10 Successful Gimmicks You Forgot WWE Tried Again
WWE badly wanted John Cena's rap gimmick and Triple H having a mentor to work TWICE.
Repeating the same trick typically leads to diminishing returns, but that has never stopped WWE from hoping its global audience won't mind. On one level, it makes sense. If something was successful before (even modestly), then why wouldn't the company attempt to piggy back on that with more of the same thing? Sadly, some of these tepid repeats were quickly forgotten by fans, and most couldn't reach the heights of their predecessors.
There's a twist to a few of the ones laid bare here too. Some folks reading might not actually remember the originals, so maybe they view the follow-ons as more vibrant/more successful. Few hate on WWE for doing this sort of thing anyway, because there are only so many gimmicks to go around in wrestling.
Just...please never cast anyone as a garbage/bin man again. One Duke 'The Dumpster' Droese was enough.
You could practically fill a Royal Rumble with all of the repeat characters WWE has tried again. 10 of the best examples are included here. Remember when Triple H had a mentor before Ric Flair in Evolution? It was only brief, so you'd be forgiven for forgetting all about it. How about the time Hulk Hogan tried to do his best impression of Del Wilkes? That isn't a sentence anybody thought they'd be seeing in 2025.
The fact there's only a few years between some of these is also remarkable. Maybe wait a bit before trying effectively the same thing with someone else in the future - Triple H has to learn that bitter lesson from Vince McMahon.
Drum roll, please.
10. Female Superhero (Mighty Molly/Nikki A.S.H)
Nikki A.S.H was at least partly inspired by The Hurricane. To pretend otherwise would be silly, because Shane Helms set the template for getting a quirky superhero character over. That's true, but his Hurri-sidekick Mighty Molly was a blessing in disguise for Molly Holly at a time when she badly needed something other than being Hardcore and Crash's on screen cousin. A short romance with Spike Dudley was never going to be her long-term solution.
Buddying up with The Hurricane right as that character hit a sweet spot (it even helped Rosey and Stacy Keibler, amongst others) was great for Molly. So, it's no shocker that WWE figured they could pivot Nikki Cross out of her union with Alexa Bliss into something radically different for 2021. Nikki A.S.H, which stood for "Almost (A) Super Hero" was something Nikki came up with herself.
It came from a good place. The Scot wanted to inspire young wrestling fans to always believe in themselves and chase their dreams without fear of failure. In a way, she was an even more cartoonish version of the message John Cena pushed during the PG era. Initially, things looked great for A.S.H; she won the Raw Women's Title and seemed to be more over than ever, but the magic wore off quickly.
WWE liked Nikki's pitch and clearly thought it was worth trying an amalgamated version of The Hurricane and Mighty Molly in one wrestler. Fair enough, but the beauty of Molly's character had been that she was spirited but ultimately never pushed too far in front of other, more serious characters.
It's no wonder creative went back to Nikki's unhinged roots in 2022, but the superhero thing was worth trying on for size.
9. Mad Max Tag-Team (LOD/The Ascension)
Vince McMahon viewed Konnor and Viktor as a new breed Road Warriors in late-2014. Fair enough, but the then-WWE boss sure had a unique way of trying to get The Ascension to LOD's level in the minds of fans. He instructed an outraged JBL to dump on the pair via commentary, which was supposed to make the announcer look silly because the team were ultra-successful.
One problem: WWE completely gave up on The Ascension's push. That meant Layfield's lambasting about how Konnor and Viktor were a poor man's Hawk and Animal started to ring true. This was a puzzling strategy. Why would management knowingly write off a fresh tag-team on screen whilst booking them like the bloody Conquistadors? Who knows, but they did it!
Everything about The Ascension's main roster look was supposed to conjure up memories of LOD. They had a similar red and black colour scheme, painted their faces, and initially worked a dominant powerhouse style that was too much for most opponents. The pair even took to the mic and declared that they were an improvement on the Road Warriors, Demolition, Powers Of Pain and other ancient favourites.
By mid-2015, Konnor and Viktor were glorified jobbers who had more in common with forgotten WWF 'New Generation' pair Tekno Team 2000 than the legends of yesteryear. A wishy washy union with Cody Rhodes as The Cosmic Wasteland didn't do much for their prospects of rescuing the bleak situation either. McMahon blatantly gave up on The Ascension without easing up on JBL's criticism.
They were Legion Of Doomed rather quickly.
8. Anti-American Group (Hart Foundation/Un-Americans)
This should've worked.
OK, so the upside down American flag was a controversial touch, but the overall premise of Lance Storm, Christian, William Regal and Test coming together as a stable should've been a license to print money. The Un-Americans had a workhorse tag-team (Storm and Regal), the potential for another (Storm and Christian), two workers who were excellent on the mic (Christian and Regal) and a big hoss who could do the heavy lifting (Test).
The Un-Americans began airing their unhappiness with all things USA in June of 2002, but they'd splinter by September. Yes, the foursome lasted around three months. That wasn't anything close to a fair shake. It was especially annoying to fans hoping for a killer heel group in the same mould as The Hart Foundation. Bret, Owen, Davey Boy Smith, Jim Neidhart and Brian Pillman earned rave reviews for their anti-American/pro-Canadian stance in 1997, so a precedent had been set for this sort of thing.
Five years later, poor Storm, Christian, Regal and Test watched their own faction fizzle out without reaching the same heights Bret's crew had. They weren't in main events, but they did get to mix it in the World Tag-Team division. That was something - a morsel The Un-Americans had to make the most of. It wouldn't prove to be enough to sustain them.
It's largely forgotten about now, but these anti-American agitators were supposed to carry the same torch The Harts did before them. You'll rarely find anybody putting them in the same breath these days. Maybe the quartet just needed Christian to tell Pittsburgh that they'd stick the hose in Pennsylvania if the US needed an enema, eh?
7. Wrestling Vampire (Gangrel/Kevin Thorn)
Who looks cooler? If you're of a certain vintage, there's no way you're picking ECW reboot's Kevin Thorn. Gangrel was an 'Attitude Era' mainstay who spat blood after sipping it from a chalice, emerged onstage in a ring of fire and helped give Edge and Christian a foot on the company ladder by way of The Brood. He was always a midcard worker, but Gangers had some dramatic vibes to him.
It's understandable why WWE thought trying another vampire gimmick was worth it in 2006 then. Thorn and his valet Ariel had an even darker look than Gangrel's 'white wolf' aesthetic, but something was missing. Maybe it was that Thorn had bungled as Undertaker wannabe Mordecai in 2004, or perhaps fans just didn't want to see supernatural/OTT characters like this so shortly after the ECW revival. Whatever it was, Thorn and Ariel failed to properly click with crowds.
This writer even knows fans who were definitely watching some wrestling between 2006-2007 but don't recall Thorn at all. That's remarkable considering he and his New Breed cohorts worked a match vs. old ECW faves like RVD, Sabu, Tommy Dreamer and The Sandman at WrestleMania 23.
It's a bad sign when folks completely forget someone who worked 'Mania.
WWE chiefs must've been disappointed by the Mordecai flop, but they weren't willing to give up on Kev just yet. Sadly, the vampire reprise and Gangrel mimicking didn't cut it either. Third time wouldn't be a charm for Thorn - he didn't get that chance before leaving the promotion for good.
6. Sumo Wrestler (Yokozuna/Rikishi)
During an otherwise serious creative meeting building up to Yokozuna's title win (then loss) at WrestleMania IX, some unnamed staffer stood up and asked the question: 'What would happen if we exposed his big behind, put some sunglasses on him and made Yoko dance to cheesy, 1980s-inspired beats as fans roared their approval?'. That entirely made up scenario would've birthed Rikishi before Too Cool was even a twinkle in Vince Russo's eye.
Yep, it's true. Rikishi was originally supposed to be Yokozuna 2.0. Legend has it that Vince McMahon wanted Fatu to wear a thong Yoko had balked at. It was supposed to be a sumo wrestling mawashi, but let's be real about it. Kish rocked a thong-tha-thong thong thong during matches. Sometimes, if he didn't like certain wrestlers, Rikishi would reportedly skip the "wash" part of mawashi and perform his stinkface spot anyway.
Wrestling is some industry, isn't it? Apologies to anybody reading this over lunch, but various WWE stars could probably tell you what Kish had for his that day pre-match. Eventually, Fatu's creative moved him further away from the sumo style and more towards a standard big man one. Comparisons to Yokozuna faded by the time he was hanging out with Scotty Too Hotty and Grandmaster Sexay on TV.
It's actually a bit of a surprise WWE didn't come back to the more serious Yoko-esque presentation once Kish turned heel in late-2000. He might've been able to make that work rather than effectively sticking to his comedic look and slapping a 'Bad Man' nickname over the top like that'd solve everything.
More like bad booking.
5. Masked Patriot (The Patriot/Mr. America)
Bruce Prichard has lifted the lid on some of Vince McMahon's historical creative quirks across hundreds of 'Something To Wrestle With' episodes. Usually, Prichard then defends them even if they're rather silly and make no sense. Case in point: The curious case of Del Wilkes as The Patriot. According to Bruce, McMahon wasn't fond of masked babyfaces.
That didn't stop him from bringing Wilkes in as a masked American hero in 1997 though, did it? Work that one out. Vince overlooked his own pet peeve so Bret and The Hart Foundation had someone to wave 'Old Glory' right in their faces. This was a bizarre choice considering the changing face of the biz and the fact more hardened faces like 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin had been running rampant.
Approx six years later, WWE were at it again. Admittedly, things were a little more tongue in cheek second time around. Hulk Hogan had been fired by McMahon, so he introduced the world to Mr. America. It was Hogan under a mask and armed with a US flag. That was literally it, but Vince was supposed to be fooled and go to extreme lengths just to prove that it was his arch nemesis under the hood.
Suspending disbelief can be a challenge on occasion, but that's part of wrestling's charm. In short, Mr. America was another stab at The Patriot's red, white and blue sentiment. The main difference was that Hogan wasn't up against Canada. He clearly didn't watch that episode of South Park everyone else did then.
Hulk Hogan was a Del Wilkes hanger on. You learn something new every day.
4. Intellectual Saviour (The Genius/Damien Sandow)
Thankfully, Damien Sandow didn't recite any of Lanny Poffo's poetry.
Instead, Sandow declared himself an "intellectual saviour of the (unwashed) masses". He was a scholar, a gentleman, and he was here to enlighten everyone whilst wearing what looked like a bath robe he'd nicked from a rather fancy hotel. Damien did borrow some other things from Poffo though. He had the same punchable smirk The Genius sported, and he was often forced to use brainpower when outgunned by opponents inside the ring.
Very much unlike The Genius, who was mainly a manager during his time in the WWF and only wrestled in featured bouts sporadically, Sandow almost cracked the main event scene permanently. He won Money In The Bank back in 2013, and critics agreed it was only a matter of time before Damo traded his swish leather bound briefcase for one of WWE's World Titles.
Or not. His push was abruptly cancelled, and he slid right back down the ladder. Not even knocking it out of the park as The Miz's stunt double could save the poor lad in the end. WWE soured on Sandow for...whatever reason, and nothing was going to change their minds on that. He was yesterday's man. End of story.
It shouldn't have been the end of his story. Sandow updated Poffo's Genius character for the modern era and proved to be an accomplished worker between the ropes. Nothing should've stood in his way of the top line picture. Nothing. Tragically, "nothing" was replaced by Vince McMahon and his army of knackered writers, and they had final say.
That "intellectual saviour" gimmick still has potential.
3. Million Dollar Man (Ted DiBiase/Ted DiBiase Jr)
Sons and daughters of famous wrestlers face a hard ol' shift. Succeed, and critics will cry nepotism. Fail, and those same people will wonder why promoters even bothered trying in the first place. For every Cody Rhodes or Charlotte Flair, there's an Erik Watts or Ted DiBiase Jr. Living up to the family name and breaking free of that iconic shadow to forge your own legacy is hard to do.
WWE didn't help Ted Jr one bit by sticking his dad's legendary 'Million Dollar Man' gimmick on him in 2010. They even brought the old Million Dollar Title along for the ride in hopes it'd give DiBiase Jr the same heel edge his father had throughout the second half of the 80s into the early-90s. Was this worth trying? Maybe/maybe not, but it didn't really matter in the end anyway.
'Million Dollar Son' was never going to fly.
Ted Jr tried. He really, really tried, but he had none of the natural charisma Sr did. His suits weren't as flashy, his promos were unconvincing and his matches were nowhere near as solid as dad's had been. Enlisting Virgil flopped, and even sticking the glamorous Maryse by his side failed to elicit much of a response from crowds.
By 2011, DiBiase Jr had turned babyface to host parking lot tailgate parties before shows. That didn't really go anywhere either. He acknowledged that it had been a bad idea to try mimic his father's iconic character, then faded away before being cut loose from the roster in 2013.
Some fans might not remember he was a repeat of the 'Million Dollar Man' persona at all.
2. Perfect Mentor (Mr. Perfect/Ric Flair)
Despite the gravelly-voice lyrics from Motorhead frontman Lemmy claiming otherwise, there was no mystery about why Evolution succeeded in WWE. Triple H did his best blending of Harley Race and Ric Flair from the 1970s and 80s as leader, Flair himself ably backed 'The Game' up as a manager and occasional worker, and young bucks like Randy Orton and Batista were prime first round draft picks to fill things out. It's still one of the best stables in company history.
Did you know? Curt Hennig actually beat Flair to the punch in 1996 by becoming Hunter's first mentor in the then-WWF. This happened right before Mr. Perfect left for WCW later the same year. Hennig was cast in the role of an experienced advisor to Triple H, and even conspired with him to screw Marc Mero over so Trips could win the Intercontinental Title.
There's a fair chance this Perfect duo would've reached even greater heights had Curt stuck around in the federation. They might even be remembered as fondly as Flair and Hunter. Right, quick diversion on that. "Fondly" could make some laugh, because some fans despised the 2002-2003 era of Triple H. They'd have to admit that Evolution was badass though, surely.
It's a confusing one!
There was nothing confusing about Hennig advising Hunter. They went together well, and both guys carried themselves with almost identical arrogance. In a way, 'Slick Ric' was a copycat idea once Evolution launched years later. He'd likely refute that, but go back and watch the footage - the similarities are plain for everyone to see.
1. Bad Boy Rapper (John Cena/Slam Master J)
John Cena struck gold when he began rapping to try entertain the rest of the roster on the tour bus in late-2002. Stephanie McMahon caught wind of what was happening and had the foresight to change Cena's generic boots n' tights style into a Vanilla Ice-meets-Eminem bad boy rapper for TV. John never looked back. He used that chance as a springboard to immortality.
WWE liked the gimmick so much they tried to use it again in 2009 for Ray Gordy. Sure, Gordy had worked something similar down in developmental territory Deep South in 2006 (as "Ray Geezy"), but that was different to appearing on big shows like Raw or SmackDown. Fans ridiculed the "Slam Master J" name immediately, and the fact Gordy's bad boy rapper was supposed to be tongue in cheek didn't save it.
Slam Master J only lasted a short while before Ray was dropped from screens and later released in April 2010. He'd stumbled around under a few different gimmicks before landing on the 'second coming of Cena' thing. There were several problems with it. One, WWE's product was now PG so writers couldn't be as edgy as they'd been with John. Two, Gordy wasn't as skilled a performer as Cena. Three, his name was bloody horrible and turned Ray into a laughing stock akin to Chad Gable going by 'Shorty G'.
Armed with zero menace and treated like a bad joke from day one, Gordy was cooked once he started wearing the sideways cap and mugging like he was doing his best 2004 Cena impression for Halloween.
What other gimmicks did WWE try repeating over the years? For more like this, check out 10 WWE Jobbers Who Became World Champion and 10 Most ANNOYING Wrestlers Ever!