the guy. Serious, The Self-Destruction documentary was such a hatchet job, with current and former stars and even Vince McMahon himself lining up to throw stones at the guy. Warrior, naturally, didn't take too kindly to this and sued WWE over defamation of character. Proving that time doesn't heal all wounds, Warrior made it known when he returned to the company for a Hall of Fame induction that he was deeply hurt by the DVD and felt that WWE were wrong to produce it. Warrior was right, of course. No matter your opinion on the man, you have to ask yourself: who was the audience for this presentation? Newer fans who had no idea who Warrior was? Disgruntled former co-workers? Vince himself? It was obvious that WWE and Warrior would, one day, work together again. The bad blood might have been boiling but they'd always managed to work it out when it came to making money. All the DVD did was make WWE look vindictive, piss off Warrior and alienate Warrior fans.

3. Asking Steve Austin To Job To Jonathan Coachman

In April 2004, Steve Austin left WWE yet again, this time over differences pertaining to his contract and, to a certain extent, the creative direction of his character and the company in general. Austin had walked out of WWE before but he'd been established as an on-screen authority figure for about a year when he decided to pursue other endeavours post-WrestleMania XX. He returned to the company a year later at WrestleMania 21 as a guest on Piper's Pit. After that he showed up for the odd segment here and there, and come October 2005 WWE were making plans to book him in a match. Against Jonathan Coachman. Yup, Stone Cold's first 'match' since WrestleMania XIX was going to be against the pudgy announcer. WWE figured they could pop the buyrate for Taboo Tuesday by featuring Stone Cold in a wrestling capacity (not that he'd do much besides beat the holy hell out of the Coach and his cronies - strictly no bumps). Incredibly, WWE actually asked Austin to do the job for ESPN's finest, to which Austin promptly said 'f*** that'. He wasn't about to have his credibility ruined by suffering the 1-2-3 at the hands of someone like Coach, regardless of how much outside interference it took. Add in the fact that Austin was fighting for the honour of his good friend Jim Ross and he'd look like a double loser. It's something that certainly wouldn't have happened to the Stone Cold character in years gone by, but WWE were adamant that he lose. So, Austin once again said 'goodbye' to WWE and left the company, being replaced by Batista at the PPV. The Animal won in about five minutes, which begs the question - why were WWE so keen for Austin to lose? Their insistence cost them the services of their biggest ever draw, and he wouldn't be seen in WWE again until the March 18th 2006 episode of Saturday Night's Main Event.

2. Eddiesploitation

The wrestling world was stunned when news broke on Sunday November 13, 2005 that Eddie Guerrero had passed away in his hotel room, at the age of 38. Latino Heat was a former WWE Champion, an active member of the WWE roster and in the midst of one of, if not the, biggest pushes of his career. WWE and their roster were understandably devastated and dedicated that week's episodes of Raw and Smackdown to the beloved Guerrero. Following that, WWE inducted Eddie into the Hall of Fame class of 2006 and introduced the Wellness Policy, which would drug-test and monitor wrestlers' health in order to avoid another wrestler prematurely dying. The tributes were classy and it looked as though Eddie's legacy and name were going to be respected and honoured...for about two weeks, anyway. Yes, a fortnight after his passing WWE began the process of using his name in storylines as a means of generating heel heat. The November 29th episode of Smackdown ended with Randy Orton placing The Undertaker into one of Eddie's low riders, crashing it into the set, exploding it and ostensibly killing The Phenom. Yes, WWE ran this angle sixteen whole days after Eddie had passed on. As well as this deplorable cheap heat stunt, WWE also ran with the headline 'Viva La Savings!' and used Guerrero's likeness in order to shill merchandise on their website. The upshot was that every fan with even half a soul made it known that WWE were in the wrong and that exploiting their recently deceased star like that was disgraceful. Unfortunately, WWE didn't learn (or care) and continued on with the Eddiesploitation well into 2006.

1. Airing The Muhammad Hassan/Undertaker Terrorism Angle

Muhammad Hassan really is one of the biggest 'What Ifs?' in WWE history. He arrived on WWE screens in later 2004, proclaiming to be a victim of American prejudice and discrimination post-9/11. It was an interesting twist and could have been so much more that your typical 'evil foreigner' type that WWE like to present. WWE being WWE, they naturally made it just that, and mere weeks into his run Hassan (and manager Daivari) was like a modern-day Iron Sheik. Still, despite the black-and-white nature of the character and subsequent diluted intrigue, Hassan was given a hearty push, including being put into matches with the likes of Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels. Then he was transferred over to Smackdown in the draft and was matched up with The Undertaker, a huge test for any rookie. As a way to draw heat and create more of an issue in the run-up to their match at the Great American Bash, WWE presented a controversial angle at the July 5th Smackdown tapings. In short - masked, terrorist-like men clad in ski masks attacked The Deadman in the ring and garrotted him with piano wire, before hoisting a downed Daivari into the air and carrying him off, as if he was a martyr-like figure. It was close-to-the-bone, controversial stuff, but unfortunately for WWE it would become even more so following some very real-life events. The angle was taped on July 5th but didn't air until the 7th, the day of the London Undergound bombings. Yes, WWE regrettably aired this terrorism-themed angle on the day of a horrific real world terrorist attack. It resulted in the mainstream media condemning WWE (who claimed they didn't have time to edit/remove the footage) and the president of UPN requesting the immediate removal of Muhammad Hassan from Smackdown. So, come the Great American Bash, WWE were 'forced' to write Hassan out of storylines. He, his henchmen and Daivari were battered by The Undertaker and Hassan was then given a Last Ride through the stage. Last Ride indeed - Hassan was history, all because of one ill-judged and badly-timed angle.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...