10 Times WWE Tried The Same Failure TWICE

Failure + failure = failure.

The Undertaker Giant Gonzales Great Khali
WWE

Punch something generic into Google like, "mistakes quotes" and you'll see countless memes about using errors to better yourself or improve the situation.

"It's OK to make mistakes, so long as you learn from them", says one desktop background in-waiting. "Mistakes are meant for learning, not repeating", says another fridge magnet wannabe. These phrases are cobbled-together motivational tools designed to ease the burden of missteps and paint them as character building exercises that'll stand one in good stead.

The thing is, they're only useful if you actually change something - the most humbling of failures are rendered totally useless if someone plods ahead and tries the same thing about without changing much (if anything) about it. WWE has done this so many times over the years, and it almost always makes fans wonder what the hell they were thinking.

For all the good he's done as a promoter and creative mind, Vince McMahon has also reached into his bag of tricks for an old defeat and fooled himself into thinking things would be different next time. They were - the results were sometimes even bloody worse than before...


10. Doppelgänger Warfare

The Undertaker Kane Doppelgänger
WWE

Back in 1994, someone thought it'd be a good idea to try an Undertaker vs. Undertaker match. Maybe it sounded good on paper; this is the kind of thing young kids lucky enough to have two 'Taker action figures might've booked on the kitchen table. In reality though, it absolutely sucked.

SummerSlam '94 should've taught Vince McMahon that doppelgänger warfare is less horror movie showdown and more horror show that gets fans down, but in 2006 he...tried it again. There was a slight twist this time, admittedly. 'Fake' Kane appeared as the character's old-school gimmick, and new, (baldy) serial killer Kane didn't return to the mask.

Still, it was just as bad as 'Taker vs 'Faker.

WWE failed to realise that fans didn't want twin-sanity - they wanted fresh ideas. The Kane story arguably bombed harder than the original with The Undertaker, and that's saying something.


9. A School Teacher Gimmick

Dean Douglas Matt Striker
WWE

The logic behind turning Shane Douglas into a hoity-toity professor called 'Dean' was simple: Douglas would get on everyone's t*ts for reminding them of school when they were watching wrestling, and he'd get nuclear heat without doing much other than playing the smug git who used words like 'vivify' on WWF telly.

Years later on WWE's version of ECW, Matt Striker tried the same thing.

The bizarre thing here is that Douglas was a genuine legend in the original land of extreme. By 2006 (a great year if the past two entries are anything to go by), Striker was plundering Dean's old material and using it as part of his unwanted 'Classroom' segments. Neither of these characters had any success, and the first was even an aberration in Douglas' career.

Why in the name of buttoned-up polo shirts did the company think this monstrosity was ripe for recycling? Things wouldn't have been any worse had they looked back to 1995 and decided that Mantaur 2.0 should become ECW's next heel menace.


8. The Kayfabe Son

Vince McMahon Hornswoggle Kurt Angle Jason Jordan
WWE

If you're a wrestler and someone in creative pitches that you become Authority Figure A's illegitimate son, punch them in the balls, write your own P45 and run away. It's a recipe for disaster if recent WWE history is anything to go by. You'll either become a comedic afterthought or be accused of killing an icon's comeback.

Avoid it like the plague.

In 2007, WWE were ready to reveal that Mr. Kennedy was Vince McMahon's boy, but Wellness Policy violations got in the way and Hornswoggle got the nod instead. A decade later in 2017, promising ex-NXT man Jason Jordan was also suddenly outed as Kurt Angle's lad, and it actually led to both men sinking in fan estimations, at least for a while.

WWE should sit down and have a right good think the next time they plan some phoney family reveal. It's rarely taken seriously, and it had an adverse affect on everyone involved in the past two examples. Let's not go here again, Vince.


7. A Giant Who Can't Wrestle

The Undertaker Giant Gonzales Great Khali
WWE

The Undertaker could've been forgiven for punching McMahon in the plums, and not just because he was booked against 'himself' in 1994. One year earlier, the WWF wheeled out Giant Gonzales in the world's worst onesie and forced 'Taker to try and work with someone who didn't know a sell job from a...never mind.

'Taker's nightmares were far from over when Gonzales flopped and left the biz. WWE's inherent need to lumber him with giants who simply cannot wrestle has been there for all to see since the dawn of time though, and so The Great Khali marched (or, more accurately, stumbled due to sore knees) onto screens in, you guessed it, 2006.

This article may have to be renamed, '10 Worst Moments From WWE's 2006'.

Khali wasn't quite as bad as Gonzales, but he was hardly someone The Undertaker was going to have killer matches with. Worse, the presentation was almost identical to how one Giant had debuted at the 1993 Royal Rumble. So much for learning from past errors.


6. A 'Minis' Division

Max Mini Jerry Lawler WWE Junior's Division
WWE

Wrestling has always had this crude fascination with "freak show" elements. That stretches right back to the medium's carny days, and isn't WWE exclusive, but they're no stranger to promoting a circus-like feel. This isn't always a negative - in fact, variety and showmanship are good things and should be encouraged.

The dreaded 'Minis' are an exception.

In 1997, the WWF began promoting Mexican 'Minis' like El Torito, Tarantula, Mosaic, Nova and the most famous of the lot, Max Mini. Strangely, rather than acknowledging that they were vertically challenged adults, the company presented these guys like children. They'd go one step further with that idea in 2005 when launching the 'Junior's Division'.

Oh yes, f*ck Palmer Cannon's drive to make SmackDown more appeasing to sponsors by laughing at little people. Everything, from the way announcers giggled throughout matches to the play school font used for the division, made a mockery of these dudes again.


5. A Totally Useless International Bauble

Braun Strowman The OC Greatest Royal Rumble Tag-Team Trophy
WWE

Time to admit something: Your writer is a cheater.

Think of this as a temporary break in proceedings, because it's not something WWE stopped at doing twice. No, Vince McMahon has seen fit to promote more than two international baubles that meant precisely bugger all to viewers worldwide, and even he seemed to forget they existed a few weeks after they were won.

Braun Strowman's Greatest Royal Rumble championship belt, The OC's Tag-Team World Cup and The Undertaker's Tuwaiq Trophy were all utterly useless; it'll irk some fans that only Shane McMahon's WWE World Cup trinket had any sort of constructive character use when the promotion returned to the United States.

This phoned-in method of adding value to international shows didn't start when WWE struck a deal with Saudi Arabia either. Back in the mid-to-late-90s, the company also ran tournaments for the Kuwait Cup. They were as thrilling and impactful on main TV as they sound.


4. Brand-Invading Wild Cards

WWE Wild Card Rule Brand To Brand Invitational
WWE

WWE's commentators made a big deal out of the fact FOX had exploited the bold "new" 'Brand-To-Brand Invitational' rules when Charlotte Flair recently popped up on SmackDown. According to the guidelines, certain wrestlers can appear up to four times per year on rival brands.

That sounds eerily like 2019's awful 'Wild Card Rule'.

'Wild Cards' failed last year and they'll fail again once WWE get bored of them. There's no way they'll stick to the "four times per year" format, just like they squished the previous shake-up attempt by changing how the 'Wild Card' trick worked, and this idea will be forgotten about within months.

It's baffling to see the creative team pretend 'Brand-To-Brand Invitational' means something different to 'Wild Card' too. They really should've come out and admitted that TV is stale right now, and explained away this haphazard booking style as beneficial to the shows during the current climate.


3. A Definitive Brand Split

WWE Draft 2002 2016
WWE

Of course, conceding that things might not be thrill-a-minute isn't something WWE feel comfortable doing. That's fine, because there are always ways to make Raw and SmackDown feel like must-see, uniquely identifiable and totally different weekly delights. For example, the brand extension/split.

Which...hasn't worked twice.

Both brand splits started out so promisingly in 2002 and 2016. Vince McMahon seemed dead set on properly promoting each major show as competitive ratings-seekers that'd drive one another on. Unfortunately, he got in his own way and cross-pollinated to the point that the entire premise lacked serious credibility within months.

2002's first go-around needed to teach McMahon what to do if he ever tried to divide his top shows again. Rather than learn what not to do though, Vince bashed his head against the wall and repeated the same mistakes 14 years on, then decreed that fans didn't really want a definitive split anyway.


2. The End Of Mr. McMahon

Vince McMahon Limo Million Dollar Mania
WWE
"I can't be on TV if I'm dead, pal".

That line, one Vince reportedly told Bruce Prichard many moons ago, is why he penned himself to be blown up in a fiery limousine explosion in 2007. To McMahon, it made sense that he'd go out in such an unambiguous blaze of glory, because then he'd never be able to return - he was apparently sick of playing his Mr. McMahon character anyway.

Around 12 months later, Vince was back on Raw shifting millions of dollars to fans in some overhyped giveaway that didn't draw the ratings he thought it would. So, seeking the publicity such a stunt would surely draw, McMahon "killed' his on screen persona off again by having a piece of the staging fall on top of him.

Nobody bought it. The punishing law of diminishing returns was in effect, especially when Vince had survived the previous year's limo blast (one he couldn't disappear after due to the very real Chris Benoit tragedy), and he was back on TV within six months.


1. XFL

Vince McMahon XFL 2001 2020
WWE

Vince McMahon has given so much to pro wrestling, and it's a shame that owning one juggernaut isn't enough for him. Rather than being content with the empire he's built since the mid-1980s, Vince wants to expand into other avenues and prove himself as a promoter who can thrive in real-world sports.

That's why he's tried to push the XFL as an NFL alternative twice.

2001's defeat was a harsh and brutal lesson that sent Vince away to lick his wounds. The XFL lost millions, and led to a thorough roasting in the mainstream press from those lining up to bash this wrasslin' guy for thinking he could hack it in pro football. 'Stick to that fake stuff' was very much the prevailing message from anti-WWE revellers.

By 2018, McMahon was back for another shot. When the new XFL launched in 2020, things initially seemed hopeful; the first week delivered solid football and benefitted from doing away with the WWE razzmatazz of before. Sadly, the glory didn't last. The ongoing global health crisis afflicted the XFL, and Vince's league filed for bankruptcy in mid-April.

Next stop: ICO-PRO 2K21?

Which other failures did WWE try more than once? Hungry for more content? Check out 10 Times Wrestling Video Games Broke The Fourth Wall and 10 Gimmick Ideas WWE Were Right To Turn Down!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.