10 Ways NXT Got Its Groove Back

NXT! NXT! NXT!

Lola Vice
WWE

Even the most optimistic wrestling fan would have to admit NXT has had a rough time of it these past few years.

After the golden era of 2015-2018, the show hit a slump following the emergence of AEW in 2019. The Wednesday Night Wars - where NXT went head-to-head with AEW Dynamite - saw NXT routinely drubbed by the upstart promotion, as fans turned away from a show that felt like Triple H was booking a bizarre pastiche of his own wrestling career (drab promos, po-faced presentation and matches so self-consciously epic they bordered on parody).

What followed next was, somehow, even worse.

The neon-splattered NXT 2.0 was a perfect representation of the decaying minds that birthed it. A hopeless attempt by a group of septuagenarian sociopaths to connect with a younger audience, NXT 2.0 was an embarrassing farrago of gimmicks that were hokey at best and downright offensive at worst

Fortunately, however, NXT has seen a resurgence over the past year. For a variety of reasons - from the development of its younger talent, to a generous approach to cross-promotion - NXT has escaped from the shadows of its recent past and emerged as a credible contender in the wrestling landscape once more. So if you're a lapsed viewer, or have never seen the show , let's take a look at why now is the perfect time to dive into WWE's most under-rated program.

10. Out With The Old...

NXT One Final Beat Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa Candice LeRae
WWE.com

Finn Balor, 2016; Gargano/Ciampa, 2018; Adam Cole, 2019.

Like vintage wine to a sommelier, recalling these names and dates can't help but bring a smile to the faces of any wrestling fan. Each of these wrestlers was responsible for making NXT appointment viewing, and they all played a crucial role in turning WWE's developmental program into the hottest wrestling show on the planet.

Unfortunately, like a vintage wine left open for too long, these NXT icons eventually soured and left a bitter taste in fans' mouths.

The implosion of Adam Cole's Undisputed Era faction, which had the potential to be the hottest storyline in NXT history, instead resulted in a sluggish morass of self-indulgent matches; Gargano and Ciampa's legendary feud stretched on too long and ended with the abysmally poor One Final Beat (aptly described by WhatCulture's Michael Hamflett as  "One Giant W*nk); and Finn Balor's return to the brand as an ultra-serious veteran waszzzzzzzz...

These men deserve all the respect in the world for what they accomplished in NXT's black-and-gold days, but they needed to move on so NXT could start building for the future.  Which is not to say that NXT's renovation happened overnight...


9. ...In With The New

NXT Stand & Deliver 2024 Roxanne Perez
WWE.com

As much as NXT needed to move on from its past, the decision to place focus on developmental talent led to some rather obvious growing pains. This was best exemplified by matches like Saree vs. Lash Legend, in which respected veteran Saree failed to get anything out of her woefully inexperienced opponent (to be clear, this isn't meant as a knock on Lash - she's come a long way since then, and the NXT higher-ups should never have put her on TV before she was ready).

Yet, much like a young sports team maturing into a dynasty, many of NXT's young talent have become genuine superstars thanks to their time on the brand. Trick Williams evolved into one of the most charismatic superstars in the entire WWE, Roxanne Perez has been absolutely killing it in and out of the ring as NXT Women's Champion, and Tiffany Stratton and Bron Breakker used their time in NXT to build up their confidence, move-set and knowledge of the business to becomes can't-miss talents on both NXT and the main roster.

It may have taken a couple of years, but NXT's decision to invest in youth is paying dividends right now and the show - and its fans - are reaping the rewards.


8. Genuine Shock Factor

NXT Heatwave 2024 Ethan Page
WWE

The intro to this article touched on HHH's booking woes during the Wednesday Night Wars, so it's only fair to laud the success he's currently enjoying. WWE is the hottest it's been in years, and as the man holding the pen, Triple H deserves a substantial swathe of the credit.

WWE has delivered some great surprises over the past year - Damian Priest cashing in on Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania, Drew standing over CM Punk's lifeless body on SmackDown, Jacob Fatu's debut - and it's fitting that Triple H's real-life best friend Shawn Michaels has followed suit in his booking of NXT.

2024 has seen some genuinely stunning storyline developments in the developmental brand. Quintessential babyface Wes Lee viciously attacking The Rascalz was the most surprising heel turn of the year across all of WWE, and anyone who says they predicted NXT icon Trick Williams losing in only his second title defense is (a) lying or (b) part of NXT's booking team.

Long-term storytelling is the lifeblood for any wrestling promotion, but the occasional swerve along the path does wonders for keeping the audience's attention. And NXT, much like its main roster counterparts, has done a great job in delivering both this year.


7. Established Stars Actually Helping Out

Cody Rhodes Trick Williams
WWE

WWE sending established stars down to NXT isn't a recent phenomenon - just look at Finn Balor's aforementioned stint at the dawn of the Wednesday Night Wars - but it feels like it's only within the past year or so WWE has got the balance right on how to juggle NXT's established cast with appearances from main roster members.

In the bad old days, WWE had a tendency to allow RAW and SmackDown superstars to run roughshod over NXT's roster. Just look at Charlotte's pointlessly destructive reign as NXT champ for proof, as WWE's golden goose obliterated the NXT Women's Division - a division that included future WWE2K24 cover stars Bianca Belair & Rhea Ripley - before losing the belt in a triple threat match in which she wasn't even pinned. The message couldn't have been clearer - the main roster was for stars, and NXT was for schlubs.

Thankfully, WWE have since learned such counterproductive booking helps no-one. Becky Lynch's run as NXT Women's Champion helped elevate those who contended for the belt (not least Lyra Valkyria, who was actually allowed to pin Becky clean); Baron Corbin's year-long stint in NXT played a big role in helping Bron Breakker become main-roster ready; and even Cody Rhode's day trip saw the current WWE Champion treat the NXT roster with dignity and respect.

NXT may still be behind RAW and SmackDown in terms of public perception, but the gap between the three has shrunk considerably over the past year.


6. Strong Midcard Scene

Kelani Jordan NXT Women's North American Title
WWE.com

Every wrestling show needs a strong midcard to hold the audience's attention, and NXT is no exception. Fortunately, NXT is well served in that regard with a trio of worthwhile prizes for wrestlers to fight for outside the top titles.

Let's start with the most divisive prize - the Heritage Cup. Contested over a series of rounds, Heritage Cup matches may not be to everyone's taste - but there's nothing like them in all of wrestling. (Also, shoutout to Tony D'Angelo for treating the Cup with such reverence during his recent run. Nothing makes a belt - or trophy, in this case - matter more than when wrestlers treat it with respect).

Next up, the North American Championship has been given a huge glow-up during Oba Femi's reign. The current NA Champion is being booked as the NXT equivalent of Gunther - an imposing, menacing Goliath who has slain more than his fair share of Davids - and whoever takes the belt from him will have a rocket strapped to their back.

And finally, there's the Women's North American Championship. Replacing the moribund NXT Women's Tag Team Championship, NXT's most recent bit of hardware already feels like a big deal - it was won in an explosive 6-women ladder match, and feels like a successful blueprint for how WWE could bring midcard women's titles to RAW and SmackDown.

(Just to be clear, this writer isn't implying that WWE should scrap the Women's Tag Team Championships and replace them with singles titles - he's stating it outright).


5. The Place To Be

NXT Heatwave 2024 Ethan Page
WWE

You don't need to be entrenched in the wrestling industry to realize that the past 18 months have seen a seismic shift in the public perceptions of NXT and AEW.

When AEW launched five years ago, it was seen as the hottest ticket in wrestling by fans and workers alike. The biggest independent acts in the world were queuing up to make AEW their home, and former WWE superstars soon followed. Even up until 2023, the very idea that any wrestler would choose the relative obscurity of NXT over the bright lights of AEW seemed laughable.

Suffice it say, things have changed.

NXT has seen an influx of disgruntled AEW talent who decided that the grass wasn't greener in Tony Khan's company, and more and more independent wrestlers are choosing NXT as their first port of call. Hell, Former CMLL champion Stephanie Vaquer signed with WWE shortly after wrestling a stellar match in AEW against one of their biggest stars! (Two years ago, there's no way that match wouldn't have been quickly followed by a "Stephanie Vaquer is All Elite" graphic).

NXT is once again seen as the place to be for aspiring indie talent, and that perception has gone a long way to repairing the battering the show's image took during the 2.0 years.


4. Much Improved In-RIng Action

NXT Stand & Deliver 2024 Oba Femi Josh Briggs Dijak
WWE.com

NXT suffered from its own success when it came to the quality of wrestling on offer.

In the glory days of the black-and-gold era, NXT offered the best wrestling of any promotion in North America. WWE's decision to go on a signing spree among the standouts of the independent scene resulted in the best matches the company had put on for decades, as the likes of Sami Zayn, Asuka and Adam Cole (BAY-BAY) lit up the wrestling ring.

Then came the shambles of NXT 2.0, which this article has already touched on. Suffice it to say, seeing barely-trained rookies stumble around the ring and missing their marks like drunken stuntworkers did not engender much optimism towards NXT's future.

Nowadays, things are blessedly improved as NXT PPVs (or PLEs, if you must) that offer quality wrestling are the norm rather than the exception. The tremulous, startled ponies of NXT 2.0 have matured into capable workhorses, and the resurgence of veteran talents signing with NXT means the show's cup doth runneth over with proficient in-ring talent.

NXT may no longer offer the best wrestling on the planet, but it's a lot closer to it's peak now than it has been at any time since. 


3. The Strongest Women's Division In North America

Toxic Attraction Jacy Jayne Gigi Dolin
WWE

Admittedly, it does feel like NXT earned the above accolade by default. AEW's Women's Division has spent five years being the company's weakest link; RAW has given precious little of substance to any women not named Rhea Ripley or Liv Morgan; and the less said about Bayley's recent Championship run on SmackDown, the better.

Yeah, it's safe to say we're a long way from the halcyon days of 2018 when it comes to women's wrestling. So it's a good thing NXT has emerged as the industry's greatest provider in this time of famine.

Roxanne Perez has been superb in and out of the ring as a cocky heel champion, the decision to replace the albatross that was the NXT Women's Tag Team Championship with the Women's North American Championship  is already paying dividends, and women are even getting strong storylines outside the title scene. From Toxic Attraction's breakup to Thea Hail becoming the beating heart of Chase U, NXT deserves props for allowing its women the opportunity to tell stories away from "She wants her belt".

Let's put it this way - in NXT, you won't see six women sent out in the death slot for a meaningless tag match. NXT excels at giving its women's division meaningful storylines, and when you combine that with reliably good matches, you've got a recipe for success every other wrestling show in America should be copying from.


2. The TNA Crossover

NXT Joe Hendry
WWE

Admit it, you're hearing the song right now aren't you? "Say his name and he appears / I belive in Joe Hendry *clap clap* / I believe in Joe Hendry..."

Ah, magnificent. Joe Hendry's self-composed theme song is guaranteed to brighten up the day of any wrestling fan, and thanks to NXT's cross-promotion with TNA, it's an ear-worm that has burrowed its way into the brain of every NXT viewer. Frankly, if that had been all NXT took from its association with TNA, then it would still have been a win for the WWE brand.

And yet TNA has been the gift that keeps on giving. After years of watching WWE deny the existence of TNA - hell, of any wrestling outside the WWE bubble - it has been a surreal delight to see TNA wrestlers make regular appearances on WWE TV. Even better, WWE has been careful to treat wrestlers from both shows as equals as TNA's wrestlers have provided the impetus for some of NXT's most intriguing stories. Wes Lee's heel turn was predicated entirely on his friendship with TNA tag team The Rascalz, and Wendy Choo teaming up with supernatural stalwart Rosemary promises to be kooky fun.

Watching NXT and TNA's relationship flourish has been one of the most genuinely heartwarming events in recent memory, as WWE has finally done away with the stale business practices of yesteryear and embarked on a new era of jolly cooperation. Long may it continue!


1. It's Fun, Pure And Simple

Trick Williams
WWE

...for a lot of people, life is just one long, hard kick in the urethra. And sometimes, when you get home from a long day of getting kicked in the urethra, you just want to watch a show about good, likable people who love each other. - Bojack Horseman

Replace "good, likeable people" with "a fun cast of characters" and "love" with "knock the stuffing out of" and you've pretty much nailed the vibe of a modern NXT episode.

If the purpose of wrestling is, as WWE is wont to remind us, to put a smile on people's faces, then NXT fulfils that remit with aplomb. NXT has finally found a happy middle ground between the Serious Business of Triple H's latter-day booking and the neon-splattered lunacy of NXT 2.0 to become a coherent, enjoyable show. The good guys are likeable, the bad guys are hateable (any show that turns Ridge Holland into a heat magnet must be doing something right) and watching them go at it seldom fails to provoke a smile.

Wrestling doesn't always need to be complicated, and watching an episode of NXT is like indulging in a nice helping of comfort food - it may not be fancy, but it's a guaranteed pick-me-up no matter how hard you've been kicked in the urethra.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.