10 Times WWE Totally Changed Its In-Ring Style

A blooming Sahara.

Eddie Guerrero Kurt Angle
WWE.com

The 'WWE style' has obviously shifted over the years - Giant Gonzalez wasn't out there on Superstars doing suicide dives to segue to the commercial break - but it retains what is often a pejorative connotation at its core.

The WWE style, relative to the wider landscape, is safe and comprehensible. It's how they hooked the kids all those years ago: with theatrical, histrionic performances that didn't require a deep knowledge or understanding of the craft. That would have undermined the aim; Hulk Hogan fought for the rights of every man, which wouldn't have worked had he lost them.

It's also how Vince McMahon made much of his vast fortune, before the paradigm shifted: the touring schedules that only now can be described as "old" were torturous; to withstand them, a certain way of working was enforced. What was earnest and magic in the 1980s resonates as patronising and boring now. We know the roster is capable of so much more - only the hardcore fans that remain have seen it before, exposing WWE's approach and informing its viewership decline - but they mostly aren't allowed to show it.

The monopoly bred an arrogance and contempt for the pro wrestling WWE's sports entertainment dominated so thoroughly, and that pro wrestling has to "scratch and claw" to break through...

10. Randy Savage Vs. Ricky Steamboat - WrestleMania III

Savage Steamboat
WWE

A sacrosanct match that, while incredible, is perhaps more remarkable in context.

The mid-'80s WWF boasted some tremendous workers, particularly in the tag team ranks, but a match of this technical quality and profile was virtually unprecedented; the prevailing fashion was of heavily muscled men overcoming sneaky or elephantine heels in hair-shaking audience begs. The WrestleMania III Intercontinental Title match paved the future in content and approach.

Worked with a sense of furious tension and advanced craft, it never relented from a white-hot opening salvo. Deftly incorporating the stark moral contrasts and theatrical outside shenanigans that defined the WWF style, this was an unforgettable and electrifying pure wrestling/sports entertainment hybrid. Steamboat's strategy to lull Savage into those beautiful arm drags - contrasted with Savage's deceit to pummel his back with those running knees - remains a total joy, all these years later.

Moreover, Savage and Steamboat essentially rewrote the administration of a professional wrestling match by laying out move for move ahead of it in a practise that, while the norm now, was frowned upon as a betrayal of wrestling's extemporaneous performance art spirit.


9. WrestleMania X

Bret Owen WrestleMania
WWE.com

Bret Hart had worked several sumptuous, decidedly non-Hogan matches well before 1994. Shawn Michaels had shown serious glimpses of an ability to challenge his throne as the top guy of what would be marketed imminently as the New Generation.

The triumph that was WrestleMania X marked the night it all come together; "it" being, and this was an incredible claim to make at any point in the 1980s, the WWF's ascent to the throne of the best in-ring North American promotion.

Bret Hart and brother Owen worked one of the all-time great WWF matches, one that incorporated gorgeous flexing technicality, high emotion and combustible brawl elements into its own distinct, stirring story of an older brother remonstrating with - and helplessly exploding on - his younger brother.

In the other legendary attraction, Razor Ramon won the undisputed Intercontinental Title in a groundbreaking Ladder match with Shawn Michaels. A tremendous match in its violence, drama, and spectacle, it informed a new genre of WWE's in-ring storytelling: the weapons match as an organic extension of a trad wrestling encounter, as opposed to a plunder brawl.

Before the Attitude Era lowered the tone, and the quality, the New Generation saw the WWF dominate a (healthy) North American in-ring scene for the first and only time.


8. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind - WWF In Your House: Mind Games

Mankind Shawn Michaels Mind Games
WWE.com

In 1995, Bret Hart and Diesel had tapped the wall of the WWE style by destroying the Spanish announce table for the first time.

At In Your House: Mind Games, Mankind and Shawn Michaels tore it down and the load it bore, collapsing the foundation and rearranging it in a new ultra-violent image.

The Firefly Fun House match drew awe-struck critical praise for its audacious and cathartic take-down of the John Cena myth. The main event of Mind Games followed a similar narrative path, but was actually told through the medium of a total banger of a professional wrestling match: Mankind evoked the vicious, combative side from Michaels, and it surfaced in an intoxicating and innovative war that rewarded the hardcore fan in virtually every sense. Michaels really was that man, and he worked the match like a strongly motivated version of the 1997 vintage; the brutal, destructive action was an insane spectacle the likes of which 'The Fed' were perceived as too cartoonish to deliver; and, in one awesome spot, Michaels worked the meltdown he had legit suffered the prior month at SummerSlam.

Convincing, unhinged and artful, this drafted the blueprints for the best of the Attitude Era.


7. Aja Kong Vs. Chaparita Asari - RAW November 12 1995

Aja Kong
WWE

Twitter is a hellscape of an app that stinks of the piss of its endless contests, but it's good for the odd meme and reappraising certain wrestlers and certain eras.

The Barbarian and Lex Luger have developed a cult retrospective acclaim years removed from the gimmicks and fashion trends that had mothballed their work. Davey Richards has emerged to receive his due credit as a genuinely terrific pro wrestler once damned by the self-indulgence and fired-up no-selling that is so prevalent now.

Perhaps one day this will create a new lens through which to analyse the WWF Women's scene of the mid-'90s which, while a one-dimensional vehicle to push Alundra Blayze, yielded some very good matches. The terrifying Bull Nakano was, ironically, a joy to watch, and brought with scary physicality a level of creativity and technique that far outstripped all but the elite male talents contracted at the time.

But Aja Kong Vs. Chaparita Asari is such a crazed outlier in WWE's canon that it gets over in cult circles as a fantastic, ghoulish aberration. Asari in an early, desperate bid for control unleashed a series of innovative, athletic strikes the likes of which haven't been since before Kong used her drastic power advantage to effectively kill her to death with a series of gruesome moves one will never see in a WWE ring ever again.

For one weird night, WWE distilled the diverse joy of joshi in four fabulously macabre minutes.


6. Shotgun Saturday Night

Shotgun Saturday Night
WWE

The WWF knew change was necessary; they just didn't know how to effect it. With Shotgun Saturday Night, they stumbled in the dark down the correct path.

It was all very, very 1997: a melting pot of new ideas sat uneasily alongside the fading New Generation with a southern-fried rock theme in the age of Korn. In one episode, broadcast from the All-Star Cafe in Times Square, the wholesome dork that was Todd Pettengill ostensibly called Sunny a slut as the fake Diesel worked 'Wildman' Marc Mero before white hip-hop cosplayers PG-13 introduced the Black Panthers-inspired Nation of Domination.

There was much to take in, and with a new environment unlocked, the encouraged creativity manifested with new slants on the old way of wrestling. This was a show shaped by its environment and "late nite" pass.

Steve Austin and Terry Funk waged war in a bar room; Mankind and Bret Hart worked something that more resembled an ECW match with a referee more lenient than he would have been, were he surrounded by thousands in the traditional arena; and the Undertaker, of course, infamously dropped Triple H with a Tombstone piledriver down an escalator.

Shotgun Saturday Night was almost DDT before DDT was created.


5. Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin - WrestleMania 13

Shamrock, Bret Hart, Austin
WWE.com

The most intimidating match ever to write about, for fear of disrespecting its profound brilliance and influence, Bret Hart and Steve Austin changed everything in March 1997 - even if it took some time before its gravity informed the events to come.

On a purely stylistic level, the structure and stipulation inspired much of the Attitude Era and the eras that followed. The scorching early brawling sequences (worked with incredible inspiration) put over the animosity at the heart of the rivalry, literally confronting the crowd with the decision they would soon have to make. This device was plundered by virtually every limited hardcore wrestler two years later. The pronounced submission element was a departure for the WWF, but Hart, a genius, orchestrated a molten crowd response without leaning on the pavlovian near-fall.

On a story level, the detail and artistry remains unsurpassed. Hart was so incredible at gradually turning - the imperceptible viciousness, the uncanny knack of revealing opportunism to be something that bit more sinister - that he and an equal Austin, with perhaps the greatest sell-job ever, told the impossible story.

Oddly, WWE rarely embraced its most powerful and effective choice - to book Austin to lose cleanly in show of unreal guts - instead opting in later years to contrive losses to the point of grotesque parody.


4. Steve Austin Vs. Dude Love - Over The Edge 1998

Stone Cold Steve Austin Dude Love
WWE

The TV built the pay-per-view, the pay-per-view settled the TV. That was old, pre-1998 formula the WWF destroyed, wonderfully, at Over The Edge 1998.

The Attitude Era undergoes a fluctuation of appraisal years removed from it. Was it a hot main event scene with rotten, unwatchable dreck on the undercard? Was the booking a necessary and compelling move away from a tired pattern, or a nonsensical excuse to strip women of their clothes and dignity? Has it aged as badly as the music that soundtracked so many of its video packages?

Is the Attitude Era the nu-metal of professional wrestling?

When Steve Austin was anywhere near it, it rolled with the timeless thunder of Pantera. His match - his spectacle, his attraction - with Dude Love at Over The Edge remains the apex of the whole damn thing. Hilarious and violent without compromising either tone, this ultra-gimmicked war fused the incredible TV plotting of the greatest feud ever in Austin Vs. McMahon with a molten, elite-calibre PPV brawl.

A profoundly creative exercise with a constantly unfolding tension/release cycle, this twisting main event distilled all that is great about pro wrestling, much the less the particular era of it.


3. The Two Extremes Of The Post-Attitude Era

Eddie Guerrero Chris Benoit
WWE

This spiritual split happened literally across flagship programmes RAW and SmackDown.

The crazed arena-wide brawling of the Attitude Era settled down, after the WWF botched the Invasion, and a sort of civil war gathered pace in the company between the stalwarts and the technical studs. On RAW, the Undertaker and Triple H held down the fort - very tediously, on the "strength" of King Of The Ring 2002. Trips worked as more pupil than student of the game, misapplying the lessons of the past under the belief that an inverted Indian death lock made him 1986 Ric Flair.

On SmackDown, the talent, conditioning and diverse disciplines of its star "six" saw the WWF, at it most stagnant creatively in years, hark eerily back to the New Generation by drawing a similar level of critical acclaim. Edge honed his defensive counter-wrestling brilliance; Rey Mysterio adapted his gorgeous lucha libre flourishes into a total winner of an underdog babyface role; Eddie Guerrero infused the scene with lashings of technical expertise and yet more incorrigible personality; Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle brought an at-times disturbingly intense perfection of the mat game. The scene was electric at its peak, but clearly, tragically incompatible with the WWE grind.

The deaths of Guerrero and Benoit and the departure of Angle, combined with WWE's single-school developmental programme, homogenised its in-ring output before the doyens of the Independent scene brought a new change...


2. CM Punk Vs. Daniel Bryan - Over The Limit 2012

CM Punk Daniel Bryan Over The Limit
WWE.com

The WWE canon was hardly bereft of the technical banger up until 2012 - Bret Hart, Mr. Perfect, Kurt Angle et al. wrestled many incredible matches in their time - but those matches were consistent with a thread of pro wrestling WWE has never denied, only marginalised to the upper midcard when the outsize megastar was on top.

This match was in the vein of a genre and spirit that WWE had openly mocked just two years prior, and it was contested for the WWE Championship.

This was a technical banger so informed by Punk and Bryan's Indy exploits that they even, with tongue in cheek or heart on sleeve, paid tribute to Super Dragon's curb stomp. This was a love letter to the dreaded Indy scene of the 2000s in which Punk and Bryan came up penned with a squelching viciousness.

Punk offered the body toned and elasticated through the running-heavy workout he had recently adopted for Bryan to contort at gross angles in an early, mat-based exchange. When Punk escaped, Bryan leathered his jaw with a succession of super-stiff elbow strikes Michael Cole sounded genuinely appalled by on commentary.

Punk and Bryan worked almost the exact match Bryan purportedly had to get away from, to "make it in WWE," and a spellbound North Carolina crowd went apesh*t for it.


1. Cinematic Matches, Various

Doink the Clown money in the bank
WWE.com

Vince McMahon is fond of the "attraction"; the man has obviously promoted straight professional wrestling matches, countless incredible ones, but the greatest professional wrestling promoter ever is cognisant of and was once exceptional at selling over-the-top bombast.

The past tense is a deliberate choice because the cinematic matches he has promoted amid the global crisis consistent with this approach have sucked sh*t.

The Boneyard drew earned raves, and the Firefly Fun House match was worthy of them, but the closer these things get to wrestling - and they must, else they become just diminished, wretched monstrosities of TV - they become awful. The Money In The Bank match was a staggeringly awful attempt that betrayed its escapist premise by reminding the audience - twice - of WWE's warped and wildly counterproductive onscreen power dynamic.

Look!

There's Doink!

Except it doesn't look a f*cking thing like Doink, and he's not doing anything except being Doink, except he barely looks like Doink. Sh*t. Absolute sh*t. The unique environment didn't inspire any creative wrestling, because there was barely any wrestling in it. The players mostly walked and brawled to the next rubbish sight gag. One Final Beat would have been cringeworthy melodrama, were it not so inadvertently funny. The clip show skit WWE presented at Backlash was an affront to the craft of comedy.

The upcoming Swamp Fight will most assuredly be awful. Maybe they can get Erick Rowan to appear in it because he isn't working and might do it.

Heartless pricks.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!