10 Times WWE Failed To Create Main Event Players
Making an ass out of the 'Ass Man' and other short (horror) stories...
Every wrestling fan has heard the same old phrases by now.
Superstar wannabes on the lower card must "reach out and grab that brass ring" or "break through the glass ceiling" if they want main event riches. This is a delicate procedure. Wrestlers can be as talented as they come, but there are still no concrete guarantees that they'll be able to transition smoothly from midcard solidity to main event glory for longer than a match or two.
Sometimes, WWE's probing outright fails to create headline attractions, and the reasons are as varied as the cast of characters featured here. A handful were ridiculously skilled workers, but just couldn't shatter the glass or grab some mythical bullsh*t ring due to all the obstacles in their way. After trying, they returned to their midcard berths or were repackaged for another go later.
Three of the 10 did go on to become World Champs without really sustaining the top tier momentum they should've. Don't be fooled into thinking this is all on creative either, because it's not. Don't worry though, they don't get off scot-free...
10. Test (1999)
There's an alternate dimension in which Test runs NXT, is married to Stephanie McMahon in real life and can look back on a trophy-laden career stacked with 14 World Titles. Maybe that would've been the ex-bodyguard's future had the WWF not aborted his push in 1999 and moved on without really giving him another go.
Before Triple H bounded out and scooped up Steph for himself, Test seemed destined for big things. He had a great look that Vince McMahon surely loved, was athletic for a dude his size and was young enough that the company could mould him how they wished. Post-marriage drama though, everything went to sh*t.
Test, who had soundly beaten Stephanie's brother Shane at SummerSlam and was slowly gaining traction with the fans, was moved into a tag team with Albert that only existed to highlight Trish Stratus' breasts (T&A). When the company were ready to try again mid-Invasion in 2001, it was too little, too late.
The guy didn't have top promo skills, but they gave up way too soon.
9. Ryback (2012-13)
In WWE land, "Feed Me More" translated to feeding Ryback less and hoping nobody would notice.
The Goldberg clone he played during his first few months as the character gave way to an emerging headline push opposite CM Punk and Paul Heyman's sovereignty over the WWE Title. That's when John Cena, a man who could make or break Ryback, came into things. He was the one who played cheerleader for Ryback at HIAC.
Following the Punk feud, Ryback weirdly lost to Mark Henry at WrestleMania 29, then turned heel and challenged Cena for the top belt. That was an arse-backwards way of getting to the rivalry, and it made poor Ryback look like a chump rather than potential champ. Try as Cena did after that, it was a lost cause.
Things got worse when WWE later turned Ryback into a schoolyard bully who'd intimidate production workers and other wrestlers. All his potential was squandered, first by an unnecessary heel turn and questionable losses, then a strange association with Heyman.
Six months later, Ryback was teaming with Curtis Axel as 'Ryb-Axel'. Yeah...
8. Rob Van Dam (2001/2002)
One can only guess that some within the WWF were intimidated when a handsome, popular and talented young Rob Van Dam joined the promotion post-ECW demise. He immediately became one of the darlings of the WCW/ECW Alliance, and it was clear that Rob had top line potential once the story was (mercifully) killed.
He did. RVD had main event ability coming out his ears.
Van Dam had proved it in matches against Jeff Hardy, Kurt Angle, Steve Austin, The Undertaker and more. By 2002, he was put back in the midcard as Intercontinental Champion; people didn't mind that because he was feuding with workers like Eddie Guerrero, William Regal and more, but there were questions about exactly when RVD would hit the big time permanently.
'02 wasn't the year, not quite. Despite feuding with Triple H for the World Title, dazzling every time he appeared on TV and receiving one of the biggest reactions going, Rob was doomed to play mid-level player in WWE. He'd have to wait until 2006 for his big title reign, and even that was a false dawn for personal reasons.
7. Christian (2005)
"Christian! Christian! At last you're on your own!".
Those opening lyrics to the ex-tag supremo's singles entrance theme were true for more reasons than just Christian breaking away from long-term associate Edge. He really was on his own, and that included separation from WWE's creative dept. They, guided by Vince McMahon, didn't see the Canadian as a big money player.
Bruce Prichard has been very open about this on his podcast over the past three years. According to him, everyone else in creative thought Christian could easily slot into one of the top positions on the card, challenge for World Title regularly and become a star. McMahon thought otherwise, partly 'cause he thought Christian was "ugly".
Rather than capitalising on his new 'Peep Show' talking segment, recognising that he was getting mega responses from crowds and harnessing the man's talents, WWE p*ssed Christian up against a wall. By late-2005, he was so frustrated that he engineered his WWE release and fled to TNA.
6. Bobby Lashley (2006-07)
It's 2019 and Bobby Lashley still sounds like he's gently scolding a puppy when he's angry in promos.
Some wrestlers don't have much in the way of verbals skills, and Lashley is one of them. He looks like he could crush a car with his bare hands physically, but there's no natural charisma to Bobby. That was something WWE learned first hand when they tried to turn the legitimately impressive athlete, fighter and specimen into a main eventer in 2006-07.
Fans, though taken by Lashley's look every bit as much as Vince McMahon was, couldn't shake the feeling that this felt forced. There was no organic connection between wrestler and audience, which is a fatal flaw WWE neither spotted early enough nor worked hard to put right. Throwing Donald Trump in his corner wasn't enough.
Bobby wasn't the ECW Champion a hardcore fanbase (still clinging to the thought that things might turn around with the brand again) wanted either. When he took time off for surgery in 2007, WWE realised they weren't missing anything and released him before he returned.
5. Owen Hart (1997-98)
If nothing else, the controversial 'Montreal Screwjob' of Bret Hart at the 1997 Survivor Series should've given his brother Owen some renegade babyface momentum. At first, it did. Fans were into the idea of seeing a bitter Owen, named the 'Black Hart' by announcers, avenge what Vince McMahon and Shawn Michaels had done to his family.
By mid-1998, Owen was a member of the Nation Of Domination. OK then.
The WWF chose to downplay Hart's rebel-with-nothing-to-lose persona and program him with Michaels' DX pal Triple H instead. Worse, they tied a tired Sgt. Slaughter issue with the group to the feud as well, instantly diluting fan interest in Owen's story. It was a frankly crap decision.
When Owen should've been targeting those who had wronged his family, he was happy to go for the European Title and then join a militant faction. This is proof that not everything in the Attitude era was gold. This flat booking was 10x sh*ttier than the nugget HBK compared Hart to.
4. Jack Swagger (2010)
It's not hard to see why Jim Ross and other WWE chiefs were so enamoured with Jack Swagger when they headhunted him then signed him to a deal in 2006. Boasting size, a chiselled jawline and amateur wrestling accolades, Swagger seemed like a star of the future. He, much like most others on this list, had his limitations.
Promos, mainly.
Admittedly, WWE made matters harder for Swagger when they booked him to cash in MITB 24 hours after winning the thing at WrestleMania XXVI. That left Jack looking like a transitional champ who'd only beaten Chris Jericho because he had the element of surprise. That may have been fine for an opportunistic heel like Edge, but it didn't suit Swags.
His character relied on the notion that he dominated because of physical attributes and a will to win. By stripping those away, booking shock as the only reason for his success and then forcibly adding gimmicks ('Swagger's Soaring Eagle'), his main event aspirations and brief title reign were doomed.
3. Hardcore Holly (2004)
Bob Holly's sudden main event push seemed late even for 2004.
This was a guy who'd been on the company map for a decade and had always been portrayed as a plucky midcard act who was notoriously tough. Wiry and ballsy though Hardcore was, he wasn't realistically a match for a mega-star pet project like Brock Lesnar. Fans knew it, and (if they were being honest) so did WWE.
That wouldn't stop them from trying to convince everyone that the former Sparky Plugg was on Brock's level before the 2004 Royal Rumble. In fairness, the feud was based around Lesnar's vicious, neck-breaking Powerbomb in 2002, so it had some reality to it. Even so, Bob vs. Brock wasn't a winner on pay-per-view, and Holly's headline push wasn't sustainable.
When the Lesnar feud ended, Hardcore had nothing else to do at the top of the card, and he dwindled back down to where he'd been for years. It was a worthwhile experiment, but that was about it for Holly's main event run.
2. Billy Gunn (1999)
The problem with some of The Rock's scathing babyface promos during his prime was that he was often bang on with his criticism. That was the case when Billy Gunn won the 1999 King Of The Ring and the WWF dabbled with a top line push for the former New Age Outlaw. What did the people think of this?
Same as Rocky, probably.
According to big Dwayne Johnson, Gunn still 'absolutely sucked'. Behind the scenes, The Rock wasn't sold on the thought of working with Billy either, and that was problematic. On top of all that, Bruce Prichard and Jim Ross have dished details on Gunn's asthma issues; they stopped him from working long matches as a singles star.
Everything was working against 'Mr. Ass' here in '99. Once Rock had dispatched him at SummerSlam in a suspect, by-the-numbers 'Kiss My Ass' match, it was back to the midcard for Billy. The WWF's plan to turn him into a heel sensation in the upper deck had failed, and they quickly reformed the Outlaws a few months later.
1. Mabel (1995)
1995: King Of The Ring's disaster piece, a desperate year for star power and a financial flub of a 12 months for the WWF as they scrambled to find something, anything that'd drag them out of the doldrums. Presumably, that's why Vinnie Mac leaned on the kind of monster heel he'd churned out to oppose Hulk Hogan in the '80s.
All hail 'King' Mabel, a character you'd be forgiven for thinking was some sick joke.
As if it wasn't bad enough that Mabel worked twice on pay-per-view at KOTR (including a grossly unpopular win over The Undertaker), his push continued afterwards. This newly-minted main eventer was scheduled to face Diesel at SummerSlam '95 for the WWF Title, and everyone collectively groaned at the thought. Kevin Nash was likely one of them.
McMahon did everything he could think of to make Mabel work for a few insane months. Becoming 'King', beating 'Taker, headlining one of the biggest events of the year and generally pushing him to the moon didn't fly with fans however. They could see through the bumbling, dangerous heel's bump up the card, and they weren't keen to encourage it.
-
What other instances can you think of when WWE failed to turn someone into a sustainable headliner? Let us know down in the comments section below!