10 Times WWE Revived AWFUL Storylines

Some feuds should have been allowed to rest in peace. Sadly Vince disagreed.

The Fiend On Fire
WWE.com

Vince McMahon and WWE are not always very quick on the uptake. There is an entire catalogue of feuds and characters that massively overstayed their welcome despite the fans clearly rejecting the idea. Men in turkey costumes emerging out of eggs, getting Roman Reigns over as a heroic babyface, Lana’s love affair with the announce table, the list goes on. This gets even stranger though.

Because over the years there have been plenty of situations where WWE initially realized an angle was rubbish and binned it, only to revive it in the future for no good reason.

For some unexplained cause, the mad old brain of Vince McMahon thought dumpster fires like the Randy Orton-Bray Wyatt feud, or the constantly under-delivering Jeff-Matt Hardy rivalry, or the long expired babyface vs heel authority figure storylines deserved another go, despite all evidence being to the contrary.

No one other than the boss will ever know the reason why. But what we can do is go through these pointless resurrections and list them in order of most undeserved. These are 10 times WWE revived awful storylines that really should have allowed to rest in peace.

10. Ronda Rousey Vs Nia Jax

WWE TLC 2018 Nia Jax Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Now credit where it’s due, the matches between the two were fine on both occasions. However the feud itself simply did not merit any kind of reboot.

In mid-2018, after her pretty sensational debut at WrestleMania, Ronda Rousey found herself in a championship storyline for the first time. It came about in odd fashion when then Raw Women’s Champion Nia Jax simply approached her at a WWE event and proposed they fight for the title. A slightly flustered Rousey accepted the challenge, as Charlotte Flair of all people bizarrely cheered this whole thing on.

The two met at Money in the Bank where the match ended in a DQ following an Alexa Bliss cash in. This would seem to be the end of the feud, as Rousey then entered a program with Bliss; one that would eventually end with her coronation as Women’s Champion.

However, right at the end of the year WWE revived the Jax-Rousey rivalry, the former being a heel this time around. The story wasn’t anything special before, and it certainly wasn’t any better the second time.


9. Jeff Hardy Vs Matt Hardy

Jeff Hardy Matt Hardy Backlash 2009 I Quit
WWE.com

Right so on paper this should have been pure fire. One of the greatest tag teams ever, two of the most sensational performers of all time, and a real life sibling rivalry to boot. Surely Jeff Hardy vs Matt Hardy should have blown the roof off of every arena that was lucky enough to witness them go at it. Sadly that never quite materialized.

Somehow their feuds never reached the heights everyone thought they would. They butted heads in 2001 which led to an uninspiring encounter at Vengeance. The storyline also centered around Lita and her torn loyalty. Once the dust had settled, it served as a clear sign that a feud between the two is probably not the best idea.

Still WWE gave this another go in 2009 when Matt Hardy was revealed to be the one trying to KILL Jeff. This time the story was far too close to Jeff’s real life struggles for anyone to enjoy. Their match at WrestleMania 25 was pretty good. But still, just like before, it was nowhere near what fans would have hoped for.


8. Big Show Vs Randy Orton

Big Show Randy Orton
WWE

Another pairing that never really came off, Big Show Randy Orton feuds have always seemed to placeholders at best; a means of killing some screen time before more important stuff kicks off.

They feuded in 2013 when Big Show was part of the whole Authority angle. You know when he was forced to punch Dusty Rhodes and screw over Daniel Bryan because Triple H threatened to fire him. Unsurprisingly enough, this led to him challenging the Face of the Authority or WWE or whatever it was, Randy Orton, for his WWE Championship. No one believed Show had any real chance. And sure enough he lost.

Fast forward to 2020, the two butted heads again. This time it was during Orton’s Legend Killer rampage where he was trying to kill every legend he could find. Once more it was just a way of keeping the Edge-Orton hype alive by having the Viper take out another future Hall of Famer.


7. Bobby Lashley Vs Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

Yet again, on paper this feud should have been very good. No one does the cowardly heel gimmick better than Sami Zayn right now. Bobby Lashley as the unstoppable monster babyface who just can’t get his hands on the slippery heel should have been the ideal foil. Yet despite all the pieces being in place this never delivered.

Following WrestleMania 34, Lashley made his return to WWE and soon found himself in this program with Zayn. It never clicked. The final nail in the coffin was that awful segment on Raw where Zayn brought out a bunch of dudes dressed as Bobby’s sisters.

This would not however stop WWE from reigniting this feud in 2020 where Zayn and Lashley collided as opposing champions representing their brands as part of T-shirt festi…Brand Warfare. It was marginally better this time around, which is not saying much.


6. Daniel Bryan Vs Sheamus

Daniel Bryan Sheamus WrestleMania 28
WWE.com

People often accuse WWE of lacking patience. Not here though. They tried this feud again and again and again. Unfortunately it never seemed to click, despite the obvious talent involved.

Daniel Bryan is one of the greatest wrestlers of his generation. Sheamus is perhaps one of the most underrated of his. But when pitted against one another, the storylines and the matches never quite delivered.

They butted heads over the United States title in 2010, where the Irishman even put his career on the line at one point. Despite their best efforts they could only earn a spot on the WrestleMania XVII pre-show. And even that ended in a DQ.

WWE rebooted the feud in 2012, this time with the World Heavyweight Championship being up for grabs. Any chance of it being cherished by fans was dashed when WWE for some reason decided to make Bryan lose in 18 seconds on the Grandest Stage of Them All.

The third time wasn’t the charm either as the 2015 iteration of the feud, this time over the IC title, was cut short because of Bryan’s then career ending injury. Sigh.


5. Kane Vs The Shield Members

kane seth rollins
WWE.com

Technically this covers multiple feuds. But since the original feud involved all four men, it just about qualifies.

In early 2014, the Shield had begun inching towards their first ever face turn. The driving force behind it was then Director of Operations, Corporate Kane. They clashed over the Shield’s wavering loyalty towards the dark side. Kane was convinced they would soon turn on the Authority.

It was a bit of a nothing feud, though it did culminate in that highly entertaining squash at WresleMania XXX where the Hounds of Justice demolished Kane and the New Age Outlaws.

This would not be the last of it, however. Throughout the years, Kane in his various forms would continue to feud with the Shield members, long after the latter had disbanded. He challenged Seth Rollins for his WWE World Heavyweight Championship, fought Reigns in a series of encounters following the original breakup, and had a fair few run-ins with Ambrose. Finally he engaged in one last rivalry with the whole group when joining forces with the Miz and Braun Strowman.

None of these however were anything to write home about.


4. Kane Vs Rey Mysterio

kane rey mysterio
WWE.com

It’s not really any surprise seeing Kane pop up on this list multiple times. After all he was part of several of the dumbest angles WWE have done. This is certainly not a rib on the Big Red Machine. He is without a doubt one of the greatest wrestling characters of all time. And no matter how bizarre these stories got, he always threw himself at them with everything.

In 2008, Kane began carrying a mysterious sack, while continuously repeating the words, “ is he alive or is he dead?”. This was eventually revealed to be Rey Mysterio’s mask. For some unexplained reason, Kane had apparently tried to kill the Master of the 619.

The two had their feud, which also went through a World Heavyweight Championship Scramble match at Unforgiven that year, but it was hardly blowing the roof off arenas. The confusing narrative only made it harder to invest in.

Come 2010, WWE were in the mood to give this another try. Weirdly enough, the backstory was yet again centered around attempted murder. This time Kane had tried to murder his brother the Undertaker and framed Mysterio for it. That’s right, Rey Mysterio was accused of putting the Undertaker in a vegetative state.

The World Title was also in the mix, as Kane cashed in his Money in the Bank contract to take the belt off Rey. The end result was more or less the same as fans simply waited for this to end so the Undertaker could make his return.


3. The Undertaker Vs CM Punk

CM Punk Undertaker
WWE

This simply should not be on a list such as this. Two of the best personalities in WWE history, anything involving these two should have been magic. But the storylines and the some of the execution was just so bad.

Their first feud came in 2009, which saw Taker go after Punk and his World Heavyweight Championship. In what was yet another case of WWE kicking Punk to the curb despite all his star potential, this was a complete burial program for the Straight Edge champion.

He won a Submissions Match against Taker after Teddy Long of all people conducted a screwjob. Then he was utterly destroyed inside Hell in a Cell, thus ending his reign.

WWE did not learn their lesson from this and decided to make Undertaker-Punk one of the main programs heading into WrestleMania. Now yes the match they had here was absolutely incredible and deserved to end the show. But there is no getting away from the atrocious story that WWE told which saw Punk narrow all his focus on desecrating the name of the recently deceased Paul Bearer.


2. Hulk Hogan Vs The Undertaker

The Undertaker Hulk Hogan 1991
WWE

This didn’t work in the early 90s. A decade later this didn’t work in the early 2000s either.

Undertaker and Hulk Hogan are two of the biggest names in all of wrestling. Many would place these two on their Mt. Rushmore of pro wrestling. A chance to see the two titans lock horns should have been something every fan cherished. While the rivalries certainly were heavily anticipated and involved high stakes, the execution was never quite right.

In late 1991, Undertaker became involved in the Hogan-Flair tussle and found himself in a title match against the Hulkster. He won the match thanks to some Flair interference. It hardly felt like a monumental changing of the guards and was reduced to a complete farce when the Deadman simply lost the title back to Hogan 6 days later.

Fast forward to 2002, WWF gave it another go. This time it was the Big Evil going up against Hollywood Hogan. The Undisputed Championship was also up for brags. Once more Undertaker defeated the Immortal One, albeit in a match that featured the worst-Chokeslam-ever. Much like before, it didn't leave any lasting impressions on the audience’s minds. At least not of the desirable kind.


1. Bray Wyatt Vs Randy Orton

Bray Wyatt Randy Orton
WWE

Anything that involves one man burning down another man’s shack is either going to be incredible or absolutely terrible. For Randy Orton versus Bray Wyatt in 2017, it was the latter.

The two shared a long running storyline with quite a slow burn. It started with Randy Orton being in the crosshairs of Bray Wyatt, who soon turned to his former Wyatt Family cohorts for support. This then led to Wyatt courting Orton to join his side; an offer the Viper took up.

Of course this was only a ruse. Orton eventually turned on Wyatt and burned down the Wyatt Family home, or everyone presumed it was their home. The big payoff was a WWE Championship match at WrestleMania 33. Unfortunately that didn’t deliver either, mainly because Wyatt tried to beat Orton using spider holograms.

As ever, WWE refused to let it lie. 3 years later in 2020, the Legend Killer and the now rechristened Fiend Bray Wyatt are going at it in a rivalry that is even more bonkers than the previous one. The arson has now given way to outright murder using fire. The rivalry is still alive as we speak, despite the Fiend being very much dead. Only time will if it ends any better than last time.


Contributor
Contributor

After battling Galactus and pinning Hulk Hogan in the main event of Wrestlemania, I've taken a break from living in fantasy worlds, to focus on writing about them. I'm a comic book geek, a wrestling mark, a break dancer, and a scientist. One of those things may not be true.