10 Undeniable Wrestling Truths That Don't Make Any Sense
Weddings = ratings, temporary retirements, and other wrestling paradoxes...
Professional wrestling is a sport, scripted entertainment, reality show, superhero comic book, and art, all blended into one distinctive and unique product. This is one of the predominant reasons that pro wrestling has such a devoted and dedicated following. Even through the bad times, we stick with it because there is nothing else quite like sports entertainment.
Wrestling, regardless of what market it is skewered to represent, appeals to everyone. It only requires one thing from each member of its audience – the suspension of disbelief. Admittedly this is a big adjustment. If you are going to view an episode of Raw with a “make it make sense” demeanour, you’re not going to have a good time. Neither is your friend whose prized possession is a Sable Beanie Baby (the one with the creepy handprint on its non-defined chest).
For those of us who can throw out our disbelief, much fun awaits. But just because we accept ‘The Fiend’s’ spooky shenanigans, and would likely be okay with him returning with an Infinity Gauntlet to dust half of the roster, some undeniable truths are harder to swallow than others...
10. Wrestling Weddings ALWAYS Drew
The adage “everybody loves a good wedding” is rarely true outside of the wedding party, a few close family and friends, and anybody who is profiting from the ceremony - the pious priest included.
Professional wrestling is often likened to a soap opera, almost as often as it is compared to other combat sports. And while some fans may be hesitant to admit it, we love both aspects of sports entertainment. Outsiders could taunt us “if you love it so much, why don’t you marry it?”, which would be an angle too bizarre for even wrestling, but WWE turning us all into cultish sister wives is one way to eradicate much criticism.
From a drugged Stephanie McMahon being guided through a Vegas wedding, to Al Wilson and Dawn Marie’s tighty-whitey nuptials, wrestling weddings are prime cringe. In spite of being the antithesis of the typical macho image of wrestling, such segments consistently draw increased ratings among the fanbase.
AEW’s recent ceremony for Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford sparked a viewership increase of 97,000 for Dynamite’s quarter-hour. Even more impressive it outdrew the NXT debut of Royal Rumble winner and Hall of Famer Edge by 250,000 viewers.
9. Bad Product = Huge Profits
WWE has its figurative feet in two avenues: wrestling and corporate. Logically, one would assume that success in both arenas would be the reason for financial triumph. Yet this is not the case.
During the pandemic, WWE reported record revenues sitting just below $1 billion when adjusted for inflation. On top of this, OBIDA (the company's preferred profit-measuring metric) rose by 59% to $286.2 million, which is the highest in WWE history. The new $1 billion streaming deal with NBCUniversal will only see profits continue to rise.
WWE's balance sheet is far mightier than its creative output, though large portions of the fandom stick around based on their affinity with a bygone WWE, with the Attitude, Ruthless Aggression, and Golden Eras the most popular. Nobody is out there arguing that “the PG of today is A-OK”.
In 2020, WWE had pockets of greatness (mostly over on NXT) that kept fans onside. It also depleted fan’s spirits with booking decisions such as Goldberg squashing ‘The Fiend’, Rob Gronkowski at WrestleMania, and RETRIBUTION. The Peacock deal will only prompt the promotion to dig its heels in further.
8. Entrance Numbers Don't Matter
The drawing of Royal Rumble numbers isn't the spectacle it used to be. They don’t even use a bingo cage and brightly coloured numbered balls anymore!
In the 30-participant match, the logical limitations of the human body would play a factor in assessing a challenger’s likelihood of winning the Rumble, facing the champion of their choice, and justifying their gurning and pointing towards the skyward ‘Mania sign. The natural conclusion is that the later a wrestler enters the better their odds.
Although a look at the statistics shows, of the 38 recognised Rumble matches, #30 has only produced three winners. The exact same success rate as #1. Further, a participant has almost as much chance of winning from entering in the first three as the final three (#1-#3 has produced seven winners, #28-#30 includes eight victors).
Trying to apply real-world reasoning to the chaos that takes place every January is a pointless endeavour. The glaring truth is that entrance number has little effect on a Rumble performance. But every year #30 receives the rub from every wrestling analyst from the pre-show hype to the in-match commentary.
7. Wrestlers Don't Understand Pin Dynamics
Failed pin attempts are a staple of in-ring storytelling. When correctly plotted into a match’s structure it can be a dramatic beat to the bout. The problem is a combination of the overuse of attempts, and that even chancing a pin 90% of the time is illogical.
Any wrestler trained well enough to appear on international TV knows the craft of professional wrestling. Even so, you see twenty-year veterans of the sport hit a Russian leg sweep two minutes into a match and go for a pin. The opponent inevitably kicks out, followed by the unsuccessful pinner stretching their mouth in pantomime shock.
Such ill-timed pins ruin fan immersion and make the wrestler hoping for the win look like a moron. WWE's pre-pandemic schedule was intense, with wrestlers on the road most of the week. They have practised the art of wrestling enough to know what moves are finishers, transitions, fan pleasers, etc.
Though the finisher spamming and kicking out is a highly contested trope, at least it’s believable (in the realm of pro-wrestling) that any of the string of finisher attempts could end the contest.
6. PG Wrestling For An Ageing Fanbase
As long-term wrestling fans come to terms with middle age, they have likewise had to accept that WWE is pulling a Benjamin Button. The product has devolved from an occasionally overboard edgelord teen to an entity requiring Parental Guidance.
WWE’s overwhelming motivation to turn to a PG product was to entice more lucrative sponsors, however, outside factors, such as the Chris Benoit murder-suicide and Linda McMahon’s original senate campaign played a part as well.
Despite Linda McMahon describing the PG strategy as “from the cradle to the grave", the fanbase is keeping The Undertaker company.
The Wreddit Census (2019) showed only 16% of those surveyed had been a fan of wrestling for less than ten years. In 2020, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported:
“The current WWE audience by age looks like this – 22% is between the ages of 2-17, 23% is between the ages of 18-34, 26% is between the ages of 35-49, and 30% is age 50 or older.”
The PG output is not attracting new and younger fans, a demographic that those lucrative sponsors also value. Without change, the company could find itself in a new sponsorship dilemma.
5. Any Move Is Superpowered Outside The Ring
Even in the PG Era, there is still some danger and excitement to be had when a bout breaches the confines of the squared circle. Outside brawling tends to by more risqué on pay-per-view, where PG can subtly slide up to 12A. Roman Reigns and Kevin Owens’ Royal Rumble 2021 Last Man Standing match was a recent example of how the backstage area can be reinterpreted as a battlefield.
Vicious backstage beatdowns were most prevalent during the ‘90s. We challenge anybody to look at a cold stretch of water the same way after watching Al Snow and Hardcore Holly fight in the Mississippi River (St. Valentine’s Day Massacre 1999). WCW were even inspired enough to release WCW Backstage Assault, a wrestling game that omitted a ring entirely.
Contemporary backstage attacks, while not as violent, cause the same physical devastation. A simple DDT is enough for medics to come running. A suplex on linoleum flooring will provoke accusations of sadism from the commentary team. Quite often the attack is limited to a clothesline and a few stomps, which leave the fallen party writhing in agony well into the ad break.
4. Referees Are Immune From Performance Evaluations
While integral to the behind the scenes work of a wrestling match, sports entertainment referees are shockingly ineffective in their kayfabe officiating role. They are a walking clump of vulnerabilities waiting to be exploited by heels. Additionally, they can be fooled by the same tricks over and over.
Referees are so easily distracted, to an extent it would prove disastrous in any other career. Their attention spans are so brief that if they weren’t independent contractors the company would be paying out for a heap of Ritalin prescriptions.
They often display a lack of ring sense allowing their view to be blocked without question, and frequently don’t bother to observe all the body when a pin is close to the ropes.
The most famous weakness of pro-wrestling refs is their fragility. In real life, if you were persistently and easily knocked out during your working day you would be medically retired. It is implausible that WWE don’t employ out-of-work doormen, who have the brawn to hold their ground, rather than the current crop who bump from a shove. Also, doormen have significant background checks likely to deter anyone with a history of undercutting their company by selling questionable merch...
3. Opening Promos Are A Poor Soapbox
In WWE, the opening promo is as integral as zingers are to an award show – an expected and ubiquitous part of the structure that surprisingly few people pull off well.
Opening promos once riled the crowd; in the modern-day, they are a tired trope that expects you to suspend your disbelief for no reward. The only people who seem to be shocked when an opening monologue is interrupted are the person ranting, and the commentary team backing up the sense of awe.
By now at least a handful of wrestlers should have figured out that a show-opening rant is not an effective way to convey a message. Not only does nobody get to the end of their supposed script, they are often attacked for the attempt. More wrestlers overtime have swapped the shock and head grasping for eye-rolls and huffs. Nevertheless, even these smarter more tempered performers are still using a tired and inadequate soapbox.
After thousands of opening promos, wrestlers should have figured out a new way to get their voice heard without interruption. Even backstage interview segments have a better success rate than their in-ring equivalent.
2. Ring Crews Endanger Wrestlers
If the wrestling ring is The Undertaker’s yard, beneath it is Hornswoggle’s den.
Dylan Postl, the man behind the Little Bastard, has spoken of his time under the mat. The longest time he ever spent under a WWE ring was seven hours. Postl managed to sleep despite the action centimetres above him. Unfortunately, for our discussion, he didn’t discuss the furniture in his ad-hoc home space.
In the words of Jim Ross:
"If I live to be a hundred, I will never understand why they keep so many damn weapons under the ring. It's almost like they want the competitors to use them on each other."
There is the reasoning that the space is essentially a travelling, easily locatable/accessible storage cupboard. This excuses the like of duct tape, steel pipes, and possibly even thumbtacks, but rolls of barbed wire and kendo sticks have no use in proper ring maintenance. There’s also no real use for enough press tables and steel chairs to hold a sit-down street party for some sort of royal occasion (we are led to believe this was once a thing).
And do ring crew really need a hammer at the “sledge” level?!
1. Retirements Are Subject To Change
As final as The Undertaker’s retirement felt, there is a collective dubiousness about burying the career of ‘The Deadman’. I
n wrestling, the maxim “never say never” might as well be law.
Terry Funk exists. Retirements don't stick.
In our real lives, we would be at least mildly irritated if our colleague returned to work shortly after we’d paid out for a going-away present. Yet we welcome back our wrestling heroes with enthusiasm and say goodbye to them with a heart as heavy as Keith Lee’s personal lifting best.
The prime example is Ric Flair. We challenge any fan to watch the conclusion of his retirement match at WrestleMania XXIV without being riddled with goosebumps and searing empathy as Shawn Michaels delivers his “I’m sorry, I love you line” and the Flair family sob. And this is the emotional impact knowing he featured on the proceeding years WrestleMania, albeit in a managerial capacity, and he hasn’t left our screens for too long since.
This trope has taken a turn towards the inspirational with Edge’s return from “career-ending injury” and subsequent success. Returns like that? Cathartic and awesome, but Edge's retirement was medically forced.
Flair's wasn't.