10 Times Outside Factors Totally Changed WWE WrestleMania

War don't draw.

SADAM Wrestlemania VII Speech
WWE.com

At time of writing, one internal factor is in the midst of changing WrestleMania 35 - and plans are changing by the minute amid pure, fascinating chaos.

That factor is Vince McMahon.

Even in this modern era of rash, impulse booking, one constant abides: WWE intricately books WrestleMania months in advance. Midcard attractions are sometimes left to the last minute - hence the grand tradition of "a multi-man ladder match, f*ck it" - but the key matches usually leak and or are foreshadowed by the end of the prior year.

This year is different. This year, Vince McMahon, in the desperate pursuit of short-term ratings gains, appears to have lost his mind once and for all.

There is as yet no final, concrete plan for the WWE Heavyweight Championship bout, and it is astonishing. With so many normalised bodies strewn across the main roster, WWE will resurrect an as-yet-undetermined corpse (Kevin Owens, Bray Wyatt et al.) to face Daniel Bryan, chiefly in the hope that we forget the extent to which they were murdered in 2018.

Hordes of those bodies - Finn Bálor, Drew McIntyre, Braun Strowman, Samoa Joe, Jeff Hardy, Andrade - are ostensibly on the Road To WrestleMania, only, they've no earthly idea of the direction.

It is an inexcusable indictment of the process - but Vince used to have excuses, once upon a time.

Sometimes.

10. A SHAMBOLIC Approach To Customer Service (WrestleMania XXX)

Batista Alberto Del Rio
WWE

If he could get away with it - if the match drew just enough money and merely silenced the crowd, as opposed to pissing them sufficiently to risk a mass exodus - Vince McMahon would have The Great Khali Vs. Baron Corbin headline WrestleMania.

All of these things that we hold so affectionately in our hearts - superb technical wrestling, babyface performers we enjoy an organic bond with - don't mean a bloody thing to the COO.

This is how we almost arrived at a main event attraction in Randy Orton Vs. Batista at WrestleMania XXX. That Daniel Bryan guy you love so much? You can still love him, in a 10 minute midcard match, as he squares off against Sheamus - and this time, unlike WrestleManias XXVII and XXVIII, it is actually happening and won't last just 18 seconds!

Rounded off by CM Punk Vs. Triple H - a match Trips wanted in order to funnel that sweet, sweet hardcore fan heat - WrestleMania XXX was almost a grotesquely wasteful drizzles of a show. We were spared it through, let's see here: CM Punk's shocking walkout, Batista's status as persona non grata, and the absolute, deafening refusal of WWE fans to receive an abrasively stubborn narrative.

It's precisely this sort of of bullsh*t that lands WWE in a mire of brand distrust right now - and worryingly for them, the fans may no longer have the heart to fight back.


9. The Sad Death Of Eddie Guerrero (WrestleMania 22)

Rey Mysterio Vickie Guerrero
WWE

Eddie Guerrero's late 2005 passing remains a deeply sad moment in the modern history of professional wrestling.

Any young death is, obviously, but Eddie had overcame his demons. This stirring, true story had informed his deeply deserved ascension as a main event player. That Guerrero in the end succumbed to those demons lends his legacy an ironic and stark pathos.

WWE, in response to Eddie's death...

...picked the bones of his corpse for every last morsel of flesh in an attempt to sell a pay-per-view. WWE dropped the Randy Orton big push, looked around backstage, selected the nearest, most marketable man of Mexican descent, and had him vie for the World Heavyweight Championship, cynically using his association with Eddie to craft a "tributary" babyface story.

We say this - but who are we to say this? Seeing his great, old friend Rey Mysterio triumph against his own, admittedly smaller odds is what he would have wanted. Eddie would have wanted to see Vince experience buyer's remorse (and he bought a distressing storyline). The religious Eddie would have wanted Orton to claim he was "down there in hell".

Eddie would have wanted Finlay to go over the storyline weakest World Heavyweight Champion ever in a throwaway non-title match.


8. Injuries & Insults (WrestleMania 2000)

Chris Benoit Chris Jericho Kurt Angle
WWE.com

A rare misfire of the shared universe excellence of the Chris Kreski era, WrestleMania 2000 was something of a mess of contrived dynamics and multi-man might-as-wells. It wasn't a horrible show - the awesome roster and white-hot brand meant that it couldn't entirely fail - but Kreski had to contend with both McMahon megalomania and the crazed flux of incoming and departing talent.

The injury to Steve Austin created several headaches - and yet more accounts of what the alternate timeline may have looked like. Austin Vs. The Big Show, a spiritual sequel to Hulk Hogan Vs. André The Giant, was a purported main event pitched when Vince was in negotiations with his prized asset. To think of how much Vince once loved him.

With Austin shelved, Vince ultimately settled on the Fatal 4-Way main event, the complexion of which changed from inception to execution. Chris Jericho was dropped, having disappointed McMahon, with Mick Foley replacing him in the sort of sentimental gesture that seems so incompatible with the modern image of the man.

Jericho's insult relegated him to the Eurocontinental Title match, in which he was joined by Chris Benoit. The insults dealt to him and his Radicalz defectors by WCW upheaved the WWF's midcard - for the considerable betterment of it, once Kreski detangled the web.

Some readers might bristle at this love-in, for a resistant narrative has emerged on the podcast circuit.

Since that whole Chris Kreski-as-Head Writer thing was a myth, and Bruce Prichard is back to restore us to the glory years, we promise to put an end to it in six months, by which time wonderful episodic TV order shall be restored.

Doot doot doot!


7. Who Knows, Honestly (WrestleMania VIII)

Hulk Hogan Sid Justice
WWE

Admittedly within the WWF's control (mostly), what became of WrestleMania VIII lives on as a fascinating insight into a bygone era.

The company had foreshadowed what was then the biggest match imaginable in all of pro wrestling at the time - and if held just three years prior, of all time. WWF Champion Ric Flair Vs. Hulk Hogan never did happen. The subjective, hazy history yields an inconclusive account. Did the match fail to draw big on the house show loop? Was the finish too much of political minefield to navigate?

Had Vince McMahon, despite building Flair as Hogan's new nemesis on television, really promised Sid Justice the WrestleMania main event? Was he that entranced by the sweating beef of a potential long-term Hogan replacement?

It's probably the sweating beef, let's be honest.

Elsewhere, trouble swarmed the Hoosier Dome far more effectively than Papa Shango did; the WWF at large was mired in sexual and steroid scandal, and its roster found itself in controversy of their own making. Even the self-anointed kid-friendly hero (and consummate professional) Bret Hart contravened the rules, and bladed in his match with Roddy Piper.

The arrest of Marty Jannetty, who had attempted to assault a police officer outside of a nightclub in a cocaine-fuelled fracas, put paid to his grudge match with former Rockers partner Shawn Michaels.


6. Advances In Human Evolution (WrestleMania XXIV)

John Cena 2008 Royal Rumble
WWE.com

John Cena is, or was, a cyborg.

Defying modern medicine - in the era of the Wellness Policy, can you believe it?! - John Cena rehabilitated his torn-apart pectoral muscle within four months. Doctors had advised him that the process would take between seven months to a year. Cena, however, was an absolute freak in both his physical make-up and his mental determination to work tirelessly for the WWE cause.

He took the idea of being WWE's Ace with the utmost seriousness - if only he'd reflected this more often in his promos, instead of dissing those he probably should have built up as credible challengers - and this manifested as an unprecedented drive. Back to work! Those guys aren't gonna bury themselves!

His return, at the 2008 Royal Rumble pay-per-view, altered plans for the upcoming WrestleMania XXIV pay-per-view. Now, the title of this article specifically states 'Totally Changed'. We are aware of this. Things didn't "totally change" - Cena was merely tacked on to the mooted Triple H Vs. Randy Orton singles match - but any remotely fresh tweak on that Unholy Trinity of 2007-2008 felt like the dawn of a new f*cking era.

This also renders the events of WrestleMania 25 even more morbidly hilarious. WWE in effect "saved" the singles match for a further year, as if it had to be done.

As if another year of anticipation was the way to really put it over the top.


5. Film Awards Bodies (WrestleMania XXIV)

The Wrestler Mickey Rourke
Fox Searchlight

In which everyone lost.

Pro wrestling is largely considered an abomination of the arts by those who who operate within more "respectable" circles. It is absurd and fake and pitched exclusively to idiots...

...which is precisely why Darren Aronofsky's The Wrestler (2008) struck such a chord with critics. A moving portrait of modern Americana framed through a lens the arts crowd did not have to lower themselves to view, they praised its depiction of harrowing industry and the grim fates of those who broke themselves in pursuit of it. Impeccably stunt cast - his reconstructed face reflected the multiple lifetimes wrestlers of that era had endured - Mikey Rourke was nominated and tipped for the Best Actor Academy Award.

His flirtation with WWE, that was to be consummated with a match against Chris Jericho, allegedly turned off the Academy - and certainly Rourke's people, who warned him against the gig. Ultimately, everybody lost; the match didn't happen, Rourke didn't win, and we were subjected instead to the decrepit work of Roddy Piper and Jimmy Snuka in a bizarre three-on-one handicap undercard offering.

Happily, a survivor of that era, and an all-time great, Ricky Steamboat rolled back the years with an unexpectedly phenomenal performance in which he timed everything to babyface comeback perfection.


4. Shawn Michaels Being A Prick (WrestleMania 13)

Shawn Michaels Lost Smile
WWE Network

Shawn Michaels suffered a legitimate knee injury in the early spring of 1997. That wasn't in doubt; the extent, however, was.

As Dave Meltzer recounted in the Wrestling Observer, renowned orthopaedic surgeon Dr. Jim Andrews disclosed that it wouldn't require surgery, but rather four-to-six weeks of rehabilitation.

"The belief," Meltzer wrote, "is that it was something he could have continued to work on had he wanted to."

This was a time before wellness, much less Wellness with a capital W. Michaels himself worked through an in injury far more drastic and painful at the following year's WrestleMania, but with no Undertaker taping up his fists in '97, a teary-eyed, checked-out Michaels instead relinquished the WWF Heavyweight Title. He had lost his smile, infamously, but we're willing to bet he cracked one with Kliq buddy hunter Hearst Helmsley back in the motel room.

That is because he had successfully engineered his way out of doing a job, maintaining stunning form in that department - research the manner in which dropped titles throughout the 1990s for a wry laugh - and wreaked havoc on the WrestleMania 13 card.

Shawn's absence generated a wildly uneven show - an industry-defining classic of a Submissions match and a literal stinker, if we are to indulge an old urban legend - one that drew an abysmal buy rate, but ultimately restored the karmic balance a year later.


3. Shawn Stasiak Being A Dumbass (WrestleMania X-Seven)

Shawn Stasiak
WWE

Shawn Stasiak is a medical professional nowadays, which makes for frightening reading. The guy many entrust with healing their backs made a rod for his own throughout the Attitude Era with a super-dumbassed approach to backstage etiquette.

Wrestling is a secretive industry, even now, when there are few if any secrets to protect. There are things you simply do not do, and the very opposite of keeping it shtum - recording private conversations - is one of them. Booted from the WWF for this transgression, he was to return as part of an invading WCW faction under the most auspicious circumstances imaginable. Purportedly set to interfere in the Vince Vs. Shane McMahon match at WrestleMania X-Seven alongside several other 'WCW Wrestlers', Stasiak ruined the finish on a radio show, and naturally, furious management changed tack.

"Austin's gonna turn heel too, man. Come along! It's gonna be a hell of a show!"

Shawn Stasiak in effect ruined North American professional wrestling for 18 long years - and the man who couldn't keep his mouth shut is also a motivational speaker now, bloody hell.


2. Multiple Injuries (WrestleMania 32)

seth rollins injury
WWE.com

The WWE schedule is untenable, and it is untenable for all.

Demonstrably, hilariously at this point, Vince McMahon has neither the nous nor the patience to produce this many hours of coherent programming. The fandom cannot possibly care enough to invest in it, since his impulses converge to create an incomprehensible whole. And, all the while, the static cast of talent struggles to toil through it all, as their painstaking work is ignored by management or received ungratefully by us. It's almost as if we resent them for boring us, when they exist to wow us.

It is untenable. Nobody wins; 50/50 booking isn't just a symptom, it is a plague. A metaphor. This has been true for years, but it was particularly damning in 2016.

Seth Rollins, John Cena, Neville, Randy Orton, Cesaro and Luke Harper all missed WWE's biggest-ever super-show through injury, and the f*cking thing still lasted six and a half hours, inviting more flesh into the maw. With so few full-time performers at WWE's disposal, the Mad King took the decision to bring back the prodigal son.

Shane McMahon's return actually drew tens of thousands of punters, solidifying the "F*ck the guys who are around all the time lol" mentality. And now, they're f*cked.

Untenable.


1. The Gulf War (WrestleMania VII)

hulk hogan sgt slaughter
WWE.com

Quick question: Would you rather...

A) Read up on the increasingly dire India/Palestine conflict? It's fascinating, if grim; the latter nation has now threatened the former with, quote, a "surprise". The taunting, puffed-out chest language of stunted children, the tragic human toll, the generational determinism...it's all so awful, so helpless.

OR

B) Escape into a vibrant, technicolour world of simulated drama and epic, athletic theatre?

Well you're not reading the f*cking New York Times, and for that, there can be no blame.

The WWF attempted to capitalise on the Gulf War, ahead of WrestleMania VII, by pushing Sgt. Slaughter as an "Iraqi sympathiser". The role alienated the public. This was a monumental and calculable promotional error; the show, downscaled from a stadium to an arena, failed to draw interest because it brought into focus that which the public wished to escape. Besides which, the WWF didn't even appeal to the xenophobic crowd effectively, for Slaughter was a transparently phoney Boogeyman. Vince used the familiar - the white, let's face it - to mine fear of the "other". The passe foreign menace wasn't even foreign.

Deeply contrived, the WWF barely allowed themselves time to change the colour of the Ultimate Warrior's belt, too rushed to realise that the black strap at least reflected one colour of the Iraqi flag - and again, the promotional shots only served to underscore the vulturism of it all.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!