10 Times WWE Went Back On Big Decisions
Looks like there's a fairly good reason for telling us "card subject to change"...
Up until a few weeks back, it looked as though Brock Lesnar vs. Finn Balor was set to headline the 2018 Royal Rumble pay-per-view.
Balor’s win over AJ Styles at October’s TLC show felt like something of a primer for a main event push, while Paul Heyman had been planting the seeds for a match against Lesnar since way back in May.
Of course, we now know that Balor won’t be facing Lesnar come the Rumble, with the champion instead defending against Kane and Braun Strowman in what looks like quite the about-turn from WWE. Not that this is the first time we’ve seen the company have itself a little rethink and seemingly go back on a big decision. And while the Balor vs Lesnar match was never officially announced by WWE, plenty of the company’s other backtrackings have been far more highly publicised.
From curtailed storylines to cancelled matches, as well as a handful of incidents that have gone as far as affecting people’s employment status with the company, here are just a few examples from over the years of WWE going back on big decisions.
10. Triple H’s King Of The Ring Win
In May of 1996, Vince McMahon had allegedly decided that an as-yet-unestablished Hunter Hearst Helmsley was his man to win June's King of the Ring tournament. However, the controversy of the Madison Square Garden Curtain Call incident seemingly brought about a change of heart.
The story goes that after Triple H had broken kayfabe alongside Shawn Michaels, Diesel and Razor Ramon at an MSG house show on May 19, McMahon felt he needed to punish someone. With Michaels headlining as WWF champion at the time, and with Diesel and Ramon on the verge of leaving the company, that left Triple H drawing the short straw as the only available scapegoat.
Just eight days after the Curtain Call incident, he lost a King of the Ring qualifier to Jake Roberts and his tournament push was derailed. He’d spend the next two months losing to Marc Mero at live events, ultimately ending the year with 129 losses to his name.
No need to feel too sorry for him, though. The company made amends by booking him to win the ’97 tournament having served his time in the doghouse.
9. Mick Foley’s "Retirement"
After one last run in the main event picture, Mick Foley’s WWF career appeared to reach its end at No Way Out in February 2000.
It had been stipulated that if Foley, having reprised his Cactus Jack persona, couldn’t beat Triple H inside Hell in a Cell, he’d be forced to announce his retirement. The company even went as far as to give him a 24-minute segment on the go-home showing of SmackDown, during which he all-but-confirmed he was saying goodbye, as well as the big post-match send-off come the PPV itself.
Except, all that ballyhoo proved to be for nothing because five weeks later, he was back in the ring at WrestleMania 2000.
Making a mockery of the retirement stipulation, Foley was inserted into a four-way elimination bout for the WWF title, where he was pinned at the halfway point of a match that revolved more around the McMahon family than anything else. Somehow, that doesn’t sound quite as good as going down swinging in a blaze of glory inside (and on top) of Hell in a Cell...
8. Ric Flair Vs. Hulk Hogan
When Ric Flair was fired by WCW in the summer of 1991, it paved the way for a move to the WWF and a dream showdown with Hulk Hogan.
Initially, that meeting had indeed been the plan, with Flair’s billing as the "real" world's champion and Hogan’s possession of the WWF title putting the two on the collision course. But the more Flair was featured on television, the more he lost his aura as this mysterious outsider. Plus, the pair had been thrust straight into a house show programme and though it drew well at first, attendances slowly but surely declined.
By the time December rolled around, the rivalry seemed to be running its course and so Vince McMahon went back to the drawing board.
After Hogan was stripped of the title, Flair went on to win the belt in the ’92 Royal Rumble match and though he'd enter WrestleMania as champion, his challenger wasn’t Hogan. Flair faced Randy Savage while the former champ squared off with Sid Justice instead, despite heavy promotion of Flair vs. Hogan for WrestleMania VIII on the Feb. 8 showing of Saturday Night’s Main Event.
7. Rikishi Ran Over Stone Cold
Technically, the company didn’t go back on itself with the reveal of who ran over Stone Cold. To this day, Rikishi remains the guy who supposedly took Austin out at the 1999 Survivor Series. However, the writers did appear to backtrack somewhat when they had Triple H take responsibility for being the mastermind behind it all.
Even though Rikishi had claimed he "did it for the Rock," four weeks later Triple H came forward and said he’d actually been the one giving the orders.
Granted, that about-turn may have been planned from the beginning, but it doesn’t seem particularly likely.
Rikishi’s big heel turn had hardly set the world alight, though that’s arguably because he was beaten in five minutes in the blow-off cage match versus Austin. Still, the addition of Triple H’s name to the mix felt more like less of a premeditated twist in the tale and more of an attempt to rescue an angle that was in danger of falling flat.
6. Mr. McMahon’s Illegitimate Child
After a tumultuous summer – more on that later – it was revealed in early August of 2007 that Mr McMahon was being served with a paternity suit for an illegitimate child that he sired. In other words, McMahon had a mystery long-lost child.
Mr Kennedy was initially teased to be the bastard offspring, which could’ve been a decent pay-off, though it was ultimately announced on the Sep. 10 showing of Raw that Hornswoggle was McMahon’s illegitimate child.
Somehow, that wasn’t quite as impactful.
This prompted a "tough love" angle in which Hornswoggle was put into matches he had no hope of winning, meaning a storyline that could’ve been used to push an up-and-coming name instead gave us Hornswoggle vs. the Great Khali on PPV.
After five months of such shenanigans, and in what came across as a bid to sweep the whole thing under the rug, JBL told McMahon that Finlay was actually Hornswoggle’s father and the whole thing had been a ruse designed to make McMahon look like a fool.
Mission accomplished, though perhaps not in the way they’d intended...
5. Mr. McMahon Limo Explosion
Just a few months prior to that long-lost son malarkey, WWE had decided to sensationally kill off the Mr McMahon character. And, as ever, they went all-in on it.
On the Jun 11 showing of Raw, the show ended with McMahon entering a limo that was promptly blown to smithereens. WWE.com then published an article noting that the boss was "presumed dead" before the following week’s Raw saw Stephanie McMahon announce that the Jun 25 show would stage a celebration in memory of her dad’s life.
Instead, though, the memorial show opened with Mr McMahon himself standing in the ring, acknowledging his demise had been a storyline whilst addressing the real-life passing of Chris Benoit, at a time before the details of his horrific double-murder suicide were known. Understandably, the limo story was nixed.
Mind, even before that on-screen admission, the company had been forced to admit to CNBC that the angle had been staged and wasn’t in fact real. Some viewers had apparently forgotten that wrestling was, you know, scripted, leading to people calling in to the company offices for updates, including future US president Donald Trump. Just let that one sink in for a minute.
4. Selling Raw To Donald Trump
Speaking of Trump, two years after the limo debacle, the business magnate supposedly purchased Monday Night Raw from Vince McMahon on Jun 15, 2009.
Now, Raw is a TV show, not an organisation, so you may be asking how Trump could have even purchased it in the first place. In which case, you’re already one step ahead of WWE stakeholders who, much like Trump in 2007, were said to have bought into the act a little too much.
In fairness, the USA Network themselves put out a press release – a bogus one, mind – announcing Trump’s purchase of Raw. But even so, it seems a little rash that investors panicked to the point that the WWE stock price saw a near-overnight decline of 7%.
The fallout led to the USA Network retracting its statement and acknowledging there was no actual sale, though WWE weren’t ready to drop the act just yet. The following week’s Raw was scheduled to be a Trump-backed, commercial-free show, though the company eventually doubled back that night and had Trump "sell" Raw back to McMahon for twice the price, moving swiftly on from the whole affair.
3. Firing Emma (The First Time)
While most of these examples have affected on-screen storylines, here we have an instance that related to something rather more real in the form of Emma’s employment status with the company.
On Jul 2, 2014, a tumultuous day saw Emma released from her contract in the afternoon, before the company reneged on its hasty decision by reinstating her just an hour later.
The whole debacle stemmed from a shoplifting incident, whereby Emma took home an iPad case, valued at a handsome $21.14, without officially paying for it. Of course, it seems the misdemeanour wasn’t quite as bad as it sounds, with Emma’s lawyer maintaining that her alleged theft was the result of a mix-up whilst using the self-service checkout.
As such, WWE brought her back almost as quickly as they’d gotten rid of her, presumably because they’d realised they might’ve overreacted, but perhaps also because they happened to have a number of names on their roster who’d racked up far worse offenses, including DUIs, and yet remained on the company’s books.
2. Blackballing Ultimate Warrior
For the better part of two decades, the Ultimate Warrior was blackballed from WWE.
Between 1987 and 1996, he’d come and gone on multiple occasions amidst pay disputes and steroid scandals before the company seemed to firmly cut ties after his no-showing of a series of ’96 live events.
Over the years, the love-hate relationship spawned a handful of lawsuits between the two parties, with both sides claiming ownership of the Ultimate Warrior character, though the man himself had legally changed his name to Warrior in 1993 in order to be able to use the name. Vince McMahon would later be heard to call Warrior a nut case before his company put out a damning DVD charting the "the Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior."
In short, the bridge appeared to be burned beyond repair, until it was surprisingly announced that Warrior would be making a signing appearance WrestleMania 29 – the announcement even saw him go as far as speaking positively about his former employer, McMahon.
12 months later, Warrior was inducted into the Hall of Fame and welcomed back to the WWE family with open arms, in perhaps one of the biggest "never say never" stories in all of pro wrestling.
1. Bret Hart’s Contract
On October 21, 1996, and amidst interest from WCW, Bret Hart signed a staggering 20-year contract with the World Wrestling Federation worth more than $1million per year. And yet, just 13 months later he was out the door following the most infamous screwjob in the business' history.
One year into that lengthy contract, Vince McMahon apparently realised that $20million is, in fact, an awful lot of money. Meanwhile, and conveniently for McMahon, Hart was reported to be unhappy about the company’s "cruder" new direction. As such, when WCW came snooping once more, McMahon – having decided one and for all that $20million wasn’t actually within his budget – encouraged Hart to make the jump and negotiate the best deal he could for himself.
In isolation, that all sounds fairly amicable. Of course, come the end of Survivor Series’ 97, the situation looked rather different after McMahon had double-crossed Hart and legitimately screwed him over on live television in the most written-about controversy pro wrestling has ever seen.
While there were a fair few factors that contributed to the Montreal Screwjob of November '97, McMahon’s apparent change of heart – no pun intended – regarding Bret’s contract was certainly a sizeable one.