10 Times WWE Punished Success
That's a nice push. It'd be a shame if someone just crapped all over it...

Like any business, WWE is geared towards making money. That's the end goal in everything the company does, or it's supposed to be, at least. Sometimes, other factors tend to get in the way of that. Oh yes, it's time to talk about good ol' wrestling politics, and the senseless way in which they undermine success.
In a perfect world, they wouldn't. This, as everyone knows by now, isn't a perfect world.
It's not quite as easy as Wrestler A convincing creative that they deserve a push and getting one. It's not even as simple as Wrestler A showing initiative, getting over completely on their own and then receiving the plaudits that should come with such gumption in-house. All too often, wrestlers are punished for their achievements, and it rarely (if ever) makes much sense why.
At one point, everyone on this list had some momentum or the potential to create it. Then, as if WWE resented what they were doing, these stars were stomped all over for having the audacity to show resourcefulness. This asinine approach has ruined a lot of unexpected money-making opportunities...
10. Daniel Puder

Heck only knows what WWE were hoping to achieve here.
To anyone watching, Hardcore Holly, Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero came across as bitter high-school bullies who begrudged a young rookie getting his first big opportunity. So, live on pay-per-view at the 2005 Royal Rumble, all three chopped the living p*ss out of Daniel Puder and left his chest looking like mincemeat.
This was blatantly a punishment for Puder's prior cheek. He'd made Kurt Angle look foolish during a shoot segment on SmackDown in November 2004, and thus he apparently deserved to be punished. There's just one big problem with that: WWE were silly enough to book some real sparring on the show, but they weren't willing to reward Puder for succeeding afterwards.
Once he'd humbled an Olympian on TV, his name was mud internally. Two months after making a mockery of Angle's challenge, Puder was unceremoniously thumped by three veterans on one of the biggest shows of the year. So much for showing he was Tough Enough.
9. Fandango

Certain gimmicks come with an expected shelf life, and Fandango's dancing fool persona was one of those predicted to burn out quickly. It was a quick fix for former NXT man Johnny Curtis, and it'd end up being an albatross around his neck more than a pat on the back. He's absolutely not to blame for that.
Success is.
It's like WWE panicked when Fandango, fresh off a win over Chris Jericho at WrestleMania 29, suddenly became the post-'Mania Raw's hot topic. Fans belted out his catchy theme tune for the entire duration of the show, often interrupting matches and other segments to sing, "Dooo-do! Do do do-do dooo, do-do-do!" all night.
That wasn't in company plans, and neither was some surprise chart success for the song over in the UK. Almost embarrassed by their 'Dancing With The Stars' wannabe and how he had become an unlikely babyface sensation, WWE creative pulled the plug and dropped Fandango's push.
8. Rusev

Congratulations for reading this article on 'Rusev Day'. What a blessed day it is. Buy the t-shirt from WWE Shop. Hell, buy a couple of the things, but don't dare overshadow others by treating the man who invented it like he's a bigger star than he is during episodes of Raw and SmackDown. Don't dare.
That was the attitude towards Rusev and his mock holiday when the Bulgarian's comedic routine resonated with fans in 2017. Oddly, the gimmick was born from a legit event; Rusev returned to his hometown of Plovdiv and was handed a key to the city by the mayor. This is something WWE rightly decided to capitalise on by showing footage.
Then, they decided to "machka" his push when fans ran with it.
Rather than giving Rusev a thumbs up for making something out of nothing and creating merch dollars aplenty, the promotion's top brass decided this whole 'Rusev Day' thing was a nuisance. They squashed the potential for a hot babyface run quickly because it didn't fit into plans to keep Rusev as a midcard heel.
7. Bart Gunn

The 'Brawl For All' remains one of the most stupid, ill-conceived ideas in WWE history. Promoting genuine fights amongst worked ones was silly enough, but then the company failed to follow up on their tough man contest at all. You see, they'd hoped new hire 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams would blast through the competition.
Doc didn't. Bart Gunn, a nondescript, tough tag wrestler, did.
Gunn won all of his fights, beating Bob Holly, Williams, The Godfather and Bradshaw to become the first (and only) champion. Instead of using this sudden, accidental success to their advantage on the wrestling side of things, WWF chiefs elected to program Bart opposite Butterbean, a man who earned a living from knocking schmucks out, at WrestleMania XV; even if hopes were high that Gunn might do well in the fight and the WWF didn't consider this spot a punishment per sé, it was misplaced confidence.
Besides, this probably wouldn't have happened to Dr. Death had he won the tourney. Talk was that Williams would've gone on to receive a big push on the wrestling side of things, possibly against Steve Austin. Gunn didn't get that spot. He ate canvas in 35 seconds on the biggest show of the year instead.
6. Tazz

You'd have to go some to find a more convincing debut than the one enjoyed by Tazz at the 2000 Royal Rumble. In a little over three minutes, the ECW incomer was booked to be the federation's new hard man. He creamed Olympic hero Kurt Angle and sent Madison Square Garden into raptures with a bevy of stiff suplexes.
Shame he wasn't 6' 5".
The rap sheet on Tazz shortly after his intro was a depressing read. Reports began circulating that he was deemed "too small" to be a credible headliner in the WWF, and all his menace evaporated when the 'Human Suplex Machine' was demoted to the afterthought Hardcore Title division. So much for that.
Everyone knew Tazz wasn't the biggest when he signed with the WWF, but he had an aura about him that needed protecting. The WWF had a different plan. They'd punish him for a fiery, successful debut performance by dropping him down the card to feud with announcers before becoming one himself.
5. Neville

WWE's revamped Cruiserweight division was a purple-roped joke before Neville bagged the belt at the 2017 Royal Rumble. Unlike previous champs TJP, The Brian Kendrick and Rich Swann, this surly Englishman came armed with a cerebral strategy that'd turn Cruiser chaos into Cruiser consolidation.
Rethought as the 'King Of The Cruiserweights', Neville started cutting career-best promos and showed personality few inside WWE knew he had. Almost overnight, he went from high-flying jobber-to-the-stars to bona fide heel badass. His two stints with the title (interrupted by a meaningless six-day run for Akira Tozawa) saved the entire concept of 205 Live.
'Thanks, but no thanks', said WWE.
After Neville had worked tirelessly to get the Cruiserweight idea over, creative pivoted towards Enzo Amore and replaced their 'King'. Just like that, months of hard work were thrown away. No wonder Neville was p*ssed at his position in the company.
4. Damien Sandow

The hilarious 'Twice In A Lifetime' branding could describe Damien Sandow's career better than any John Cena vs. The Rock rematch. WWE pulled the rug on him twice, and it was totally avoidable both times. The first occasion came when Sandow won Money In The Bank in 2013 and then dropped his leather-bound briefcase and the guaranteed title run that came with it like a klutz.
If that was a stubbed toe, then the next failure must've been a lopped off arm.
Rescuing his career from the brink of irrelevance, Sandow got himself over as The Miz's stunt double. He even carried around a mini version of the Intercontinental Title and willingly played the class clown for fans who lapped up his silliness. The story needed progression from there, and it didn't get any.
Sandow, who was blatantly more over than his on/off tag partner, was promptly returned to lower card hell when WWE didn't fancy a prolonged feud between star and stunt double. They chucked the whole idea down the drain by booking both into the Battle Royal at WrestleMania 31 before swiftly moving on.
3. Daniel Bryan

WWE really tried with Daniel Bryan. They really, really tried to resist pushing him despite countless live crowds chanting his name relentlessly in between epic sessions of, "Yes! Yes! Yes!". Bryan had been so entertaining alongside Kane as 'Team Hell No', and he was so obviously one of the best in-ring workers under contract. People spotted that, and they wanted him to get his just desserts.
They'd have to wait.
The story of "B+ Player" Daniel squaring up to The Authority that ran between SummerSlam 2013-WrestleMania XXX was awesome at times. It successfully turned Bryan into a made man, but it's easy to be cynical and claim it wasn't 100% intentional. At times, including when he was replaced by Big Show at Survivor Series, it seemed like WWE wanted fans to move on from Dan.
That "B+" angle didn't seem to be fake. Looking back now, there's a sense that WWE gave in to dogged fan demands more than embracing the idea that Daniel Bryan could be the man in their company. They tried to sidestep with Show, put Bryan in The Wyatt Family briefly and also attempted to fool people with a Batista comeback.
2. Zack Ryder

There may never be a bigger example of someone showing initiative than Zack Ryder. He was the first to jump on the YouTube craze in WWE, and that platform helped him get over with an army of fans who didn't see him much on regularly-scheduled programming. That's because Zacky boy wasn't considered anything more than auxiliary.
His online show, 'Z! True Long Island Story' pre-dated modern phenomenons like 'Being The Elite' by almost a decade. Ryder showed balls, creativity and personality in his vids, so much so that fans started to take notice and chant, "We Want Ryder" incessantly at shows. This led to a mini-wave of love that forced WWE's hand.
The troubles started when Ryder began interacting with top names like John Cena on TV. He was never presented on an even keel with anyone, including Eve Torres; WWE's plan was to make Zack a lovable idiot who had lucked out rather than worked hard.
He was briefly spotlighted then cruelly discarded back to the undercard after months of poor booking killed momentum he'd created.
1. Kofi Kingston

SummerSlam 2019's feud between Kofi Kingston and Randy Orton relies on their history as enemies. Back in 2009, Randy cut the legs out from underneath Kofi when he was heating up, and it's taken the one-time phoney Jamaican nearly 10 years to scramble his way back to the top.
Who knows how different things could've been had Orton not been on a power trip.
In November 2009, Kofi blasted Randy through a table in the hallowed halls of Madison Square Garden and looked every bit like WWE's next babyface hit. His main event run was virtually guaranteed at that moment, and fans responded in kind to Kingston dropping the Jamaican accent, ruining Randy's sports car and cutting some seriously good promos.
It all went to sh*t when Kofi botched an RKO finish, Orton spat his dummy and the entitled headliner complained to management that Kingston wasn't ready. They listened when they should have persevered, and the successful run Kofi was on dried up quick. He was punished for the smallest of incidents.
-
When else has WWE punished success? Let us know your thoughts and memories down in the comments section!