10 Underutilised WWE Stars Who Would Excel In Lucha Underground
A monster, a ballroom dancer, and a showoff all need a change of scenery.

Lucha Underground did the unthinkable last year. No, not killing off characters, or featuring a teleporting dead woman, or giving us a man who transformed into a dragon. No, they turned Ezekiel Jackson into an interesting character.
WWE tried for years with the man. They gave him a big push, teamed him with various partners, and made him the Intercontinental champion, but he was always just "eh" at best. After his release, he joined Lucha Underground, and morphed into Big Ryck, a cigar smoking, one-eyed henchman of Dario Cueto. He showed he had a lot more range than the standard smiling babyface he was playing in WWE. Sadly, his character was then killed in LU by The Disciples of Death. Oh well!
But the lesson with Ryck is that Lucha is simply much more creative than Vince's team, and gets more of their talent over than a bunch of former soap opera writers led by Stephanie McMahon ever could. We've seen it happen with Johnny Mundo, Alberto Del Rio, and the former Justin Gabriel. A trip to The Temple can be great for one's career. Many other wrestlers under WWE contract should take note.
Here are ten underutilized wrestlers who would also excel in Lucha Underground.
10. Neville

Before Neville made the step up to the main roster, there were rumors going around claiming he was going to debut with a Mighty Mouse like gimmick, complete with a mask. The way his career has gone since then, that might not have been that bad of an idea.
After graduating from NXT, Neville was a featured talent for awhile. He received a nice program teaming up with Stephen Amell to take on Stardust and Wade Barrett at SummerSlam, but after that, he hasn’t done much of note.
He’s currently returning from an injury, but there doesn’t seem to be any signs of WWE prepping him for a big push. His Lucha equivalent right now would probably be Son of Havoc. Havoc is a smaller wrestler, but he moves incredibly fast in the ring, pulling off crazy high-flying moves with ease. He was looked over by WWE, but has quickly won over fans in The Temple, becoming one of their most popular babyfaces.
Neville may yet succeed in WWE, but he may also be relegated to an Evan Bourne-like role, in which he’s used to put up a good fight, but is there to put others over. The Man That Gravity Forgot is worth more than that. The Temple is calling him.
9. Kane

Maybe Dario Cueto has a long-lost second psychopath brother?
This may seem like a strange choice, but there are a couple reasons why Kane may actually be a better fit in Lucha Underground than in WWE. First off, Kane is a good actor. He can play a monster, he can do buddy comedy, and he can be a corporate hack, all to great effect. Despite his range, though, he’s insanely stale in his current home. He returned to the ring recently after months away, and fans were bored as soon as his music hit.
In Lucha Underground, the man would be given a fresh atmosphere to unleash hell. Give him a mask, and have him play a new character. He would be the biggest wrestler on the roster by far, and look more dominant than he has in years.
Kane is 49-years-old, meaning he’s not going to be keeping up in the ring with Dragon Azteca Jr. But he wouldn’t need to. He could be in hellacious battles with Mil Muertes and Matanza, and finally return to having an edge. In the PG world of WWE, there’s only so much you can do with a monster. In Lucha, there really are no limits, as their bad guys will even murder people! Kane would fit in well in that type of environment.
8. Kalisto

Kalisto is struggling a bit in WWE right now. Since his run with the US Title ended, he’s been pushed back down the card, and doesn’t really have much going for him at the moment. He’s one of the most athletically gifted wrestlers on the roster, but he doesn’t have a lot of opponents who can work his style, often leading to matches you’ve forgotten by the time the night is over.
In Lucha Underground, Kalisto would have great matches awaiting him with Prince Puma, Dragon Azteca Jr., Aerostar, and Drago just to name a few. And from a character standpoint, he’d have more depth than what WWE has given him, which solely consists of pointing at the ceiling and yelling "Lucha" over and over again.
Maybe a couple fans out there would be upset if the Lucha Dragons broke up, but Sin Cara will be okay. He always seems to land on his feet.
7. Bo Dallas

Bo Dallas is so good at everything he does character-wise, but the man simply gets no respect.
He showed some promise upon his main roster debut, but Vince either gave up on the character or got bored with it. Dallas’ winning streak was cut short, and he moved right into full-time jobber mode. Now he’s in the Social Outcasts, which has been embarrassing for everyone involved. He deserves better.
Lucha Underground would have given Bo the opportunity to keep his momentum going, and not be so effectively shut down. Dallas could be a Marty 'The Moth' type act - a man who seems just a bit off on the surface, but deep down is actually very disturbed.
There are a lot of places Bo could fit in on the show, and the LU brain trust would very likely give him a better push than the one his current employer has provided him with.
6. Fandangoris'Meara

I’ll give Fandango some credit, as I never thought the gimmick would last this long. That’s either due to the failure of WWE creative to think up something else for him, or a testament to what Curtis Hussey brings to the role. However, he likely has more to bring to the table than portraying a ballroom dancer for the rest of his career.
Fandango would be much better suited for the world of Lucha Underground. He would be allowed to work a faster-paced style, and be able to show off more of his personality on promos, and in backstage segments.
It's his acting skills that would make him successful in Lucha. Whether you like or hate his character, the man does go all-in on it. He’s comfortable in the role, he gets it, and it’s actually hard to picture anyone else playing the part. He has a lot of range as an actor, but he’ll never move up the card with what he’s been given. Lucha would free him up to try out something new, and see if he’s capable of being a star.
5. Bubba Ray Dudley

Bubba Ray Dudley seemed incredibly excited to be back in WWE. He was lobbying hard on Twitter for months before it finally came to fruition. His dream came true, and he’d get to ride out the rest of his wrestling days as a national star.
Things haven't gone quite to plan.
From a character standpoint Bubba did the best work of his career in the last chapters of his TNA run as Bully Ray. That character would have been great in WWE, feuding with top babyfaces like John Cena and Roman Reigns. But management wasn't interested. They wanted a Dudley Boyz reunion instead. They’re basically mid-card tag team fodder at the moment, which is a bit of a waste.
In Lucha, Ray would likely be much closer to his Bully character. Overall, their roster is filled with smaller competitors, which would be perfect for Ray to push around and beat up. His mic skills are vastly underutilized in WWE, and it would be interesting to see what Lucha would do with him by introducing him once more to an ECW-like environment.
4. Dolph Ziggler

Would you rather see Dolph Ziggler battle Baron Corbin for the 700th time, or see what he could do in The Temple?
Ziggler is perhaps the best bump taking wrestler in the business right now. But when is the last time he was actually interesting? His babyface turn has been incredibly underwhelming to say the least, and it seems like his main job is now to be a stepping stone for other talent. Dolph could contribute a lot more than that.
He could be the equivalent of Johnny Mundo/Morrison if he went over to Lucha Underground. A guy that WWE never went all-in on, and never gave much of a character to grow into. But Mundo has excelled in his new environment, becoming one of their most featured wrestlers on the roster, and drawing great heel heat from the crowd.
Dolph would easily make more money as a WWE wrestler, but from a pure entertainment standpoint, he’d be far better off talking to Dario about a contract.
3. Paige

WWE can’t seem to make up their mind with Paige. She received a big push out of the gate, but is positioned as maybe the fifth most important woman on their roster right now. Since the company is only capable of booking one women’s feud at a time, this means she basically has nothing to do.
Paige could be a blast in Lucha Underground. Working with Ivelisse, Taya, and Sexy Star could bring her to the best matches of her career. She’d be free to not work the WWE style, and get to be a lot more aggressive. While Charlotte and Sasha Banks would also be great additions to the Lucha roster, it seems that WWE has big things planned for their future. Paige is more of an uncertainty.
If nothing else, she’d be more interesting from a character standpoint mixing it up with Lucha’s eclectic mix of talent, including the men. She’s made WWE her house, but could she make Lucha Underground her temple?
2. Luke Harper

Luke Harper is so incredibly talented in the ring for a big guy, and yet he’s been relegated to playing a background henchman for most of his WWE tenure. The announcers keep comparing him to Bruiser Brody, except that Harper isn’t perceived as anywhere near as dangerous as the legend, because he never wins.
He’s currently out with an injury, but upon his return he’s likely to re-join The Wyatt Family, continuing with what he’s been doing the past few years. He could be worth so much more. In Lucha Underground, Harper would be a fantastic opponent for just about anyone on the roster. We’ve seen the big man work great matches with Dolph Ziggler, and he would look absolutely dominant in The Temple against their roster of mostly smaller talent.
From a character standpoint, Harper doesn’t have much going for him in WWE. He has a decent spot on the card, but we still don't know anything about him. Lucha would give him a backstory, and likely push him in a top role. He could work exciting matches with anyone from The Mack to Mil Muertes, and be booked in a Brody-like way to finally earn those comparisons.
1. Roman Reigns

Vince McMahon’s heart would shatter into a million pieces if Roman jumped to Lucha Underground, but it could help the wrestler become a bigger star than ever.
Maybe Roman gets burnt out for a bit, and hates the WWE schedule, so he leaves. He still wants to work, though, so he heads out West.
In The Temple, Reigns could be the top heel of the company. An alliance with Dario Cueto would draw incredible heat, and help him unleash all his frustrations against the fans who boo him every week. He would no longer be portrayed as a top babyface, meaning fans would likely lighten up on him...despite being a bad guy.
From an in-ring standpoint, Roman would be one of the least flashy members of the roster, but the man isn’t a bad worker. He could be carried to some great matches from a variety of opponents. Who wouldn't want to see Pentagon Jr. threaten to break his arm?
Perhaps a year in Lucha would open Vince’s eyes to how much more valuable Roman could be as a heel than as a babyface. The two could then reunite, glue Vince's heart back together, and the returning star may even have more respect from the fans for his time away. Yeah, it would never happen, but still, it would be fascinating to see what the Lucha Underground team could come up with for the troubled superstar.