10 Ups & 6 Downs For WWE In 2023 (So Far)
2023 has already been some year for WWE. Time to grade the good and bad!
What will you remember most from the first half of WWE's 2023? Stadium show splendour? The sheer brilliance of Roman Reigns' star-making Bloodline faction? Missed opportunities with one Bray Wyatt? Vince McMahon's 'I'll get you, Spider-Man' moustache?
There's been a lot to take in.
It's easy to see when taking a quick glance at the counts for 'Ups' and 'Downs' that WWE's year has been generally excellent, especially in-ring. Tune into Raw, SmackDown or PLEs (more so the latter) and you're bound to see some top class wrestling - that's been matched by some of the storytelling.
Not everything has been all fun and games though. The (ahem) annual Draft has chomped a chunk out of fan faith yet again, and multiple titles have been let down by so-so handling. Then, there are top stars like Bray and Bianca Belair. What the hell happened there?!
This is the perfect time to take a snapshot look at WWE's 2023 thus far. Fresh faces, Triple H's commitment to preserving cherished gimmicks, top performers, absolute stinkers, belts that need to go away and everything in between.
Let's get stuck in.
Downs...
6. Bray Wyatt’s Mediocre Reprise...Stops!
Gather round for a good old sigh, everyone.
Cracks began appearing towards the end of 2022 for Bray Wyatt, being honest. Sh*t really hit the fan with that dreadful Mountain Dew-Branded "Pitch Black" match vs. LA Knight at Royal Rumble though. There, Wyatt ended the night as a neon-soaked version of his old 'Fiend' gimmick. Or, at least, that's what it looked like.
He didn't really go on to do much after that. A mini-feud with Bobby Lashley heading into WrestleMania 39 was called off due to illness. Hopefully, Bray is alright, but his WWE run is surely toast again unless someone in the writing room can pull rabbits from nearby hats. Not rambling rabbits either.
Seriously though, things look grim. WWE has run into the same problems with Wyatt's character they did the last time, and fans have probably lost interest in all this 'Uncle Howdy' business too. It'd take a brave person to predict his year will pick up now.
5. Those Women’s Tag-Team Titles
Sure, Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler just won the Women's Tag-Team Titles on Raw and definitely deserve the chance to make those belts mean something. That's an uphill battle though, because WWE's apathy towards the straps stinks to high heavens.
The division is blighted by too many teams that feel randomly shoved together 'cause creative has nothing for members individually, and the belts just come across as a weekly headache for writers. Liv Morgan's injury, as well as injuries to Ronda/Shayna, didn't help either.
Pointing to those as the sole reason(s) for failure would be an excuse.
Truthfully, fans don't give a damn about the Women's Tag belts. Why? Well, they've been conditioned to view them with the same eye-rolling response WWE staffers do. These titles will be on the wrong end of the year-end 'Ups & Downs' list too unless something radical happens.
Don't hold your breath.
4. Bianca Belair’s Fading Fortunes
Bianca's babyface run ran out of steam.
WWE outright failed to furnish Belair with top challengers that'd prolong her Raw Women's Title reign or make it feel must-see, and live crowd began losing interest in her character as a result. Then, the company stuck Bianca on SmackDown during the Draft, but kept the Raw belt on her.
Belair has since lost the thing to Asuka at Night Of Champions, and most seem to believe a slow-burn heel turn is on the cards. That could fix things. "Could", but it's not guaranteed. WWE has shouted from rooftops about Bianca for so long without any meaningful character development though, so it's a risk they have to take.
Seeing someone so talented get pushed to the background hasn't been fun, to be fair. Belair didn't really do anything wrong, but still heard a smattering of boos ring out during her matches against women like Asuka and even Alexa Bliss.
3. The “Secondary” Strap
First off, this guy actually likes the design of WWE's new World Heavyweight Championship, so this isn't in the 'Downs' because of aesthetics. No, it's here because everyone's worst fears about the belt becoming second-rate are quickly coming true. It shouldn't fill anybody with joy to report that.
Seth Rollins vs. AJ Styles opened Night Of Champions; that's a good spot for any match, but it did feed into the "secondary" stuff AJ had been talking about pre-show. Then, WWE missed a trick by having both opponents team together in a seemingly-random tag match on the subsequent Raw.
Why? Wouldn't it have been better to see Rollins sell the full-timer aspect of that belt compared to Roman Reigns by firing out an open challenge? Unless this Judgment Day stuff leads to a proper feud, then it's placeholder bullsh*t for a title/champion that really needed to start off hot.
Hmm.
2. Vince McMahon’s Return
The entire wrestling world was shocked when Vince McMahon suddenly announced his retirement in July 2022. That shock quickly turned to excitement though, not least when folks realised that WWE could feel fresh for the first time in a long time without McMahon's micromanagement.
Early signs under Triple H weren't perfect, but they were promising. Then, Vince returned in early-2023 and fingernails were chewed. The McMahon patriarch was largely there to oversee a company sale, which happened, but he also dipped a toe back in creatively by changing TV scripts last-minute.
Realistically, Vince was still contributing ideas from home, but actually having him there backstage again was said to have a negative knock-on effect to roster morale/overall mood. Unwanted, last-minute script tampering is something nobody missed.
So much for another wrestling retirement.
1. The 2023 Draft
Everyone is in agreement that the WWE Draft is little more than a hollow excuse to promote "special" episodes of Raw and SmackDown at this point, right? Many figured things might be different this year with Triple H calling the shots, but no. It's been another messy situation.
Here's the strange thing: WWE is responsible for f*cking up their own formatting. If they knew that Rhea Ripley would be winning the SmackDown Title at 'Mania, and Bianca Belair would still be Raw's champ, then why did they pen brand hops for both without clearing up the title scenes first?!
That's just thick.
Other problems have popped up too. AJ Styles, for example, rolled out on Monday's Raw despite being a SmackDown guy. It's been less than a full month since Styles was on Mondays, guys. Come on now. Adam Pearce pretending he has to justify this to some unnamed higher-up on the phone was laughable too.
Ups...
10. Legitimately Fresh Faces
Grab a beverage and raise your glass, because there's a ton of good to get through.
Perhaps the only positive thing about this year's Draft is that it put some deserving NXT stars in the spotlight on Raw and SmackDown. Alba Fyre, Isla Dawn, Cameron Grimes, Indi Hartwell, Apollo Crews, JD McDonagh, Zoey Stark, Pretty Deadly, Katana Chance, Kayden Carter, Grayson Waller, Indus Sher and Odyssey Jones were all bumped up.
Of those, Grimes, Fyre and Dawn, Pretty Deadly, McDonagh and Stark have made promising early impressions and seem to have a really good chance of becoming main roster stalwarts. It's lovely to have some fresh faces on these shows after seeing the same old, same old.
All will be forgiven if WWE manages to get some of these lads and lassies over long-term. If nothing else, being able to tune into the top two shows and know you'll see energetic newbies throughout the second half of 2023 is very welcome.
9. Hell In A Cell Done Right
Cheers could be heard from all corners of the wrestling map when news spread that Triple H planned to scrap Hell In A Cell as an annual pay-per-view. Instead, WWE would bust out the famous cage when needed, and that's exactly what they ended up doing for Edge's blowoff with Judgment Day man Finn Bálor at 'Mania.
It was glorious to see the Cell used properly within the context of a feud that merited it. People had been moaning for a decade plus that HIAC's annual nature forced bouts into the cage without proper context, so it was cracking to see that change. The match could end up being Edge's career swan song too.
Hopefully not, but it'd be some match to go out on.
Regardless, it's difficult to throw stones at Trips for ditching HIAC as a PLE for 2023 and beyond. That plan has already reaped rewards, and it will again when the likes of Cody Rhodes and Brock Lesnar get locked up come SummerSlam. Cheeky little prediction there!
8. Stratusfaction Guaranteed
Speaking of SummerSlam - Trish Stratus is likely heading for another collision with pal-turned-rival Becky Lynch in Detroit. Turning the legend heel on Becks and Lita after WrestleMania was a risk, because fans might've rebelled against booing a cherished Hall Of Famer.
Nope, they've embraced it, and Trish is having the time of her life.
Stratus' performances have been so watertight that WWE top brass got the reactions they craved from this turn. Better yet, Trish's heel run has given former NXT star Zoey Starks a much-needed boost on the main roster. There's clearly more to come from this union too, which is great.
Anybody who had Stratus down as a possible MVP performer in the women's division for 2023 would've been lying. Most believed she'd come back for one match, then stroll off back to her yoga studio. To her credit, Trish is out here working bangers and elevating new names.
7. Puerto Rico’s Insane Live Crowd
Let's pause to applaud that live crowd in San Juan for Backlash.
Approx 17-18,000 people roared themselves hoarse in Puerto Rico for a card full of quite excellent wrestling. Here, WWE exhibited the value of taking pay-per-views international. San Juan got a thrill out of hosting, and peeps in the stands went wild for pretty much everything put in front of them.
Countryman Bad Bunny beating Damian Priest in a ridiculously-fun 'Street Fight' was just the tip of this iceberg. The whole night was some laugh, and there's no doubt the rowdy live crowd heightened the experience for those watching from home. What a crowd, man. What. A. Crowd.
Backlash (and WrestleMania Backlash) used to be a bit of a forgettable evening on the calendar. If WWE fancies heading back to Puerto Rico next year for it, then no-one would be mad. That was one of the best audiences they've ever produced a show in front of.
6. Cody Rhodes Bounces Back
An awful lot of folks were understandably disappointed when Cody didn't win the Undisputed WWE Universal Title(s) from Roman Reigns at 'Mania. In fact, the disappointment was so mighty that many are likely screaming at their screens upon seeing this housed in the 'Ups' section.
It's here because Rhodes bounced back in a big way.
Matches vs. Brock Lesnar have been intense and story-driven, and he's managed to maintain top babyface status despite failing to "finish the story" on WWE's grandest stage. Make no mistake about it: Cody's "story" still has legs, and this fan has faith Rhodes will have his day.
Granted, it personally didn't bother the dude writing this that WWE kept the belts on Roman, but he completely understands why others feel differently. Absolutely no-one can dismiss the strength of Cody's bouts with Brock though, or the conviction of his heroic promos.
5. GUNTHER = Iron Man
If you're p*ssed at the Cody defence, then you'll be pleased with this.
GUNTHER's performance in the 30-man Rumble was special to witness. He went nose-to-nose with Brock Lesnar, and went down to the wire against eventual winner Cody Rhodes. Both moments felt like a preview of things to come for the hard-working Imperium leader and all-round wrestling machine.
He's been tearing it up as Intercontinental Champ since last year, and it seems likely WWE will let GUNTHER shatter Honky Tonk Man's record. That'll only give him and the belt yet more credibility, which is a huge plus. Honestly, go back and watch some of his matches - they're phenomenal.
GUNTHER just...doesn't phone it in. His journey from guy Vinnie Mac didn't even know to one of the most important workers on WWE's roster has been a joy to watch, and this is the opening chapter. Who says pro wrestling can't create fresh stars anymore?!
4. Dominik Mysterio’s Development
Really, who?!
Gee, it's almost like Dominik Mysterio was a young wrestler with huge pressure on his shoulders who didn't deserve social media sniping but instead patience to develop. The Judgment Day man gets some of the best heel heat on TV these days, and he plays his character to the hilt.
Dom's prison story was gold, and eventually led to a match against his own father Rey at WrestleMania 39. There, the young breakout star more than held his own. This, ladies and gents, is the tale of a rookie wrestler with a famous dad who has started to carve his own path. Surely that's worth celebrating?
Mysterio Jr Jr has gone from giving his daddy piggybacks to being on fan lips as a possible 'Mr. Money In The Bank'. That's progress. Christ, he's even being mentioned on AEW programming in May 2023! Yep, Dom Mysterio is rapidly becoming hot sh*t, and he's only going to get better.
3. Rhea Ripley’s Redemption
A critically-derided loss to Charlotte Flair in 2020 sent Rhea Ripley spiralling a bit, but she's recovered to stand tall as a powerhouse even Chyna would quake in her boots at. Rhea's role in Judgment Day is strong, and she's experienced a lot of success this year already.
January's Royal Rumble win and her 'Mania 39 title triumph both hit hard.
Ripley has even managed to sidestep speed bump-style challengers by first bringing the best out in underdog Zelina Vega at Backlash and then squashing the veteran Natalya at Night Of Champions. She's on a real roll, and things would be even rosier if WWE could only sort out the post-Draft title confusion.
Incredibly, it doesn't look like Rhea is going to let that mess wreck the quite-excellent time she's having on top of the world. She's blossomed into the star best-placed to take women's wrestling through the rest of the decade.
Here's to more.
2. An Unforgettable WrestleMania Headliner
The next two entries wouldn't be possible without the influence of Roman Reigns or his Bloodline stable. It's important to recognise that when showering praise on WWE for booking real-life mates Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn to beat The Usos for those Undisputed Tag-Team Titles at WrestleMania.
It was endlessly heartwarming to see the pair bubble over with emotion as they celebrated in front of a happy live crowd in LA. Putting that tag match on last during 'Mania's opening night was the right call, and it conjured up the same kind of vivid passion Bryan Danielson did when he headlined in 2014.
Sometimes, wrestling is just awesome eh?
Everyone knew that Sami and KO would win once the match was announced as night one's main event, but that didn't take the edge off it. Fans in attendance that evening will never forget seeing their heroes hoist belts above their heads, and neither will said heroes.
1. Sami Zayn’s Bloodline Exit
Months earlier, Sami Zayn ditched his "Honorary Uce" status by blasting Bloodline leader Roman Reigns in the back with a steel chair. That turn, and the build up to it, was booked to perfection before and during Royal Rumble. Zayn's chair shot has become iconic.
WWE didn't stop there. The promotion handed Sami some keys to the main event kingdom by letting him headline opposite Roman at Elimination Chamber in Montreal, and everybody in attendance believed (even just for a second or two) that Zayn might topple the 'Tribal Chief'.
What a story.
Sami didn't win, and was "demoted" to the tag-team division soon after, but his brief headline push took everyone on a ride. The fact he also got to headline on pay-per-view against the best all-rounder in the business is a huge compliment to Zayn's unlikely Bloodline membership and how over it was with fans.
What do you think about WWE's 2023 thus far? For more wrestling, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After Night Of Champions 2023 and 10 New Directions For AEW After Double Or Nothing 2023!