10 Underrated PPVs From WWE's Ruthless Aggression Era

Change can sometimes be a good thing.

Wwe Armageddon 2007
WWE.com

The ‘Ruthless Aggression’ era was handicapped from the very start, since it followed the most popular period in WWE’s history: the Attitude Era. Stars were born from dismissing the typical conventions of what a wrestler was supposed to be, which isn’t easily replicated when you shift your focus to a different demographic.

From 2002 to 2008, Ruthless Aggression symbolised the need for a transcendant all-round superstar: one who had the mic work to carry a show but had more in-ring ability to sell a feud going forward. Superstars such as Brock Lesnar, John Cena, Randy Orton, and Batista, just to name a few, owe their success to the impact that they had whilst debuting within this era, which allowed for a less risky but more creative edge to programming.

Whilst this period had some disappointments and isn’t looked back on with many fond memories, it is important to recognise some of the incredible programming and booking that made men look like stars.

10. No Mercy 2003

Vince Stephanie No Mercy 2003
WWE Network

Match of the Night: John Cena vs Kurt Angle

At this point in the year, SmackDown was starting to challenge Raw on a weekly basis for ratings. Seen as the second show compared to their flagship programme, they had more to gain and less to lose from the success of their brand exclusive PPVs. The weekly show was consistently delivering strong storylines and started the build early for WrestleMania by putting the emphasis on talent that would bring SmackDown success for years to come. By the time No Mercy came to be, it seemed every talent had a part to play in its dynamic brand, seemingly knowing that its use of authority figures worked with the amount of personable wrestlers they had.

Big Show would win the US Title from Eddie Guerrero and would hold that belt until WrestleMania XX, where he would lose to John Cena. Cena in turn lost to Kurt Angle at No Mercy, who would then go on to a programme with Eddie at WMXX. This just shows how talented and versatile the roster was at the time. One uncomfortable moment manifested itself in the Vince vs Stephanie ‘I Quit’ match, which typified the Ruthless Aggression era in a nutshell: WWE wanted the edge of the Attitude Era but didn’t know how to define the boundaries just yet. But we were treated to some hidden gems in the meantime.


9. Armageddon 2007

Beth Phoenix Mickie James
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Batista vs The Undertaker vs Edge

2007 had a coasting feeling to it for WWE, especially compared to the year that followed it. This was the year of the pushes that fell flat and, as the year progressed, a feeling of anticipation grew within the WWE Universe. 2007 was most notable for being the time when the Chris Benoit tragedy occurred and WWE tried to compensate for the feeling of embarrassment by stacking cards through the year. However, it's understandable that the company couldn't wait to start 2008 afresh.

The last PPV of the year created a sense of what was to come ahead of the transition to the PG era. Jeff Hardy and Triple H competed for the #1 contender spot for the WWE Championship in what was considered Jeff’s best singles match to date. A card including Shawn Michaels vs Mr Kennedy and Batista vs Edge vs Undertaker should have felt bigger, but did exactly the job it needed to do: not make itself too aware of the year that was and showed that the company and the talent were able to up their game for a huge shift in tone to come.


8. ECW One Night Stand 2005

Mike Awesome Masato Tanaka ECW One Night Stand 2005
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Tajiri vs Super Crazy vs Little Guido

Before its reboot a year later, ECW came back for what was supposed to be one last show. Under the guidance of Paul Heyman, One Night Stand showcased the essence of what made ECW a serious rival of WWE for four years. The Hammerstein Ballroom was welcomed for their attendance by a visibly emotional Joey Styles and kicked off with Lance Storm vs Chris Jericho. The PPV was seen by fans as an honest homage to the chaos and mayhem that defined its unique brand of wrestling, and it could not have been better received by those attending.

The card was mediocre at best, but what brought the magic was seeing matches many thought were no longer possible in the United States. Seeing Balls Mahoney back in a ring swinging chairs at anything that moved, Justin Credible help his old friend to a victory over 'Lionheart' Jericho: it all felt homely to the extreme audience. The best match of the night had to come from a place where it maybe wasn’t expected, and whilst a good case can be made that the moment of the night came at the end when Eric Bischoff received his comeuppance, the cruiserweight three way dance reminded everyone that ECW did ‘unique’ better than anyone.


7. WrestleMania 22 - 2006

Rey Mysterio WrestleMania 22 sign
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Edge vs Mick Foley

WrestleMania is the pinnacle of the sports entertainment calendar, so one would expect this show to be excellent by default. However, 2005 was not a great year for WWE in the sense that the same acts that excelled during the early part of the Ruthless Aggression Era had now started to wear thin some of the appreciation and respect they had gained. John Cena was starting to receive mixed crowd reactions similar to those he receives today and the supposed ‘big star’ of the era, Brock Lesnar, was nowhere to be seen. This event needed to dazzle in the eyes of the fans and prove to them that WWE was not out of ideas already, so soon into its new era.

Fortunately, the card was strong from start to finish. A fantastic opening involving the Tag Team Champions which featured both solid ring work and a healthy dose of comedy did much to alleviate some of the early pressure. The main event between John Cena and Triple H delivered an impressive rendition of the tried and tested ‘passing the torch’ storyline, but a contest that eclipsed even that was the Hardcore Match between Edge and Mick Foley. The moment where Edge speared Mick through a flaming table has left an impression on this business that is rarely, if ever, seen today. It was the right match, with the right build and the right figures leading it, which led to this PPV still being talked about today.


6. Taboo Tuesday 2005

Ric Flair Triple H Taboo Tuesday 2005
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Ric Flair vs Triple H

WWE were ahead of their time with this concept, which allowed the fans at home to vote on stipulations and opponents for upcoming matches. Whilst outcomes are always predetermined, the ability to influence a show threw up some interesting chances for fans to ‘hijack’ a show. However, the options were reasonably uninspiring and somewhat story-led, so by choosing an alternate option would feel as if you were ruining the canon of what was being created in front of you. Nonetheless, this PPV highlighted talents’ ability to improvise and create something decent without an awful lot of preparation time, which has to be commended.

The show itself created some quite extraordinary moments: Big Show and Kane teaming up after losing the popular vote to Shawn Michaels (who went on to compete for the World Championship that night) to win the Tag Team Championships springs straight to mind. But for pure brutality and for the way a story of master vs student was reconstructed to demonstrate the beliefs of both athletes, Ric Flair vs Triple H in a steel cage for the Intercontinental Championship received the reaction of the night. It is undervalued just how much of themselves they left out on that ring floor that night.


5. SummerSlam 2005

Eddie Guerrero Rey Mysterio SummerSlam 2005 Ladder Match
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Rey Mysterio vs Eddie Guerrero

With brand-inclusive PPVs, there is a proverbial hype-train that runs through the company. Traditionally, the excitement builds more on one side as they are the ones to round off the night and deliver ‘the’ match that exceeds any expectations set. As part of the group of Big Four PPVs throughout the year, SummerSlam during the Ruthless Aggression period signaled the end of a lot of feuds that had been brewing since the previous WrestleMania. However, this SummerSlam was an exception to the rule.

In one of the most overblown contests of recent times, Shawn Michaels faced Hulk Hogan and delivered an Oscar-worthy performance of bumps and reactions that undermined the build to the contest. But a few matches previous, Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio fought in a ladder match for control of Dominik: Rey’s child.

Whilst an argument can be made that the ridiculous nature of the circumstances that led to this arrangement would devalue a PPV, Rey and Eddie put on a spectacular show full of emotion and interesting uses for ladders. This ran through the card, with JBL and Undertaker having an all-out brawl for the WWE Championship, and Edge beating John Cena in one of their better matches together. With the exception of the main event, this PPV does not receive the recognition it deserves years later.


4. No Way Out 2004

Eddie Guerrero No Way Out 2004
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Brock Lesnar vs Eddie Guerrero

SmackDown’s last exclusive PPV before WrestleMania XX saw the defining moment in Eddie Guerrero’s WWE career. But the PPV itself was one that built itself around the premise of story over action. It asked fans to suspend belief just a little more than usual and engross themselves with the idea that, whilst anything is possible, what they wanted would be unlikely to happen. The added tease of having Goldberg appear at ringside gave the PPV a big feeling of importance, even before the events of the night transpired.

Despite a rather uncomfortable match involving Nidia and Jamie Noble, where Noble was blindfolded to face his former lover, the card remained solid and anticipation built nicely to the main event. In a sense, this was a PPV that lived and died by the outcome of the main event and it proved to be a historic night. Goldberg broke the brand wall by appearing, and later spearing, which lea to Eddie’s emotional WWE Championship win. This PPV is underrated in the sense that the Match of the Night could feasibly have been the #1 Contenders Match or the Cruiserweight Championship match; such was the fine margin of emotion and error that tiny mistakes stop them from being considered higher at the time.


3. Backlash 2004

randy orton cactus jack backlash 2004
WWE

Match of the Night: Cactus Jack vs Randy Orton

Backlash tends to serve as ‘Diet WrestleMania', where bad booking decisions can be reversed and fans are treated to special matches without the expenditure of a WrestleMania weekend. Typically being a Raw only show, it’s seen as the first step after WrestleMania to build the next big things for the year. Since this followed the 20th edition of the supershow, the card was set to be stacked until the first WWE Draft since the brand split. This allowed the company to bring something fresh and new to an audience which was reasonably fickle. Drafts such as Edge and Shelton Benjamin to Raw changed the dynamic for the brand and made Backlash unmissable.

Shelton fought Ric Flair in his first solo match as a singles competitor, which is something to be treasured. Triple H, Shawn Michaels, and Chris Benoit rehashed their classic from a few weeks prior and Edge began his programme working with experienced veteran Kane. But the moment that stays with fans was the brutal confrontation between Mick Foley and Randy Orton. The Intercontinental Championship was on the line but that felt almost irrelevant, in amongst the feeling of bitterness and jealousy that were palpable during their feud.

Mick’s jump from the ramp down to Randy on a pile of crates only served as an appetiser to the extraordinary visual of seeing Randy’s pristine body punctured by hundreds of thumb tacks. The result didn’t matter too much: both men came out of that barbaric fight higher in the opinions of the fans.


2. Judgment Day 2002

The Undertaker Judgment Day
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Edge vs Kurt Angle

At a time when the Undisputed Title was still in play for both brands, company loyalty mattered in bringing more integrity to the belt and subsequent feuds. Since Hulk Hogan was only returning on a short-term deal and The Undertaker remained through the company’s turbulent patch, it made a lot of sense to have him take the belt. But the match itself wasn’t exactly top quality, as personified by the botched choke slam to Hogan. However, the card before the main event was both intriguing and allowed for some matches to gain more exposure than previously expected.

Rikishi winning the Tag Team Championships from Billy and Chuck with Rico as his mystery partner gave everyone the feel-good factor going into the main event, and a Hell in a Cell match that wasn’t standard rate surprised most at the time. But it was the story-telling and emotion-provoking match between Edge and Kurt Angle that stole the show. It wasn’t five stars but it engrossed the crowd as thoughts of what the competitors would look like bald both amused and horrified Michael Cole and Tazz. It gave Edge main-event credibility and seemed to be a fitting end to the programme between the two.


1. Survivor Series 2002

Shawn Michaels Survivor Series 2002
WWE.com

Match of the Night: Triple Threat Tag Team Championship Match

The brand split between SmackDown and Raw was only in its infancy when this joint production was brought to Madison Square Garden in November of 2002. A card that was consistent on the SmackDown side and top-heavy from Raw, the balance of matches that made the event meant that every next match was something different. Putting the PPV inside wrestling’s spiritual home also meant that the audience wouldn’t accept anything less than brilliance, which is exactly what was delivered.

Whilst the night may be remembered for the Elimination Chamber match in which Shawn Michaels finally got revenge on Triple H by winning his World Heavyweight Championship, SmackDown had match of the night in the triple threat tag-team elimination match between Los Guerreros, Edge and Rey Mysterio, and Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle. Not a moment of rest was given to the audience as these teams brought physicality, story-telling, and acrobatics to a whole new level.


In this post: 
Batista
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Just a simple gamer trying to make his way through as many heart-stopping experiences and anything No Man's Sky can still throw at me. Always happy to have a talk, pull up a pew and welcome you into my slightly crazy world.