10 Things Cody Rhodes Achieved From The List
Chris Hero, Trevor Lee, Moose, and others Cody Rhodes can tick off his famous list.
"After 8/19."
That was the whole caption. Accompanied by a simple piece of paper that had 14 goals for Cody Rhodes post-WWE, the future AEW Executive Vice President sent social media into a frenzy on 28 May 2016, just six days after WWE formally confirmed his WWE release.
There was legitimate hype for what, exactly, Cody would achieve outside of WWE. He'd always been a gifted in-ring worker - his dad's Dusty Rhodes, for God's sake, it's sort of a family tradition - but WWE had rarely let him showcase this. A gorgeous Moonsault on Road Dogg from atop a steel cage shouldn't be the sole career highlight for someone of Cody's calibre.
Thus, when his WWE release was announced on 22 May 2016, we, as wrestling fans, understandably wanted to see the guy succeed. We knew he could go, he created investment with this list, and all the major promotions wanted a slice of the pie.
It's odd to reflect on this wondrous period, given how drastically the landscape of pro wrestling has changed since 2016. You could argue that, for all the epics the Young Bucks were producing, this transformation began with the American Nightmare leaving WWE.
Cody didn't complete the list, sadly, but he did get quite far in doing so...
10. The Streamers Thing (ROH Supercard Of Honor XII)
Streamers were a regular occurrence in Ring of Honor when they had live audiences, and so 2018's Supercard of Honor XII wasn't actually the first time Cody Rhodes had received the tradition.
It was a marquee situation, however.
Cody was wrestling Kenny Omega in what was only Omega's second singles match in the company throughout the Bullet Club era. For the uninitiated, the bout came during the peak of Being the Elite's success, with that excellence translated into a superlative story throughout the main companies the Elite was part of.
The particular arc between Rhodes and Omega had stemmed from the prior June's New Japan Dominion event, where Cody had teased throwing the towel in during Kenny's IWGP Heavyweight Championship quest against Kazuchika Okada in their classic. Their story was a main talking point not only in Ring of Honor, but in the wrestling industry as a whole; their match was an anticipated clash during a WrestleMania weekend that also featured Ronda Rousey's in-ring debut and Daniel Bryan's return.
That's how big this was.
For Cody - and Omega, for those wondering - to receive the streamers during their respective entrances told you that this was a big-time fight. It was a Wrestle Kingdom-calibre match, both in terms of its story and the match that ensued; streamers had to be thrown.
9. Adam Cole (NEW Spring Slam Tour 2017: Newburgh)
Prior to Adam Cole's WWE debut in August 2017, he was closely linked to Cody Rhodes through their allegiance to Bullet Club. Cole and Rhodes had represented the acclaimed faction on a handful of occasions, most notably seeing off SCU's Christopher Daniels and Frankie Kazarian - then named the Addiction - in February of that year. They were great together, making it a shame that we never saw more of them as a tag team.
By 26 May 2017, Bullet Club was out of the picture.
Just over a week after Cole was ousted from the Club, he challenged for Cody's Northeast Wrestling Heavyweight Title. Taking place at the Newburgh stop of the company's Spring Slam Tour, the pair wrestled a 17-minute banger, going down as the second-longest defence for Cody in his reign as NEW's top champion. Cole failed to dethrone him, just as Bobby Fish, Ricochet, and Jerry Lawler (!) had, too.
This was the only straight singles match between the two, though this isn't much of a surprise considering they were aligned in the same stable for the majority of their time in the same scene. Such a match shouldn't be overdone to maintain its aura as a legitimate dream match.
8. Mike Bennett (IMPACT Wrestling, October 2016)
Cody Rhodes and Mike Bennett's clash from the 13 October 2016 IMPACT Wrestling broadcast was good. It served well as an IMPACT in-ring debut for the former, while Bennett didn't look out of place across from Cody. The Miracle sold the Cross Rhodes with blissful perfection, getting across the vibe that it's a legitimate match-ender.
It wasn't their only outing together, though; simply put, it was their most notable.
The first Rhodes vs. Bennett encounter went down two months prior for the aforementioned Northeast Wrestling promotion. As part of the Wrestling Under the Stars tour, Cody was victorious in just his fourth match since leaving WWE, with Bennett again serving as a solid adversary for him.
In March 2017, Cody won his third singles bout vs. Bennett, beginning his reign as NEW's Heavyweight Champion when he pinned Mike at that year's March Mayhem show. This 12-minute match would be Bennett's fifth-last before arriving in WWE at that June's Money in the Bank pay-per-view.
There could have been something to a credible feud between the pair had Cody's stint in IMPACT not been as short-lived as it was. Bennett was quickly becoming a top-tier name in the company at the time Rhodes arrived, and would have flourished exponentially against an opponent of his calibre. Nonetheless, their handful of matches together were decent.
7. Katsuyori Shibata (ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017)
If we're only going by singles matches here, then no, Cody Rhodes has never wrestled the legendary Katsuyori Shibata.
They did, however, compete in a tag team match on Night 1 of ROH and New Japan's co-promoted Honor Rising: Japan weekender in February 2017. There, Cody teamed with then-Bullet Club teammate Hangman Page, whereas Shibata was joined by Jay Lethal.
Tasked with semi-main eventing the Korakuen Hall, it was Lethal and Shibata who came out victorious after a 14-minute bout, with the former pinning Page via Lethal Injection. Though the match was nothing special, it did provide some interactions between Rhodes and Shibata, with a post-match confrontation seemingly teasing a singles match between the duo later on.
That, as we know, sadly never came to fruition.
Just two months later, Shibata would wrestle that epic IWGP Heavyweight Title match vs. Kazuchika Okada in which he headbutted the sh*t out of Okada, discovering soon after that he was suffering from a subdural hematoma. As of this writing, Shibata hasn't competed since.
There's no point in explaining how tantalising a singles bout between the duo sounds because it's that obvious. A marquee collision at one of ROH or New Japan's bigger events sounds appropriate. Still, Katsuyori Shibata can technically be crossed off the list.
6. Trevor Lee (PWG Only Kings Understand Each Other)
Cody Rhodes vs. Trevor Lee is precisely what Cody set out to achieve from this list.
It was never about Cody coming out of WWE, putting on this list of dream matches, and going over every time; it was about him just having a series of superlative encounters, regardless of the outcome. His bout vs. the now-Cameron Grimes is a testament to this.
Going down at Pro Wrestling Guerrilla's February 2017 show, there wasn't a moment to breathe in the ten-minute match. That it began with a middle-rope German Suplex told the story perfectly. They weren't messing about here, and thus, a big spot was necessary to kick off the match. The remainder of the match flowed in a similar fashion, with Cody's springboard dive to ringside and Trevor's Cave In being neat highlights.
Let down only by an absolute shambles of a Disaster Kick from Cody - from the angle, Cody missed by a clear mile, with his ankle twisting awkwardly mid-flight - the match was a success. It came at the peak of Trevor's success in PWG, coming immediately after wins over Dalton Castle, ACH, and Kamaitachi - the future Hiromu Takahashi.
It was one of only three, often forgotten matches Cody ever had in PWG, yet it proved crucial for the career of Trevor Lee.
5. Chris Hero (EVOLVE 67)
Chris Hero holds a significant record with regards to Cody Rhodes' post-WWE life, being just the second opponent Cody had after leaving the company. Their bout went down on 20 August at EVOLVE 67, with Hero going over the former Stardust in a 20-minute bout. The prior day, Cody had defeated Zack Sabre Jr. in his return to in-ring competition.
The match had just one major flaw; Cody's transition from a sports entertainer to a professional wrestler.
If you recall, Cody never once wrestled on the independent circuit. He started his career in WWE's then-developmental territory, Ohio Valley Wrestling. You needn't be told the drastically different style between WWE and the indies, even back then, and this created a slight issue for Rhodes. He tried to be too indie, for lack of a better term; he was hitting Moonsaults and taking Short Piledrivers just because he was able to. They added little to the overall arc of the match, though.
Nonetheless, Chris Hero performed exquisitely against Cody, delivering the sort of performance that would become the norm for Cody's run on the indies. He worked magic vs. the 'Prince of Pro Wrestling', proving within the first five minutes why he was on Cody's hitlist, if you will.
4. Moose (IMPACT Wrestling, March 2017)
Cody Rhodes' fourth and final IMPACT Wrestling contest saw him unsuccessfully challenge for Moose's Grand Title in March 2017. All things considered, the match worked well.
Contested in a system similar to that of traditional World of Sport clashes, Cody played the role of the underdog fighting back against the big beefy bruiser, a situation that Cody has consistently thrived in throughout All Elite Wrestling (see: Wardlow, Mr. Brodie Lee, et al). Moose destroyed Cody early on, with a Pop Up Powerbomb, jumping Senton, and diving Moonsault combination going down a treat.
The second round saw Rhodes mount a comeback through targeting Moose's lower limbs, which, again, is an area in which the American Nightmare proves himself as an expert. Cody was superb in his slow, calculated manner to bring Moose down a level. A simple dropkick to the knee is what began Cody's onslaught, creating a reliable star within Moose as a direct result. He sold wonderfully for Rhodes here.
You must remember that Moose was at the peak of his popularity here. It perhaps didn't come across as such in those dark days of IMPACT, but everywhere else he went, the then-Grand Champion was on the tip of everyone's tongue.
Of course Cody would want a slice of that attention.
3. PWG Battle Of Los Angeles (2016)
Being an entrant in Pro Wrestling Guerrilla's Battle of Los Angeles tournament is the key principle to making it as an independent wrestler.
The tourney weekender is a hive of the most transcendent grapplers. Of the 15 winners thus far, five are currently with WWE, while Major League Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling both have two signed, and All Elite Wrestling and Ring of Honor currently house one winner apiece.
Cody, upon realising this, wanted a teaser of the BOLA atmosphere, competing in two matches as part of the 2016 offering. What made his debut venture to the intimate American Legion Post venue was that both of those encounters offered something unique to its audiences.
Night 2's outing against Sami Callihan saw Rhodes don his infamous face mask from his 'Dashing' days in WWE, while Callihan covered his face with a Space Cat mask. They wrestled the sort of super indie match that you'd expect from a traditional PWG event. Meanwhile, Cody's second-round match vs. eventual tournament winner Marty Scurll leaned more towards the sports entertainment heading. It had only one or two high spots, plus Cody was Superkicked in the d*ck (Superd*cked, anyone?) while Brandi Rhodes was, inadvertently, distracting the referee.
He was varied in the tournament, with this later being shown in AEW's inaugural TNT Title tourney, too.
2. Dalton Castle (ROH Final Battle 2017)
Like other entries, Ring of Honor's 2017 Final Battle PPV wasn't the sight of the first clash between Cody Rhodes and Dalton Castle - that honour goes to their Experience show from February of the same year - but it was inarguably their most notable.
It was contested over the company's World Title, you see; a title that Dalton had never been able to capture. He was hardly the stereotypical face of a pro wrestling company, while Cody possesses that natural leadership to take a company to new heights.
Combine that with each man's elaborate entrances, the Final Battle main event instantaneously came with a big fight aura. The match was equally about elevating Dalton Castle as it was furthering the saga between Cody and Kenny Omega that led to their epic ROH bout over WrestleMania 34 weekend.
By the match's end, Dalton's reputation within the Cary Silkin-helmed promotion had been raised. His run as ROH World Champion isn't remembered, really, but for this night, the Hammerstein Ballroom viewed him as a leader.
Cody Rhodes, this legitimate headline act, listed Dalton Castle as a must-have match for him upon leaving the biggest professional wrestling organisation in the world; that, in itself, is a testament to the Party Peacock.
1. Kurt Angle (WCPW True Legacy 2016)
Cody Rhodes and Kurt Angle didn't just happen in the now-defunct WCPW/Defiant Wrestling, but, like numerous other entries here, it was their most notable together.
Going down in front of a packed Altrincham Ice Dome in Greater Manchester, Rhodes and Angle delivered a scintillating contest that combined an array of wrestling styles. Taking an age to officially begin, the duo - alongside referee Steve Lynskey - drew big cheers for their cartwheel display, before Angle would target the ankle of the future AEW TNT Champion. It's the match expected of the Olympic gold medallist, and ultimately worked for him, as Rhodes tapped to the Ankle Lock after 12 minutes.
This was the duo's second outing together, though. The first came in August, promoted by Northeast Wrestling at their Wrestling Under the Stars 5 show, with Cody winning that inaugural clash. Their third, contested inside a steel cage, also occurred on a NEW show, happening at the 21st Wrestlefest event. There, in Angle's final indie match before heading back to WWE, Cody Rhodes went over in another 12-minute clash.
Cody and Angle surprised many, your writer included, in their WCPW encounter. Despite being somewhat similar in their in-ring style - they both execute a neat top-rope Moonsault, for example - the chemistry they displayed together was exemplary.
It's quite fitting, then, that it was at the company's highest-attended show at that time.