10 Ways To Save WWE's Failing Stars

Or how to make Eva Marie the most genuinely hated heel on WWE's roster.

One problem World Wrestling Entertainment have in 2015 is a lack of genuine, money-drawing stars. There's no shortage of talent, that's for sure, but it's turning those performers in box office entities that seems to be the problem. Even the chief of WWE, Vince McMahon, has spoken about the need for the talent themselves to stand up and be counted. It seems that McMahon feels many men and women under contract aren't doing enough to get themselves over. Adding more fuel to the fire, The Big Show has previously stated during interview appearances that there's a sense of entitlement with today's pro wrestler. It's a hard subject to fully decipher, because a lot of wrestling fans feel the talent is fine, but WWE just don't know what to do with them. It's not uncommon to hear wrestling critics discussing the idea that Vince McMahon has lost his magic touch. Gone are the days when he could create stars like 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin or The Rock at the drop of a hat. The thing is, WWE have a hell of a lot of talent on their books. Many of those performers are explored here, along with what could be done in order to help them take that next step. WWE badly need more performers who make them money, rather than relying on the WWE brand itself as the strong selling point. Perhaps the ideas contained here could offer a solution.


10. Abandon Hokey 'King' Barrett Schtick

Straight away, WWE need to do away with the 'King' Barrett gimmick, because it's clearly not working. Since winning the 'King Of The Ring' tournament earlier this year, Wade Barrett has actually regressed as a performer. Rather than launching the Englishman to the next level, the 'King' moniker has actually made him into a lower mid-carder. That's a shame, because in matches against the likes of Randy Orton and Sheamus, Barrett has shown he's one of the best brawlers in the company. His skills are being wasted on the pre-PPV 'Kick Off' matches, because he definitely has a hell of a lot more to offer. Get rid of the cartoon-like 'King' premise instantly, and make Barrett a more serious character.
Years ago, the promotion seemed interested in promoting him as a bare knuckle fighting champion, but it was deemed to violent for the 'PG Era'. Unfortunately, the writing staff didn't seem to have any other ideas for Wade Barrett, but anything would be better than what he's doing now. Take that silly crown off his head, he's not Jerry Lawler, and the gimmick doesn't have a place in today's WWE.

9. Give The Lucha Dragons A Cruiserweight Division

WWE could do a whole lot worse than building an entire Cruiserweight division around Sin Cara and Kalisto. Both men have shown themselves to be tremendous high-flyers, and shine as a tag-team whenever they appear on screen. However, if recent reports coming out of the company are to be believed, Vince McMahon isn't keen on The Lucha Dragons. This explains why they haven't really been featured recently. No wrestling promotion on the planet should have an excuse for not using such talented individuals, so if McMahon doesn't like them as a team there are plenty other ways to use them. One idea would be a new Cruiserweight division, actually pitting the tandem against one another.
Imagine a tournament being held for a new WWE Cruiserweight Title, with the final coming down to Sin Cara vs. Kalisto. The division could even start out on NXT, because if it shines there and becomes popular, there's every chance it'll end on the main programming too. WWE seem to see 'Cruiserweight' as a dirty word, but there would be interest in seeing another dynamic on shows.

8. Bring Stardust Back To Reality

Many wrestling fans thought it was a given that Cody Rhodes would abandon the Stardust gimmick after the death of his father. When the 'American Dream' Dusty Rhodes passed on, there was ample opportunity to make Cody a more realistic character again, but thus far he has still been using the Stardust persona. Unfortunately, it's not really working. Cody Rhodes has been someone WWE have had high hopes for over the years. Way back in 2008, when he was placed in 'Legacy' alongside Randy Orton and Ted DiBiase Jr, the feeling was he'd be a main event star in the future. That hasn't happened, and Rhodes has had to settle for a number of different tag-team combinations instead. The most recent was alongside Goldust, which led to the birth of Stardust.
By removing Rhodes from the glitzy character, WWE could give him a harder edge. There's a story to be told there, such as Cody revealing he wants to win the WWE Title and make his father proud. Becoming a sympathetic, yet steely babyface could really suit Rhodes, but he'd need to be booked strong over a sustained period of time. No more start/stop writing, it's hurting Cody Rhodes ability to connect with fans.

7. Put Adam Rose In The Wyatt Family

The dancing babyface character of Adam Rose failed to get over with fans. It certainly didn't help that WWE's creative team wanted to have his first major feud be with a man dressed up as a bunny, but the novelty factor of the 'Rosebuds' wore off relatively quickly. A short-lived tag-team with another struggling star, Fandango, also didn't impress. Rose himself has dropped hints on social media of a character change coming, and many fans are predicting he's about to join The Wyatt Family. There are worse things he could do right now than become a minion of Bray Wyatt, that's for sure. There was always something quite cult-like about Rose's original main roster gimmick anyway, so it could be a natural fit.
Adam Rose could cut promos upon hooking up with the Wyatt clan, claiming that he was doping our minds with his happy-go-lucky antics. That's the kind of subliminal messaging that The Wyatt Family are all about, with nuances related to real-life cult leaders like Charles Manson.

6. Make Roman Reigns A Bad-Ass Heel Again

Ever since WWE officials decreed that Roman Reigns was to be a top babyface star, they've dropped the ball with him. The biggest mistake the promotion have made with Reigns has been to turn him into some sort of watered-down alternative to John Cena. This is an ill-fit for the guy, because he's one of the most physically intimidating men on the roster. Roman Reigns should not be cutting smart-ass promos, he should be destroying people and coming up against adversity. Better yet, don't make him similar to Cena in terms of his 'Superman' like ability to overcome the odds. If Roman is going to be kept babyface, he needs to have weaknesses his opponents can exploit, otherwise there's no sympathy factor there from the audience.
Perhaps the best thing WWE could do at this point is have Reigns turn on the fans for their lack of clear support. His babyface run hasn't been as good as his tenure in The Shield, so have him return to being that moody, silent killer. He could still come through the people, but threaten more of them on his way down to the ring.

5. Put Damien Sandow With A Tag Partner That Fits

For some reason, WWE have tried to move Damien Sandow away from his 'Intellectual Saviour' character that was so over with fans. Quite clearly, those in charge didn't feel the gimmick could help transport Sandow to the main event mix permanently, but they've done nothing worthwhile with him since. At Money In The Bank 2013, Sandow won the right to challenge for the World Heavyweight Title. It looked like WWE were serious about his push, but he confusingly went on a losing streak, before cashing in and losing to John Cena. This was not a satisfying result, and made the whole Money In The Bank idea look pointless. One way to rebuild Damien Sandow could be to put him in a tag-team with a character that complements his previous brainy persona.
David Otunga isn't doing anything, and WWE fans know he's a smart guy, so why not him? They could perform a lawyer gimmick, judging other members of the roster for their wrongdoings. It's simple, but effective storytelling - they'd be obvious heels, making it easy for fans to dislike them, and could refocus what is a stuttering career.

4. Put Lana Back With Rusev

One mistake made during the saga between Rusev and Lana was that it didn't last long enough. It felt like no time at all before Lana was ignoring her frosty Russian characteristics of old and kissing the face off of Dolph Ziggler. There really should have been more build to it all, and Rusev looks relatively aimless with Summer Rae by his side. It seems unlikely to happen, but Rusev could win the services of Lana back in some sort of stipulation match against Ziggler. When the Bulgarian brute returns from injury, he should be directly going after Lana, not as a love interest, but out of spite. There's mileage in that story, this Russian beauty being held against her will by Rusev.
Together, Lana and Rusev looked strong. Split, there's not a whole load of places WWE can go with the characters as they are, they revolved around one another too much. Summer Rae isn't a good fit for Rusev, and Lana is far from ideal for Dolph Ziggler. Besides, there's a story in Ziggler chasing Rusev to free Lana from his proverbial chains.

3. Make Bray Wyatt A Cult Leader Again

Legendary WWE commentator Jim Ross has asked the question on his podcast, what exactly makes Bray Wyatt a heel? That's a valid question, because since shedding Luke Harper and Erick Rowan, Bray hasn't really been doing an awful lot of cheating. On the contrary, what has he done apart from come across as quirky and cool? Fans by the thousand hold up mobile phones, becoming Bray's 'Fireflies' during his entrance. That's not a traditional heel move, and whilst the industry has evolved, there still needs to be distinct villains. It looks like The Wyatt Family are getting the band back together, which is a good thing for Bray Wyatt. He's been fairly ponderous over the past year or so.
If WWE are interested in making Bray Wyatt a main event heel, he needs to start using his 'Family' to his advantage again. There didn't seem to be any point in removing Harper and Rowan from his side in the first place, and if they can add another few members, it'll just make Wyatt feel more powerful. He needs that perception, rather than simply being a 'cool heel'.

2. How To Make Eva Marie The Most Hated Heel On The Roster (Before Making Her The New Sable)

Eva Marie has been earning rave reviews from people like Brian Kendrick and even The Rock on social media. Training hard to make a splash in pro wrestling, the Total Divas star desperately needs to make a sudden impact on her return to the main roster. Previously, Eva couldn't really do much in the ring and didn't have much of a story, which made it difficult to care about her appearances. This knuckle down approach to training could be used to her advantage. Providing an instant character for her, Eva Marie's husband, Jonathan Coyle, could also become involved and promoted on-screen as her "husbandger". Ramping up their public displays of affection and heightening their conscious of their self image, they would be so easy to dislike and with Eva tearing down all Divas with dominant displays, it won't be long until "go away heat" is changed to real heat. The pair are no stranger to social media selfies, and that's exactly the kind of thing that could give them a platform. As his wife's manager, Coyle could raise the ire of males everywhere by rubbing their relationship in the faces of everyone. From there, a scenario not unlike that of Marc Mero and Sable from the 90s could emerge. Growing weary of her husband's attitude, Eva Marie could break out on her own and become a huge star in her own right. For those citing her ring work as a problem, recent clips of her training show she can already do more inside the ring than Sable could during her prime.

1. Have Cesaro Conflict Vince McMahon's Statements

During Vince McMahon's interview with Steve Austin on the WWE Network, the company owner made some interesting remarks. Cesaro came in for some direct criticism, with McMahon saying he found it hard to market his personality. According to the Swiss star himself, he approached Vince and simply said, "challenge accepted". WWE could do a lot worse than using this natural story. The comments could be re-aired, leading to Michael Cole promising to have a sit down interview with Cesaro to clear the air. During the chat, the wrestler could become heated, destroying the set, and directly cutting a promo towards the camera that he was sick of McMahon's words haunting him.
Throughout all this, continue booking Cesaro in lengthy matches, and have McMahon around ringside to watch. Vince could then grade Cesaro's performances, acting as a snide heel, rallying support for the 'Swiss Superman'. McMahon doesn't need to become physically involved, other villains could do his bidding, but it'd give Cesaro the chance to prove his worth. What other ideas do you have for WWE stars? Do you agree with the points raised on this list? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section!

In this post: 
Eva Marie
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.